Speaker 1 (34:19):
Here ye, here ye, here ye. All persons having anything to do before the Honorable William Sullivan, Justice of the Superior Court now sitting in Plymouth, [inaudible 00:34:26] the Commonwealth, draw on the edge of your attendance and you shall be heard. God saved the Commonwealth of Massachusetts. This court is now in session. Please be seated.
Speaker 2 (34:35):
Good morning, Your Honor. May I proceed?
William Sullivan (34:35):
Yes, please.
Speaker 2 (34:35):
Your Honor, before the court today, we have the matter of Commonwealth versus Lindsay Clancy. Ms. Clancy is present. She is represented by attorney Kevin Reddington and attorney Laura McConnell. The Commonwealth is represented by Assistant District Attorney Jennifer Sprague and Assistant District Attorney Shannon Buckingham.
William Sullivan (34:51):
Good morning, everyone. Good morning, Counsel.
Jennifer Sprague (34:54):
Morning.
William Sullivan (34:54):
Good morning, Ms. Clancy.
Speaker 2 (34:55):
Good morning, Your Honor.
William Sullivan (34:56):
All right. So this was on really for status. We had the arguments a couple of weeks ago, a number of motions. I issued the decisions on those motions, and I think we talked about leaving this as a status date or a scheduling date. And so I guess my thought would be to discuss the next scheduling in regards to that. So, Commonwealth, can you tell me what the status in regards to the request, what the next date would be?
Jennifer Sprague (35:31):
Well, I think from the Commonwealth's perspective, given what the charges are, it requires a jury trial. So we'd be ready to pick a jury trial date. We haven't heard from defense counsel about any other direction for the trial, so felt that we'd be ready to pick a trial date.
William Sullivan (35:47):
Okay. Yeah. Mr. Reddington?
Kevin Reddington (35:56):
So as they say, Alea iacta est, the die has been cast. I think you can read between the lines that when they say that the case is going to require a jury, that it's an indirect comment from the DA that they intend to proceed on first degree murder indictments. So we will pick a trial date.
William Sullivan (36:19):
All right. I think we had talked... I mentioned last time, maybe sometime in March, and so I think that's what I'd like to do. And then maybe kind of go backwards in regards to that, in regards to final trial, if there's other discovery issues or any other kind of things that have to be addressed. Commonwealth?
Jennifer Sprague (36:42):
Your Honor, ADA Buckingham and I have looked at our trial calendars, which are pretty full with other murder trials, a lot of which are older than this case and some of which haven't had their first trial date yet. So looking at our availability, the first availability we have is in May.
William Sullivan (37:05):
All right. Mr. Reddington?
Kevin Reddington (37:07):
I'd say we split the difference in say April. I mean, they can continue those cases. Cases are continued all the time. I think it's readily apparent that this is a case that needs to be tried. And I indicated to the court that I wanted to, myself, wanted to have it done before the spring ended. So I would say an April date.
Jennifer Sprague (37:33):
Your Honor, I do have a trial scheduled in April on a homicide case from 2014. We've looked at our calendars. We've looked at the trials that we have between now and May. I believe all of them are older than this case. Many of them, as I said, haven't even had their first trial date yet. So I don't understand why this defendant would be entitled to a second trial before some of these older other cases where people are waiting in custody in jail to get their first trial date.
William Sullivan (38:06):
Well, in regards to the 2014 case...
Jennifer Sprague (38:10):
That's separate.
William Sullivan (38:11):
Right? I imagine that there are other circumstances that have led to that. Either there's a question of competency or a return to competency or there's been a motion for new trial. So that doesn't seem to be... And I can't imagine the Commonwealth... I know this office. I can't imagine the Commonwealth would just waited 12 years to try somebody.
Jennifer Sprague (38:40):
No, there absolutely have been issues with competency.
William Sullivan (38:43):
Right.
Jennifer Sprague (38:43):
However, where the defendant has been restored to competency and they're competent at this moment and that there are witnesses to this homicide who were children when it happened and have been waiting for 12 years to testify on behalf of the victim, their mother in that case. I would be hesitant-
Jennifer Sprague (39:00):
The victim, their mother in that case. I would be hesitant to try to take away that date from them because if we do move that date, maybe the defendant's no longer competent going forward when we eventually reach it. I would like to take advantage of the fact that he's competent now and get that trial done, if possible.
Kevin Reddington (39:19):
I suggest, Your Honor, that that case that everybody's pretty much aware of has been kicked around for quite a while, obviously 14 years. The individual, obviously I don't know about his competency, but I don't see that all of a sudden he's going to miraculously become incompetent because the Lindsay Clancy case happens to move it a couple of months. So I would again reiterate that I believe this case deserves attention from the court. I would prefer to have it in April.
