Judge (15:05):
(silence) Brook, how you holding up? How you holding up? How you doing? Good. So I guess that's no better than it was yesterday.
Brook (15:09):
Sean, he looked at it this morning. He can't figure it out. I was giving him a little cues. So when her computer goes down, this one goes down and I noticed that it's not the HDMI thing. It's the browser box on here for some reason. I don't know if it's the internet that's going in and out or something. I don't know. He said he doesn't know.
Judge (15:27):
I expected it to work better when we put it under the microphone, but it didn't.
Brook (15:31):
Didn't.
Judge (15:31):
Didn't compare.
Brook (15:31):
It didn't compare. It's working right now, so we'll see. I think it's just because the press is hooked up and everything and something's affecting it because it's not done that for me before like that.
Judge (15:58):
Well, I'm not a tech guy and leave that to Sean. Might have to bring somebody else in from outside.
Brook (16:10):
Yeah, maybe the manufacturer, whoever can fix.
Judge (17:54):
Lebo, do you know if the jurors are here?
Lebo (17:57):
I believe they are. I know the bailiffs came out a few minutes ago, so I would assume they're here.
Judge (18:02):
All right. Good morning, Mr. Steel.
Mr. Steel (18:04):
Good morning. Good morning, everyone.
Judge (18:10):
We think they are all here if y'all are ready.
Speaker 1 (18:15):
Yes, sir.
State Attorney (18:15):
We're ready.
Judge (18:16):
Okay. Let's bring them out, please.
Speaker 2 (18:18):
Do you know who the next witness is? Virginia Edwards.
Speaker 3 (18:18):
[inaudible 00:18:41]
Speaker 2 (18:18):
Thank you.
Speaker 7 (18:18):
They aren't ready.
Judge (18:18):
No? Okay.
Mr. Steel (18:18):
So I heard what Mr. Treadaway said yesterday about...
State Attorney (24:10):
Your Honor, may we address the court while we're in the waiting period right now? Mr. Steel approached me moments ago and he said the witness we couldn't get in touch with, he will make available to us at the lunch break and will give us time to talk to him. We would ask for an extra 20 minutes if we could have that to talk to this witness during the lunch break. And I guess he will be here at lunch. Is that correct? Because the intention is to let him be called out of order and he will be their first witness after lunch is my understanding of what we're trying to do here.
Mr. Steel (24:38):
That's fine or whenever it's convenient for the trial progress. But he's not far. I just need maybe 30 minutes notice. And I told him that that's not... Mr. Treadaway said that he didn't speak with him. Mr. Warren said that they did speak, but I said regardless, that's not what we're doing. So he's going to be open and I'm going to share all my, before that, before they meet with him, I'm going to share all my notes with the prosecutors as well so that they're more educated.
(25:08)
And I also said, if it's just too much information, I don't know if the court wants to do this. I don't know if the State wants to agree, but he just can't be here after today. But if you do Zoom, if they need more time, I could just Zoom him Monday or Tuesday with the court's acknowledgement if they want more time to understand and digest. So whatever accommodations need to be made. I'm not trying to limit it to 20 minutes.
Judge (25:37):
All right. I appreciate that. Sounds like plan A may work and we might have to even consider the Zoom option. So we'll take a slightly longer lunch today and hopefully that'll work out.
State Attorney (25:49):
Your Honor, why don't we wait. May I step out.
Judge (26:12):
Sure.
(26:12)
Morning.
Speaker 4 (26:12):
Morning.
Speaker 5 (26:12):
[inaudible 00:30:08]
Judge (26:12):
On Wednesday? Okay. We'll see what they say.
Speaker 5 (26:12):
It's all right. I mean, it's so important to have to...
Judge (26:12):
All right. We'll see what they say.
Mr. Steel (31:58):
Your Honor, do you have a minute? This is probably redundant, but this witness same type of motion that we discussed yesterday. She's Mr. Akers aunt and she states that Lacy Boles hit her in 2015. We believe that should not come in. And that Lacy children, I was told this was just wrong, but were born positive testing for drugs. It would be hearsay. It's untrue. I believe it's untrue anyway. And I don't understand why that would come in for a trial. And there was a recording, I believe.
State Attorney (32:43):
It won't.
Judge (32:44):
It won't. Very good.
Mr. Steel (32:45):
Okay. And there was a recording that I believe the prosecutors said last trial they were not planning to use. So I assume that's fair.
State Attorney (32:51):
I think that was a recording that was made unbeknownst to the defendant. This witness coming up was surreptitiously recording her not using it.
Judge (32:59):
Okay.
Mr. Steel (33:00):
Thank you, sir.
Judge (33:00):
Makes it easy. Thank you.
Speaker 6 (33:01):
Are you ready?
Judge (33:05):
Yes, ma'am.
(33:05)
Good morning, everybody. Welcome back. Does the State have another witness?
State Attorney (33:50):
Yes, Your Honor. If it would please the court, State calls Virginia Lee Edwards. Ms. Edwards.
Judge (34:00):
Ma'am, good morning. I'll swear you in. If you would please raise your right hand. Do you swear or affirm the testimony you're about to give in the matter before the court will be the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so help you God?
Virginia Edwards (34:49):
I do.
Judge (34:51):
Thank you very much. Have a seat.
Lawyer 2 (34:59):
Good morning, ma'am. Can you introduce yourself to the jury by telling me your name?
Virginia Edwards (35:03):
Virginia Edwards.
Lawyer 2 (35:05):
Did you know the decedent in this case, Daniel Akers?
Virginia Edwards (35:10):
I did.
Lawyer 2 (35:10):
Can you tell the jury how you knew that person?
Virginia Edwards (35:11):
He was my brother.
Lawyer 2 (35:15):
Did you maintain a close relationship with your brother throughout his life?
Virginia Edwards (35:18):
Very.
Lawyer 2 (35:19):
Was there any time that you were on the house or you didn't see him for many, many years or anything like that?
Virginia Edwards (35:26):
No.
Lawyer 2 (35:28):
Okay. Did you maintain a close relationship, sibling relationship, right up until the time of his death?
Virginia Edwards (35:33):
Absolutely.
Lawyer 2 (35:38):
And just to give the jury an idea how many times you would s... How frequently would you see him? Are you local to this area? First question, I guess, are you local to this area?
Virginia Edwards (35:49):
Yes, I am. I would see Dan probably more than not during the week. Four times a week, five times a week he would come over and stop at our house.
Lawyer 2 (36:01):
All right. And would you see him at holidays, Thanksgiving?
Virginia Edwards (36:04):
Every holiday.
Lawyer 2 (36:05):
Christmastime?
Virginia Edwards (36:06):
Mm-hmm.
Lawyer 2 (36:06):
I guess would you see his children and him both?
Virginia Edwards (36:11):
Yeah.
Lawyer 2 (36:11):
All right. Was there an opportunity that you had to see Dan near the very end of his life?
Virginia Edwards (36:17):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (36:17):
So if his life ended on Sunday, December 22nd, 2019, when was the last time you saw him?
Virginia Edwards (36:23):
Friday night.
Lawyer 2 (36:26):
Friday night would've been December 20th, I guess.
Virginia Edwards (36:30):
Mm-hmm.
Lawyer 2 (36:31):
Okay. Can you tell just the circumstances to the jury of how you were able to interact with Dan on Friday night?
Virginia Edwards (36:36):
Well, he called me while-
Lawyer 2 (36:39):
Don't say anything that he said, but just what were the circumstances or the nature of that interaction?
Virginia Edwards (36:44):
He was getting a mitt for his daughter.
Lawyer 2 (36:48):
Like a baseball glove or something?
Virginia Edwards (36:50):
Yeah, like a little girl's mitt.
Lawyer 2 (36:51):
Okay. Was he involved in his daughter's sports?
Virginia Edwards (36:56):
He was going to put her in softball when she was old enough, but it was-
Speaker 8 (37:02):
Object as to hearsay.
Lawyer 2 (37:04):
To your knowledge, did he come-
Judge (37:04):
Sustained.
Lawyer 2 (37:05):
I'll just ask another question. To your knowledge, did he come to get a baseball club or something for the upcoming season? And why was that at your house?
Virginia Edwards (37:16):
A lot of Dan's things were at our house and there's still a lot of things there now.
Lawyer 2 (37:26):
Did Dan have experience playing sports when y'all were growing up?
Virginia Edwards (37:30):
Yep.
Lawyer 2 (37:30):
Did you happen to see him play?
Virginia Edwards (37:31):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (37:34):
What sport did he play?
Virginia Edwards (37:35):
Football, baseball, basketball.
Lawyer 2 (37:40):
What arm did he throw a football with?
Virginia Edwards (37:42):
His right hand.
Lawyer 2 (37:44):
Was he equally capable of throwing a football with his left hand?
Virginia Edwards (37:47):
No.
Lawyer 2 (37:47):
Did you ever see that?
Virginia Edwards (37:47):
No.
Lawyer 2 (37:51):
What arm or hand did he throw a baseball with?
Virginia Edwards (37:54):
His right hand.
Lawyer 2 (37:55):
Was he equally capable of using his left hand to throw a baseball?
Virginia Edwards (38:03):
I've never seen him do it, so I assume not.
Lawyer 2 (38:04):
Did you ever see him wearing the glove on his right hand to show that he was maybe left-handed?
Virginia Edwards (38:08):
No.
Lawyer 2 (38:08):
Or ambidextrous?
Virginia Edwards (38:11):
Mm-mm.
Lawyer 2 (38:11):
Did you ever see that?
Virginia Edwards (38:12):
No.
Lawyer 2 (38:13):
You what ambidextrous means?
Virginia Edwards (38:15):
Mm-hmm.
Lawyer 2 (38:15):
Equally able to use either hand?
Virginia Edwards (38:15):
Yeah.
Lawyer 2 (38:16):
Would you characterize him as that?
Virginia Edwards (38:18):
Absolutely not.
Lawyer 2 (38:26):
When you were involved with Dan, it sounds like pretty frequently or pretty regularly, did you ever arrive in a situation where you were concerned about his mental state to the point where you would contact other family members?
Virginia Edwards (38:39):
No.
Lawyer 2 (38:39):
Were you ever concerned about his mental state to the point where you moved to contact or bring in intervention people from mental health team or anything like that?
Virginia Edwards (38:49):
No.
Lawyer 2 (38:54):
I'm assuming, and I guess I won't assume, I'll just ask, some of these interactions weekly, many times per week and holidays, was the defendant, Lacy Boles, involved in that as well?
Virginia Edwards (39:06):
Most of the time.
Lawyer 2 (39:07):
So did you have an opportunity to interact with her also regularly?
Virginia Edwards (39:10):
Regularly.
Lawyer 2 (39:11):
Because that was his spouse?
Virginia Edwards (39:13):
Mm-hmm.
Lawyer 2 (39:13):
Right? So can you just characterize for the jury the nature of their relationship, please? Don't go into specific things, but just how'd they get along?
Virginia Edwards (39:24):
Towards the end?
Lawyer 2 (39:36):
Yes, ma'am.
Virginia Edwards (39:36):
Tumultuous.
Lawyer 2 (39:37):
Okay. Do you have any knowledge of this defendant being familiar with firearms?
Virginia Edwards (39:41):
I do.
Lawyer 2 (39:41):
Can you tell the jury about that?
Virginia Edwards (39:44):
I was at their home one day and she took out a gun from a safe that was in the garage, in the back of the garage, and she said her dad gave it to her. And I said, "Well, that shouldn't be in this house because Dan's not supposed to be around guns." And she said, " Well, I keep it in the safe."
Lawyer 2 (40:01):
When you say she, are you referring to this defendant, Lacy?
Virginia Edwards (40:06):
I am.
Lawyer 2 (40:09):
Do you possibly remember, or have you ever seen this item, State's Exhibit 173? If I may approach the witness? Is this possibly the weapon?
Virginia Edwards (40:21):
I believe so.
Lawyer 2 (40:21):
Is this the safe, 197?
Virginia Edwards (40:36):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (40:37):
197 was the safe you saw?
Virginia Edwards (40:37):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (41:01):
Did you have an opportunity to attend a memorial or a funeral type service or remembrance celebration of lifetime service of the decedent, Mr. Akers after his death?
Virginia Edwards (41:14):
I did.
Lawyer 2 (41:14):
Did you have an opportunity to interact with this defendant at that service?
Virginia Edwards (41:18):
No.
Lawyer 2 (41:19):
Not at all? Did you have an opportunity to observe her demeanor?
Virginia Edwards (41:23):
Yes, twice.
Lawyer 2 (41:25):
How would you characterize that, please?
Virginia Edwards (41:31):
A little surprising. The first time I saw her through glass doors as she was out back and she was just loading herself up with body spray, and then the second time she came in the courtroom and didn't acknowledge any of us.
Lawyer 2 (41:47):
You say courtroom, I mean [inaudible 00:41:50].
Virginia Edwards (41:49):
I'm sorry. The church.
Lawyer 2 (41:50):
You're a little nervous?
Virginia Edwards (41:51):
Yeah, a little bit.
Lawyer 2 (41:52):
I'm sorry. Just act like we're just having a conversation. That's all we're doing, okay? So you meant like a service room or castle or something?
Virginia Edwards (41:59):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (41:59):
Okay. When you say you never saw her acknowledge any of us, who is us?
Virginia Edwards (42:08):
Everyone that was there for Dan. Me, his two daughters, all his family.
Lawyer 2 (42:27):
I don't want you to say anything that anybody told you or even Dan, but did you have any kind of personal knowledge from seeing things, from observing things about whether Dan was employed at the time of his death?
Virginia Edwards (42:45):
I 100 believed he was employed.
Lawyer 2 (42:46):
Do you have any reason to believe he was not?
Virginia Edwards (42:48):
Well, no, not at all.
Lawyer 2 (42:55):
Okay. Let me ask you this. Did you ever see Dan Akers with State's Exhibit 183, that silver pistol?
Virginia Edwards (43:01):
No.
Lawyer 2 (43:03):
Okay. And any pistol, did you see Dan Akers yourself personally with any kind of pistol or gun?
Virginia Edwards (43:07):
No.
Lawyer 2 (43:10):
As y'all were growing up and you knew him even into adulthood, did he like to go shooting on the woods or at a range or anything for sport?
Virginia Edwards (43:17):
No.
Lawyer 2 (43:22):
Did you ever see Dan Akers carry a holster with a gun in it?
Virginia Edwards (43:26):
No.
Lawyer 2 (43:29):
Did you ever see Dan Akers carry any kind of a firearm pistol in a pocket?
Virginia Edwards (43:36):
No.
Lawyer 2 (43:36):
In a hoodie?
Virginia Edwards (43:36):
No.
Lawyer 2 (44:04):
Would you recognize Dan? Do you have a recollection of what he looked like in life when he was alive.
Virginia Edwards (44:09):
Obviously.
Lawyer 2 (44:10):
May I approach opposing counsel please to show what's been marked for identification purposes only as State's two?
Judge (44:57):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (44:57):
Thank you. [inaudible 00:44:58]. May I approach the witness, please?
Judge (44:58):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (44:59):
Let me show you what's been marked for identification purposes on State's 228. See if you recognize that, okay? Do you recognize what's depicted in that photo?
Virginia Edwards (45:09):
Yeah. Dan?
Lawyer 2 (45:12):
You don't have to... How do you recognize what's depicted in the photo?
Virginia Edwards (45:20):
Do you mean as Dan?
Lawyer 2 (45:20):
Yeah-
Virginia Edwards (45:20):
Yeah, it's Dan.
Lawyer 2 (45:20):
Does it look like an accurate portrayal depiction of Dan that you knew in life?
Virginia Edwards (45:23):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (45:24):
Move the court respectfully to admit what's previously been marked for identification purposes only as State's Exhibit 228.
Judge (45:35):
Any objection?
Speaker 8 (45:37):
No, sir.
Judge (45:38):
All right. Admitted.
Lawyer 2 (45:39):
Thank you. Do you think this is close to what you remember Dan looking like toward the end of his life or is this an older photo? What do you remember?
Virginia Edwards (45:54):
No, it wasn't an old photo. I was there when it was taken.
Lawyer 2 (45:58):
Okay. Do you know when it was taken approximately?
Virginia Edwards (46:00):
October 11th, a couple of years before he passed.
Lawyer 2 (46:06):
Okay.
Virginia Edwards (46:08):
Maybe two.
Lawyer 2 (46:09):
Two years before he passes?
Virginia Edwards (46:09):
Mm-hmm.
Lawyer 2 (46:11):
Maybe a little dated, but not an extremely old photo?
Virginia Edwards (46:13):
No, no, no. Not at all.
Lawyer 2 (46:28):
After the memorial service or the remembrance service, did you ever see this defendant again till today?
Virginia Edwards (46:38):
Actually, I did once see her going into a tanning salon.
Lawyer 2 (46:44):
Is that the only time?
Virginia Edwards (46:44):
That was the only time.
Lawyer 2 (46:46):
That's all I have. Thank you.
Judge (46:47):
Ross?
Lawyer 2 (46:51):
They may have some questions.
Speaker 8 (46:51):
Can we approach, Judge?
Judge (46:51):
Sure.
Lawyer 2 (46:52):
May we have the defendant's waiver of presence of the bench on the record the first time?
Judge (46:55):
Yes. Okay.
Lawyer 2 (46:55):
We'll explain.
Judge (46:55):
Were you done with your questions [inaudible 00:51:23]?
Lawyer 2 (46:55):
Yes, Your Honor.
Judge (51:28):
Thank you. Okay. And defense?
Speaker 8 (51:29):
Thank you, Judge. We don't have any questions.
Judge (51:29):
Go ahead. Ma'am, thank you very much. You can be excused.
Virginia Edwards (51:29):
Thank you.
Judge (51:42):
Any objection from either party with her leaving the courtroom? You can [inaudible 00:51:47]
Speaker 8 (51:46):
She's...
Judge (51:47):
Go ahead.
Speaker 8 (51:48):
Go ahead. Until we maybe have a meeting at the break, I would ask her. After that meeting, it depends on how the court rules.
Judge (51:56):
That sounds fair. So ma'am, if you could remain outside at least until you're told otherwise, okay?
Speaker 8 (52:01):
Thank you.
Judge (52:01):
Thank you. Next witness.
Lawyer 1 (52:06):
State calls Aaron Edwards.
Judge (52:07):
Sir, good morning. I'm going to swear you in. Raise your right hand, please. Do you swear or affirm that the testimony you're about to give in this matter will be the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so help you God?
Aaron Edwards (53:15):
Yes, sir.
Judge (53:15):
Thank you, sir. Please have a seat.
Lawyer 1 (53:21):
Could you state your name please, sir?
Aaron Edwards (53:24):
Aaron Edwards.
Lawyer 1 (53:25):
And how are you employed?
Aaron Edwards (53:29):
I'm a sheet metal worker at BHW Metals.
Lawyer 1 (53:33):
And do you belong to any particular union?
Aaron Edwards (53:37):
Local 85.
Lawyer 1 (53:39):
And did you know an individual by the name of Daniel Akers?
Aaron Edwards (53:45):
Yes, sir.
Lawyer 1 (53:46):
How did you know Mr. Akers?
Aaron Edwards (53:48):
He was my uncle.
Lawyer 1 (53:55):
And how long have you known Mr. Akers?
Aaron Edwards (53:59):
My whole life.
Lawyer 1 (54:05):
And how often would you see Mr. Akers during the course of your life?
Aaron Edwards (54:13):
It varied, but once a week, a couple of times a week.
Lawyer 1 (54:25):
And when you saw him, what types of locations did you be seeing Mr. Akers?
Aaron Edwards (54:35):
Everywhere. My house, my grandparents' homes, his house.
Lawyer 1 (54:42):
And what did you call Mr. Akers? How did you address him?
Aaron Edwards (54:44):
Danny.
Lawyer 1 (54:46):
Danny? Okay. So when you saw Danny, did you continue to see him all the time during the course of his life?
Aaron Edwards (55:01):
Yes, sir. When he lived locally.
Lawyer 1 (55:05):
And when was the last time you saw Danny?
Aaron Edwards (55:16):
Probably Thanksgiving.
Lawyer 1 (55:21):
What Thanksgiving would that have been?
Aaron Edwards (55:22):
2019.
Lawyer 1 (55:24):
Okay. So that was a Thanksgiving before he died?
Aaron Edwards (55:26):
Yes, sir.
Lawyer 1 (55:27):
And where did you happen to see Danny?
Aaron Edwards (55:31):
We were at my grandparents' house.
Lawyer 1 (55:34):
And who- Oh,
Aaron Edwards (55:34):
I'm sorry. We were at my sister's house for that Thanksgiving.
Lawyer 1 (55:38):
Now, what sister's house were you at?
Aaron Edwards (55:42):
Amanda's.
Lawyer 1 (55:44):
And that's your sister?
Aaron Edwards (55:46):
Yes, sir.
Lawyer 1 (55:47):
And what kind of a gathering was that for Thanksgiving? About how many people were there?
Aaron Edwards (55:58):
20, maybe. 15, 20.
Lawyer 1 (56:01):
And when you saw Danny, who'd he come there with?
Aaron Edwards (56:10):
Lacy and their kids, their younger kids and his kids.
Lawyer 1 (56:16):
Okay. Now, when you say his younger kids, how many kids are his younger kids?
Aaron Edwards (56:23):
Three.
Lawyer 1 (56:25):
And then you said the other children. What other children was that?
Aaron Edwards (56:30):
Lindsey and Ava.
Lawyer 1 (56:32):
And they were also Mr. Akers' Danny's children as well?
Aaron Edwards (56:36):
Yes, sir.
Lawyer 1 (56:38):
Okay. Now, what was the atmosphere at this Thanksgiving gathering?
Aaron Edwards (56:45):
Typical, good.
Lawyer 1 (56:49):
Did you happen to see or pay attention to this defendant, Lacy Boles, at that gathering?
Aaron Edwards (56:57):
Not particularly.
Lawyer 1 (57:01):
Now, since you've been around this defendant several times, about how many times a week would you be around Danny?
Aaron Edwards (57:12):
It varied from a couple of times a week to we'd go a month sometimes. We were close, we would exchange messages and stuff, but I would see him often enough.
Lawyer 1 (57:33):
Now, did you ever work with Danny?
Aaron Edwards (57:35):
Yes, sir.
Lawyer 1 (57:36):
And where did you work with Danny?
Aaron Edwards (57:38):
It was a Piedmont Atlanta job. We both worked at Knox at the time, and we were on different job sites, but I would come work weekends with him when his job site had overtime available.
Lawyer 1 (57:55):
And how many years were you apart from Danny in life? What were your age differences?
Aaron Edwards (58:06):
We were five years apart.
Lawyer 1 (58:11):
And what kind of a relationship did you have with Danny as far as knowing his capacity to use a right hand or a left hand or something like that?
Aaron Edwards (58:28):
I knew Dan very well. He was one of my best friends. He was right-handed.
Lawyer 1 (58:39):
I'm sorry. Did you ever see him use his left hand to throw a ball or do anything with his left hand?
Aaron Edwards (58:46):
No, sir.
Lawyer 1 (58:49):
And you knew him from the time you were born about to when he died, is that right?
Aaron Edwards (58:57):
Yes, sir.
Lawyer 1 (59:07):
Now, when you would see Danny from time to time, was he ever with this defendant, and that's Lacy Boles? Do you recognize Lacy Boles in court this morning?
Aaron Edwards (59:23):
Yes, sir.
Lawyer 1 (59:24):
Can you point her out and describe what she's wearing?
Aaron Edwards (59:29):
She's over there. She's wearing a black jacket.
Lawyer 1 (59:32):
Let the record reflect he's identified the defendant, Lacy Boles. And when you would see him with this defendant, were you able to notice any type of relationship they had with each other? Did you ever become aware of that?
Aaron Edwards (59:59):
I was aware of it, of them having arguments and stuff, but aside from maybe Dan coming to stay at my house a time or two or stay at my grandparents a time or two, I feel like did a pretty good job of presenting themselves.
Lawyer 1 (01:00:28):
I'm sorry, go ahead.
Aaron Edwards (01:00:29):
Presenting the better side of the relationship, I guess I would say.
Lawyer 1 (01:00:32):
All right. Who called the shots in the relationship about what's going on from what you observed?
Aaron Edwards (01:00:40):
Oh, I couldn't tell you that.
Lawyer 1 (01:00:42):
All right. And did you ever see Danny in such a state that you were concerned about his mental wellbeing?
Aaron Edwards (01:00:57):
No, sir.
Lawyer 1 (01:00:59):
Did you ever see Danny in such a state that you felt like maybe mental health authorities might need to be contacted to help him in some situation he was struggling with?
Aaron Edwards (01:01:12):
No, sir.
Lawyer 1 (01:01:15):
Now, were you aware of any prescription drugs that Danny was on?
Aaron Edwards (01:01:21):
Yes, sir.
Lawyer 1 (01:01:22):
And what was that?
Aaron Edwards (01:01:24):
Adderall.
Lawyer 1 (01:01:32):
And what was the general mood of Danny? You said you never saw him and were concerned about his mental health. What was his mood generally when you were around him?
Aaron Edwards (01:01:51):
Happy, energetic.
Lawyer 1 (01:01:57):
You obviously were around him on Thanksgiving. Were you ever around him on Christmas?
Aaron Edwards (01:02:03):
Yeah, most years, yeah.
Lawyer 1 (01:02:07):
And what was his attitude around Christmastime?
Aaron Edwards (01:02:11):
Good. He was a family man.
