Know Your Rights: Phone Call Recording Laws by State
Is it okay to record this phone call?
From a legal standpoint, the most important question when recording calls is consent. As a general rule of thumb, it’s polite to make sure that all parties involved in a conversation are aware that it’s being recorded. However, in some states, only one person is required to know by law.
Unsure about your call recording rights? Here’s what you need to know about recording laws by state:
It’s okay to record conversations that take place in person or over the phone. In most states, only one party needs to give consent for recording. Eleven states require two-party consent. In other words, everyone involved in a conversation must agree to be recorded. Those states are, California, Delaware, Florida, Illinois, Maryland, Massachusetts, Montana, Nevada, New Hampshire, Pennsylvania and Washington.
More Information on Recording Laws by State
Federal and state laws that govern the recording of conversations aren’t always easy to understand. So, we’re here to help clear up any confusion you might have about your rights when it comes to recording conversations.
Generally speaking, federal and state laws allow recording of conversations that are in person or over the phone. However, the laws differ when you look at whether one person involved in the conversation or all people involved in the conversation must give their consent. Also, the criminal and civil penalties for violating these laws vary.
One-Party Consent or Two-Party Consent?
According to Wisconsin-based law firm Matthiesen Wickert & Lehrer, 38 states and the District of Columbia allow what’s known as “one-party consent” for recorded conversations, either in person or over the phone, while 11 states require “two-party consent.” Those 11 states are California, Delaware, Florida, Illinois, Maryland, Massachusetts, Montana, Nevada, New Hampshire, Pennsylvania and Washington.
Although the laws in those 11 states are sometimes called two-party laws, they actually mandate that all parties must give their permission before a conversation can be recorded.
In Vermont, state legislators haven’t enacted a consent law for recording conversations. Therefore, Vermont would be treated as a one-party state based on federal law.
Federal law requires one-party consent, enabling you to record a conversation in person or over the phone, but only if you are participating in the conversation. If you are not part of the conversation but you are recording it, then you are engaging in illegal eavesdropping or wiretapping.
Different Recording Rules in Different States
Adding to the patchwork quilt of recording laws is that in some states, consent kicks in only when those involved in a conversation have a “reasonable expectation of privacy,” according to legal website Justia.com. In other words, you expect privacy if, say, you’re inside your home and not in a public place like a coffee shop.
Moreover, how the consent is given isn’t the same everywhere. Some states require consent to be explicitly stated, Justia.com says, whereas other states are OK with consent only being implied.
State laws get even stickier when you dive into the details.
For instance, Nevada has a one-party consent law on the books, according to Justia.com, but the state Supreme Court has viewed it as an all-party consent law.
In Maryland, all parties must consent to recording conversations, whether in person or over the phone, Justia.com says, yet courts there have ruled that consent is restricted to cases when there’s a “reasonable expectation of privacy.”
Given the inconsistencies among state and federal laws, Justia.com recommends following the strictest law that applies to recording a conversation or getting permission from each party to record a conversation.
Recording Interstate Conversations
Now, what happens if you’re in a state with one-party consent, like New Jersey, and recording a phone conversation, but the person on the other end of the phone is a state with two-party consent, like Pennsylvania?
“A good rule of thumb is that the law of the jurisdiction in which the recording device is located will apply,” Matthiesen Wickert & Lehrer says.
However, it can be difficult to determine whether federal or state laws govern a recorded phone conversation, according to Matthiesen Wickert & Lehrer, and whether, in the example above, the recording law in New Jersey or Pennsylvania prevails. Therefore, it’s wise to heed the common advice and follow the toughest recording law or obtain consent from every participant in the call (or both).
“It is generally legal to record a conversation where all the parties to it consent,” Matthiesen Wickert & Lehrer says.
If participants in a phone conversation are in different states, then the odds of federal law applying to the situation go up, according to Matthiesen Wickert & Lehrer.
“However, when you and the person you are recording are both located in the same state, then you can rely with greater certainty on the law of that state,” the Digital Media Law Project says. “In some states, this will mean that you can record with the consent of one party to the communication. In others, you will still need to get everyone’s consent.”