William Sullivan (39:51):
All right. Well, I would say Commonwealth, we need to pick a March date or an April date, kind of whatever the Commonwealth would want to do.
Jennifer Sprague (40:02):
Well, I know ADA Buckingham has a trial in March.
Kevin Reddington (40:09):
Excuse me, I apologize. I have trials all over the state and I'm willing to move them.
William Sullivan (40:14):
I understand, but this is the case that's in front of me right now. All right? I want to get this done. I want to deal with this. We had talked about this two weeks ago as a possibility and I appreciate everybody looking at their calendars, but I hear Mr. Reddington quoting Julius Caesar.
Kevin Reddington (40:36):
And the Rubicon.
William Sullivan (40:37):
I would quote Shakespeare. We can't go "tomorrow and"-
Kevin Reddington (40:39):
You and I can talk about that.
William Sullivan (40:39):
"... tomorrow and tomorrow creeps upon its petty pace." We can't do that. We're going to pick a trial date and I understand the Commonwealth's thing, but in weighing all that, I see it as either a trial date in March or a trial date in April.
Jennifer Sprague (40:55):
I would just say for the court and for the record that some of these defendants have filed motions in court saying that we are prejudicing them by focusing on this case to the detriment of them waiting in jail for their trial date and that it's unfair to them.
Kevin Reddington (41:12):
I think this case is being used as an excuse all over the state for a lot of things.
William Sullivan (41:16):
Here's what we can do. Pick a trial date in March or April. And then if we have to address that or the other cases have to be addressed, we'll do that. But I don't have all of those cases in front of me. I've got this case in front of me. This is a case that I want to get tried, the parties want to get tried. And like I said before, we've all done retrials and generally the sooner the case is retried, the better it is for all of the parties, including the attorneys, rather than waiting a year to get something done. So that's why I was asking. This gives everybody about four months to prepare, four months to make adjustments in regards to their schedules. That's a pretty significant amount of time. So again, March or April, I mean, so...
Jennifer Sprague (42:18):
We'd have to ask then for the end of April and I'd just ask for the court for some type of order ruling to protect the Commonwealth in a Rule 36 motion on the other case that's scheduled for April.
William Sullivan (42:30):
All right. Well, I'm not going to rule on something I don't see, so I'd have to see it.
Kevin Reddington (42:37):
How about Monday, April 19th? Or the 12th?
Jennifer Sprague (42:43):
I'd ask for the 26th if possible.
William Sullivan (42:47):
How about April 5th?
Kevin Reddington (42:50):
Whatever date you say, I'd make work. April 5 is fine.
Jennifer Sprague (42:57):
I don't think that would give ADA Buckingham sufficient time to finish for a trial in March and then prepare properly for this.
William Sullivan (43:07):
We're going to schedule it then. Well, when's that other trial going to start? Keeping with historical quotes, we could do this on March 15th, the ides of March.
Kevin Reddington (43:16):
The ides of March.
William Sullivan (43:19):
And then if that other case has to be continued, we can continue that.
Kevin Reddington (43:23):
I could do that.
Jennifer Sprague (43:24):
I'm sorry. I don't have any jokes.
William Sullivan (43:27):
I'm not saying any jokes. All right. I'm just trying to talk to both counsel about getting a date. So I'm not making any jokes. I'm just speaking to counsel that I've known for quite a while and I know that wants to serve the Commonwealth, serve their clients. I'm just trying to get a date. So we came in here last time, we talked about a possible date in March. We come back here two weeks later and now I'm getting a different position or different arguments. That's all.
Jennifer Sprague (44:07):
Your Honor, on the last date you suggested March, but I don't think there was a discussion among the parties about availability in March.
William Sullivan (44:12):
How's March 15th?
Jennifer Sprague (44:18):
March 15th, ADA Buckingham's starting a trial on March 8th.
William Sullivan (44:22):
All right. How about the 22nd then?
Jennifer Sprague (44:30):
I though we were doing April.
William Sullivan (44:32):
Well, everybody's getting... We say April and then you go the very end of April. We've been talking about March, so that's all. And then I said the 15th, you said counsel can't do it because starting a trial on the 8th. So I'm saying let's go two weeks after that. That becomes March 22nd. How's that?
Kevin Reddington (44:54):
And I don't want my silence to be taken that I don't have a case scheduled pretty much every week. Whatever the court recommends for a trial date, I will make work.
Jennifer Sprague (45:03):
If ADA Buckingham starts that trial on the 8th, it's a murder trial. If it takes a week and a half, two weeks, that gives her zero preparation time.
Kevin Reddington (45:10):
We've already tried it for seven weeks.
Jennifer Sprague (45:12):
We have a right to present it in a different manner.