Lawyer 1 (01:02:21):
That's all the questions I have here with me.
Speaker 8 (01:02:22):
Judge, can we approach?
Judge (01:02:39):
Yes. Can you wait until [inaudible 01:02:40] rests?
Speaker 8 (01:02:39):
Yes. All right.
Judge (01:06:26):
Ladies and gentlemen, let's take a coffee break, okay? Sir, will you do me a favor and wait outside until we discuss this?
Aaron Edwards (01:07:04):
Yes, sir.
Judge (01:07:36):
Y'all give me a minute and then we'll put on the record what we discussed.
Lawyer 2 (01:07:41):
Maybe just step out briefly outside, sir.
Judge (01:07:44):
Sure.
Lawyer 2 (01:07:44):
Thanks Your Honor.
Judge (01:07:45):
Victoria.
Speaker 9 (01:07:45):
[inaudible 01:07:57].
Judge (01:07:45):
[inaudible 01:07:59].
Mr. Steel (01:07:45):
[inaudible 01:08:01].
Judge (01:07:45):
[inaudible 01:17:45]
Mr. Steel (01:18:44):
When the court's ready, can I also give a case?
Judge (01:18:45):
Yeah, one sec please.
Mr. Steel (01:18:45):
Of course. [inaudible 01:18:47].
Judge (01:19:21):
Whenever you're ready, Mr. Steele.
Mr. Steel (01:19:24):
I'd just like the court to look at the parties of Franklin, F-R-A-N-K-L-I-N versus State. It's 251 Georgia 77. It's a concurrent opinion, but it's the majority opinion. The last three paragraphs, they're not numbered. It has a two next to it, but it's not division two.
Judge (01:19:46):
Okay. And I'm giving the court reporter a little time to search for something I asked her to look for. I'd like to give the lawyers a chance to put on the record what we discussed. In the last two bench conferences, it was the same thing, but I can start or I'll just let you... Why don't you go ahead, Mr. Steele?
Mr. Steel (01:22:53):
Sure. The first one was during Ms. Virginia Edwards' testimony today, Your Honor. We approached the bench with the knowledge of Ms. Bowles. Ms. Bowles is about to hear what happened. If she has any questions, we will answer them as well. But what my recollection is that Mr. Lale and I, and the two prosecutors, approached this honorable court's bench outside the presence of the court reporter and the jurors and Ms. Bowles. Ms. Bowles was in your courtroom and watched us approach and knew that we were approaching for this purpose. And I specifically stated potentially on the record that Ms. Bowles, for purposes of that conference, is waiving her right to be present under Georgia and Federal Constitution. I didn't say all that, but I said to Ms. Bowles we are waiving her presence. The issue discussed was that Ms. Virginia Edwards stated... I'm not saying that this is verbatim and we asked at the appropriate time for this honorable court to permit the court reporter to enlighten us what was actually said, but the prosecutor elicited testimony, " Did Ms. Edwards ever see Mr. Akers carry a gun?"
(01:24:06)
That's my notes. Of course, we'll go by the transcript. Ms. Edwards was excused without asking any questions. She did not remain in the courtroom pursuant to this honorable court's order because we were going to take this up at a later witness. What we asked for is we believe that testifying that never saw Mr. Akers carry a gun after she said that she's so close with him, they're brother and sister, they've been together her whole life. And that's misleading to the jury. And we'd like to test her knowledge of her relationship with her brother because there's a 2002 Cobb County plea of guilty by Mr. Akers to being a party to a crime, although it's him personally and the other gentleman who testified yesterday, burglarizing a home and firing a weapon and then pleading guilty to theft by receiving, I believe it was at least six firearms, different calibers. That's my memory.
(01:25:15)
The court said, "No, not at this time." That's the initial ruling. And I'm not saying it's not the permanent ruling, but that's what this honorable court said. It's Ms. Bowles' number, and I can't remember the exhibit number, but I will get it right now, it's the 2002 Cobb County guilty plea that I'm referring to. And it's... For the record, it's not in evidence at all. And it's number 144. Ms. Bowles. Then we had another witness who came, I believe right afterwards, Aaron, A-A-R-O-N, Edwards, also a family member of Mr. Akers. And during his testimony, the prosecutor said at the bench... Well, we approached the bench to answer your question, and we said again, Mr. Lale and I asked this honorable court to again permit us to test the witness's knowledge of Mr. Akers since he stated that he's very close, knows him, and that he described Mr. Akers as a family man.
(01:26:23)
I don't know many family men who commit crimes that Mr. Akers commits. I'm not trying to disparage him, I'm just challenging the witness, characterization that he's a family man. I believe that this is sympathy. I believe that it opens the door. Yes, the prosecutor said, "You've already..." You, being the defense, already proved Mr. Akers' prior convictions, got in the Douglas County case, the probation revocations, that there's a Cobb County case. I understand that, but there's another case in Cobb County that the jurors did not hear about, and we would like to test this witness's memory of, "Why do you call him a family man? Is this what you call a family man?" Now he may say, "He's changed." That's fine, but right now there's no change in here. And the court, at that point, I believe we broke and we stepped back. And I believe that is what happened outside the presence of Ms. Bowles, if I left something out.
Judge (01:27:24):
It was all argument about what evidence was [inaudible 01:27:28].
Mr. Steel (01:27:30):
That's my memory of what happened. The prosecutor's position was they were asking about Christmas, if Mr. Akers was... How was his demeanor at Christmas without limiting it to any Christmas, I think, but they may limit it to this Christmas we're talking about in 2019. And that's where happy came from and, "He's a family man." I believe that was the prosecutor's position.
Judge (01:27:56):
All right. So there's two things. Number one, I agree that's what was discussed perhaps with a little bit more detail now, but anything else you want to say because the motion is allowed as evidence?
Speaker 10 (01:28:15):
Your Honor, the state would point out for the record, obviously with Mr. Edwards' testimony, absolutely no mention of any gun was ever addressed with regard to anything. And the question that I recall that was put to Mr. Aaron Edwards was, "What was Danny Akers' demeanor at Christmas?" And I was expecting happy or whatever, but he said, "Happy," and, "He's a family man," which of course was not responsive to my question. And I don't believe that had any bearing on saying that this is a family man that never does anything wrong or anything like that. Obviously he knows this man. He knows he's known him all his life. He knows about those convictions, I'm sure. And that is not painting a picture of a wholesome individual in the entirety of his life.
(01:29:19)
And I don't believe that did open the door. I think that the issue before the court is whether these other items are more probative or prejudicial with regard to this witness's testimony and this victim. And I don't believe that there needs to be a pile on at this particular moment. And I would urge the court not to allow the defense to proceed with that.
Judge (01:29:45):
All right. One of the reasons I asked a court reporter to help me out, and she did, is because I want to know, is it a cumulative where we're getting multiple comments that look like good character? We know everybody just heard this witness say, " Family man," which is good character. And I know you didn't ask for that, but y'all have an obligation to, and I know you do, talk to witnesses outside and tell them what they can't get into. Then I heard some tests... And by the way, I've got the case that Mr. Steele just cited, the Franklin case, and I found another Hill versus State, H-I-L-L versus State, 243 Georgia Appeals 124, saying someone's a good father is good character evidence. And that's pretty similar to what we heard here. I heard testimony about him going to church, I think, with the family.
(01:30:37)
Donaldson v. State, 279 Georgia Appeals 407. That's evidence of good character. I heard evidence about him coaching the children, being a good worker. Holt v. State 2... I'm sorry, Holt, H-O-L-T, v. State, 352 Georgia Appeals 506, 2019 case, that's evidence of good character. So I just think there's a cumulative effect. I think you've opened the door. So that's my ruling. All right, let's get the jury back.
Mr. Steel (01:31:11):
May I approach you at the exhibit?
Judge (01:31:28):
Sure. Can we get our witness back, please?
(01:32:29)
Thank you. Welcome back, sir. You can have a seat. You're still under oath, okay?
Speaker 11 (01:32:36):
Okay.
Mr. Steel (01:32:44):
May I have one moment, Your Honor?
Judge (01:32:46):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (01:32:47):
Pardon me. How long have you known Mr. Akers?
Speaker 11 (01:33:25):
My whole life.
Mr. Steel (01:33:30):
I'm sorry for the loss.
Speaker 11 (01:33:33):
Thank you.
Mr. Steel (01:33:36):
Judge, we're going to need to approach again. We've just been given an exhibit by the defense. We need to approach again about your ruling, please.
Judge (01:33:47):
All right. Defense, you want to do that without the client's presence?
Mr. Steel (01:33:48):
Yes.
Judge (01:33:48):
Y'all worked it out? No? Okay.
Mr. Steel (01:33:48):
Sorry. [inaudible 01:34:24]. I think we're going to have to take one other thing in relation to the document up outside the place.
Judge (01:34:24):
Okay. I'm so sorry. So I don't forget, note from the jury says, "Jurors agree to work up to 8:00 on Monday and Tuesday and not work at all on Wednesday." That's court's Exhibit 8.
Mr. Steel (01:35:58):
Your Honor [inaudible 01:35:59]?
Lawyer 2 (01:35:58):
Mr. Edwards, can we step out? May I have him step out, Your Honor?
Judge (01:35:58):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (01:35:58):
Your Honor, we are [inaudible 01:36:32] but I think this is an important issue, respectfully, Your Honor. There's been a lot of... And I respect the court's ruling, but I think the court might have had some information that's not reflected on the sentence order. I was handed the document by Mr. Steele, I'm assuming means to the defense exhibits of the convictions out of Cobb County that we've been talking about that Your Honor's considered. They're limited to the four corners of the document. And the sentencing order says that Mr. Akers was only convicted on count three, which is theft by receipt. And there's been all kinds of argument in support of the admission of this evidence that he was shooting guns at people's house, that he was firing guns. That's just not in the sentence order. All he was convicted of is count three, theft by receiving a stolen firearm.
(01:37:15)
And as you know, Your Honor, that doesn't necessarily mean that this item was possessed or used or carried or transported or fired, which was what we [inaudible 01:37:25] that he was shooting at people's house during a burglary. That's just not on it. I mean, it's alleged, but he only pled guilty on count three, theft by receiving. That can be as simple as what we see frequently, somebody gets pulled over in a vehicle and there's a gun in the glove box and it's stolen, so somebody gets theft by receiving. So I think it's a far cry from what was advanced by the defense as far as the nature of this 24-year-old crime. And I just thought it might affect... Respectfully, I thought it might have bearing on the court's ruling that you just made that... Somebody who would commit theft by receiving cannot be a family man or put his character at issue to the point where his character could be refuted.
(01:38:08)
His good character could be refuted by theft by receiving, because that's what it boils down to. That's all it is. It's on the sentence work. So I don't know if it possibly affects the court's decision on the matter, but it's certainly a more... It's not a violent crime at this point like it was when we were arguing about this. Obviously now when we look at it, it's not violent. It's not the actual transportation or possession or firing of any firearms. So I think it's... Respectfully, I would never try to invade the purview of this court, but I think it's possibly something the court might find livable.
Judge (01:38:43):
All right. Well, the basis of the court's ruling was that I felt like the state had opened the door to good character evidence, and I think that theft by receiving is bad character evidence. So that wouldn't change my ruling.
Mr. Steel (01:38:58):
And just for the record to be complete, Your Honor, I disagree, but I do agree that there seems to be a page missing of the sentence. It says on the face of the indictment that Mr. Akers pled guilty to count two and three, which is what was announced, the firing the weapon into the doorway of Mr. Davis, causing criminal damage to property, as well as count three, which is, what, theft by receiving the six firearms. But what the prosecutor, and I'll show it to them just so that they're aware, it appears that the honorable Judge Lark Ingram in Cobb County wrote the sentencing sheet for count one and two, and it's missing. Then it has count three and four. And the reason I say that is because for the co-indictee who is a witness, Mr. P-O-A-G, he pled guilty to count one, two, and three. And what we have here is going to be the same as the sentencing sheet and it only goes on one page. It talks about count one and three and he pled guilty to count one, two, and three, Mr. Crow, but sentencing sheet has count one and three on page one. But then when you turn it over, then it has count two on a separate page. So I'm comfortable that we're just missing a page, but regardless, it's just the character door was-
Judge (01:40:36):
Okay.
Mr. Steel (01:40:37):
... open.
Judge (01:40:38):
Anything else?
Mr. Steel (01:40:38):
But I can show it to the prosecutors what I'm talking about if they want to see.
Lawyer 2 (01:40:41):
I would just ask that the cross-examination subject matter be limited to that receipt. That's all we have. It says count three and count three only. Whether or not there's a good faith basis that something's missing, then that's on the defense to produce the document for introduction as evidence in this case that he pled guilty to one, two, three or two or three or whatever. All we have is the sentence order which appears to me to be complete and it says guilty on count three. So I'd ask that it just be limited to that by receipt.
Mr. Steel (01:41:09):
And that's just factually wrong. On the face of the indictment, it says, "The defendant," meaning Mr. Akers, "Waives copy of the indictment, lists the witness's formal arraignment and pleads guilty to count two and three."
Judge (01:41:23):
And does it say what count two is?
Mr. Steel (01:41:24):
Yeah.
Judge (01:41:26):
Okay. Can I see it?
Mr. Steel (01:41:27):
Yeah. May I approach?
Judge (01:41:28):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (01:41:33):
And regarding just, your Honor, what's factually wrong, what I said is on the sentence order, it shows count three. How is it factually wrong that on the indictment it says two and three? What I said is factually correct. On the sentence order, which is all we have to show what he pled guilty to on the sentence order by the sentencing judge, it's count three only. Sometimes we're in court, we're busy, people sign accusations or indictments. That's not what matters. What matters is on the sentencing order. It couldn't be revoked for a count that he put on the sentencing order...
Lawyer 2 (01:42:00):
He couldn't be revoked for a count that he put on the sentencing order... I'm sorry, on a count that he put or a guilty plea that he put on the face of the indictment because he could be revoked for that if he were never sentenced to that because we have to go by the sentencing order.
Mr. Steel (01:42:14):
If it matters, we're clearly missing the first page of the sentencing because there's a count one and two that are not addressed in the sentence on three. And it says count four is nolle pros. He pled guilty count three. We're missing the additional page that shows count one should be nolle pros, that's the burglary, and count two is the sentence. I just don't want to... We don't have it, but we'll get it. It's the clerk's office. I'm confident in Cobb County they have it. We'll supplement the record.
(01:42:43)
But regardless, the face of that indictment says that he pled guilty to count two and three. And when you look at Mr. P-O-A-G, Mr. Poag's sentence, they're separated. We're just missing a page. If you keep going back, you'll see Mr. Poag and he has sentence on count one, two, and three and count four was nolle pros.
(01:43:06)
And the judge has it separated. She says counts one and three on one page and then count two and four on the next and count four, nolle pros. We're just missing a page. It's clearly omitted.
Lawyer 2 (01:43:19):
Isn't the onus of the movant for the admissibility of this evidence? Isn't the onus of clarity and completeness on the movant? We didn't produce this evidence. The defense did. And if they're missing a page, then we shouldn't have to... A theme of this case is we shouldn't have to guess. We shouldn't have to guess. Well, if the defense had gotten the entire exhibit, we wouldn't have to guess what Judge Ingram sentenced the guy to. It's incomplete. That's on the movant for the admissibility of the exhibit.
Judge (01:43:47):
But on the first page it says, and this is, I guess when they joined issue, he pleads guilty to counts two and three and then we see what counts two and three are.
Lawyer 2 (01:43:59):
Yes, sir. And as the court's seen and having experience with 100 times, there can be negotiations in the middle before the ultimate sentence. Somebody can sign up on the Boykin forms in the face of the indictment and further negotiations can go on. The prosecutor can change their mind and say, "That's fine. You just plead to count three" or whatever. And that's all we have on the sentence order for the exactitude of the matter that's at issue because all we have is to show that he was sentenced to count three. I just respectfully say that while what's on the face of the indictment could be indicative that he intended to plead to one and two or may have pled to one and two, all we have is that he pled to count three. And again, the onus of clarity and completeness is on the movement for the exhibit.
(01:44:48)
We can't just guess that he was convicted on one and two because what it says on the indictment. Now, Like I said, let's say that somebody brought him a petition to revoke his probation on count one and he came forward with a sentence order and said, "I only pled on count three. Here's the sentence order." And they said, "Well, you signed up on one and two on the indictment." That doesn't matter. You go by the sentence order. We don't have anything here to say he pled to one and two.
Judge (01:45:14):
I'm going to admit it and you can argue if you want about the significance of that.
Mr. Steel (01:45:22):
Thank you, sir.
Judge (01:45:28):
All right. Does anyone need a break? Are we ready to go forward?
(01:45:34)
All right. Let's get him back.
Judge (01:45:35):
Have a seat right there.
Speaker 15 (01:46:20):
I can't find it.
Judge (01:46:25):
Sir, welcome back. You can have a seat.
Aaron Edwards (01:46:27):
Thank you.
Judge (01:46:27):
Try to minimize that happening going forward.
(01:46:27)
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (01:46:37):
All right. Did you know that on Halloween of October 31, 2019, that Mr. Akers wrote a text message saying that he was depressed and lonely and sad? Did you know that?
Aaron Edwards (01:47:00):
No.
Mr. Steel (01:47:01):
Did you know that the next month, Mr. Akers wrote an email saying that he was in turmoil? I mean a text message, excuse me, that he was in turmoil?
Aaron Edwards (01:47:15):
No.
Mr. Steel (01:47:16):
Did you know that Mr. Akers ever said that he was going to bury Lacey and himself and the children would go to foster care? Were you aware of that?
Aaron Edwards (01:47:34):
No.
Mr. Steel (01:47:42):
To you during this time, he seemed okay, right?
Aaron Edwards (01:47:48):
He was okay.
Mr. Steel (01:47:50):
And did you know that the night before his God forbid death, so the night of Saturday, December 21, 2019, he was writing a text message how nobody looks at anyone but him if he can't support the family, can't feed the family, can't give shelter to the family? Did you know that?
Aaron Edwards (01:48:26):
No, sir.
Mr. Steel (01:48:26):
Were you aware that he was in bad financial strait, that he couldn't even take out $30 or $40 from a ATM machine?
Aaron Edwards (01:48:44):
I didn't know that. We've been there. I've been there, so it doesn't surprise me. He was an apprentice.
Mr. Steel (01:48:52):
Did you know it?
Aaron Edwards (01:48:54):
Yeah.
Mr. Steel (01:48:57):
Okay. And were you aware that in 2002, so we're going back 17 years before God forbid pass, were you aware that he pled guilty to criminal damage to property in the second degree by intentionally damaging the property of Mr. Davis in Cobb County to the window, the wall, the door and the furniture of Mr. Davis without Mr. Davis' consent by breaking the window and firing a gun, damage exceeding $500 along with a man named James Poag, P-O-A-G. Were you aware of that?
Aaron Edwards (01:49:42):
I don't remember that.
Mr. Steel (01:49:46):
Were you aware that on that same date in February 26th, 2002, that Mr. Akers, along with Mr. James Poag, P-O-A-G, received and disposed of stolen property by receiving stolen property, two nine millimeter handguns and four 40 caliber handguns, the property of Mr. Davis, that Mr. Akers knew and should have known that the property was stolen? Were you aware of that case too?
Aaron Edwards (01:50:22):
Oh, you're talking about when he was 16 and back in high school?
Mr. Steel (01:50:26):
Do you remember that?
Aaron Edwards (01:50:26):
I don't remember that. I was 12 years old at the time. 11.
Mr. Steel (01:50:30):
Say it one more time.
Aaron Edwards (01:50:32):
I don't remember that.
Mr. Steel (01:50:33):
I'm going to show you what's been marked and admitted. I move for the admission of Ms. Boles Number 143.
Lawyer 2 (01:50:39):
We have no more objection.
Mr. Steel (01:50:41):
May I approach?
Judge (01:50:42):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (01:50:43):
May I approach you?
Aaron Edwards (01:50:44):
Yeah.
Mr. Steel (01:50:52):
I'm just showing you Number 143. We're going to display it on the screen, okay?
Aaron Edwards (01:50:56):
Okay.
Mr. Steel (01:50:58):
You might have it right here.
Aaron Edwards (01:50:59):
Okay.
Mr. Steel (01:51:00):
May I approach the investigator?
Judge (01:51:18):
Yes.
Judge (01:51:18):
Ms. Boles 143.
Mr. Steel (01:51:22):
And sir, this is in evidence. This is a general bill of indictment. It says Superior Court of Cobb County. Do you see? I don't know if you can see where I'm pointing, but it's at the top right of the... There's a lot of writing on here. You see that? Cobb County or Cobb Superior Court?
Aaron Edwards (01:51:36):
Yep.
Mr. Steel (01:51:37):
And then it says, it's 2002, the March, April term, the state of Georgia versus... And do you know Mr. Poag?
Aaron Edwards (01:51:46):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (01:51:47):
And are you friends with him as well?
Aaron Edwards (01:51:50):
No. [inaudible 01:51:52]-
Mr. Steel (01:51:51):
He was more Ms. Akers' friend?
Aaron Edwards (01:51:53):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (01:51:54):
Okay. And then it said Daniel Lee Akers. You know who that is, of course.
Aaron Edwards (01:51:57):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (01:51:58):
That's the gentleman we're talking about, right?
Aaron Edwards (01:52:00):
Mm-hmm.
Mr. Steel (01:52:01):
You have to answer yes or no.
Aaron Edwards (01:52:02):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (01:52:03):
And this is a true bill, 18th day of April 2022, and this is a foreperson signature. And then if you can scroll up a little bit, if you don't mind. This is... I don't know if you recognize it. Do you know what a verification or a certification of a clerk of court is?
Aaron Edwards (01:52:21):
I see it.
Mr. Steel (01:52:22):
And that's right here. Do you recognize that as clerk of court of Cobb County's certification that these documents are accurate?
Aaron Edwards (01:52:31):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (01:52:32):
And then underneath it, it says that defendant herein... A defendant, that's what people are called if they're charged with a crime. Are you aware of that?
Aaron Edwards (01:52:44):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (01:52:46):
Okay. Waives a copy of the indictment to list the witnesses formal arraignment and pleads guilty. You see this counts two and three, Daniel Akers' signature, you see that?
Aaron Edwards (01:52:56):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (01:52:57):
Okay. And then that's his lawyer and this is the prosecutor. If you could turn... And then just for completeness, on this side, this is Mr. Poag. You see he pled guilty to count one, two, and three. You see that?
Aaron Edwards (01:53:13):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (01:53:14):
Okay. And if you just turn the page over.
(01:53:23)
I'm going to skip all this, but this is the grand jury. Have you ever been on a grand jury? Do you know what I'm talking about?
Aaron Edwards (01:53:29):
No, sir. All right.
Mr. Steel (01:53:30):
We're going to skip that and we're going to skip count one. We don't need that. We did not enter a plea to count one. When I say plea, a guilty plea, you know what I'm referring to?
Aaron Edwards (01:53:42):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (01:53:43):
Okay. But this is what I just read to you, just to be fair. Count two, this is what both Mr. Poag, but I'm really not interested in him, Mr. Akers, the grand juries aforesaid in the name behalf of the citizens of Georgia, charged and accused Mr. Poag and Mr. Akers with the offense of criminal damage to property in the second degree. You see that?
Aaron Edwards (01:54:06):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (01:54:06):
For that said accused that said means these two gentlemen in the county of Cobb, state of Georgia on the 26th day of February 2002 did intentionally damage the property of Mr. Davis, to wit, and that means they're going to explain it, a window, wall, door and furniture without the owner's consent by breaking said window and firing a gun, said damage exceeding $500 contrary to the law of said state, good order, peace, dignity thereof. You see that?
Aaron Edwards (01:54:40):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (01:54:40):
And then count three was pled guilty. You remember that from page one?
Aaron Edwards (01:54:44):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (01:54:44):
And this is just for Mr. Akers. It's Mr. Poag too, but I'm interested in Mr. Akers. The grand jurors aforehand named and behalf of Citizens of Georgia charged and accused Mr. Poag and Mr. Akers with the offense of theft by receiving stolen property for that said accused, that's Mr. Akers and Mr. Poag, but in the County of Cobb, state of Georgia on the 26th day of February 2002, received and disposed of stolen property, to wit: two nine millimeter handguns and four 40 caliber handguns. The property of Mr. Davis and Accused knew and should have known that the property, excuse me, said property were stolen and said property not having been received and disposed of with the intent to restore it to its own are contrary to the laws of the state, the good order, peace and dignity thereof. That's what it says, right?
Aaron Edwards (01:55:37):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (01:55:37):
All right. And were you aware that... Back up. Go. Go. Were you aware in 2009, Mr. Akers pled guilty to drug offenses in Douglas County? Are you aware of that?
Aaron Edwards (01:56:00):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (01:56:00):
Okay. And the jurors have already seen those documents. Were you aware his probation was revoked?
Aaron Edwards (01:56:08):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (01:56:09):
You know what I mean by person's not in prison, they're allowed to be at home, work, but they're under supervision by the governor? That's probation. Is that your understanding?
Aaron Edwards (01:56:19):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (01:56:20):
All right. And you knew he was on probation, right?
Aaron Edwards (01:56:22):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (01:56:22):
And you knew that while on probation, he was brought back to Douglas County Court for revocation, meaning according to judge, he wasn't following the judge's requirements and he had to be re-sentenced. Are you aware of that?
Aaron Edwards (01:56:37):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (01:56:38):
And then you aware in Cobb County again, he was arrested for other drug offenses? You aware of that?