Penalty for Violating Recording Laws
OK, so what are the consequences if you break one of these laws, no matter whether it involves one-party or two-party consent?
As a general rule, you could be charged with a crime, slapped with a lawsuit or both. In some cases, you could be charged with a more serious felony rather than a less serious misdemeanor. In many states, you could face jail time, fines or both if you’re found guilty in criminal court of violating consent laws.
If you’re ever in great doubt about the legality of recording a conversation, err on the side of caution and don’t record it. And if recording conversations is part of your everyday work, then it might be a good idea to consult an attorney to make sure you’re following federal and state consent laws.
Etiquette Tips for Recording Conversations
So, now that you’ve got things squared away (mostly) regarding consent laws, let’s go over some etiquette tips for recording conversations. Aside from checking your state’s laws on consent and alerting all parties involved that you’re recording a conversation, here are seven etiquette recommendations.
1. Be open and honest
In some states, you might be breaking the law if you’re recording secretly, even in a public place, according to the Digital Media Law Project.
“Whenever possible, make it clear to those around you that you are recording. Don’t hide your camera or tape recorder,” the project advises. “Being upfront puts people on notice that they are being recorded, affords them an opportunity to object and undercuts any argument that you are acting secretly.”
2. Listen carefully
It sounds simple, but if you’re “in charge” of a conversation that’s in person or over the phone and you’re recording it, then it’s your job to listen to what the other person or people are saying. After all, you’re recording the conversation to pick up information that you can refer to later.
3. Don’t mumble
One of the worst things that can happen when you’re listening to a recorded conversation is that you’re not able to understand some or all of what was said. Therefore, you and everyone else engaged in the conversation should speak clearly. If you have to remind someone to speak clearly, then do so — politely.
4. Don’t eat
So, maybe you skipped lunch to hop on a phone call that’s being recorded. That doesn’t give you permission to noisily chomp on your PB&J sandwich and carrot sticks during the conversation. Wait till after the call to eat your lunch.
Another tip: Don’t chew gum during the conversation. It’s rude and distracting (and no one wants to hear it again on the recording).
5. Make sure everyone’s identified
If you’re chatting on the phone, especially during a conference call, everybody should identify himself or herself at the outset.
6. Watch your tone
Again, if you’re on a phone call, be mindful of how you’re coming across. Your tone of voice can convey many messages — some of them not so positive.
“Do not sound overly anxious, aggressive or pushy,” AdvancedEtiquette.com suggests.
7. Be respectful
In the case of a recorded phone call, focus on the conversation and avoid multitasking. For example, AdvancedEtiquette.com suggests steering clear of distractions such as your computer, your paperwork or your coworkers.
Which Conversations Should Be Recorded?
Now that you’re up to speed on etiquette, what types of conversations should you be recording? Here are four examples.
If you’re a writer, it’s often wise to record interviews you’re conducting. This way, you can review the recording or transcript to double-check information or flesh out quotes if you were simultaneously taking notes.
2. Client meetings
Whatever line of business you’re in, it might make sense to record a meeting with a client. Afterward, you can listen to the recording or read the transcript to refresh your memory about key points that were brought up. This can also provide confirmation that you’re following their directions, if they later claim that they wanted a different service or product from what you provided based on the phone meeting.
3. Conference calls
In some cases, you might need an official record of business that was conducted during a conference call, especially if any formal votes were taken. If there’s any doubt about what happened during the call, you can go back to the recording or transcript for verification.
During a long lecture at school, you might miss some of the most vital parts when you’re writing them down, especially if your hand gets cramped. Recording the lecture and listening to it later or poring over a transcript can help you recover information that’s not in your written notes.
Transcribing a Recorded Conversation
Once you’ve recorded a conversation, how do you transcribe it?
Well, you can do it the old-fashioned way by listening to the recording and then writing down or typing the conversation verbatim. That’s very tedious and time-consuming.
However, a number of digital tools are available to help speed up audio transcription. We recommend you give the Rev Call Recorder app a try. The app allows you to capture important phone conversations — at no charge — and then have the call transcribed for just $1.25 per audio minute.