William Sullivan (45:14):
Please talk to me, not to each other. All right. How's the 29th? March 29th.
Jennifer Sprague (45:23):
No, the Commonwealth's objection.
William Sullivan (45:27):
All right. Why don't we put it on from March 29th then over the Commonwealth's objection? And then what I would suggest, a final pretrial, maybe a month or so before that.
Kevin Reddington (45:59):
I don't know how it works. I'm sorry.
Jennifer Sprague (46:01):
No, go ahead.
Kevin Reddington (46:02):
I was just going to say 17, 18, 19, 23, 24.
Jennifer Sprague (46:08):
I'm on trial the week of February 22nd through that first week of March. So I can either do the week of February 15th or the week of March 8th.
William Sullivan (46:22):
[inaudible 00:46:23].
Kevin Reddington (46:23):
February 15th would-
Jennifer Sprague (46:23):
Oh, actually-
Kevin Reddington (46:24):
That's a holiday, I think.
Jennifer Sprague (46:25):
I'm sorry.
Kevin Reddington (46:25):
Yeah.
Jennifer Sprague (46:26):
ADA Buckingham will be on trial March 8th and February 8th. Sorry. So either February 18th or 19th or the week of March 8th. I apologize.
William Sullivan (46:38):
How's the 18th?
Kevin Reddington (46:39):
Yep, that's fine.
William Sullivan (46:41):
All right. So that'll be for the final trial conference. And I'm going to suggest maybe a status date, maybe after the first of the year cases, any other issues come up. I don't know if there's any additional discovery or motions that are going to come up. I don't expect any, but they may... Whether or not there's going to be additional witnesses or additional evidence that's going to have to be dealt with, I don't expect it, but just in case, so we can pick a status date maybe in January.
Kevin Reddington (47:22):
Well, again, depending on scheduling, I would think December would probably be better. Then if we need another date, we can always pick one in January. It could get a little choppy and complex with some of the pretrial motions, that's all.
Jennifer Sprague (47:35):
And I anticipate quite a few pretrial motions to deal with not only the trial itself, but procedure, security, media, all of that.
William Sullivan (47:43):
Right.
Kevin Reddington (47:45):
And I would just note that-
William Sullivan (47:45):
That was my next one after that. It's going to suggest kind of a logistics meeting regarding logistics, security, media, all those. But we could maybe fold those all in together for kind of a status.
Kevin Reddington (47:58):
I would just say, Your Honor, that all of the issues that were raised prior to trial dealing with security, transportation have all been resolved. They've been fantastic. No problem whatsoever.
William Sullivan (48:07):
I just want to go over them again. It's like they've been great. They'll always be better.
Kevin Reddington (48:14):
December 9th, does that work?
Jennifer Sprague (48:19):
That doesn't work for the Commonwealth. I could do the week of the 28th, December 28th.
Kevin Reddington (48:36):
Yep, that works. Perhaps that Wednesday is the 30th.
William Sullivan (48:43):
Is it December 30th?
Jennifer Sprague (48:43):
That's fine.
William Sullivan (48:43):
Okay.
Jennifer Sprague (48:49):
We also haven't addressed any appellate issues. I know that there's been statements by Attorney Weinberg, I believe, about appealing the motion to dismiss decision that could potentially affect the trial date as well.
Kevin Reddington (49:03):
That motion appeal is not going to affect the trial date at all.
William Sullivan (49:06):
All right. We'll wait and see when that comes up. So my thought would be to get these dates and then we'll see what happens on any of the other issues. All right. Anything else, Commonwealth?
Kevin Reddington (49:18):
No.
William Sullivan (49:18):
All right.
Kevin Reddington (49:19):
I might need to speak to magistrate regarding maybe a little help in some of the other counties on scheduling, just to let you know.
William Sullivan (49:28):
So I'm going to say the same thing that I said to Ms. Sprague in regards to any of those. We'll deal with those when I see it kind of concrete. All right?
Kevin Reddington (49:38):
Very good.
William Sullivan (49:39):
All right.
Kevin Reddington (49:39):
Thank you.
William Sullivan (49:40):
All right.
Speaker 2 (49:41):
[inaudible 00:49:42] and status at 9:00 AM.
William Sullivan (49:43):
Yeah, let me see that. Yeah.
Speaker 2 (49:46):
So for the record, this case is continued to December 30th, 2026 at 9:00 AM for status. Final pretrial conference is scheduled for February 18th, 2027 at 9:00 AM. And trial will begin on March 29th, 2027 for impanelment.
Kevin Reddington (49:59):
Thank you.
Speaker 2 (49:59):
9:00 AM.
William Sullivan (49:59):
Counsel, thank you.
Speaker 3 (49:59):
Court, all arise.
SILENCE (49:59):
(Silence)