Aaron Edwards (01:56:43):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (01:56:44):
And that was methamphetamine. Do you remember that?
Aaron Edwards (01:56:46):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (01:56:48):
And then you remember he was concerned, or did you know Mr. Akers, right around the time of his God forbid death, he was concerned that he was looking at going to prison on probation revocation until 2024? Were you aware of that?
Aaron Edwards (01:57:02):
No.
Mr. Steel (01:57:02):
Okay. All right. I want to thank you so much. We have... You're not telling the jury that Mr. Akers doesn't use his left hand. You're saying he's a righty. That's what you're saying, right?
Aaron Edwards (01:57:26):
I'm saying he doesn't use his left hand. Oh, to throw a ball.
Mr. Steel (01:57:30):
Say it one more time.
Aaron Edwards (01:57:31):
He does not use his left hand to throw a ball or shoot a gun.
Mr. Steel (01:57:36):
I mean, you never saw him throw a ball with his left hand?
Aaron Edwards (01:57:39):
No.
Mr. Steel (01:57:40):
But he uses his left hand, right?
Aaron Edwards (01:57:44):
As much as I use my left hand, yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (01:57:46):
Yeah.
Aaron Edwards (01:57:46):
Yeah.
Mr. Steel (01:57:47):
And you never saw him shoot a gun with his left hand?
Aaron Edwards (01:57:51):
No, sir.
Mr. Steel (01:57:52):
You saw him shoot a gun with his right hand?
Aaron Edwards (01:57:55):
I don't recall ever seeing him shoot a gun, to be honest.
Mr. Steel (01:57:57):
Okay. Then you wouldn't know which hand, I guess-
Aaron Edwards (01:58:00):
No.
Mr. Steel (01:58:00):
... he shoots it.
Aaron Edwards (01:58:00):
I wouldn't.
Mr. Steel (01:58:06):
Can I have one moment, Your Honor?
Judge (01:58:07):
Yes, sir.
Judge (01:58:10):
On [inaudible 01:58:11] something else.
Mr. Steel (01:58:29):
Can I show you what I'll mark as Ms. Boles Number 145?
Aaron Edwards (01:58:34):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (01:58:36):
Just give me one second. I have to show it to the prosecutor.
Judge (01:58:45):
[inaudible 01:58:45].
(01:58:45)
That's what she was saying. [inaudible 01:58:54].
Mr. Steel (01:59:36):
I'm not going to... Wait. I'm not going to. I'm withdrawing 145, Ms. Boles. I have no other questions. Thank you, Your Honor.
Judge (01:59:41):
All right. Redirect. You may.
Speaker 12 (01:59:49):
Now, Mr. Edwards, was there a time when Danny lived with you?
Aaron Edwards (01:59:57):
Yes. Well, I lived with him more.
Speaker 12 (02:00:01):
Okay. Well, what age was it that you lived with Danny?
Aaron Edwards (02:00:11):
Maybe 17 to 18 years old or a year, maybe two, I lived with him and my cousin Jessica in Douglasville. I would've been about somewhere around 18 years old.
Speaker 12 (02:00:28):
Okay. Did you live with him also or did he live with you when you were about 11?
Aaron Edwards (02:00:39):
Yes. Yes.
Speaker 12 (02:00:40):
Where did that occur?
Aaron Edwards (02:00:42):
That was at my parents' house in Powder Springs.
Speaker 12 (02:00:45):
That was in Cobb County?
Aaron Edwards (02:00:47):
Yes, sir.
Speaker 12 (02:00:49):
And how old was Danny at that point? Do you recall roughly how old he was? You were then-
Aaron Edwards (02:00:56):
I want to say Dan was around 16 years old when he came and lived with us.
Speaker 12 (02:01:02):
And you've known Danny all your life, you've known him?
Aaron Edwards (02:01:09):
Yes, sir.
Speaker 12 (02:01:09):
And everything this defense attorney brought up about Danny, you were aware of all the troubles he'd had in his life, weren't you?
Aaron Edwards (02:01:18):
Yes, sir.
Speaker 12 (02:01:20):
And you were asked what his demeanor was. You recall saying it was happy and that sort of thing, and then you added something and said, "Well, he was also a family man." Do you recall saying that?
Aaron Edwards (02:01:34):
Yes, sir.
Speaker 12 (02:01:38):
Now, what did you mean by him being a family man?
Aaron Edwards (02:01:44):
He was just all about the kids, all about us getting together and stuff. Actually, to go into that, my bachelor party, it was earlier that year, and I had invited him, I think it was in October of 2019.
Mr. Steel (02:02:06):
Objection to specific instances. It's the state's witness.
Judge (02:02:12):
Specific instances of character?
Mr. Steel (02:02:14):
Specific instances of character. It's the state's witness. I object.
Judge (02:02:19):
Okay. Next question.
Speaker 12 (02:02:20):
Well, let me rephrase the question then, Mr. Edwards. Do you remember on direct examination a while back, I asked you, were you aware of who controlled the relationship about who did what and determined who called the shots in the relationship?
Aaron Edwards (02:02:43):
Yes, sir.
Speaker 12 (02:02:43):
And do you recall one specific instance involving this defendant concerning your bachelor party?
Aaron Edwards (02:02:53):
Yes.
Speaker 12 (02:02:54):
And what do you recall about this defendant and your bachelor party concerning Danny?
Mr. Steel (02:03:02):
I'll object to specific instances, character, 404(b) notice, 403, asked and answered.
Speaker 12 (02:03:09):
I won't insist on it, Your Honor.
Judge (02:03:10):
Okay.
Speaker 12 (02:03:30):
The question that was initially put to you is you said that Danny was a family man. Do you recall me asking you that?
Aaron Edwards (02:03:36):
Yes, sir.
Speaker 12 (02:03:37):
And you started to answer it with a specific instance, but without addressing a particular exact moment in time.
Aaron Edwards (02:03:50):
Yes, sir.
Speaker 12 (02:03:50):
Can you tell me why you say that Danny was a family man, in your opinion, in spite of knowing all of these other things about his troubled past?
Aaron Edwards (02:04:00):
Yes, sir. His kids and Lacy always came first.
Judge (02:04:03):
[inaudible 02:04:08].
Speaker 12 (02:04:08):
That's all the questions I have.
Judge (02:04:08):
Any recross?
Mr. Steel (02:04:08):
No, sir.
Judge (02:04:12):
Sir, thank you very much for being here.
Aaron Edwards (02:04:14):
Thank you very much.
Judge (02:04:14):
We're done.
Aaron Edwards (02:04:14):
Yes, sir.
Judge (02:04:14):
Everybody good on the jury? Good? All right. Next witness.
Speaker 12 (02:04:14):
State calls Dwight Eason.
Judge (02:04:14):
[inaudible 02:04:45].
Speaker 13 (02:04:14):
Thank you.
Judge (02:04:14):
Mm-hmm.
Judge (02:05:34):
Hey. Good morning, sir. Let me swear you in, if you don't mind. Can you raise your right hand? Do you swear or affirm the testimony you're about to give in the matter before the court is the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so help you God?
Speaker 13 (02:05:35):
I do.
Judge (02:05:35):
Thank you, sir. Have a seat.
Speaker 12 (02:05:35):
Your Honor, could we take a brief recess just a moment?
Judge (02:05:35):
[inaudible 02:05:53].
Speaker 16 (02:05:35):
Yes.
Judge (02:05:35):
Do you see what I'm saying?
(02:05:35)
This is the court's?
Speaker 16 (02:05:35):
Yes.
Judge (02:05:35):
[inaudible 02:06:30] this one?
Mr. Steel (02:06:44):
No. No. No. No. Dylan, Dylan.
(02:06:44)
No, no, Todd. Todd, you're writing. He's here.
Speaker 12 (02:06:48):
Okay. He is listed. I'm sorry. The opposing counsel has indicated that his name was not provided to him prior to trial. I've found it hard to believe, but anything can happen.
Judge (02:06:54):
I think that's good. Okay.
Mr. Steel (02:06:55):
He's not a supplemental witness. You were right.
Speaker 12 (02:07:01):
Okay. All right.
Judge (02:07:03):
All right. Well, everybody's been taking breaks except court staff, so let's take just a quick five-minute break.
Speaker 12 (02:07:09):
Thank you, Your Honor.
Mr. Steel (02:07:09):
Sorry.
Judge (02:07:09):
[inaudible 02:07:13].
Speaker 14 (02:07:09):
[Inaudible 02:07:17]. He's there?
Judge (02:07:09):
[inaudible 02:07:21].
Speaker 14 (02:07:09):
Okay.
Judge (02:07:09):
[inaudible 02:14:20]? 14173.
(02:07:09)
[inaudible 02:14:29].
(02:07:09)
Right now.
(02:07:09)
Okay.
(02:07:09)
[inaudible 02:14:45].
(02:07:09)
That's right. Let's go. Let's start.
(02:07:09)
[inaudible 02:15:47].
(02:07:09)
Are we going to...
Lawyer 1 (02:16:47):
Sir, I believe you've been sworn, is that correct?
Dwight Eason (02:16:49):
Yes, sir.
Lawyer 1 (02:16:50):
And could you state your name?
Dwight Eason (02:16:51):
Dwight Eason.
Lawyer 1 (02:16:54):
And where do you live, Mr. Eason?
Dwight Eason (02:16:57):
I currently stay in Ohio, working up there for my company.
Lawyer 1 (02:17:03):
Who's your company?
Dwight Eason (02:17:04):
RF Knox.
Lawyer 1 (02:17:08):
How long have you worked for the Knox Company?
Dwight Eason (02:17:10):
Since 2004, so 22 years.
Lawyer 1 (02:17:15):
And how did you get here just to testify today?
Dwight Eason (02:17:24):
I drove.
Lawyer 1 (02:17:25):
All right, sir. And you drove from Ohio to here?
Dwight Eason (02:17:32):
Yep, last night.
Lawyer 1 (02:17:34):
All right, sir. And did you work for the Knox Company in 2019?
Dwight Eason (02:17:45):
Yes, sir.
Lawyer 1 (02:17:46):
And during the time you worked for the Knox Company in 2019, did you come in contact with a Daniel Lee Akers?
Dwight Eason (02:17:56):
Yes, sir. Me and him worked hand in hand. He was my apprentice.
Lawyer 1 (02:18:01):
He was your apprentice. And what does that mean?
Dwight Eason (02:18:06):
That means I was a field foreman and I get a group of guys that I work with every day. And so he was just one of my guys that I had. When he got hired on, he started working with me.
Lawyer 1 (02:18:22):
And when you say he worked with you, approximately how many days a week would he be working with you?
Dwight Eason (02:18:29):
Whatever we worked, five, six days a week. Yeah.
Lawyer 1 (02:18:33):
And what hours would you work with him?
Dwight Eason (02:18:36):
I believe on that Piedmont job, we were coming in at four o'clock in the morning and leaving at five o'clock in the afternoon, five or six o'clock.
Lawyer 1 (02:18:50):
And how many days a week was that?
Dwight Eason (02:18:52):
That was during the week. That was five days a week and then we'd work Saturdays on occasions.
Lawyer 1 (02:19:02):
Now, he was your apprentice. How dependable was he for coming to work and being able to rely on him being there?
Dwight Eason (02:19:12):
He was pretty dependable. He had a couple issues with his probation, which he'd shoot me a message and let me know that he'd have to take off, which we don't hold that against nobody.
Lawyer 1 (02:19:30):
And what actually did he do as your apprentice? What was his job?
Dwight Eason (02:19:39):
So starting out, I had to learn what he was capable of, but he's worked his way up where I was over seven different areas, and so I kind of handed him off an area. It's a place at Piedmont Hospital called the auditorium. So I was kind of letting him lead that area.
Lawyer 1 (02:20:04):
And when you say, "Letting him lead that area," what did that mean?
Dwight Eason (02:20:10):
That means that I gave him a set of drawings and he used to go install all the duct work. And if he had a question, he could call me or shoot a message.
Lawyer 2 (02:20:20):
Objection, Judge. Relevance.
Lawyer 1 (02:20:23):
Your Honor, I'm trying to lay the foundation for the kind of worker this man was and how dependable he was and how he was an asset to the company and was not about to lose his job. That's the whole point for this line of questioning.
Judge (02:20:37):
Go ahead. Overruled.
Lawyer 1 (02:20:40):
All right, sir. If you would continue. You were talking about you gave him a set of plans and he would, I guess, what would he do once you gave him the plans?
Dwight Eason (02:20:50):
So I had him and two other guys working in the auditorium. It was his job to go and work that area and finish all the duct work and install everything.
Lawyer 1 (02:21:02):
Well, who was in charge of these other two men that were working on that area?
Dwight Eason (02:21:09):
Technically me.
Lawyer 1 (02:21:11):
All right. And then have you ever heard the term right-hand man?
Dwight Eason (02:21:16):
Absolutely.
Lawyer 1 (02:21:17):
And what does that mean to you?
Dwight Eason (02:21:19):
As somebody that's dependable that I can count on.
Lawyer 1 (02:21:23):
And how would you classify Daniel Akers?
Dwight Eason (02:21:28):
He was very much my right-hand man and he would've been something in the future.
Lawyer 1 (02:21:35):
You say, "He would've been something in the future." What do you mean by that?
Dwight Eason (02:21:40):
He would-
Lawyer 2 (02:21:40):
Objection, relevance and speculation.
Judge (02:21:44):
All right. Sustained.
Lawyer 1 (02:21:46):
All right, sir. Did you ever have any concerns in observing Mr. Akers that his mental health was in crisis mode?
Dwight Eason (02:22:07):
No, sir.
Lawyer 1 (02:22:09):
Did you ever observe anything by Mr. Akers that would make you think, "Hey, we might contact some authorities, professionals to help address Mr. Akers in his emotional crisis," or anything like that?
Dwight Eason (02:22:26):
No, sir.
Lawyer 1 (02:22:36):
Now you worked with him, I mean, you're talking maybe 40, 60 hours a week, is that right?
Dwight Eason (02:22:44):
Yes, sir.
Lawyer 1 (02:22:46):
And were you able to know whether he was right-handed or left-handed?
Dwight Eason (02:22:52):
I mean, everything he did was with his right hand.
Lawyer 1 (02:22:57):
Did you ever see him use his left hand as a dominating hand in whatever he did?
Dwight Eason (02:23:07):
No.
Lawyer 1 (02:23:15):
And what about Mr. Akers' tools on the job? Did he have his own tools on the job?
Dwight Eason (02:23:24):
He did.
Lawyer 1 (02:23:26):
And what does that mean when you have your own tools on the job?
Dwight Eason (02:23:29):
So we are to supply our own sheet metal hand tools, which are snips, hammer, screwdriver, cheaters. I mean, just the base essentials, and then all power tools are provided by the company.
Lawyer 1 (02:23:45):
Being his supervisor, were you aware of his job being in jeopardy at all in December of 2019?
Dwight Eason (02:23:53):
No, sir.
Lawyer 1 (02:23:55):
And what was your attitude about him working once this one job was completed? What kind of position did you have in mind for him?
Dwight Eason (02:24:05):
It was just I'd have rolled him over to push him in another area.
Lawyer 1 (02:24:10):
So he was not going to lose the job at all?
Dwight Eason (02:24:13):
Absolutely not.
Lawyer 1 (02:24:15):
He just don't quit, he'd just go to another job?
Dwight Eason (02:24:16):
No. My job is to build people up. So I start with people down at the bottom and I work them up to take over more and more responsibilities.
Lawyer 1 (02:24:28):
And how was Mr. Akers fitting into that dynamic?
Dwight Eason (02:24:32):
Wonderful.
Lawyer 2 (02:24:40):
He's with you.
Judge (02:24:42):
It's cross-examination.
Lawyer 2 (02:24:44):
Thank you, Judge. No questions, sir. Thanks.
Judge (02:24:46):
Sir, thank you so much for being here. You're free to go.
Lawyer 1 (02:24:52):
Your Honor, I'd ask that Mr. Eason be released from this subpoena.
Judge (02:24:53):
[inaudible 02:24:59] Next witness.
Lawyer 1 (02:24:53):
May I approach opposing counsel just real briefly? Thank you. Mr. Browny. State calls Dr. Keith Lehman please.
Judge (02:26:22):
All right. Welcome, sir. Good morning. I'll swear you in, if you don't mind. Raise your right hand, receive an oath. Do you swear or affirm the testimony that you're about to give in the matter before the court will be the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so help you God?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:26:33):
I do.
Judge (02:26:34):
All right. Thank you. Please have a seat.
Lawyer 2 (02:26:43):
Good morning, sir. If you could please introduce yourself to this court and spell your first and last name.
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:26:48):
Yeah. My name is Keith Lehman. First name Keith, K-E-I-T-H. Last name Lehman, L-E-H-M-A-N.
Lawyer 2 (02:26:57):
How are you employed at this time, sir?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:26:59):
I'm employed as a medical examiner, a forensic pathologist. I work for the same medical examiner's office here in Georgia. It's part of the Georgia Bureau of Investigation.
Lawyer 2 (02:27:08):
Can you please give the jury an idea of your qualifications and education that allow you to hold a job as medical examiner with the Georgia Bureau of Investigation, please?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:27:18):
Yeah. I earned a degree in chemistry from Wake Forest University. I earned a medical degree from the Medical University of South Carolina. I successfully completed five years of residency training in the field of pathology at the University of North Carolina hospital system. And during my five years there, one of those years was spent doing a special year of study called a fellowship. That was in the field of forensic pathology, and that's the field that I work in now.
(02:27:51)
And then after my residency training in North Carolina, I did another year of fellowship training again in the field of forensic pathology, this time at the Fulton County Medical Examiner's Office, which is in Atlanta. I'm board certified in anatomic and clinical pathology, which basically means general pathology, and I'm board certified in the subspecialty field of forensic pathology, which is the field that I work in now. And I have a license to practice medicine in the state of Georgia.
Lawyer 2 (02:28:23):
Dr. Lehman, have you ever been tendered as an expert in the field of forensic pathology before in the state of Georgia?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:28:31):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (02:28:32):
How many times?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:28:33):
Over 300 times.
Lawyer 2 (02:28:35):
Any other states in this country where you've been tendered as an expert in the area of forensic pathology?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:28:41):
In North Carolina.
Lawyer 2 (02:28:43):
How many times, sir?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:28:49):
Probably, maybe, it's been a long time, but approximately 10 times.
Lawyer 2 (02:28:56):
Do you keep current with annual continuing education in your field that allows you to know and be abreast of the most recent changes in forensic pathology?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:29:07):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (02:29:07):
Do you attend conferences on that subject matter, forensic pathology?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:29:11):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (02:29:12):
Have you ever had a chance to leave one of those conferences?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:29:14):
No, I've never... I've given a presentation at a conference many years ago, so I guess, yeah, I guess I haven't led a conference, but I gave a presentation at a conference.
Lawyer 2 (02:29:26):
Have you authored any articles in your field of study?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:29:30):
No.
Lawyer 2 (02:29:32):
Tender the witness as an expert in an area of medical examination, forensic pathology.
Lawyer 1 (02:29:37):
No opposition, Your Honor.
Judge (02:29:39):
Go ahead.
Lawyer 2 (02:29:40):
Dr. Lehman, if you can please tell me, did you work in the medical field prior to working in the GBI?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:29:50):
No, I came directly out of my training. As soon as I finished my training, I came to work at the GBI and I worked there ever since. That was 27 years ago.
Lawyer 2 (02:30:03):
I see. All right. And as a medical examiner, do you know how many... Do you perform autopsies?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:30:09):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (02:30:09):
What is an autopsy?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:30:11):
So an autopsy is an examination of a body after death in order to make certain determinations, including determining what caused the death.
Lawyer 2 (02:30:21):
How many of those procedures have you undertaken, sir, completed?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:30:23):
Over 7,000.
Lawyer 2 (02:30:26):
7,000 autopsies?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:30:27):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (02:30:28):
All with GBI?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:30:30):
The large majority with the GBI. I did some at the Fulton County Medical Examiner's Office during my training there and in North Carolina during my residency training. I did some of those there as well.
Lawyer 2 (02:30:42):
Majority, overwhelming majority, would you say you were with the GBI?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:30:46):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (02:30:46):
As a GBI board certified medical examiner versus pathologist?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:30:51):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (02:30:52):
All right, sir. Can you tell the jury about the autopsy process, why you conduct autopsies?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:30:59):
Well, I think the main reason... There could be a number of reasons to conduct an autopsy. One reason is to determine what caused the death. Another reason may be to document findings that might help explain what happened to the person. It may be questions about circumstances surrounding the death. In certain cases, we're involved in confirming or establishing the identification of the body. For example, if the body is... The appearance is damaged by postmortem decomposition or thermal injury or some other or trauma, we can be involved in assisting with making the identification, collecting evidence from the body can be important features. So there's a number of reasons why you might... A number of goals we have in performing an autopsy, depending on the case itself.
Lawyer 2 (02:32:03):
And what is your jurisdiction? You mentioned you work in the Fulton County Medical Examiner's Office. What is your jurisdiction of the GBI currently?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:32:10):
Yes. So the GBI provides forensic pathology services for the state of Georgia, with the exception of the largest metropolitan Atlanta area counties of Fulton County, Cobb County, Gwinnett County, DeKalb County. They're big enough to where they have their own county medical examiner's office. So those counties handle their own forensic pathology, but we're available to provide forensic pathology services for the rest of the state of Georgia.
Lawyer 2 (02:32:46):
To your knowledge, does Paulding County have its own medical examiner's office?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:32:49):
No.
Lawyer 2 (02:32:49):
So if a person were to be deceased in Paulding County, is it possible that your office headquartered in, I guess Decatur would conduct an autopsy?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:33:00):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (02:33:01):
Is that in fact where you're headquartered at the GBI department, Division of Forensic Sciences headquarters in Decatur?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:33:07):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (02:33:07):
Is that primarily where you do your autopsies?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:33:09):
Yes, it is.
Lawyer 2 (02:33:11):
Tell the jury just the type of facility that is and just describe the room or facility in which you prepare and do the actual autopsies themselves, please.
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:33:21):
Yeah. So the GBI headquarters, the medical examiner's office is there. Also, I believe all of the divisions of the crime lab are there, the other divisions, the other departments, which would include toxicology and chemistry, the fingerprint department, the firearms department, they all have labs there. And there's an investigative division has offices there as well.
(02:33:55)
The medical examiner's office is there, where we perform the autopsies is, in that area, we have large coolers where we can store the bodies, both before the examinations and after the examinations to preserve the body. And the exam room that we use is a room where there's eight stations, where each station we can bring a different body out. So in that room, we could examine as many as eight bodies at a time. We have another room in the medical examiner's office that has two stations that we can also use if necessary.
Lawyer 2 (02:34:43):
In the course of your career, sir, as a forensic pathologist at the medical examiner's offices, have you ever had an opportunity to examine victims where the persons where the cause of death was gunshot wound?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:34:59):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (02:35:00):
Do you know how many times, approximately?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:35:02):
Yeah, I would estimate probably somewhere in the neighborhood of 1,000.
Lawyer 2 (02:35:09):
1,000 autopsies performed on gunshot wound victims?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:35:11):
Right. Over my career, yes.
Lawyer 2 (02:35:14):
You mentioned one of the reasons or focuses on conducting an autopsy is to determine manner of death and cause of death. Are those different?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:35:23):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (02:35:24):
Can you tell the jury how they're different and you could define both please?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:35:27):
Yeah. So the cause of death, it's a very specific process that causes the death. There's many, many different causes of death, and they can be a natural disease such as a heart attack, cancer, pneumonia. It can be traumatic. So we can have a gunshot wound or wounds. You can have blunt force injuries. You can have sharp force injuries. So there's different traumatic
causes of death. You can have death from toxins. So a significant percentage of the cases that we do are drug overdose deaths, so you can have acute drug toxicity. So there's many different types of cause of death. The cause of death is the very specific thing that results in the death.
(02:36:19)
And so manner of death is a classification system that we use. And here in Georgia, all the deaths get classified into one of five categories. One of those categories is natural. So if somebody dies as a result of a natural disease process like heart attack or cancer, then that's designated as a natural, that's classified as a natural death. If a person dies as a result of their own actions when they're attempting to take their own life, for example, if somebody shoots themself or if somebody hangs themself, that's a suicide. If a person dies under accidental circumstances, that would be an accident. And common accidental circumstances we see are people that die in automobile accidents and people that die from drug overdoses in a situation where they weren't trying to take their own life.
(02:37:26)
And then the fourth option we have for manner of death is homicide. Homicide is typically when a person dies as a result of the actions of one or more individuals, and it's usually where there's intent to injure. That doesn't cover all the cases, but that would cover the vast majority of the cases where somebody dies as a result of the actions of another individual, usually where there's intent to injure. And then the last choice we have for manner of death, if we can't make a determination whether the death should go under natural suicide, accident or homicide, we have the option to classify the death as undetermined.
Lawyer 2 (02:38:19):
So if a person were to shoot somebody else and the victim in that gunshot scenario did not survive, how would you classify that?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:38:31):
Yeah. I mean, yeah, if a person pointed a gun at somebody and intentionally pulled the trigger and resulted in a gunshot injury to the other person that caused their death, that would be a homicide.
Lawyer 2 (02:38:44):
Have you had familiarity in your job, sir, and Doctor... I apologize. Have you had familiarity in your job, Doctor, differentiating between homicide, suicide and natural death?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:38:56):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (02:38:57):
Is that something that you do on every autopsy?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:39:00):
Yeah. For every autopsy we do, we make a determination of manner of death. So we make a determination whether we think it's natural, accident, suicide, homicide or undetermined.
Lawyer 2 (02:39:13):
So you have that catchall number five, if you were unable to make a clinical diagnosis of the manner of death, you can say, "Undetermined."
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:39:20):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (02:39:34):
All right. Can you please tell the jury members, Doctor, just give us a roadmap of the autopsy process itself, please?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:39:43):
Yes. So the autopsy starts with gathering of information. We obtain information usually provided by the coroner's office, often in conjunction with a local law enforcement who investigate a death. Typically, if the coroner, as they're investigating in the death, feels like it's a kind of case that requires a forensic autopsy, an autopsy by our office. They will call us and provide us the information that they've gathered regarding the circumstances surrounding the death and what their examination of the body has shown either at the scene or at the hospital, if the person made it to the hospital.
(02:40:23)
And then we'll make a decision as to whether we think an forensic autopsy is warranted. And if we decide that it is, then the coroner's office will make arrangements to have the body transported to our office. They'll place the body in a body bag, label the body with identification tag to indicate who's in the bag, and then they'll have the body sent to our office.
(02:40:50)
When it arrives to our office, we'll check the body in, we'll put it in the cooler to preserve the body until such time as it's time to do the examination. And then when we actually examine the body, we'll bring the body out into the exam room. And in a case where we do a full autopsy, we'll examine first the outside of the body and do the external examination, and we're looking for any evidence of trauma or natural disease findings to help us understand what happened to the person.
Lawyer 2 (02:41:22):
Let me stop you right there because you're using the term we. Do you work with an assistant at times?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:41:27):
Yes. Yes.
Lawyer 2 (02:41:29):
Do you work with an assistant on every autopsy?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:41:31):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (02:41:32):
Is that person medically trained?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:41:34):
Yeah. Well, the people that we use, sometimes they have medical training before they come to us. If they don't, they'll be trained in our office.
Lawyer 2 (02:41:44):
What is that person's title? Just a medical examiner's assistant?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:41:48):
Yeah. In our office, we call them death investigation specialists. And so we train them to be able to gather investigative information, so do some investigation and to assist us with performing the autopsies. In addition to these DIS, death investigation specialists, we also have photographers that assist us.
Lawyer 2 (02:42:15):
Do you have other people within the GBI that do your job as well? Other physicians, right?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:42:20):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (02:42:21):
Can you tell the jury how many?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:42:23):
In the GBI, other forensic pathologists, we probably have, I don't know the exact number, probably around 15.
Lawyer 2 (02:42:31):
15 for the state, statewide, other than counties that have their own medical examiner's office?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:42:35):
Yes. That's just part of the state medical examiner's office, part of the GBI. Okay.
Lawyer 2 (02:42:42):
And I'm sorry, if you'll continue. I think you were up to external examination of the body.
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:42:48):
Yeah. So for the external examination, again, we're looking at the outside of the body, looking for any findings that might help us understand what happened to the person. We'll document any clothing on the body. We'll document any emergency medical devices. Sometimes the people that have died have received emergency medical treatment, so we'll make those documentations.
(02:43:10)
And part of what we do for documentation is we take photographs, so there will be photographs of the body. And depending on the type of case, we also may do X-rays. And then after the external examination, we perform an internal examination. So in the case of a full autopsy, we'll look inside the body, including inside the chest, inside the abdomen and pelvis. We'll examine the internal organs of the neck and we'll open the head. We'll remove the internal organs of the brain, the internal organs in the neck, the organs within the chest and abdominal and pelvis or pelvic region.
(02:43:50)
And then we will examine those organs, dissect those organs and examine them, and then we'll look back inside the body once the organs are removed to see if removal of the organs has uncovered any other findings. We're looking for any evidence of trauma or natural disease or any other findings that might help us understand what happened to the person.
(02:44:12)
During the autopsy, we'll collect different types of evidence depending on the case. We'll collect blood if it's available and often other body fluids. And then depending on the case, we may collect other pieces of evidence as well. And then at the conclusion of the autopsy, eventually the autopsy findings are compiled into a report that lists those findings, and it will also list the classification of the cause of death and the manner of death.
Lawyer 2 (02:44:44):
I want to back up just a moment. You mentioned terms of pathology and forensic pathology. Is there a difference?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:44:52):
Yeah. Pathology is a branch of medicine that involves examination of body tissues and sometimes body fluids. Most pathologists look at tissue from living people. So if you have a biopsy taken, that biopsy will typically get sent to the pathologist. The pathologist will look at it, including under the microscope, and make a diagnosis, usually a medical diagnosis. Is it cancer? Is it an infectious process? Is it some other kind of process? So most pathologists look at tissues from living people.
(02:45:31)
A forensic pathologist, our primary job is to perform autopsies, which as we stated is examination of a body of a deceased individual in order to make certain determinations, including determining what caused the death. So forensic pathology is a branch of pathology.
Lawyer 2 (02:45:50):
You mentioned homicide. You know, sir, Dr. Lehman, if you have this information, do you know what percentage of autopsies result in a finding of homicide?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:46:01):
In our office, I would say it's probably close to-
Lawyer 1 (02:46:05):
Excuse me, Counsel. Relevance.
Lawyer 2 (02:46:07):
It's absolutely relevant, Your Honor.
Judge (02:46:08):
Overruled.
Lawyer 2 (02:46:10):
What percentage of your manner of death findings in your office are homicide, sir?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:46:16):
I'd say approximately 15%.
Lawyer 2 (02:46:21):
15. Can you tell the jury please, what is the purpose of generating an autopsy report or a medical examination report?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:46:29):
Well, it's to provide a permanent record of what the autopsy findings are, and sometimes we'll list opinions that the pathologist had, including the opinion as to the cause and manner of death so that it preserves that information, that evidence that was seen. So in a case where you may get called to testify or questions may come up years later after the autopsy, you'll still have a record of what was identified during the autopsy, what the findings were.
Lawyer 2 (02:47:05):
You make a report in every autopsy?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:47:07):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (02:47:07):
Okay. Does that report stay with that case or that file, if you will, throughout its journey through the GBI?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:47:16):
Yeah, those materials are retained indefinitely. That information, yes.
Lawyer 2 (02:47:21):
All right. If I can please show opposing counsel what I'll mark for identification purposes on this, I believe State's Exhibit 229. Just may make sure that's what I have. Thank you. State's Exhibit 229. If I may approach opposing counsel, please. Thank you, sir.
Judge (02:48:01):
What number is that?
Lawyer 2 (02:48:03):
229, sir.
Judge (02:48:04):
Thank you.
Lawyer 2 (02:48:05):
Thank you. May I approach the witness, please?
Judge (02:48:06):
You may.
Lawyer 2 (02:48:07):
Sir, Dr. Lehman, let me show you what's been marked for identification purposes only as State's Exhibit 229 and ask you if you recognize that. Do you recognize that document, sir?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:48:44):
Yes, I do.
Lawyer 2 (02:48:44):
How do you recognize it, Dr. Lehman?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:48:46):
This is just from briefly reading through some of the different pages, this represents a copy of the autopsy report I prepared for the autopsy of Mr. Daniel Akers.
Lawyer 2 (02:49:01):
Do you recognize your signature on it?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:49:03):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (02:49:04):
Other than just maybe being a different photocopy, does it appear to be fair and accurate to the examination report that you made in the case of Daniel Akers?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:49:13):
Yes, best I can tell it is, yes.
Lawyer 2 (02:49:15):
Seeing you look through multiple pages of it, if you need to, you can do so again, but does it look like there's been any changes, alterations, deletions that would make it somehow not accurate as to the report you prepared after autopsy of Daniel Akers?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:49:39):
No, not that I can tell.
Lawyer 2 (02:49:41):
We move the court to admit into evidence what's been previously marked for identification purposes only as State's Exhibit 229.
Lawyer 1 (02:49:47):
I don't object for the purpose of the courtroom, but I'd like to discuss whether it goes out with the jury.
Judge (02:49:52):
It's admitted.
Lawyer 2 (02:49:54):
When you undertake an autopsy, if you could please give the jury an idea of any kind of documents or records-
Lawyer 2 (02:50:00):
... Jury an idea of any kind of documents or records or information from any source that you may consider other than the actual physical body you're examining?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:50:10):
Yeah. So we always get investigative information regarding the death. What were the circumstances surrounding the death may include medical history, social history such as drug alcohol use. That's information that we will always get. And that information is typically provided by the coroner's office, although sometimes it can be provided by local law enforcement as well.
(02:50:39)
Depending on the case, we may also look at additional records. We may review death scene photographs. We may review law enforcement reports. We may discuss the case. In addition to just receiving their initial report, we may call and discuss the case with local death investigators. It could be the coroner's office. It could be local law enforcement. If the GBI is involved in the investigation, we'll sometimes talk to the GBI agents about it. Sometimes, we'll review medical records. And like I said, sometimes, we'll review police investigation records too. It really just depends on what's necessary for the case.
Lawyer 2 (02:51:19):
So sometimes, you mentioned something you see a lot, unfortunately, auto accident cases where people that are deceased from auto accidents. Is it possible you might review medical records from the attending physicians at a hospital?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:51:35):
Yes, that's possible. Yes.
Lawyer 2 (02:51:37):
But more with a criminal type of case or suspected homicide case, do you ever have occasion to review law enforcement records?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:51:45):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (02:51:46):
Did you perform an autopsy on a person that you may have known to be named Daniel Akers in 2019 or early 2020?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:51:57):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (02:51:57):
Do you know the date you performed that autopsy, sir?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:51:59):
Yeah. I've got a copy of my report here. It was on December the 23rd of 2019.
Lawyer 2 (02:52:09):
May I approach the witness please?
Judge (02:52:10):
Yes, sir.
Lawyer 2 (02:52:10):
Permission to publish State's 229 please.
Judge (02:52:10):
Yes, sir.
Lawyer 2 (02:52:16):
Dr. Lehman, there's a monitor in front of you. You can look at that, although you've heard from some other people it's kind of blurry, so you may want to look at the big screen, but I want to take you through some of this information contained on State's 229 because I believe you said your report of this case, this autopsy report. So in this case, do you see the DOFS case number here ending in 419?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:52:41):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (02:52:41):
Would that be the unique conspicuous number that would follow this report or this subject, this case through the GBI as it winds its way through various divisions?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:52:53):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (02:52:54):
Does that number ever change, sir?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:52:55):
No.
Lawyer 2 (02:52:55):
Okay, sir. And then your report date, I see, I can't help but see here is different than what you just said. You said 12/23 of '19 was your examination date, but then we see here on State's 229, you see where it says May 25th, 2020?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:53:13):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (02:53:13):
Can you tell the jury why those dates might be different?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:53:17):
Yeah, because the date that the autopsy is performed where the examination of the body is performed is different because the date of the report is the date when the report is released. So we have to have time to prepare the report. And sometimes, there's other things we need to do other than just prepare the report.
(02:53:40)
We may need to wait on toxicology results or results from looking at tissue under the microscope. We may need follow up to get more investigative information. So there's a number of reasons of why, but the reports are in our office are basically never released on the day of the exam. We don't have the ability to get reports out that same day. I guess theoretically, it's possible. But I think in reality it doesn't happen.
Lawyer 2 (02:54:10):
So in this case, is it fair to say that about, looks like about five months elapsed between the examination of Aker's body and the release of the report. Is that right?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:54:22):
Yeah. Yeah. Approximately six months.
Lawyer 2 (02:54:24):
I'm sorry. Six months.
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:54:25):
Yeah.
Lawyer 2 (02:54:26):
I apologize. Six months. So during that six months, can you just give the jury, you mentioned, for example, you may have to wait on one of your colleagues in toxicology to give you something or you may be waiting on this or that. Can you give the jury an overall idea of what you were waiting on exactly in this case that may have taken that kind of time?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:54:46):
Yeah. Well, this case was presented to be, felt to be a straightforward self-inflicted gunshot wound. When we did the examination, the findings were highly unusual for a self-inflicted gunshot wound. So we needed to get in touch with law enforcement and collect more information, more investigative information about the circumstances surrounding the death.
(02:55:15)
So that's part of it. There was additional testing done in this case too. There was examination of the gun that was performed. And in a case like this, this type of case would have to be peer reviewed in our office too. It would go through an official peer review. So that means another medical examiner has to review the case and sign off on it.
(02:55:46)
And so those are some of the things, gathering additional information, having additional testing done and having a peer review done on the report. Those are some of the things that would've delayed, created a delay between when I did the examination of the body and when the report was released.
Lawyer 2 (02:56:06):
Can I get, Your Honor, ask the court for leave to dim the lights just a little bit.
Judge (02:56:11):
That'd be fine.
Lawyer 2 (02:56:12):
Thank you, sir.
(02:56:15)
Doctor, I'm going to go back to State's Exhibit 229 here, maybe on your screen in front of you, if you can read it. You see here where it says agency, Paulding County Coroner L, I think her name's Lindsey Eberhart?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:56:26):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (02:56:27):
So what does that mean as far as your report as part of your report? What can you tell the jury what that means?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:56:33):
Yeah. So this is part of just sort of the form for the GBI crime lab reports. I think probably all the different divisions might have this sort of part up on there. The part that I add in doesn't come until you get down to reason for examination. Everything above that is filled in by, I don't even know exactly. It's sort of the process of going through the crime lab and getting entered.
(02:57:06)
So I don't fill that information in. That just indicates where you specifically referenced Paulding County coroner. It was a death in Paulding County, so the Paulding County coroner's office had jurisdiction of it, and they were probably the agency that called us and gave us the initial information. And Lindsey Eberhart is the Paulding County coroner or was at the time.
Lawyer 2 (02:57:30):
If a person is in a car wreck, like you say out here on Highway 278, and they die unfortunately at Paulding Wellstar Hospital, for example, does the hospital release a body to you and ask for your autopsy findings or would that still go through the coroner? In other words, is the coroner only for suspected criminal cases or self-inflicted cases? Is there a difference?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:57:52):
Well, for us, it would almost always go through the coroner's office.
Lawyer 2 (02:58:00):
Okay. All right. Thank you, Doctor. If you can raise that up just a little bit. We'll get down to what you pointed out was where you come in, so to speak, in your reason for examination. Can you basically summarize what that section of your report would contain,, and why it's written there?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:58:17):
Yeah. That's just a very brief statement. It typically will indicate what some of the circumstances were surrounding the death and give an indication as to why the body was brought to our office because most people that die don't get a forensic autopsy. Most people that die don't come to the GBI. There's certain types of cases that do. And so that's an indication of why this person, Mr. Akers, came to our office.
Lawyer 2 (02:58:48):
If you see here where it says Daniel Akers was a 36-year-old man who, according to reports, shot himself in front of his wife, where does that information come from for you to put that in as a reason for examination?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:59:03):
The large majority of cases, we get that information from the coroner's office.
Lawyer 2 (02:59:07):
Okay. Do you have any reason to believe in this case that that information did not come from the coroner's office?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:59:22):
Yeah. I've got our investigative report here, and it indicates that it, in fact, did come from the coroner's office, that initial report.
Lawyer 2 (02:59:31):
Okay. Is it fair to say that's just a summary of how and with what information you received the body for examination?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:59:39):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (02:59:40):
All right, sir. And then we have your actual date and time of the autopsy process commencing at 10:50 AM. How long does it take to do?
Dr. Keith Lehman (02:59:52):
It depends on the case and how complex it is. Probably a simple autopsy might take an hour, but a complicated autopsy might take multiple hours or even most of a day.
Lawyer 2 (03:00:11):
Do you know how long, if you remember, estimate this autopsy took, you and your team to perform?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:00:16):
Just the examination of the body, I don't recall that. The autopsy itself wasn't a complicated autopsy. It may have taken two or three hours, a couple hours maybe.
Lawyer 2 (03:00:31):
When you're undertaking and actually performing the autopsy, sir, do you have access to high intensity light to show you what you do?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:00:40):
We do have lighting in a morgue, yes.
Lawyer 2 (03:00:45):
Is it just like what you see on TV, there'd be a table that the body's examined on? Is that fair?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:00:54):
It's a station. In our office, the bodies are on... When they are brought into our office, they're put on a rolling table, so a table on wheels. They're in the cooler on that table. And when it's time to do their examination, that table is rolled out to the autopsy station.
Lawyer 2 (03:01:18):
It may become more relevant later, but I want to go through the lighting just a little bit more. Is there an overhead light that you're able to use and the dentist that comes down on any kind of a stand or... Explain the lighting.
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:01:33):
We have, I think, approximately six, four or six lights that are movable, that are attached to the ceiling and that we can move around and focus the light.
Lawyer 2 (03:01:55):
Okay. Can you concentrate light on any specific area of the body you really want to pay close attention to?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:01:59):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (03:02:02):
You mentioned that there is an extensive photographic examination or photographic documentation of the body. Is that before the autopsy commences?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:02:13):
Yeah. We'll start out. We'll photograph the identification tag on the body bag before we even open the body bag. And then we'll open the body bag and we'll take photographs of the body before we really do any significant manipulation.
(03:02:29)
And then we'll take a photograph once the face is cleaned up. Sometimes, there may be material on the face, blood or vomit or something else, or sometimes, there's not. But once we have the body cleaned up, we'll do an ID shot, a facial shot. And then depending on the case, we may do additional photographs as well during various portions of the autopsy.
Lawyer 2 (03:02:52):
Is the death investigation specialist doing the photography or is that somebody else or is it you?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:02:57):
It's usually the photography. We have photographers. So if they're available, the photographers will take the photographs.
Lawyer 2 (03:03:03):
And if they're not available, it's the DIS?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:03:05):
The DIS will usually do it. And occasionally, we'll do it as well.
Lawyer 2 (03:03:10):
You being the physician?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:03:12):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (03:03:12):
In this case, do you remember who did the photographs?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:03:14):
No.
Lawyer 2 (03:03:14):
Have you had an opportunity to review the photographs?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:03:17):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (03:03:25):
Continue to go through your findings here. You see where it says presentation of body and associated items. Can you explain why you include that in the report and what your findings were in this case?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:03:38):
Yeah. So that's basically sort of the beginning of the case. The body's in a body bag, if the body's supine, make sure that the body bag has the identification to indicate who it is, make sure we pulled out the right body. And then basically just the initial overview, what clothing or personal effects may be with the body, what obvious foreign material might be on the body will typically get noted in that section as well.
Lawyer 2 (03:04:19):
I'm going to show opposing counsel, please, what I'll mark for identification purposes only as State's Exhibit 230, 231, 232, 233. Thank you. Thank you, sir. May I approach the witness, please?
Judge (03:05:34):
Yes, sir.
Lawyer 2 (03:05:38):
Sir, Dr. Lehman, let me show you what's been marked for identification purposes only as State's Exhibits 230, 31, 32 and 33. [inaudible 03:05:42] look at those. Okay. Have you had an opportunity to look at State's 230, 31, 32, 33?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:06:41):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (03:06:42):
Do you recognize those?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:06:51):
Two of them, I recognize.
Lawyer 2 (03:06:51):
Which ones?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:06:51):
233 and 230.
Lawyer 2 (03:06:52):
Okay. May I approach?
Judge (03:06:53):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (03:06:54):
We have 230 to 233. I'll ask you about these. So can add those others? You said you recognize 230 and 233?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:07:12):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (03:07:13):
Can you tell the jury how you recognize those?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:07:16):
Yeah. These appear to be photographs taken at the time of the autopsy of Mr. Akers. They've got the type of plaque that we use and the unique GBI crime lab case number is on that plaque.
Lawyer 2 (03:07:38):
Does that appear to be accurate, those 230 and 233? Do those appear to be accurate as far as that plaque, a DOFS board that you mentioned you remember it?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:07:49):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (03:07:50):
Any changes, alterations or deletions to 230 or 233 that make it not representative of that board or that placard from the DOFS?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:07:59):
No, not that I can see.
Lawyer 2 (03:08:01):
Respectfully, move the court to admit into evidence what's been previously marked for identification purposes only as... I think I'll just to stay in chronological order. If I can just renumber those, I'm going to say two... I'm going to see what Dr. Lehman's [inaudible 03:08:14] as 230 and 231.
Speaker 17 (03:08:16):
I don't have an objection.
Judge (03:08:17):
Those are admitted.
Speaker 17 (03:08:19):
All right.
Lawyer 2 (03:08:20):
That was already 230. So let me read number 233 as just 231, Doctor, just to stay in order. So 230 and 231, you recognize those?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:08:36):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (03:08:37):
Okay. May I publish these?
Judge (03:08:40):
Yes, sir.
Lawyer 2 (03:08:42):
230, you mentioned like a placard or board. Can you tell the jury how you recognize that and why this is important in your job, sir?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:08:52):
Yeah. So this is the kind of board we use that we put the unique case number for the case for each of the autopsies we perform. We generally start with a photograph of just the board just to show the case number, and then we'll use that board for some of the photographs that we take, including typically the photograph where we show the identification tags on the closed body bag and the overall shots where we're basically showing the body as it's received once we open the body bag, and we use it for the identification photograph as well.
Lawyer 2 (03:09:31):
And you see the number ending in 419 here?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:09:35):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (03:09:35):
Does that match the number on your autopsy report?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:09:38):
Yes, it does.
Lawyer 2 (03:09:39):
Also on 231, if I can show you that. Do you see a unique DOFS identifier tag ending in 419 on this photograph?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:09:48):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (03:09:52):
So when you see this kind of black vinyl or rubberized background and then there's a tag here, do you see that?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:10:02):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (03:10:02):
What's the significance of those items? What are we looking at?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:10:06):
Yeah. So the black material is the body bag itself. And then the yellow there, that's a plastic lock that goes through the two zippers on the body bag. So the body bag has two zippers that when the body bag is closed, those zippers are together.
(03:10:28)
To open the body bag, you move the zippers apart, and then you can open the body bag. So we receive the body. There's identification typically through these closed zippers, and then often there's a plastic seal that's present through the zippers as well.
Lawyer 2 (03:10:48):
The disaster bag or body bag, do you think, is that used to preserve the body in as perfect condition as it can possibly be until it gets to your table, your examination table?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:11:05):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (03:11:09):
If I can go back to Exhibit 229, please. Did you receive this body or do you have any indication, Dr. Lehman, that this body was received in such a way as you would question the integrity of the evidence that you're looking at?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:11:25):
No.
Lawyer 2 (03:11:30):
So you've documented what we just saw, and you say you saw the identification tags. And then you also say that there were clothing and personal effects worn on the body. Did you have an opportunity to examine those?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:11:45):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (03:11:48):
When it comes into you in that bag that we just looked at, you open that, you manipulate that yellow safety tag or whatever, and then what do you see? In this case, what did you see as far as the way the body was preserved in the back?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:12:02):
Yeah. So the body was supine. So Mr. Akers was on his back. There was a large amount of blood on the face, and he was wearing clothing, including a hooded shirt, pants on one foot. He had a boot and a sock, and then there was another boot and a sock that was with the body that it looked like it may have been removed so that an identification tag could be placed on that foot.
Lawyer 2 (03:12:33):
Is it typical for you, Doctor, when you receive a body that at least... Is there anything atypical about it being arrived to you fully clothed as it was when the person expired?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:12:48):
I'm sorry. Could you repeat that question?
Lawyer 2 (03:12:49):
Yeah, I'm sorry. Is it typical for you to get a body in the body bag and receive it, sir, at the laboratory with it being fully clothed?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:12:57):
That's common. It's not always the case, but it's commonly the case.
Lawyer 2 (03:13:04):
Sometimes, do you receive a body, I guess, maybe from a medical environment that may have been unclothed? When would you receive an unclothed body?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:13:12):
Well, if somebody died and they weren't wearing any clothes and they were pronounced at the scene, that would be one example. As you were indicating, sometimes people, especially if it's a witnessed collapse, someone's witnessed to become unresponsive, will call 911. Emergency responders will come and often carry the body, attempt to resuscitate the body, carry the body to a local hospital.
(03:13:39)
And during that process, the clothing is often removed so that the medical responders can better identify anything on the body that might require treatment, such as any trauma or wounds present. So it's common for bodies that make it to the hospital before they're pronounced dead to have the clothing removed that they may have been wearing at the time the incident occurred.
Lawyer 2 (03:14:03):
Does it help you in your job, sometimes, maybe not every time, but does it help you sometimes to examine the clothing?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:14:12):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (03:14:13):
Did you do that in this case?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:14:14):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (03:14:26):
Let me show you, Doctor, what I'll mark, correct? I'm or show opposing counsel first what I'll mark as State's Exhibit 232. May I approach opposing counsel, please?
Judge (03:15:15):
Yes, sir.
Lawyer 2 (03:15:15):
May I approach the witness?
Judge (03:15:15):
Yes, sir.
Lawyer 2 (03:15:22):
Doctor, let me show you what's been marked for identification purposes only as State's Exhibit 232. Do you recognize that?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:15:36):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (03:15:37):
How do you recognize that, sir?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:15:41):
This brown paper bag has instruction on it indicating, in part, the unique GBI crime lab case number given in this case, and it indicates that the contents represent a black hooded sweatshirt.
Lawyer 2 (03:16:00):
Do you see the unique identified number 419 on that anywhere, sir?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:16:04):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (03:16:07):
If I can just describe it for the jury, is what you're seeing, just a brown, large brown, like a big grocery bag, just for the record.
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:16:14):
Yeah. Yeah. That's right. Yes.
Lawyer 2 (03:16:16):
Is that typical of something that your office reviewed personally, one of your DISs would use to preserve evidence?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:16:21):
Yes, it is.
Lawyer 2 (03:16:24):
Are you familiar with that format, the bag with the evidence tape or DOFS tape on it?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:16:31):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (03:16:32):
Do you believe that that fairly and accurately represents the collection bag?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:16:41):
I'm sorry. I couldn't hear the last part.
Lawyer 2 (03:16:42):
Sir, do you believe that this State's Exhibit 232 fairly and accurately depicts the evidence collection bag containing a piece of clothing you may have examined in this case, sir?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:16:51):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (03:16:53):
Respectfully move the court to admit into evidence what's been previously marked for identification purposes under State's Exhibit 232.
Speaker 17 (03:17:00):
No opposition, Your Honor.
Judge (03:17:01):
Admitted.
Lawyer 2 (03:17:06):
Sir, there's some medical examination blogs in front of you. [inaudible 03:17:15] put those on. I have some more senses here, but I'll... May I approach the witness?
Judge (03:17:25):
Yes, sir.
Lawyer 2 (03:17:26):
Ask you to open State's Exhibit 232 and just see what's inside there. If you can, please.
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:17:27):
Open the bag and move the contents?
Lawyer 2 (03:17:27):
Yes, sir. Can you describe to the jury what you see as far as the contents of 232?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:19:07):
Yes, sir. There's another bag that's present inside the main bag.
Lawyer 2 (03:19:25):
How would you describe the article that you're holding now, the contents of 232, please?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:19:34):
Yeah. So this represents a hooded pullover sweatshirt.
Lawyer 2 (03:19:42):
Color, please?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:19:44):
Black.
Lawyer 2 (03:19:45):
Do you have any reason to believe this is not a article of clothing that you examined on or about December 23rd as part of your overall autopsy of this decedent, Daniel Akers?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:19:57):
No, I have no reason to think that.
Lawyer 2 (03:19:58):
Your Honor, I'm going to try to label, and I'll do it more securely in the break. But I'm going to label the interior of the contents of 232 as 232A, unless there's an objection.
Speaker 17 (03:20:08):
No opposition, Your Honor.
Judge (03:20:09):
Okay. That'd be fine.
Lawyer 2 (03:20:11):
Let me try to put 232A on there, Doctor, if I can. Okay. I'll just put 232A near the tag or back part of the hoodie, sir. So is this accurate to what you examined on December 23rd as part of your autopsy of this decedent, please?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:20:42):
Yes, it does appear to be.
Lawyer 2 (03:20:43):
Okay, sir. Do you see biological material on the hood?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:20:51):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (03:20:52):
What do you know that to be?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:20:53):
Well, it's consistent with blood. It's dried at this point, but it's consistent with blood.
Lawyer 2 (03:20:56):
Okay. Do you see biological material on the front?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:21:02):
There is some discoloration there.
Lawyer 2 (03:21:03):
Okay. May I approach the jury rail, please?
Judge (03:21:14):
Yes, sir.
Lawyer 2 (03:21:15):
Thank you. Is it fair to say the majority of the biological material would be around the hood in this shirt, sir?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:21:24):
It did appear to be during my examination, my brief examination just now.
Lawyer 2 (03:21:29):
I want you to take a look at the left sleeve of this State's Exhibit 232A, please. Take a look at that left sleeve or cuff of the hooded sweatshirt.
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:21:59):
Talking about this?
Lawyer 2 (03:22:00):
Yes, sir.
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:22:01):
This cuff?
Lawyer 2 (03:22:01):
Yes, sir. Left cuff of 232A, left sleeve.
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:22:06):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (03:22:06):
Have you had an opportunity to look at the cuff area?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:22:09):
The cuff area, yes.
Lawyer 2 (03:22:11):
Does it appear to have the same quantity or concentration of biologic material anywhere consistent with the hood?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:22:18):
No, I don't see anything that I can identify as material that looks like blood.
Lawyer 2 (03:22:29):
So is it possible you could put this under a microscope or have one of your colleagues in blood or serology go and dab it with a Q-tip or do testing on it to see the presence of blood? Would that be possible?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:22:45):
Yeah, I believe so. That wouldn't be our office. That would be another lab within the GBI crime lab.
Lawyer 2 (03:22:52):
Okay.
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:22:53):
They can test for blood. Yes, they can.
Lawyer 2 (03:22:55):
Serology might be able or trace evidence might be able to look at this more closely. But with your naked eye, sir, do you see any human biological evidence on the left cuff or left-hand area of State's Exhibit 232A? Any at all?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:23:11):
I did not.
Lawyer 2 (03:23:27):
Thank you. I just want to keep those on for just a minute, unless you're comfortable changing, but there'll be a series of these. Thank you. Did you have an opportunity to examine... Is it fair to say that the body came in supine position wearing that hoodie?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:23:49):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (03:23:52):
How do you remove or how does your team remove clothing? Is it cut away the way you opened that bag or is the person carefully unclothed?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:24:01):
It's typically... It's...
Lawyer 2 (03:24:00):
... carefully unclothed?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:24:01):
Typically, it's not cut. Certain circumstances we may cut clothing, but most of the time it's not cut, it's removed without cutting.
Lawyer 2 (03:24:17):
Let's show opposing counsel please what I'll mark for identification purposes only as State's Exhibit 233, please.
Speaker 18 (03:24:18):
Yes, sir.
Lawyer 2 (03:24:19):
Okay. Thank you. [inaudible 03:24:43] show what's been marked for identification purposes only as 233. Thank you. May I approach the witness please?
Judge (03:24:50):
Yes, sir.
Lawyer 2 (03:24:53):
Sir, let me show you what's been marked for identification purposes only as State's Exhibit 233 and ask if you recognize that.
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:25:13):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (03:25:15):
How do you recognize that?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:25:17):
It's a similar paper bag of the type we use for evidence. It's got evidence tape on it and it's got an inscription indicating... It includes the unique GBI crime lab number for this case.
Lawyer 2 (03:25:35):
Again, same question, is there anything about that bag that would make you doubt that that contains clothing that you may have examined in connection with Daniel Akers' autopsy?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:25:52):
No.
Lawyer 2 (03:25:52):
Respectfully, move the court to admit into evidence what's been marked for identification purposes [inaudible 03:25:53] 233. I think it's 233, right?
Speaker 18 (03:25:55):
No opposition, Your Honor.
Judge (03:25:57):
All right. That's admitted.
Lawyer 2 (03:26:09):
Let me make sure I have the [inaudible 03:26:00]. It's 232, so hopefully not [inaudible 03:26:06]. Can you please open and remove the contents of Bates 233? Can you please describe to the jury what you're seeing [inaudible 03:26:24] Bates 233?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:26:57):
There's another bag, evidence bag, inside of the main bag. Then also present, there's a piece of paper that has that same case number again on it, inscription including that case number.
Lawyer 2 (03:27:18):
Ending in 419?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:27:18):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (03:27:19):
Okay.
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:27:21):
That's correct. The contents are gray sweatpants.
Lawyer 2 (03:27:31):
All right, sir. Thank you. I'll label that, those sweatpants and move for admission of 233A, [inaudible 03:27:40].
Speaker 18 (03:27:39):
No opposition, Your Honor.
Judge (03:27:40):
All right. [inaudible 03:27:43] admitted.
Lawyer 2 (03:28:25):
Can I please show opposing counsel what I'll mark for identification purposes only as State's Exhibit 234? It's okay. Thank you, sir. May I approach a witness please?
Judge (03:28:38):
You may.
Lawyer 2 (03:28:39):
Sir, Dr. Lang, let me show you what I marked for identification purposes only as State's Exhibit 234. Okay. May I approach the witness?
Judge (03:28:57):
Yes, sir.
Lawyer 2 (03:28:57):
Thank you. Let me show you 234, sir. Do you recognize that?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:29:05):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (03:29:06):
How do you recognize that, sir?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:29:10):
It's similar to the others. It has a bag [inaudible 03:29:14] that is often used for evidence. It's got inscription including the same unique crime lab case number on it, and it's got an inscription indicating that the contents represent a white short-sleeved shirt.
Lawyer 2 (03:29:29):
Respectfully move the court to admit into evidence, what's been previously marked for identification purposes only as State's Exhibit 234.
Speaker 18 (03:29:36):
No opposition, sir.
Judge (03:29:37):
Admitted.
Lawyer 2 (03:29:41):
May I approach the witness?
Judge (03:29:41):
Yes, sir.
Lawyer 2 (03:29:42):
Please open that bag and show us the contents [inaudible 03:30:02]. If you can tell the jury what you're seeing as the contents of 234, please.
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:30:27):
There was another bag inside the main bag, and in addition to the other bag, there was this short-sleeved T-shirt.
Lawyer 2 (03:30:35):
Can you show both sides to the jury, please? Your Honor, I'd like to ask [inaudible 03:30:43] to identify the contents of 234... It's 234A, and move to [inaudible 03:30:50].
Speaker 18 (03:30:50):
No opposition, Your Honor.
Judge (03:30:51):
Admitted.
Lawyer 2 (03:31:09):
Thank you. If I can show you what I've marked now as 234A and see if you see any type of defect or any type of marking that would be notable to you in your examination of that [inaudible 03:31:21], sir.
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:31:27):
I don't see any obvious defects. There's a patchy staining in the shirt with material consistent with blood.
Lawyer 2 (03:32:41):
Okay, sir. Thank you. [inaudible 03:32:16]. May I approach opposing counsel [inaudible 03:32:19] for identification purposes only as State's 235. May I approach the witness, please?
Judge (03:32:43):
Yes, sir.
Lawyer 2 (03:32:43):
Sir, let me show you what I'll mark for identification purposes only as State's Exhibit 235. Do you recognize this item?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:32:54):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (03:32:56):
How do you recognize that, sir?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:32:59):
Yes, sir. There's an inscription on the bag, on this brown paper bag, indicating the same unique GBI crime lab case number given in this case and an inscription indicating a pair of brown boots, sir, indicating the brown boots that were present with Mr. Akers at the time of the autopsy.
Lawyer 2 (03:33:19):
Does that 235 have the same type of characteristics with the evidence tape, the brown collection bag? Anything causes you to believe that that is not accurate as to what you may have examined, sir?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:33:29):
No.
Lawyer 2 (03:33:32):
Okay, sir. Respectfully move the court to admit into evidence what's been marked for identification purposes only as State's Exhibit 235.
Speaker 18 (03:33:38):
No opposition, Your Honor.
Judge (03:33:39):
235 I think is already handed to me.
Lawyer 2 (03:33:42):
Sir, if I may approach the witness. Please take the scissors and remove the contents of 235. What are you seeing as the contents of 235, please?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:34:33):
It appears that there's another bag inside the main bag and then a pair of boots.
Lawyer 2 (03:34:37):
Is that something consistent to what you examined on 12/23/19 as part of this autopsy?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:34:47):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (03:34:49):
If I may approach, Your Honor, and ask for leave of court to admit the left boot, the contents of 235, as 235A, and the right boot content of 235 as 235B.
Speaker 18 (03:35:05):
No opposition, your Honor.
Judge (03:35:06):
All right. 235, 235A, and 235B are all admitted.
Lawyer 2 (03:35:12):
Thank you. We can bag them back up, sir. Thank you. Let me show opposing counsel what I'll mark for identification purposes only as State's Exhibit 236, please. May I approach the witness, please?
Judge (03:36:02):
Yes, sir.
Lawyer 2 (03:36:03):
Thank you. Sir, Dr. Lang, let me show you what's been previously marked for identification purposes only as State's Exhibit 236. If you'll look at that. Do you recognize that?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:36:20):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (03:36:21):
What is that to your knowledge, sir?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:36:24):
These appear to be the socks that were with Mr. Akers at the time of his autopsy, gray socks.
Lawyer 2 (03:36:30):
Do you have any reason to believe that that evidence collection bag is not the same or is in very similar condition as to when those items were bagged up?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:36:39):
No.
Lawyer 2 (03:36:39):
Do you recognize the manner of collection of the evidence, the brown paper bag, the BOFS evidence tape? Do you recognize that?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:36:52):
Yeah, I see it. It's in a brown paper bag. It's commonly used for evidence, and there's evidence tape on the bag.
Lawyer 2 (03:37:01):
All right, sir. Respectfully, move the court to admit into evidence what's been previously marked for identification purposes only State's Exhibit 236.
Speaker 18 (03:37:09):
No opposition, Your Honor.
Judge (03:37:10):
Admitted.
Lawyer 2 (03:37:10):
Thank you. You can open 236, just publish to the jury, sir.
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:37:32):
Similar to the other bags, there was another bag inside of this bag and there are balled up a pair of socks.
Lawyer 2 (03:37:43):
Okay. They were balled up together as one when you opened the bag, sir?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:37:47):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (03:37:48):
All right. Let's ball them back up and just we'll put... Your Honor, with leave of the court, I'll attach 236A to the contents of 236 and move to admit 236A as the bag of contents.
Speaker 18 (03:38:02):
No opposition, Your Honor.
Judge (03:38:04):
Admitted.
Lawyer 2 (03:38:05):
Thank you. Thank you. Sir, let me show you what's been previously entered into evidence as Defendant's 18. See if you recognize this.
Judge (03:38:33):
Thank you.
Lawyer 2 (03:38:42):
Defendant's Ms. Boles 18, do you recognize this? Do you recognize the clothing in this picture?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:38:53):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (03:38:54):
Okay. Does it appear to be consistent in color, type, with clothing that you examined as part of the 223 autopsy that we just looked at and was admitted to court?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:39:05):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (03:39:07):
Okay. One more, just because we don't have the lower portion of the decedent here. Can I show you please what's already been admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 47? This will show hopefully the lower part of the decedent. Do you see the boots there that may be consistent with what you just saw admitted into evidence?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:39:29):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (03:39:29):
All right, sir. All right. If I can go back to 229, State's 229, please, for publication, the report. All right. You have documented in your report, this is page one of State's 229, again on the screen, you've documented all the clothing; is that right?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:39:57):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (03:39:58):
What you've documented on your report, is that consistent with what we just saw in person in court as being admitted into evidence?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:40:03):
Yes. Consistent with those items, yes.
Lawyer 2 (03:40:07):
Anything missing or left off that you believe is not accurately portrayed in your report?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:40:12):
No.
Lawyer 2 (03:40:15):
Do you remember this sentence here, "There was a red band around the decedent's left wrist"?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:40:21):
I see that.
Lawyer 2 (03:40:22):
Okay. Did you attach any significance of it other than just noting it on the report?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:40:28):
No.
Lawyer 2 (03:40:30):
Okay, sir. Anything that sticks out in your mind what that might've been, a wristband or an entrance into a restaurant/club type of band? Do you remember?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:40:40):
I don't recall specifically, but it seems reasonable to suggest that it may have been a band that someone might receive, as you indicated, in entering into a club or a bar or some other establishment that does that sort of thing.
Lawyer 2 (03:41:00):
Okay. I don't want you to suppose or guess, but if a person did have a band or wristband like a club or bar or restaurant, would that be the type of notation that you would make in your report, the same as you made here?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:41:13):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (03:41:19):
Okay. Then you have put in your report what I asked you about. If you'll go up a little bit, Investigator Burke, I can show you here. Will you read what it says there? You wrote, "Prominent blood staining and blood clot are present on the face." Do you remember writing that?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:41:36):
I see that. That's in the report.
Lawyer 2 (03:41:38):
Yes, sir. I'm going to show you what's already been actually admitted into evidence as Ms. Boles or Defendant's Exhibit 47. May I approach opposing counsel?
Judge (03:41:54):
Yes, sir.
Lawyer 2 (03:41:55):
Thank you. Sir, let me show you Ms. Boles 47 as it's been identified for admission and it's been admitted. When you say there was extensive clotting and blood evidence on the face, is this what you saw when the body was... Is this the same or similar condition the face of the body was in when you unbagged it?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:42:21):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (03:42:23):
All right, sir. If you can just tell the jury what you see. May I approach the witness?
Judge (03:42:30):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (03:42:30):
I have a pointer if you need it, sir. Can you just tell the jury what notations you may have made concerning the condition of the face or the facial structure as you saw it upon admission for your autopsy?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:42:46):
I'm sorry, can you repeat the question?
Lawyer 2 (03:42:47):
Yeah. You put on your report there's clotting, there was major blood loss, whatever language you used in your report. What do you see on this picture that you would've indicated in your report as far as the condition of the face physically?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:43:00):
Yeah. The initial examination reveals prominent blood on the face, including blood... There's some areas where there's blood clotting and then there's other areas where it's not clotted. It's more liquid or possibly dry there, but all of the red and the dark color like that represents blood on the face.
Lawyer 2 (03:43:20):
[inaudible 03:43:23]. What is clotting then?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:43:31):
Clotting is a process whereby blood, which is normally liquid, becomes into solid form.
Lawyer 2 (03:43:41):
When would there be a time when the liquid blood would more become a solid form? How long does it take?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:43:49):
It could potentially clot over different timeframes. I don't know that there's a specific timeframe, but it could clot, I would expect, within minutes.
Lawyer 2 (03:44:01):
When you receive the body and you do an external examination of the face as is depicted in this Defense Exhibit 18, I believe it was, that we're looking at, what type of examination, if any, would you make of the body in this state?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:44:22):
We would note the presence of blood, any injuries that you might see, we would further look at those. If it's a case where it's a gunshot wound and we see a gunshot injury, we would go ahead and examine it before the body's cleaned up so that we could examine it before any gunshot residue might be wiped away.
Lawyer 2 (03:44:52):
All right. Did you undertake such an examination here in this case?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:44:55):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (03:44:56):
Tell the jury what you did and what your findings were with these.
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:45:00):
Yeah. Initially this case was portrayed to us as an intraoral gunshot wound, but believed to be a gunshot wound where a person puts the gun inside their mouth and then pulls the trigger. As we're cleaning the blood from the face, an injury became apparent that eventually was determined to be a gunshot wound to the right side of the nose.
Lawyer 2 (03:45:30):
Are there any other remarkable findings that you made when the body was in this state, sir, other than what you just said?
Dr. Keith Lehman (03:45:36):
No.
Lawyer 2 (03:45:41):
Thank you. Perhaps a good stopping point, Your Honor.
Judge (03:45:43):
All right. It is noon. We're going to take just a little bit longer for lunch so we can address something, so let's say 1:30 to be back, please. Thank you. All right. Do we need to talk about anything before we break for lunch?
Lawyer 2 (03:46:31):
Not for the State.
Speaker 18 (03:46:32):
Not on behalf of Ms. Boles, Your Honor.
Judge (03:46:33):
You have a good lunch. See you at 1:30.
Speaker 19 (03:58:00):
(silence)
Speaker 20 (04:32:00):
(Silent)
Judge (05:17:07):
Gentlemen, I'm ready when you all are.
Mr. Brian Steel (05:17:10):
Yes.
Judge (05:17:12):
Yes. All right, we'll get our witness.
Lawyer 2 (05:17:29):
Your Honor?
Judge (05:17:32):
Yeah, we need to get the witness back.
(05:17:42)
All right, we'll have the jury. Welcome back. Let's resume.
Lawyer 2 (05:18:37):
Good afternoon again, Dr. Lehman. Before we took a break, you talked a little bit about the nature of the decedent's face when he was removed from the disaster bag or body bag for examination. Why is it that you don't make all of your observations, and inquiries, and findings into the subject body with that blood and clotting on the face?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:19:07):
Well, because it's important, and the blood can cover up important findings, the blood and whatever else might be on the body. So it's important for us to clean the body surface so that we can get a good look at it to see clearly what injuries are there or other findings that might be important.
Lawyer 2 (05:19:28):
I can show opposing counsel what I'll mark, for identification purposes only, please, as State's Exhibit 237, 38, 239, please.
(05:19:58)
Thank you. May I approach the witness?
Judge (05:20:00):
Yes, Sir.
Lawyer 2 (05:20:01):
Sir, Dr. Lehman, let me show you what's been marked, for identification purposes only, as State's Exhibits 237, 38, and 39. I'll just ask you if you recognize those.
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:20:13):
Yes, I do.
Lawyer 2 (05:20:13):
How do you recognize those, Sir?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:20:14):
These are photographs taken during the autopsy of Mr. Akers.
Lawyer 2 (05:20:19):
Do those photographs fairly and accurately depict the state of the decedent or the subject of your examination on 12/23/19 to the best of your recollection?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:20:29):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (05:20:30):
Any changes, or alterations, or deletions that may have been made to those photographs that make them not representative of what you saw during your examination?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:20:36):
No.
Lawyer 2 (05:20:40):
Respectfully move the court to admit into evidence what's been previously marked, for identification purposes only, State's Exhibit 237, 238, 239.
Mr. Brian Steel (05:20:47):
No objection, Your Honor.
Judge (05:20:50):
Admitted.
Lawyer 2 (05:20:50):
Thank you.
(05:20:54)
So I'll take these from you, Sir. Let me just start with 237. Before the break, we were looking at... Would you agree, just to refresh your recollection, we were looking at the face of Daniel Akers with the blood and the clot? Do you remember that?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:21:09):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (05:21:10):
And then, is that the way that the body was first presented to you for examination?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:21:14):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (05:21:14):
Okay, Sir. And then take a look at 237, please?
(05:21:15)
We see that placard there at the bottom. If you move it up just a little bit, should end in case number ending in 419, right?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:21:31):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (05:21:31):
Same GBI DOFS case number. So, obviously, the pictures before the break were much different than this picture, State's 237. What has happened to the decedent's body between those two photographs, the one with the clotting and then, now, State's 237?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:21:54):
So, we've removed the clothing from the body and we've cleaned the surface of the body so that we can see more clearly what might be there or what might not be there on the body surface.
Lawyer 2 (05:22:08):
And please tell the jury, Dr. Lehman, what is the method or mechanism that's employed to clean all of that matter away from the face and have the body represent what we see in 237?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:22:21):
Typically, to clean the body, we'll use towels with soapy water. That's usually what's used to clean it. Sometimes, there's not very much, you could use a dry towel.
Lawyer 2 (05:22:34):
Do you use any kind of abrasive, heavy cleaning instruments to scrape the body, for example?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:22:39):
No. No, no, no, we do not.
Lawyer 2 (05:22:42):
Would you use anything... And when I say you, I mean yourself, doctor, or your DIS staff, or your assistants. Would you use anything that would leave any... that would really alter the condition of the face, the nose, anything like that, from when it first came in to you for examination?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:22:59):
No.
Lawyer 2 (05:23:01):
Okay. Why not? Is it important to maintain it?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:23:04):
Yeah.
Lawyer 2 (05:23:05):
What it was?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:23:06):
Yes, yeah. We don't want to... We want to know what abnormalities are on the body, but we don't want to create any abnormalities by cleaning process. We want the body to be as preserved as possible.
Lawyer 2 (05:23:21):
You say that the body came in and you had information, either from the coroner or together with law enforcement, that this was, you said, intraoral shooting, to the best of your knowledge at first. Do you remember that?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:23:33):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (05:23:34):
But during the examination of the physical body, the face specifically, the way it was originally with the blood and the clotted blood, did you say, at that time, you made a different determination as to entry wound point?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:23:46):
Well, once we started cleaning the body, then we discovered this wound here on the... Well, I said this wound here, but the wound that you can see on this photograph on the right side of the nose. We discovered this wound. And eventually, as we further cleaned and examined the body, we realized that the gunshot wound wasn't an intraoral gunshot wound. It was a gunshot wound to the nose.
Lawyer 2 (05:24:14):
If I may show you that, Sir, on the State's Exhibit 238 and see if that better shows what you found during the cleaning process? Do you recognize 238 now?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:24:25):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (05:24:26):
And does that show specifically the decedent's right nostril? Does that show more clearly what you... Does it describe what you found during the cleaning process?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:24:36):
Yeah. As we started to clean, we saw this wound, and the wound is actually... I'll demonstrate with the pointer here. This area right here, it's area of a red discoloration. There's a tearing of the tissue there, and there's what we call marginal abrasion or a scrape-type injury around that laceration. Those are features that you typically see with a gunshot entrance wound, so where a bullet enters the body, impacts the body, and then enters the body.
Lawyer 2 (05:25:12):
Sir, did you note at all any type of what I, as a lay person, would just call exit wound? Did you notice anything that you would say might be called exit?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:25:22):
No.
Lawyer 2 (05:25:23):
Does this then mean, Sir, that then the projectile remained enlodged in the body?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:25:31):
Yes, and we confirmed that upon internal examination that that was the case.
Lawyer 2 (05:25:38):
Okay. Did you perform radiological testing on the body to see if you could find that projectile inside the skull?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:25:44):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (05:26:14):
I'd like to show opposing counsel what I'll mark, for identification purposes only, the State's Exhibit 240, please.
(05:26:21)
Thank you.
(05:26:21)
May I approach opposing counsel?
Judge (05:26:21):
Yes, Sir.
Lawyer 2 (05:26:22):
Thank you. Showing opposing counsel 240. May I approach the witness, Your Honor?
Judge (05:26:23):
Yes, Sir.
Lawyer 2 (05:26:23):
Dr. Lehman, let me show you just what I'll mark, for identification purposes only, State's Exhibit 240. Do you recognize that?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:26:25):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (05:26:26):
How do you recognize that, Sir?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:26:28):
This appears to be portion of an x-ray taken during the autopsy of Mr. Akers.
Lawyer 2 (05:26:35):
Do you have that capability of the laboratory to order x-rays or radiological film to be performed on bodies as part of your autopsy?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:26:43):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (05:26:44):
Does that State's 240 appear fairly and accurately depict radiological reports that you viewed in conjunction with your autopsy here?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:26:53):
I'm sorry, could you repeat?
Lawyer 2 (05:26:54):
Yeah, yeah. Does it look like x-ray film that you may have looked at as part of your autopsy process here with this [inaudible 05:27:01]?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:27:01):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (05:27:02):
Does it fairly and accurately depict the radiological film that you reviewed?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:27:06):
Yes, it does appear to.
Lawyer 2 (05:27:08):
Do you think it... Other than being a photograph, has it been materially altered in any way to make it somehow not accurate?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:27:14):
Not that I can see, no.
Lawyer 2 (05:27:16):
Respectfully move the court to admit into evidence what's been previously marked, for identification purposes only, the State's Exhibit 240.
Mr. Brian Steel (05:27:22):
No opposition, Your Honor.
Judge (05:27:24):
It's admitted.
Lawyer 2 (05:27:25):
Thank you. Let me see if I can take that back real quick, Dr. Lehman, State's 240. You said that you didn't see an exit wound. And based on that, did you suspect that the projectile possibly could still be in the cranial cavity?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:27:42):
Yeah. One of the first things we do is an x-ray. So, before we even opened the body, we saw what looked like a bullet inside the... in the head region. So, at that point, we suspected that that was the... We likely suspected at that point that that was the bullet that corresponded with the gunshot wound to the nose.
Lawyer 2 (05:28:05):
I'm having just a little bit of a hard time following the chronology of it, if you'll bear with me. Did you order radiological examination prior to your physical examination, or after?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:28:14):
Prior.
Lawyer 2 (05:28:15):
Okay. So, is that customary that you would do radiological examinations on all autopsies that you think there might be a reason for prior to your physical examination?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:28:26):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (05:28:27):
And you may not do radiological examination on everybody, but if you feel there's a need to, you order that first?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:28:34):
Well, usually, yeah, if it's a... Based on the case information, certain types of cases automatically get x-rayed. It's possible you may not think a case needs an x-ray. And then, during the autopsy, you may have a finding where you're like, "Okay, let's go back and do an x-ray." But usually, we know ahead of time if an x-ray needs to be performed, and the x-ray is done for the initial examination.
Lawyer 2 (05:28:55):
Do you remember if you reviewed these x-ray films before or after the physical examination?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:29:01):
I don't remember.
Lawyer 2 (05:29:01):
Okay. It could be either way?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:29:05):
Yes, correct.
Lawyer 2 (05:29:06):
And once you determined that, upon your physical examination of the cranial cavity or the exterior of the head, you saw no exit wound, then was it important for you to go look at the x-rays?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:29:21):
Yes, it would be important. Yeah, it would be important to look at the x-rays regardless.
Lawyer 2 (05:29:24):
Okay. And did that confirm then that it appeared to be a projectile still in the cranial cavity?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:29:28):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (05:29:30):
Do you see that here on State's Exhibit 240? Is that what that is?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:29:38):
That's correct, yes.
Lawyer 2 (05:29:39):
Is this the largest portion of the projectile remaining inside the cranial cavity?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:29:42):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (05:29:43):
Do you see... Looks like... I'm starting with around the center of State's 240. Do you see those dots, those small dots there, and then there's a dot over here at the 9:00 region?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:29:57):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (05:29:59):
Do those have any significance for you in your radiological evaluation?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:30:02):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (05:30:02):
Can you tell the jury why?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:30:04):
Yeah. Those appear to be small fragments of the bullet that broke off from the bullet as it traveled through the head, especially after it struck some part of the body, especially that strikes bone. And you can kind of see a linear pattern, a faint linear pattern from the nose region into the intracranial cavity, which is the cavity where the brain is located, leading all the way up to the large fragment in the back of the head, which represents the main bullet.
Lawyer 2 (05:30:37):
Does this show for you perhaps almost a bullet pathway or trajectory up through the skull cavity there?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:30:44):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (05:30:45):
Starting with the fragments and then, finally, ending with the largest piece of projectile remaining?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:30:52):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (05:30:52):
All right. Is it common in your experience in your examinations, the performance of autopsies, that you will see a bullet or projectile fragment in that manner?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:31:01):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (05:31:04):
Were you able to collect and recover the large fragment there?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:31:09):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (05:31:09):
As well as the small fragments?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:31:10):
It's not...
(05:31:25)
I believe we only recovered the large fragment, which is the... The very small fragments are generally not useful for examination purposes, so it's not necessary for us to collect those.
Lawyer 2 (05:31:39):
All right. But you did discover... or excuse me, recover the largest bullet fragment that lodged on this picture, State's 240, toward the far left?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:31:46):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (05:31:49):
I can show opposing counsel what I'll mark, for identification purposes only, please, as State's Exhibit 241.
Judge (05:31:54):
[inaudible 05:31:56].
Lawyer 2 (05:31:55):
Let me show you what's been marked, for identification purposes only, as 241. Do you recognize that?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:32:05):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (05:32:06):
What is that, Sir?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:32:08):
That's a photograph of a bullet that was recovered from the brain of Mr. Akers.
Lawyer 2 (05:32:13):
Does it fairly and accurately depict what was recovered from the cranial cavity of Mr. Akers as you saw on or about 12/23/2019?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:32:23):
Yeah, it does appear to.
Lawyer 2 (05:32:26):
Is that a common photograph that would have been taken as part and parcel of the autopsy procedure?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:32:31):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (05:32:32):
As far as anything that was recovered?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:32:33):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (05:32:34):
Do you think that that's been altered or changed in any manner that make it somehow not accurate?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:32:38):
Not that I can see.
Lawyer 2 (05:32:39):
Respectfully move the court to admit into evidence what's been previously marked, for identification purposes only, the State's Exhibit 241.
Mr. Brian Steel (05:32:42):
No objection, Your Honor.
Judge (05:32:42):
Admitted.
Lawyer 2 (05:32:43):
Excuse me. I can take that from Dr. Lehman, 241. Thank you.
(05:32:43)
So, here on 241, if you'll look at that, do you still see that unique identified case number ending in 419?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:33:05):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (05:33:06):
Okay. So you have the subject name up at the top here, Daniel Akers. Do you see that?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:33:14):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (05:33:15):
And 36 year, white male, is that the... See that, 36Y, WM?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:33:22):
That's correct, yes.
Lawyer 2 (05:33:24):
All right. And then we have the date again of the autopsy, right? 12/23/19? Do you see that?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:33:30):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (05:33:30):
And you say... Someone wrote brain here. I don't know who. Is it fair that that's just giving the general location of where this was recovered?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:33:39):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (05:33:41):
And if you see... Can you describe the defect in the projectile that you see? And if you can maybe zoom in just a little bit, Investigator Burke? You'll just explain the defect in the projectile and tell the jury how and why that would happen. If we were to assume that the projectile started out as being conical, as would be, I guess, typical conical bullet or rounded bullet, how does it mushroom and become defective like this, please?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:34:15):
Well, a bullet won't deform until it strikes something. So, in this case, as the bullet enters the body and impacts tissue, it can cause a bullet to start to deform, especially hard tissue, like a bone. The bullet, based on its pathway, it would have gone through bone near the base of the skull to go from the right nose and the right nasal cavity into the intracranial cavity, where the brain is located. So, to access that area, it would have to go through bone, and bone is particularly deforming for bullets.
Lawyer 2 (05:35:00):
And this is already in evidence. It's entered as State's number 224. I can have you take a look at this.
(05:35:12)
May I approach?
Judge (05:35:12):
Yes, Sir.
Lawyer 2 (05:35:13):
Just take a look at 224. Do you recognize that? That's already been admitted into evidence. Do you recognize that?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:35:55):
It appears that... Well, what it appears to be, again, it has labeled with the... There's two plastic boxes in here. They both appear to have the case number for this case, and one of the labels appears to indicate a .22 Long Rifle bullet, which is reported to be the type of bullet that was fired in this case.
Lawyer 2 (05:36:28):
And you see the little plastic container...
(05:36:29)
... investigator. Do you see the plastic container that preserves the evidence here on the State's 2... I forget what number that is, but what's on the screen. Do you see the little plastic container?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:36:40):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (05:36:41):
Is that consistent with what's in that exhibit you're holding there?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:36:44):
It is, yeah. It does look similar. That is the type of plastic box that we use to secure bullets once they're recovered.
Lawyer 2 (05:36:55):
So, once the bullet was recovered, the main fragment that was remaining inside the decedent, would it have been preserved and possibly sent on to another section for further analysis?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:37:07):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (05:37:14):
I'm going to go back to your report. If we can go back to the report of, [inaudible 05:37:20] what number it is, 239 for the record, your report?
Judge (05:37:18):
It's at 229.
Lawyer 2 (05:37:30):
229, sorry. If you can go there, page 2 of 229, continue on with your report a little bit? So, you have your evidence of injury section. Can you tell the jury generally what you would put, the type of findings, why you included evidence of injury section in your report?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:37:53):
Yeah. So, we separate out... The injuries are an important focus for us in a lot of our cases, and so we have a separate section for injuries so you can go quickly to know exactly where the injuries are. If they're intermingled with the other... Say, if you have external injuries that are intermingled with the other findings in the external examination, you may have to weed through... If you just want to know what the injuries are, you may have to weed through a lot of non-injury stuff, and it's more efficient and effective in a report, especially if the injuries are important, to put them in a separate section.
Lawyer 2 (05:38:32):
Could you note... If you'll read here what you note where it starts to say, "These lesions," please read that sentence, if you could see it?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:38:41):
I'm sorry, what were you saying?
Lawyer 2 (05:38:42):
Yeah, in the middle of this paragraph here where it starts... I'll just read it, "These lesions do not appear in a pattern that would be expected for gunpowder stippling." Do you remember writing that?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:38:51):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (05:38:53):
First of all, let's talk about gunpowder stippling. What is that?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:38:56):
Yeah. So, when a gun is fired, more than just a bullet comes out of the end of the barrel of the gun. One of the things that comes out of the end of the barrel of the gun is gunpowder particles that are not completely burned up. When a bullet is fired, there's gunpowder that's in the bullet cartridge. It's ignited and it produces a large amount of gas, hot gas, and that production of gas propels the bullet at very high speed down into the barrel and out. So that gas comes out of the end of the barrel of the gun. The combustion of the gunpowder particles results in the production of soot, a gray-black material, so soot comes out of the end of the barrel of the gun. And these gunfire particles, which you can think they're little... They're very small. You can almost think of them a little bit like grains of pepper or something. They're very small. They can vary somewhat in size because there's different types, but-
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:40:00):
They're very small. They can vary somewhat in size because there's different types. But these particles, they burn to create the gas, as I said before, but they don't completely burn up. So some of these particles either don't burn or don't completely burn. So these little particles come out of the end of the barrel of the gun. And if you're at what's called, what we refer to as medium or intermediate range, these particles will impact the skin around, typically around the entrance wound, around where the bullet goes in, you'll see where these particles impacting the skin with sufficient force to create very small pinpoint or slightly larger abrasions or scrape injuries in the skin. So you'll see, if there's gunpowder stippling present, it'll typically be a pattern around the entrance defect where there are these little punctator, slightly larger abrasions. That's what gunpowder stippling is.
Lawyer 2 (05:41:03):
And how is stippling different than soot?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:41:08):
Soot is the gray-black material that's produced. It's a gray-black material that can at least be partially wiped away. Stippling is an actual injury. They are actually little abrasions or scrape injuries caused by the gunpowder particles. Sometimes you'll see the gunpowder particles embedded in the stipples, but often, you don't.
Lawyer 2 (05:41:32):
And a final term, are you familiar with the term tattooing?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:41:36):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (05:41:36):
In this context of gunshot impact entry wounds...
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:41:41):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (05:41:42):
... what would tattooing be if differentiated from those two prior terms?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:41:45):
Tattooing is just another term for a gunpowder stippling.
Lawyer 2 (05:41:49):
So sooting is the chemicals that are possibly left near the entrance wound and it's stippling on the abrasions?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:41:59):
That's correct.
Lawyer 2 (05:42:00):
Is it fair that sometimes that stippling, did you say, can become subcutaneous or embedded under the skin?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:42:04):
Well, the stippling themselves are on surface. You'll see it. It pinpoint abrasions, but sometimes the powder particles can become embedded in the skin. They don't typically become subcutaneous, don't go below the skin, but it can be embedded in the skin near the surface.
Lawyer 2 (05:42:25):
I see. Embedded in the skin, but below the surface or near the surface.
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:42:29):
Yeah. They're sometimes protruding from the surface.
Lawyer 2 (05:42:33):
You stated to the jury that yourself or one of your assistants washed the face of the decedent, Daniel Akers, prior to your more thorough examination or physical examination, external examination, right? Do you remember saying that?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:42:47):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (05:42:48):
Is it possible, in your opinion, sir... I think [inaudible 05:42:53] 7,000 autopsies, a thousand gunshot wounds. Is it possible, in your opinion, sir, for all of the sooting to have been removed during the washing process?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:43:02):
I think it's possible, but I think it's very unlikely.
Lawyer 2 (05:43:04):
Do you think it's possible, in the same level of your experience, sir, for all of the stippling to have been removed is from the light washing process that you described?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:43:13):
No. You wouldn't be able to remove stippling.
Lawyer 2 (05:43:14):
Why not?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:43:16):
It's an actual injury. It's not material on the surface that can be wiped away. It would be like if you fell and scraped your knee and had a knee scrape and abrasion there, trying to wipe that away. You can't wipe an injury like that away.
Lawyer 2 (05:43:37):
Is there any relationship between the amount of stippling... Let's start with sooting first. I apologize. Is there any relationship in the amount of sooting that you would see as to the muzzle to target distance?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:43:50):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (05:43:51):
Can you explain that to the jury?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:43:56):
Yeah. I mean, I think if you're at a contact or near contact range... Near contact, I would say would be less than half an inch away, and contact meaning with the barrel of the gun touching the skin of the person being shot. With that, you would get the most soot, the contact, near contact range. As you get farther away, one inch, two inch, three inch, you'll start having less soot visible.
Lawyer 2 (05:44:31):
Do you have a point, based on your expertise, sir, at what point distance muzzle from target, muzzle to target distance, at what point would there be no soot? Would you expect to find no soot?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:44:43):
Well, it's been reported that you can commonly see soot... You typically see soot as far as six inches away, but once you get past a couple inches, you may not... Once you get past the contact to near contact range, I think when you get to one inch or farther, it can be variable whether it might be present or not. But as you get farther away, you're less likely to see it.
Lawyer 2 (05:45:12):
And I'm going to ask you, is there a relationship similarly with the stippling... The proportion of stippling or the amount that you would see, is that proportionate also like sooting to the range of fire?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:45:25):
It is, yeah. The amount that you see and the pattern of the stippling varies depending on how close the gun is.
Lawyer 2 (05:45:34):
Okay. When would you see the most stippling regarding range of fire?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:45:39):
Well, if you're talking about the most... When you're very close... Say you're... Once you get to about a half inch, that's when you start seeing stippling, because if you're closer than that, all those gunpowder particles that come out of the end of the barrel, they're going to go into the wound. But once you get far enough out, maybe a half inch or so, some of those particles can start impacting the skin around the wound, causing the gunpowder stippling, the pinpoint abrasions.
(05:46:07)
And so initially, as you're moving, if you say you're fairly close, a half inch or an inch away, what you would expect is a very dense but very small area of gunpowder stippling, close to the entrance wound. As you get farther and farther away, that stippling pattern will get wider and wider, but less dense. And as you get farther away, it'll start to be more sparse, the pattern, and then eventually you'll get to a point where there's no stippling.
Lawyer 2 (05:46:38):
So would you expect to see soothing in a contact or near contact wound?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:46:45):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (05:46:45):
Did you see it here on this decedent?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:46:48):
No.
Lawyer 2 (05:46:49):
Would you expect to see stippling on a contact or very near contact wound?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:46:58):
No.
Lawyer 2 (05:46:58):
Okay. Stippling, no stippling on a contact wound?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:46:58):
That's correct.
Lawyer 2 (05:46:59):
Would you expect to see... Do you know what stellate tearing is, or stellate wound?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:47:04):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (05:47:04):
Can you tell the jury what that is?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:47:06):
Yeah. Stellate tearing can refer to tearing in certain gunshot wounds, especially contact range gunshot wounds, because like I said before, in addition to the bullet, there's a large amount of gas that comes out of the end of the barrel of the gun. And that gas, if you're at a very close range of contact in your contact range, you can have tearing of the skin, especially, particularly if there's an underlying bony surface because the gas gets into the tissue and dissects between the skin and the bone and creates injury that way. So particularly the gunshot wounds of the head, you'll often get stellate tearing associated with a contact or a near contact range gunshot wound because of all the gas that goes into the body, into the wound.
Lawyer 2 (05:48:03):
Stellate, does it mean star shaped to you?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:48:07):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (05:48:07):
Did you see the stellate nature of a wound here on this decedent?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:48:07):
No.
Lawyer 2 (05:48:16):
I'm going to approach opposing counsel and show what I've marked as State's Exhibit 241. Sir, if I can show you what's been marked for identification purposes only as State's Exhibits 241 and 242. Well, before I do that, are you familiar with a book called Gunshot Wounds by DiMaio?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:49:05):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (05:49:06):
Is that a reference that a lot of physicians in your capacity would use to see the characteristics of gunshot wounds?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:49:15):
Yes, it is.
Lawyer 2 (05:49:17):
If you'll just excuse the term, is it kind of the go-to reference manual for gunshot wounds in this country for people in your profession?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:49:25):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (05:49:26):
DiMaio is... Is he kind of considered the expert on gunshot wounds?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:49:31):
Yes, he is.
Lawyer 2 (05:49:33):
Have you had... I'm sorry.
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:49:33):
Yes. He's considered an expert.
Lawyer 2 (05:49:36):
Have you, in your course of your career, referenced DiMaio's book on gunshot wounds before?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:49:42):
Yeah. It's the primary reference I've used for gunshot wound evaluation.
Lawyer 2 (05:49:49):
Okay. As an aid to assist the jury with the evidence, would it help you to see and explain some pictures from... some illustrations from DiMaio book, Gunshot Wounds?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:50:01):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (05:50:01):
May I approach the witness?
Speaker 21 (05:50:01):
Yes, sir.
Lawyer 2 (05:50:02):
I'll show you, sir, first, State's Exhibit 241, just for demonstrative purposes. If you can take a look at that. Do you recognize anything on 241 from DiMaio's book?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:50:18):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (05:50:20):
Permission to publish demonstrative purposes on his name to the jury from a learning treatise or source of this case?
Speaker 21 (05:50:28):
Any objection to that?
Speaker 22 (05:50:29):
No, sir. Just if it may be instruction that this is not our case. This is just from a book, from a textbook.
Lawyer 2 (05:50:39):
You want an instruction that it's not...
Speaker 22 (05:50:40):
Yes. It's not our case.
Lawyer 2 (05:50:42):
We can all agree to that. I'll ask some more questions about that.
(05:50:46)
What you have before you, 242, is that Daniel Akers's autopsy anywhere?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:50:49):
No.
Lawyer 2 (05:50:50):
Is it just an illustration from DiMaio's book, which is a treatise you may rely on in your operation sometimes?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:50:57):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (05:50:57):
Do you think it would assist, 242, explaining to the jury the different nature of these wounds?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:51:00):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (05:51:04):
All right.
(05:51:04)
Permission to publish?
Speaker 22 (05:51:05):
No opposition, Your Honor.
Lawyer 2 (05:51:06):
Just publishing this as a demonstrative aid that, Dr. Lehman, if you could possibly... I'll call it State's 241, but it's not enough. It's just a demonstrative. Can you take a look at the first illustration from DiMaio's book, letter A as in alpha? What do we see there as far as characteristics of gunshot wound?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:51:26):
Yes. So what you see is... Centrally, you see a defect in the tissue that represents the entrance defect where the bullet struck the body, and then entered the body. And then all around, all these pinpoint marks that you see, this represents gunpowder stippling. So these are the very small abrasions that are caused by impact where the gunpowder particles, those small gunpowder particles impacted the skin around the entrance when it caused these abrasions.
Lawyer 2 (05:51:57):
Okay. If we could go back to... And I want to make it clear one more time. 242, what you've shown the jury and pointed out with your green laser pointer, that's not this decedent, correct?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:52:11):
That's correct.
Lawyer 2 (05:52:12):
If we do go back to this decedent, in state's number 237, please, we can go back to this decedent, knowing what you just showed us from DiMaio. Do you see any stippling pattern, circular stippling pattern around the right nostril that you've identified as an entry wound here?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:52:40):
No. There was no gunpowder stippling.
Lawyer 2 (05:52:50):
And going back to DiMaio now for section B for demonstrative purposes only, can you tell the jury what DiMaio shows us here? B like broccoli
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:52:56):
Yeah. So this is another wound. This one, there's a defect in the center. It's kind of hard to see in the photograph, but there's heavy... These [inaudible 05:53:10] marks, these pinpoint or slight larger marks represent gunpowder stippling. And these were gunshot wounds caused by a 22 long rifle cartridge, which was the same type of bullet cartridge that was used in Mr. Akers's... that Mr. Akers was shot by, but this is not Mr. Akers's, just shot with the same type of bullet cartridge.
Lawyer 2 (05:53:33):
So DiMaio's subsection B, as in bravo, here that we're looking at, did he identify, the author identify that that's a 22 long rifle... Excuse me, 22 long rifle cartridge wound?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:53:47):
Yeah, for this photograph and the previous photograph.
Lawyer 2 (05:53:49):
Both of them. Okay. And you're aware that that's the same... Are you aware that that's the same caliber you removed from the decedent's skull?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:53:57):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (05:53:58):
What is the, if anything, sir, the significance of the grayish matter here on... I'm sorry. Take just a moment if we need to.
(05:54:11)
We have a diabetic on the jury. Do we need to stop, Your Honor?
Speaker 21 (05:54:16):
Not unless she does.
Speaker 23 (05:54:16):
No.
Speaker 21 (05:54:16):
Okay. Thank you.
Lawyer 2 (05:54:19):
No problem. So if you'll look at the gray matter or the blackish matter in the center of subsection or... subsection B or diagram B, like bravo, from DiMaio's book, do we see anything notable there in your eyes?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:54:34):
It could represent soot. It's hard to tell when the stippling gets so dense that there may be soot superimposed on that too. It's hard for me to tell though.
Lawyer 2 (05:54:44):
Could it be possibly just a super concentrated area of stippling?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:54:49):
Yes, it could be.
Lawyer 2 (05:54:51):
Okay. And going back to diagram A, as an alpha, investigator, do you see any sooting here on A, like alpha?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:54:59):
Nothing that I could be confident about, no.
Lawyer 2 (05:55:01):
But the darker area similar to diagram B, is it possible that that could be a super populated grouping of stippling?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:55:11):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (05:55:12):
All right, sir, can we go to... Can we go to diagram B again, like bravo? Okay. So you've gone over diagram B, like bravo, with the 22 power long rifle. And going back to the decedent in this case, did you see any of that similar super imposed or super populated grouping of stippling on this entrance wound on this decedent on his right [inaudible 05:55:41]?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:55:41):
No, there was no gunpowder stippling.
Lawyer 2 (05:56:04):
All right. I believe I showed opposing counsel also state's 242 for demonstrative purposes on it. Can you take a look at 242, State's 242, only for demonstrative purposes? See if you recognize that from DiMaio's treatise?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:56:16):
I do recognize it.
Lawyer 2 (05:56:20):
All right. Do you think 242 would assist you in... Do you think 242 would assist the jurors in understanding the nature of your testimony by using that as demonstrative aid?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:56:32):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (05:56:35):
[Inaudible 05:56:35] 242 as demonstrative, Your Honor?
Speaker 21 (05:56:40):
You may.
Lawyer 2 (05:56:41):
Thank you.
(05:56:41)
Also show you -- 242 is a demonstrative aid from a 22 long rifle wound here too, Dr. Lehman. What is notable about DiMaio's photograph here from a 22 long rifle wound?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:56:56):
Yeah. So these are two contact range wounds. One here, where you see the defect where a bullet entered and one here where the bullet entered. And you can see around the edges of the wound, there's this gray-black material that was described as searing. And searing is a burning of the tissue caused by all those hot gases that come out of the end of the barrel of the gut. And what happens with searing, you get searing and stick together, you get a discoloration that you can't wipe away. You can try to wipe it away, but you can't. It's seared into the... into the skin or tissue there.
Lawyer 2 (05:57:38):
Almost burned in?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:57:39):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (05:57:40):
Almost like a brand, something burned into the skin. Does searing permanently... Can it permanently alter the nature of the skin?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:57:48):
I don't know. I don't know that it permanently alters the nature of the skin, but at the time of... Immediately after, you can't wipe it away.
Lawyer 2 (05:58:01):
It may go away in time.
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:58:03):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (05:58:03):
Is that fair? But if you wash the body, for example, washed a wound like we see on the DiMaio's page here, if you prepared the wound for further analysis, do you expect searing to disappear?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:58:17):
No.
Lawyer 2 (05:58:22):
Did you see searing on the decedent's entry wound on this right [inaudible 05:58:29]? Do you see searing in this area?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:58:31):
No.
Lawyer 2 (05:58:34):
Is it more common or less common to see searing in a contact wound rather than a longer range wound?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:58:43):
You'll see the searing in a contact or a near contact [inaudible 05:58:50] wound. Once you get out past that, I wouldn't expect to see it.
Lawyer 2 (05:59:09):
Can I please show you, sir, what's been admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 238? You made some mention earlier of an abrasion or... If that's not the term you used, I don't want to use that term, but if you could take a look at this area here. I though you said abrasion, but what do you see this purplish discoloration area right here? What do you note that to be, sir?
Dr. Keith Lehman (05:59:49):
The red area here is abrasion. There's tearing here too, because it's an entrance wound right at the edge of the nostril. It's hard to see the full nature because of the resolution of the photograph, but there's some tearing here that represents impact by the bullet. And then the red coloration around it is all or predominantly marginal abrasion.
Lawyer 2 (06:00:21):
Let's see if we can get a little bit closer. And can we... Investigator Burt, can we raise it up a little toward the top? Thank you. Hopefully we won't lose too much resolution, Dr. Lehman, but is this tearing of the skin that you've talked about?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:00:38):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (06:00:39):
Okay. Is that more common with a contact or near contact range wound?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:00:47):
No. I mean, this is just sort of an incomplete entrance because the bullet impacted sort of at the edge of the nostril. If the bullet had impacted on the cheek, you'd have a more circular oval area of a defect or tearing.
Lawyer 2 (06:01:05):
So based on your knowledge, training and experience, doctor, what would cause that tearing?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:01:11):
In this case, the impact by the bullet.
Lawyer 2 (06:01:14):
Okay. So this is not a gas expansion or gas exhaustion from the muzzle. This is actually projectile?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:01:23):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (06:01:24):
In your opinion?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:01:24):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (06:01:26):
And then if you could please similarly explain that in your professional learning opinion, sir, what would cause this, what you've termed an abrasion to the top of that tearing or surrounding that tearing toward the 12 o'clock area right here?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:01:44):
Yeah, it could be... Sorry. It could be impact by the bullet. There's a somewhat tangential nature to the bullet here. It comes in kind of at an angle. The marginal abrasion at a bullet... Sorry, the marginal abrasion is a rim of abrasion around an entrance defect, right around the edge of the entrance defect where the bullet enters. It's where the skin has been scraped away or is missing. And it used to be thought that that was caused by the bullet scraping the skin as it went in, but there's been studies that now show it's related to overstretching of the skin because when the bullet hits, it creates... It comes at a high velocity, so it's a lot of energy hitting the body. It causes it to overstretch.
(06:02:33)
And then when it comes back down, the skin apparently doesn't come back as far... The superficial part of the skin doesn't come back as far as the deeper... come back to normal as part of the... As far... To the same degree as the deeper part of the skin. And so you get what we refer to as a marginal abrasion, but it's essentially related to impact by the bullet.
Lawyer 2 (06:02:55):
Did you have an opportunity to review photographs or in person, a pistol, 22 caliber pistol that was recovered and tested by the GBI in this case?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:03:08):
Yes, in photographs.
Lawyer 2 (06:03:10):
In photographs? Let me show you what's been entered into evidence as State's Exhibit 173. Sir, do you recognize 173? Do you recognize that?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:03:27):
That looks consistent with the photographs of the gun that was used in this case.
Lawyer 2 (06:03:38):
Do you have any reason to believe that this is not gun from those photographs?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:03:39):
No. No. If you're telling me it is, I don't have any reason to believe that it's not. And it does physically resemble it.
Lawyer 2 (06:03:45):
Let me show you on the projector 173A, actually removing the revolver from the evidence box. Can you see it, sir?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:03:58):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (06:04:03):
If you need to see it or handle it, let me know, but I'll just go off of this photograph on 173A. Do you know what this part of the firearm is, sir? Did you look at photographs of that?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:04:22):
Yes, I did.
Lawyer 2 (06:04:22):
You know that as to be an ejection rod?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:04:27):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (06:04:28):
Is that a rod that just clears the shells from the cylinder?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:04:32):
Yeah. You know what? I'm not sure what the function of it is, but it's called... I've seen it referred to as an ejector rod or a cylinder rod.
Lawyer 2 (06:04:39):
Cylinder rod. Okay.
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:04:40):
Or an ejector rod.
Lawyer 2 (06:04:41):
Well, what term do you use in your practice?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:04:44):
Ejector rod is fine. Yeah.
Lawyer 2 (06:04:46):
Okay. Ejection rod or ejector rod. It's a rod that protrudes, would you agree, almost equidistant from the muzzle, from the... It's about the same level as the muzzle?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:04:58):
In this case, it is.
Lawyer 2 (06:05:01):
Okay. At least in this... The way the firearm is situated positioned now, right?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:05:06):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (06:05:11):
So do you see checkered marks on the ejector rod here?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:05:16):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (06:05:21):
Going back to 238, do you have an opinion... I'm sorry, I left it in that spot. Thank you.
(06:05:35)
Sir, do you have an opinion, based on your training, knowledge and experience, whether this abrasion.... What you called an abrasion here above the tearing, do you have an opinion as to whether this abrasion was caused by the ejector rod?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:05:50):
I do have an opinion.
Lawyer 2 (06:05:52):
Can you state it for the jury, please?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:05:54):
It's my opinion that it was not caused by the ejector rod.
Lawyer 2 (06:05:58):
Why do you believe that?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:05:59):
Because if it was caused by the ejector rod, that would indicate that it was a contact range gunshot wound because you'd have to have the ejector rod up against the skin there. And that's something that we do see in contact range wounds sometimes. We'll see the outline of the muzzle, including ejector rod that protrudes all the way to the barrel of the gun, as it did in this case. But the problem with that is we know the bullet, you can see the initial part of the wound path inside the nose. It travels on the inside of the right nasal cavity and extends all the way to this abrasion that we're seeing on the skin.
(06:06:45)
So we know the bullet traveled right adjacent to that abrasion. And if you're going to say it's a contact range wound, which you would pretty much have to say, if you're going to say that was caused by the ejector rod, then the barrel of the gun, the opening where the bullet comes out would have to be right there, adjacent to where this abrasion is and where this tear is in the right nostril area. If that was the case, if this was a shot fired by a long rifle cartridge, as it was in this case, you would expect there to be soot and searing. The long rifle cartridge, in a wound caused by the long rifle cartridge, you expect prominent soot and prominent searing. And so there would be a lot of soot and you'd expect soot that you couldn't completely wipe away. And in this case, there's no evidence of soot on the nose, around the nose, inside the nose, along the wound path. There's no evidence of it. There's no even hint of soot.
Lawyer 2 (06:07:52):
The lack of that evidence, sir, would it... To somebody with your experience trained, would it indicate a longer range shot?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:07:59):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (06:08:04):
Would it also... If this were... Let's see. If this were... I can't remove... Let me show you 173A. I can't remove the safety lock, as we're in court, so it makes it impossible to press the cylinder into the frame. Point this where it's not pointing anywhere. Let me point that out. So do you see how the... I'm sorry. I don't mean to block you, sir. Do you see how the cylinder cannot be depressed into the frame of the weapon because of the gun lock?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:08:49):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (06:08:50):
But let's just assume or just do your best to assume that the cylinder was fully inside the frame of the weapon. Can you imagine that? Okay?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:09:00):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (06:09:01):
Is it true, sir, how would the gun have to be positioned? If we can go back to that picture with the marginal abrasion, as Dr. Lehman called it.
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:09:11):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (06:09:12):
So how would the gun have to be positioned if that wound... I know you don't believe it is, but if you think that wound is a... If someone though that wound was caused by the ejector rod, how would the weapon have to be positioned?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:09:28):
It would have to be positioned with the... It would be upside down, essentially, because you would have to have the ejector rod above the level of the baria where the bullet comes out. So it would be... Instead of like this, it would be like this. If you could sort of... Where the top of the gun is here, it would be with the top of the gun down. So it would have to be upside down, or I guess in this case, it would be like this.
Lawyer 2 (06:09:59):
May I approach you,
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:10:00):
Yes, sir.
Lawyer 2 (06:10:01):
So if you see the weapon and the ejector port here, do you have any doubt in your mind that the entrance wing was into the right nostril?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:10:12):
No.
Lawyer 2 (06:10:13):
Okay. So would you agree that what you've called a marginal abrasion is above the right nostril?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:10:19):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (06:10:20):
Okay. So is it fair, sir, that in order for this ejection rod to have made that mark, the pistol would've had to been inverted?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:10:29):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (06:10:30):
And I'm holding my right hand to hold to my left. So would it had to be held upside down?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:11:02):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (06:11:03):
Let me show you what's been admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 239, please. I'll show you this. Did you or a member of your team take this photograph?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:11:04):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (06:11:05):
Can you tell the jury please, what is it you were trying to show in either directing this photograph to be taken or taking it yourself here?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:11:15):
This is the closeup of the nose. This is the right nostril. This is the area of the wound that we were looking at, and this is that marginal abrasion on the edge of the nostril. And then you can see here, this is a grace type wound, a laceration, a grace type wound where the bullet, it struck the nose, as you can see in the location there on the edge of the right nostril, and then it continued on that outer aspect of the right nasal cavity. You can kind of see it here, the outer edge of the right nasal cavity and extended up, up of the right nasal cavity before, until it eventually entered the intracranial cavity in the brain. And you can see the initial wound path here. And we photographed that just to show what it looked like, the nature of the wound and the absence. And it also shows the absence of any evidence of gunshot residue.
Lawyer 2 (06:12:14):
That's what I'm getting into now. Thank you for that segue. So did you have an opportunity... I'm sorry, [inaudible 06:12:21]. Did you have an opportunity in your laboratory, sir, to visually gain access up into the right nasal cavity here?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:12:29):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (06:12:31):
And you were talking about some lighting that you could pull down, position, move. Did you have access to that type of lighting when you did the examination?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:12:38):
Well, I don't recall exactly what lighting we would've used in this case. In a small area like that, you could have just used a flashlight or you could have used the overhead lights that we have. They look sort of like what you might see in an operating room.
Lawyer 2 (06:12:53):
In any event, are you confident, sir, that you had an ability to successfully look up into and examine the right nasal cavity?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:13:03):
Yes. For the first portion of the wound, we could see far enough... Where you would expect the soot gunpowder particles to be present. We could see that far up where you would expect to see them in a significant amount if there was a contact range wound. We could see far enough up into the nose to be able to make that determination.
Lawyer 2 (06:13:29):
If you had reason to believe that there could possibly be sooting or gunpowder residue, or stippling at all in farther into the nasal passage, could you have ordered a microscopic test to be undertaken?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:13:43):
Well, we would do the microscopic examination if we see dark discoloration at the wound, at the edge of the wound, at the opening where the marginal abrasion is, or in a superficial wound path. If we see dark coloration that we think, well, that could be soot, is it...
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:14:00):
... Coloration that we think, well, that could be soot. Is it soot? That's when we would do a microscopic examination. In a case where you don't see anything, not even a suggestion of soot, the microscopic examination is not helpful because what you would expect if it's a contact regimen is a large amount of black material consistent with soot. In a wound where you don't see any evidence of it, you're not going to have a large amount of it. A small amount's not helpful because you can commonly see a small amount of similar appearing material in distant range wounds. So the utility in looking at tissue under the microscope and the superficial wound path is if you see some dark coloration that you think might be soot, because if you don't see anything, you're not going to see microscopic, there's not going to be a lot of it.
Lawyer 2 (06:14:58):
Are you aware of any kind of chemical analysis that could have been undertaken up inside the nasal passage to determine presence of soot?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:15:05):
No, there's no reliable chemical testing that I'm aware of to make that determination.
Lawyer 2 (06:15:14):
If I can go back to the evaluation or the report please. Thank you. All right. So we're back to your report a little bit. We discussed a little bit of this. If we could go up just a bit. Let's see. You say here that by the time the body came into your laboratory, you see that rigor mortis is well-formed and generalized. Can you tell what that is please?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:15:50):
Yeah. Rigor mortis is a post-mortem phenomenon where the muscles become stiff. It's not usually present right after the death, but in the minutes or hours after death, the muscles start to stiffen up.
Lawyer 2 (06:16:09):
If I can go up the next paragraph up to the top above where you talk about rigor mortis, take a look at this. Do you see where it says, "Examination of the hands reveals minimal amounts of material consistent with blood on the back of the right hand overlaying the fifth metacarpal region on the palmar aspect of the left thumb near the thumb tip and on the back of the thumb near the metacarpal phalangeal joint." Do you see that right there, sir?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:16:36):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (06:16:37):
Talk about what that means just if I, which I am, a lay person and I didn't know those words and like what you're saying there, what did you see there to make note of in your report?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:16:48):
Yeah. So I'm just describing very small amounts of material consistent with blood on the back of the right hand overlying the fifth metacarpal region. That would be this part of the hand here. I'll demonstrate on my own hand, not the fingers, but the part of the hand between the knuckles and the wrist. That's the metacarpal region. So there's a little bit of blood there. Then on the palmar aspect of the left thumb, so on the opposite side, the palm aspect of the left thumb, near the tip of the thumb, and then on the back of that thumb near the metacarpal phalangeal joint, that's basically the knuckle there. So there's minimal amounts of material that may represent blood on the hands.
Lawyer 2 (06:17:35):
Did you see a large amount of blood on the left hand, for example?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:17:38):
No.
Lawyer 2 (06:17:42):
Okay. All right. If we can go to the next page please. Okay. Then we segue into the internal examination in this case. Did you find anything that was really notable to your determination of manner of death regarding or as a result of the internal examination? Was it all just what you expected to find?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:18:18):
Yeah. In the internal examination, there were a portion of the report. We put the internal examination of the body related to the gunshot wound in the evidence of injury section. But in the internal examination section of the report, it would be the non-injury findings. I didn't see any findings. I didn't see any findings in the ... I didn't mention any findings there that would be separate from the gunshot wound that would be expected to have caused or contributed to the death.
Lawyer 2 (06:18:50):
If I could go back to the x-ray footage just for a moment, Dr. Lehman, State's Exhibit 240, please. Did you notice anything or can you tell the jury anything about the trajectory path, the pathway of the projectile as it traveled into the decedent's body? What direction, what pathway did the projectile take?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:19:33):
Yeah. So when we give wound path directions, we give directions from the deceased individual's point of view with them in what we call anatomic position, which would be standing up, facing forward, arms down by the side, palms forward. So basically in that position, the wound path, after it entered the body here, impacted the body here in the right nose, it traveled predominantly front to back. So towards the back of the head and then to a lesser degree, left to right and upward. So it sort of, I'll indicate with my finger, sort of the rough trajectory of it, it ended up inside the skull towards the back on the left side. The bullets traveled mostly ... Most of the time they travel close to a straight line.
Lawyer 2 (06:20:24):
Okay. In this path, in this particular pathway, you said that the projectile traveled upward. Can you explain that?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:20:30):
Yeah. So it traveled front to back, but also somewhat upward. So where it ended up in the head was above the level of where the bullet entered. So it wasn't just straight back. There was a somewhat of an upward trajectory and somewhat of a right to left trajectory too, towards Mr. Edgars, the left side of his head.
Lawyer 2 (06:20:55):
Could an upward trajectory of a bullet pathway indicate that the pistol muzzle was facing slightly upward when firing?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:21:04):
Yeah, relative to the decedent's head. Now we don't know. We assume he was standing basically forward just for purposes of designating the wound path direction, but we don't always know what the path of the bullet would be. I mean, I'm sorry. We don't always know what the position of the body is at the time that the person was shot. So if you assume he's standing, looking straight ahead, not up, not down, that would be evidence that the gun had an upward ... Somewhat pointing upward. Not sharply upward, but somewhat upward.
Lawyer 2 (06:21:52):
Going to page four on State's Exhibit 229, your report again, where you say other procedures. We'll go over that just a moment. You did take photographs on number one. Do you remember that?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:22:06):
Yeah.
Lawyer 2 (06:22:07):
The photographs were taken, maybe you didn't take them. I'm sorry. Then you see full radiography and you did recover the bullet from the skull, right?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:22:16):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (06:22:16):
Then you say that some evidence was collected from the femur area and possibly submitted to other divisions within your agency. Do you remember that?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:22:28):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (06:22:29):
Then number five, you say that this case was discussed with Lieutenant Mike Hill, Detective Hardy, and [inaudible 06:22:38] SO, Matthew Rollins, Ashley Good of the DA's office on 3/19/20 at the UVA headquarters. Do you see that?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:22:46):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (06:22:46):
Why would you discuss a case like this with those parties on March 19th, 2020, sir?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:22:56):
Because in this case, the case was presented as a self-inflicted gunshot wound, but the findings in the case aren't a good fit for a self-inflicted gunshot wound. So it's important for us to collect more information about the case, about what happened, about the appearance of the scene to try ... Because we always, in determining cause and manner of death, we always evaluate both the findings on the body and the investigative information. So in this case, the findings on the body didn't seem to match the initial investigative information, so we needed to gather more.
Lawyer 2 (06:23:42):
Is that the nature of your meeting in March of 2020?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:23:46):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (06:23:50):
When you say the findings on the body, does that include the things you've just now told us about with the stellate wound, the stippling, the sooting, things like the tearing, things like that?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:24:03):
Yes, especially the aspects of the gunshot wound, the location of the gunshot wound, and the range of fire of the gunshot wound.
Lawyer 2 (06:24:12):
Is there anybody at ... I mean, let me put it this way. Were you told on March 19th, 2020 that there had been a text sent by Daniel Akers that said he was sad, and lonely, and depressed?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:24:25):
I'm sorry, when did you say it was sent?
Lawyer 2 (06:24:28):
I don't know when it was sent, but prior to his death, shortly before his death, were you told there was a text that said he was sad, lonely, and depressed?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:24:34):
No.
Lawyer 2 (06:24:35):
If you had been told that, sir, would that have changed the findings scientifically on your observation of gunshot wounds?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:24:41):
No.
Lawyer 2 (06:24:44):
Were you told during the March meeting in 2020 by any investigator or any source that this decedent was suffering financially, or financially, having financial problems?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:24:57):
No.
Lawyer 2 (06:24:58):
If you had been told that this decedent was suffering financially, would that have changed your observation scientifically of the nature of the gunshot wound?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:25:06):
No.
Lawyer 2 (06:25:10):
Were you told on March 19th, 2020 by any source that this decedent was possibly divorcing, or getting divorced, or his wife was about to divorce him? Anything about his marital status on March of 2020?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:25:27):
We were told that he was having marital problems.
Lawyer 2 (06:25:30):
Okay. Did the fact that he was having marital problems change your observation of the scientific aspect of the gunshot wound?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:25:38):
No.
Lawyer 2 (06:26:06):
If you were told that ... If you were told that this defendant was happy, and upbeat, and positive at any time during the March 2020 meeting, would that have changed your opinion of the scientific observation of the gunshot wound?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:26:23):
No.
Lawyer 2 (06:26:23):
Were you told at all in March of 2020 that this decedent was about to become unemployed or possibly lose his job? Were you told that?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:26:35):
I don't recall being told that, no.
Lawyer 2 (06:26:37):
If you were told that, sir, would that have changed your observation and your analysis of the gunshot wound aspects?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:26:44):
No.
Lawyer 2 (06:26:48):
Were you told in March of 2020, sir, at any time, and these questions apply, at any time, were you told that this defendant, this decedent, excuse me, was afraid of being revoked on probation? Do you remember being told that?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:27:00):
No.
Lawyer 2 (06:27:01):
If you had been told that there was a fear of being revoked on probation until 2024, having to do time in prison, would that have changed your interpretation of the, scientifically, gunshot wounds that you saw?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:27:11):
No.
Lawyer 2 (06:27:24):
Do you have an opinion on range of fire in this case?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:27:27):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (06:27:27):
So range of fire, tell again what it is.
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:27:31):
Range of fire is when a person sustains a gunshot wound, it's how far was the end of the muzzle of the gun away from the body, away from where the bullet struck on the body at the time the shot was fired.
Lawyer 2 (06:27:46):
What is your opinion on the range of fire in this case?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:27:50):
Distant range of fire, which would mean at least the muzzle of the gun would've been ... I would expect the muzzle of the gun to be at least approximately a foot away from the nose or farther.
Lawyer 2 (06:28:13):
Was this ... I'm sorry. Would you classify this wound as being immediately incapacitating to the victim?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:28:21):
Probably. It probably would have been.
Lawyer 2 (06:28:23):
Do you think the victim would have been, based on your training, knowledge, and experience, sir, would the victim in any way have been able to manipulate a firearm after suffering this type of wound?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:28:33):
He probably wouldn't be able to have awareness or be able to have ... Yeah, so he wouldn't have been able to have awareness, so he wouldn't have been able to voluntarily manipulate a firearm, probably, probably wouldn't have been able to.
Lawyer 2 (06:28:55):
What did you note in this case as being the cause of death?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:29:00):
The cause of death was the gunshot wound.
Lawyer 2 (06:29:01):
What did you note in this case as being the manner of death?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:29:04):
Homicide.
Lawyer 2 (06:29:08):
Did you arrive at that conclusion of manner of death with a reasonable degree of medical certainty, sir?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:29:15):
I wouldn't use the word certainty in this case. I would say that as far as the manner of death goes, I would say the evidence strongly supports it, but it depends on what you mean by a reasonable degree of medical certainty. I wouldn't say certainty. If you mean by reasonable degree of certainty, well, I'm not 100% sure, but I'm so close to 100% sure I'm basically sure. I wouldn't say the level of confidence is there either. I would say the evidence in the case provides strong evidence of homicide.
Lawyer 2 (06:29:51):
Certainty could only be arrived at if you were saying eyewitness, would you agree with that, as to what happened?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:29:58):
Yeah.
Lawyer 2 (06:29:59):
So you obviously were not an eyewitness. You're not aware of any eyewitnesses to the events other than the defendant?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:30:08):
That's correct.
Lawyer 2 (06:30:14):
Let me ask you this. I can show opposing counsel what I'll mark for identification purposes only as State's Exhibit 243, I believe. Let me show you what's been previously marked for identification purposes on the State's Exhibit 243. See if you recognize this, sir. Do you recognize that?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:31:59):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (06:32:00):
How do you recognize it?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:32:03):
Just from reading through portions of it, this represents the Georgia death certificate for Daniel Akers.
Lawyer 2 (06:32:11):
Have you seen it before?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:32:14):
Not to my recollection.
Lawyer 2 (06:32:18):
Okay, that's fine. At the time that the decedent arrived at your laboratory, sir, I'll take 243 back, was the decedent, Daniel Akers, was he deceased?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:32:29):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (06:32:29):
Did he survive this gunshot, sir?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:32:31):
No.
Lawyer 2 (06:32:33):
Let me go through a few more things with you. How many examinations did you say you've conducted with gunshot wounds?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:32:43):
I estimated probably around 1,000.
Lawyer 2 (06:32:49):
1,000. Are all of those homicides?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:32:50):
No.
Lawyer 2 (06:32:51):
Some can be accident, is that fair?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:32:53):
That's right.
Lawyer 2 (06:32:54):
Some may be suicide?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:33:00):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (06:33:00):
But they're all gunshot wounds, right?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:33:01):
Yes. Yeah, that's right.
Lawyer 2 (06:33:04):
How many of those have you reviewed that were suicides?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:33:11):
I would say, I don't have an exact count or a close approximation. I would say probably ... It's probably a similar number of suicides and homicides. It's probably about close to 50%, one versus the other. There's a few ... We have some undetermined too, and accidental gunshot wounds are rare, so it's a relatively small number of those.
Lawyer 2 (06:33:42):
Okay. So you said around 1,000 gunshot wounds, is that right?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:33:46):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (06:33:47):
We take out just an indetestable amount of accidental gunshot wound cases, right?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:33:53):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (06:33:54):
So that leaves 50, 50% of the remaining wounds, did you say, were some suicide to some homicide?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:34:00):
Roughly. Yeah, that would be a rough estimate of it. Yeah, probably a similar number.
Lawyer 2 (06:34:07):
Okay. How many of those suicide cases that you've worked, Dr. Lehman, were indicative of the victim shooting selves in the nose?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:34:17):
I can't remember having ever had a case like that. I did go back and look at a nine-year period of all the non-homicide gunshot wounds that I've autopsied. So it was suicides, it was undetermined. I included the undetermined because I wanted to look at all of the potentially self-inflicted gunshot wounds I had, included I think maybe one accidental gunshot wound. About 10 or so undetermined, all the rest were suicides. It was over 200 suicides. I took out ... Actually, yeah, for this purpose, I didn't take anything out. So for all of the suicides or the gunshot wounds that were potentially suicides, there were no gunshot wounds to the nose.
Lawyer 2 (06:35:11):
Were you able to subdivide those non-homicide gunshot wounds by dominant hand?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:35:20):
No.
Lawyer 2 (06:35:21):
Okay. There's no study on that, is that right?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:35:24):
I'm not aware of a study on that. If you're trying to determine if somebody's right- handed, what are the odds that they're going to shoot themselves with their right hand and not use their left hand to shoot themselves? I'm not aware of studies that indicate that. Logically, you would think the large majority of the time you would use your dominant hand.
Lawyer 2 (06:35:49):
I know you ... It's kind of getting kind of grizzly, but bear with me, sir. I know you've seen a lot of suicide wounds. What are the most common suicide entry wounds that you've witnessed in your career?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:36:01):
Yeah, so probably the most common place people shooting themselves, where the entry wound is, is to the right side of the head, especially in the temple region. I would say that's the most common. Other places that we see not infrequently are inside the mouth, under the chin, sometimes to the left side of the head, less frequently. Occasionally, infrequently, we'll see to the forehead, especially the middle of the forehead, and then sometimes to the left side of the chest or the middle of the chest. Those are the areas that cover the large majority of entrance locations for the suicides we see, the gunshot wound suicides.
Lawyer 2 (06:36:50):
Sticking with that area of focus on gunshot wound suicides, sir. Sticking with the area of the focus on gunshot wound suicides, how many of those have you had in your career where you saw no stippling at all in the injury or around?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:37:15):
It would be rare to have a ... It's rare to have a gunshot wound, a self-inflicted gunshot wound that doesn't have any evidence of either contact or intermediate range of firing. That same group of cases I looked back at over that nine year period, I looked at about 200 gunshot wounds, it 215, I took about 10 out because the wounds may have been altered by either post-mortem decomposition or thermal injury. Say if somebody set the house on fire, and then shot themselves, and then they burn up, or if they're in the hospital for an extended time and so treatment or healing might have altered the gunshot wounds. I took those out and just looked at how many cases I had that were either suicides or possibly suicides, I included undetermined too, that didn't have any evidence of either contact range of firing, near contact range of firing, which would be the large tearing, would be the soot deposition, or didn't have evidence of intermediate range of fire, which would have been the gun or stippling.
(06:38:40)
In that group, there was only one case that was potentially a suicide that didn't have any evidence of either close contact or intermediate range of firing. That was a case of gunshot wound to the abdomen where the person went to the hospital and their clothing was not with them when they came to us. So we don't know, commonly when people go to the hospital, the clothing gets taken off as part of the emergency medical treatment. So we don't know if that person was wearing clothing over the abdomen, because that's important. You can have what would be potentially a contact, near contact, or something that would normally be considered in the range of an intermediate range gunshot wound. But if there's clothing in place, it can block the deposition of the gunshot residue on the body so that if you just look at the body and you don't look at the clothing or know the clothing was there, you might think it's a distant range wound.
(06:39:42)
So only one gunshot wound that was potentially suicide didn't, in that group, didn't have evidence of contact, near contact, or intermediate range of firing.
Lawyer 2 (06:39:53):
In this case here that you did look at with decedent Daniel Akers, do you have any indication he was wearing a sheisty, or a bandana, or any kind of clothing whatsoever that would've covered the right nostril entry wound?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:40:06):
No.
Lawyer 2 (06:40:06):
Did anything like that come in with a body bag?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:40:09):
No.
Lawyer 2 (06:40:12):
When you arrived at ... You mentioned in going over your qualifications, you mentioned a peer review system or peer review scenario and in arriving at the manner of death determination that you did here is homicide, did you introduce that finding to a peer review system in GBI?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:40:30):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (06:40:33):
Okay. How many other medical examiners were involved in that peer review?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:40:37):
Well, this would ... The official peer review was done by a single medical examiner who would've reviewed the case and signed off on it, would've reviewed the autopsy report, the autopsy photographs, and if they agreed, they would've signed off on it. That'd be the official peer review that would've been done.
Lawyer 2 (06:40:56):
After subjecting your findings to the peer review, did you still arrive at the manner of death as being homicide, sir?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:41:05):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (06:41:15):
You think it's important, sir ... Let me ask you this. Why do you view, why is it you want to view the decedent's body in person at your laboratory? Could you just look at photographs, for example, photographs that were taken some other time, they show them to Dr. Lehman, he arrives at and makes all these findings?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:41:35):
No, I mean, you can't photograph everything that might be important in the case. You need to be able to look, not just at what was photographed, but you've got to be able to see everything because you have to rule out other things. You have to make sure there's no other injuries that are present or other findings.
(06:41:56)
You want to see it in person because it's not as good to see a photograph as it is to see the body in person typically. There's things you might see in person that you won't see in a photograph. Now, sometimes there's things you might see in a photograph that you didn't notice in person too, but there's ... So there can be advantages to seeing both, but there are definite advantages to seeing the body as opposed to just seeing photographs.
Lawyer 2 (06:42:28):
Not only seeing the body, but conducting an examination?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:42:31):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (06:42:32):
In person?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:42:33):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (06:42:35):
Once your examination was finished here, do you release the body to a funeral home or what happens then?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:42:41):
Yes, that's correct.
Lawyer 2 (06:42:42):
So when you finish your external and internal physical in-person examination of the body, are you aware of any other expert that had an opportunity to physically come in and conduct a physical examination of this body?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:42:55):
No.
Lawyer 2 (06:43:18):
I know that you've been tendered as an expert, you are an expert in forensic pathology. Do you ever hire your services out to go outside the GBI and testify around the state or country, offer other opinions in other cases that are not GBI in origin?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:43:36):
I've worked part-time in the past years to perform autopsies in a couple of the county offices in the Atlantic area, DeKalb County Medical Examiner's Office and the Cobb County Medical Examiner's Office, to fill in to help with autopsies there. But I think I got involved in one civil case many years ago. I don't remember the details. That person wasn't autopsied though. As far as testifying in being an expert witness and reviewing cases that other people have autopsied, I don't recall having ... I don't believe I've ever ... I've never done expert work in that fashion.
Lawyer 2 (06:44:19):
Have you ever been paid to go and give an opinion that was in contrast to another medical examiner, sir?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:44:27):
No.
Lawyer 2 (06:44:30):
Do you get paid anything other than your GBI salary to be here today in court testifying?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:44:35):
No.
Lawyer 2 (06:44:41):
Would it have been easier or more difficult, sir, just to write this as an undetermined for you?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:44:47):
It would've been easier. As far as if you're talking about the amount of time and effort involved in the case and the amount of work, it would've been much easier to call it undetermined.
Lawyer 2 (06:45:04):
You get any kind of bonus, or points, or move up the chain at the GBI by calling this a homicide?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:45:09):
No.
Lawyer 2 (06:45:23):
Did anybody, sir, any party in law enforcement or anybody else pressure you to make a homicide determination in this case, sir?
Dr. Keith Lehman (06:45:30):
No.
Lawyer 2 (06:45:45):
That's all I have. Thank you. Thank you, sir.
Judge (06:45:46):
All right, ladies and gentlemen, we'll take a 10-minute break.
Speaker 24 (06:45:46):
Ready now Mr. Steel?
Mr. Steel (06:45:46):
Yes sir.
Speaker 24 (07:05:35):
All right. Ready when you are Diane. Welcome back. Cross examination.
Mr. Steel (07:07:04):
Doc, do you know Dr. Carol Terry?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:07:06):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:07:07):
And do you know her fairly well professionally?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:07:13):
I know of her. I worked for one year with her many years ago during my training. She was a fellowship coordinator. She was a fully trained forensic pathologist in the Fulton County Medical Examiner's Office when I did my last year of forensic pathology fellowship training there. So I worked with her then, and I know she's been the chief medical examiner in Gwinnett County for a long time.
Mr. Steel (07:07:39):
And she has a great reputation, fair to say?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:07:42):
Yes. Yes. She has a reputation of being a very good forensic pathologist.
Mr. Steel (07:07:46):
And do you know Dr. Jamie Downs?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:07:48):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:07:49):
And how do you know him?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:07:51):
He worked for the GBI in our medical examiner's office for a number of years, but it's been a while now. It may have been 10 years ago. I don't remember exactly, but he worked in our system down in the Savannah area lab.
Mr. Steel (07:08:09):
You hold him in the high regard also as far as his medical?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:08:12):
While he was at the GBI, he did good forensic pathology work.
Mr. Steel (07:08:16):
You were asked questions by the prosecutor about, did you ever go out and get paid for your time and your expertise to look over other people's works at autopsies? Remember those type of questions?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:08:31):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:08:31):
There's nothing wrong with that, is there?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:08:34):
No, no, no. There's not necessarily anything wrong with doing that kind of work.
Mr. Steel (07:08:38):
Yeah. I mean, these are people's opinions, right?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:08:42):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:08:42):
And people's opinions can agree, right?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:08:45):
I'm sorry?
Mr. Steel (07:08:46):
People's opinions can agree with one another. They can agree. They can say, "Yes, I think that that person got it right."
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:08:54):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:08:54):
And people's opinions can disagree, right?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:08:57):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:08:58):
It doesn't mean anybody is doing anything wrong. These are just the way they look at it based upon their expertise.
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:09:06):
Yeah, that's right. Just because you have disagreement in a case, it doesn't necessarily mean that one party is wrong and the other party is right.
Mr. Steel (07:09:16):
Yeah. I mean, and that's why we have peer reviews, right?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:09:20):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:09:21):
I mean, you've disagreed with other medical examiners that you respect, right, at times?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:09:27):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:09:27):
And they disagreed with you at times?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:09:30):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:09:30):
And it's just the nature of what... We're human beings, correct?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:09:34):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:09:35):
And there's nothing wrong with being paid for your time and your expertise, is there?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:09:40):
That's correct.
Mr. Steel (07:09:41):
I mean, you're getting paid, and I'm not going to ask you how much, but that's just how we function in America, right? Somebody gives a service, you get paid for a service, or you could donate your time, true?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:09:53):
That's correct.
Mr. Steel (07:09:54):
Okay. And if you wanted to do consulting work, independent consulting work when you left the GBI, there's nothing wrong with that, is there?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:10:07):
That's correct.
Mr. Steel (07:10:09):
Now, you're not a firearms expert, but because of what you do, you do understand somewhat about range of fire and what comes out of a gun and things like that. Is that fair to say?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:10:23):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:10:24):
But there are people who are firearms experts per se, they just focus on it, and they may know more than a medical examiner or more than you. Would you agree with that?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:10:32):
Yeah. Firearms expert would know more about the actual gun, evaluating a gun, evaluating a bullet, matching bullets to a gun. They wouldn't have more expertise as far as any kind of examination on the body.
Mr. Steel (07:10:50):
Sure. You start the body, that's where yours starts, your expertise starts, firearms ends once the bullet strikes the body, basically.
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:10:59):
Yeah. Their involvement is testing, evaluating the gun, testing and evaluating the bullets, and also possibly evaluate... They can do some evaluation for a range of fire and evaluation of clothing.
Mr. Steel (07:11:18):
And that's because range of fire deals with the gun, how far the soot may come out or the unburned gunpowder, things like that?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:11:26):
Yes. It's really the gunpowder pattern and the stippling pattern that they can measure. They can test fire the gun if there's a gunpowder stippling pattern and give some idea of how far the gun would've been away from the body at the time of the shot.
Mr. Steel (07:11:43):
Now with Mr. Akers, when he suffered, God forbid, the fatal bullet to the right nostril area and it entered the brain, that's almost instantaneously decapitating. I mean, decapitating, that's wrong. He can't function. Is that fair to say?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:12:01):
Probably. The most likely outcome with a gunshot wound where the bullet enters the brain is the person becomes unconscious and incapacitated.
Mr. Steel (07:12:11):
Okay. And then if there was momentum going backwards and the bullet goes into the nasal passage into the brain, God forbid, Mr. Akers may just fall totally backwards?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:12:26):
Yes. I think if you're standing in your shot, I think it's difficult to predict exactly how a person's going to fall.
Mr. Steel (07:12:33):
But is it consistent with just falling backwards, hands at the side?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:12:37):
It could. That could happen, yes.
Mr. Steel (07:12:39):
I'm going to show you what I believe you've seen before, but you tell us. It's Ms. Boles 17 and Ms. Boles 41. May I approach, Your Honor?
Speaker 24 (07:12:54):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (07:12:55):
Doctor, may I approach you? Take a look at these, and they're already in evidence. [inaudible 07:13:13]?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:13:13):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:13:14):
Do you recognize those?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:13:15):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:13:16):
Okay. I'm just going to ask the court if I can display it on the court screen.
Speaker 24 (07:13:21):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:13:24):
[inaudible 07:13:24]. Thank you.
Speaker 25 (07:13:33):
This is Boles 41.
Mr. Steel (07:13:41):
So if that's Mr. Akers and the... Thank you, [inaudible 07:13:43]. And he was standing with momentum going backwards. Once that bullet goes into his body where it was, would you expect him to land something like this?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:14:01):
I think if you're in a standing position and you're shot in the head and with injury of the brain, it's hard for me to predict exactly how the person would fall, whether they would fall backwards or forwards or sideways. I think it could be variable.
Mr. Steel (07:14:17):
But if there's momentum going backwards, if he's going backwards a little bit and then while the bullet then was discharged, would this be consistent with how he can fall?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:14:26):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:14:27):
All right. And I'm just going to show you the other one just for the jurors, but it's a similar photograph.
Speaker 25 (07:14:32):
This doesn't say state or Boles on it, [inaudible 07:14:34].
Mr. Steel (07:14:34):
It's Ms. Boles.
Speaker 25 (07:14:35):
Okay.
Mr. Steel (07:14:35):
I apologize. I'll correct it.
Speaker 25 (07:14:37):
17, it says on it.
Mr. Steel (07:14:42):
And this is just another picture, but it's the same example. Is that fair to say?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:14:48):
Yes. Yeah, from a photograph from a different vantage point, it appears.
Mr. Steel (07:14:52):
Okay. All right. I want to continue. Thank you very much, sir. I want to show you Ms. Boles 145, 146, and 147, which you've seen before. May I approach, Your Honor?
Speaker 24 (07:15:15):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:15:16):
Doctor, can I come forward?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:15:17):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:15:19):
Thank you. You've seen those and you've talked about those today?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:15:30):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:15:32):
Do you recognize these?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:15:33):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:15:33):
And these photographs that you had taken at the time of the autopsy?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:15:46):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:15:46):
Your Honor, I move for the admission of Ms. Boles 145 and 6, and 147.
Speaker 26 (07:15:46):
No objections, Your Honor.
Speaker 24 (07:15:46):
Admitted.
Mr. Steel (07:15:46):
May I [inaudible 07:15:47]?
Speaker 24 (07:15:46):
Yes, [inaudible 07:15:47].
Mr. Steel (07:15:47):
Thank you.
Speaker 25 (07:15:47):
Boles 145.
Mr. Steel (07:15:52):
Now, doctor, this is when you meet Mr. Akers after he is washed up. Is that fair to say?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:16:04):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:16:05):
And you made it clear, but he has to be washed up for you to really see what's going on because the blood is covering the area of the mouth and the nose, so you need to see where the defect is.
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:16:17):
That's correct.
Mr. Steel (07:16:19):
And you mentioned to the jurors that it is possible that when Mr. Akers was being washed up, cleaned up, I guess, so you could do your work, the soot was removed from his body, true?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:16:37):
Yeah, I think it's possible. I think the likelihood, given the bullet cartridge that was used, that all of the soot would've been able to wipe away. I think it's very unlikely, but I can't say it's impossible.
Mr. Steel (07:16:52):
Okay. And you didn't do the cleanup, you had a coworker do that?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:16:56):
Probably. I don't recall specifically, but that's probably the case.
Mr. Steel (07:17:01):
Okay. But the stippling, you can't wipe off, fair to say?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:17:06):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:17:07):
Okay. You can show the next one.
Speaker 25 (07:17:09):
Boles 146.
Mr. Steel (07:17:17):
And this is another example of what you did when you looked at Mr. Akers, and you talked about this right here. Do you see the pointer I'm using?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:17:30):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:17:30):
Did you say there's another... I call this an abrasion. Is that what I learned from you? Is that an abrasion?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:17:36):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:17:37):
Okay. And did you say there's a secondary abrasion on the nose?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:17:40):
There's a tear. There's a tear there at the edge of the nose that represents where the bullet impacted and injured the tissue, and then there's abrasion around that.
Mr. Steel (07:17:53):
You're talking about right here?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:17:55):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:17:56):
Is there another abrasion to this nostril area?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:18:00):
No. On the inside, there's a laceration or a graze wound from where the bullet enters the nose at this point and goes up along the outer aspect of the nasal cavity, the lining of that nasal cavity on the right side.
Mr. Steel (07:18:18):
You discussed this before, but if you can show the next exhibit number and announce what it is, please.
Speaker 25 (07:18:28):
Boles 147.
Mr. Steel (07:18:31):
And this is what you're talking about, this abrasion right here?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:18:35):
Yeah. Yeah. I would call that probably a laceration, but deep abrasion or superficial laceration.
Mr. Steel (07:18:41):
Okay. And is there anything down here that you noticed for abrasion?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:18:46):
No, the laceration continues up into the cavity as far as we could see, and then it disappeared past the point where we could see, and then after that entered the intracranial cavity.
Mr. Steel (07:18:57):
And using Ms. Boles number 147, if it can be usable, can you see where the bullet actually entered the nasal passage, actually struck and buried its way into the brain?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:19:11):
Yes. The tear. Where it initially hits the edge of the nostril here, causes a tear, causes the abrasion there, and it continues along the outer edge of the nasal passage and causes a graze wound, a laceration along the inside of that path.
Mr. Steel (07:19:33):
Do we have any photograph, though, showing the actual defect inside the nasal passage?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:19:40):
Yeah, you can see part of it there.
Mr. Steel (07:19:42):
Where is it? You talking about this?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:19:44):
Oh, I'm sorry. I forgot I had a pointer. Yeah, so here's the abrasion and the laceration extends here like that.
Mr. Steel (07:19:55):
Where the bullet disappears inside the brain, I'm asking you, did you do anything like a rod or any type of probe to put in to show us exactly the path going into the brain, besides?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:20:12):
No, I don't recall if we used a rod at the time, but we didn't. If we did, we didn't photograph it.
Mr. Steel (07:20:18):
Okay. And did you take a Q-tip or any other device and just swab the inside? And when I say you, it could be your coworker, the inside of the right nostril to determine whether there was any soot?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:20:32):
No, we didn't do any swabbings.
Mr. Steel (07:20:34):
Thank you, sir. Did you put in your report anything about looking into the nose for soot with a light or without a light? Is that in your report anywhere?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:20:45):
No, it's not in the report.
Mr. Steel (07:20:47):
Okay. So I'd like to discuss with you a couple of things. This is any homicide or suicide is a tragedy at some level to people. So I understand it's a tragedy, but this is also... Mr. Akers' person also tells a story. It's evidence. Is that true? His body's evidence.
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:21:19):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:21:19):
And the evidence, people like you or Dr. Terry and Dr. Downs or others, can really look at it to try to tell what happened here, true?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:21:30):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:21:31):
And by doing that, you're looking at the physical findings of the body when you see it, right?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:21:40):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:21:40):
And you try to collect all the possible evidence that you can.
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:21:44):
Everything that we think would be useful, yes.
Mr. Steel (07:21:47):
And I'm not critical at all, but being human beings, sometimes we don't gather all the evidence. Is that fair to say?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:21:54):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:21:55):
And just like I asked you, it's pretty easy to do. I'm not saying you agree with that, but to take a Q-tip or a swab.
Mr. Steel (07:22:00):
You agree with that, but to take a Q-tip or a swab and take the inner wiping or swiping of the nose to determine whether there was soot there, that's a pretty easy thing to do. Fair to say?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:22:13):
It would be easy, but I don't think it would be useful.
Mr. Steel (07:22:16):
Right. Oh, sorry. Go ahead.
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:22:19):
Yeah. I mean, it would be easy to swab the nose, but it wouldn't be useful in giving us any information.
Mr. Steel (07:22:26):
Because you don't think there was soot there?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:22:28):
Well, because I don't know that there's a test for soot. I don't know that there's any test that you can run. I'm not aware of any test you can run on a swab that we would've taken during the nasal patch that would determine if the gunshot wound was a contact range wound or not a contact range wound. If you-
Mr. Steel (07:22:59):
Oh, go ahead. I'll never interrupt you. Go ahead. I apologize.
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:23:03):
Yeah. I think that the testing that would be considered, if I saw anything that appeared like it might be soot, then you could look under the microscope. That would be the thing to do. But in the absence of finding grossly to the naked eye, soot, I don't think there's any other testing that would be useful to make that determination.
Mr. Steel (07:23:26):
But you didn't swab the inside of the nose or even just take a sharp instrument and just peel out without defacing the body, but just take some of the tissue on the inside of the nostril and then look at it under a microscope and say, but you didn't do that either, did you?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:23:45):
I did not do that.
Mr. Steel (07:23:46):
Okay. And I think you said it already, there's nothing, absolutely nothing in your report about even looking in the nose with a light or otherwise for soot.
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:23:55):
Yeah. I did mention in the report that I looked in the nose, but I didn't specify that I used a light.
Mr. Steel (07:24:01):
Or for soot, you never specified that?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:24:03):
No, but I would've absolutely done that. I mean, that's a key part of this case, the absence of soot on the surface of the nose and in the interior of the nose.
Mr. Steel (07:24:14):
Yeah. It is a key part of the case, but you don't mention it in your report at all that you did that. Am I correct?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:24:19):
It says... Well, let's see what it says. It says, "I described the abrasion." I said, "Extending from this abrasion is a laceration along the wound path involving the mucosal surface of the right nasal cavity superior laterally." That's the inside of the nose. And then the sentence after that says, "No soot or gunpowder stippling is seen." So I examined that area. I examined the outside, I examined the inside, and I stated that no soot or gunpowder stippling is seen.
Mr. Steel (07:25:00):
Okay. That's with the naked eye?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:25:02):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:25:03):
Okay. Now I want to talk with you about... You said that, and I know you're not a firearms expert, but you said that from your training, experience and knowledge, if there's 12 inches or more, you would not expect to see soot or stippling with this type of gun and that type of wound. Is that true?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:25:39):
Yeah. What I would say is for this type of gun, what you would expect is once you get to around 12 inches away, you may not have stippling. It's possible you could have stippling maybe out to around a foot and a half or so, possibly a little farther. So I can't precisely say how far the gun would have to be away, but it could be as close as around a foot.
Mr. Steel (07:26:07):
Okay. And a foot is 12 inches, obviously?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:26:09):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:26:10):
And just for demonstration, is it fair to say that if something is a contact wound, so on skin, let's say, I'm turning this on. If something is a contact wound, it touches and there's no stippling, true?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:26:33):
That's correct.
Mr. Steel (07:26:34):
Because a stippling gets consumed in the soot. It just goes straight in because it's contacted with the skin or the wall or whatever it is, right?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:26:43):
Yeah. The gunpowder particles that cause the soot in a contact wound would all go... The unburned gunpowder particles would all go into the wound. And so they wouldn't be able to impact the skin around the surface of the wound.
Mr. Steel (07:26:55):
But just like a flashlight, if you move the light away, then that's what... The light gets bigger and that's what we're talking about, the stippling, it can spread out. It has room to spread out, true?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:27:08):
Yes, that's correct.
Mr. Steel (07:27:10):
And at some point you're saying in this case, I'm just using your number and it's an estimate, but 12 inches, maybe we don't see any soot or stippling around this wound according to you, fair?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:27:25):
That's correct.
Mr. Steel (07:27:26):
And 12 inches, if this is reliable, I have a ruler it's about this long.
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:27:31):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:27:31):
Is that fair to say?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:27:32):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:27:33):
And this is not a gun, this is a toy. Your Honor, may I display? This is a toy. If I am holding... I'm not putting my finger in the trigger. If I am holding this item, this toy, and I'll mark it as an exhibit, I can get this to be 12 inches from my nose. Fair to say?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:28:05):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:28:07):
And you said earlier that, or maybe I'm saying, things are dynamic. When you come out the body, some people's bodies can move. Fair to say?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:28:18):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:28:19):
And because of that, the fact that the bullet strikes into the right nasal passage, it doesn't mean that Mr. Akers is standing straight up and the gun is pointed at him and it happens to go right through the nose and hardly make any defect except that little abrasion according to you, right? I mean, the head can move up, down, it could be moving sideways, true?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:28:44):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:28:45):
And the hand can also be up or down and moving sideways, right?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:28:49):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:28:50):
And on the gun that we have here, if it's pointed at Mr. Akers' mouth, if he's pointing the gun at his own mouth, if he's holding it, you can make that 12 inches, but it's difficult, right? I mean, the wrist has to bend, true?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:29:10):
Yeah. I think you would have to hold the gun in an atypical way, I think, to be able to hold it in your left hand and have the wound path that we have in this case.
Mr. Steel (07:29:24):
And atypical doesn't mean it can't be done. It's just not being held in the general way we think about holding a gun, right?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:29:31):
That's correct.
Mr. Steel (07:29:33):
Because if all if I do is move my wrist, that's all I'm doing. Now the gun is right here at my nose, right?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:29:39):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:29:40):
With my left hand, true? True?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:29:43):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:29:43):
And if I pulled the trigger, if this was the gun and I pulled the trigger, we could make it easy, easy for me to take the wound with the wound paths that you described to the jurors, which is front to back, slightly upward, slightly upward, and from the slightly right to left. True?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:30:04):
Yeah. The wound as far as the location of the wound and the wound path direction, you could.
Mr. Steel (07:30:09):
And I'm going to show you, this is a toy, but the actual gun that we have here, because of just safety, it has a lock on it. Did you notice that?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:30:24):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:30:25):
And because at the cylinder can't close. Did you notice that?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:30:28):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:30:29):
So even though the jurors can see it, you can't get this muzzle of the gun and the cylinder right next to each other because of safety in the actual gun, right?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:30:44):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:30:44):
So I have a replica and it's not the same model or anything. But can I approach, Your Honor? Can I approach you?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:30:53):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:30:59):
I'd like to show you the cylinder at the bottom underneath the muzzle. It doesn't come out as far as the actual weapon, which is in State's Exhibit 173. Is that fair to say?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:31:14):
Yeah. If you're saying the ejector rod here in the actual weapon comes all the way out to the, as I recall, all the way out to the end of the muzzle, whereas this one is retracted about an eighth of an inch.
Mr. Steel (07:31:27):
Can I approach? May I approach you?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:31:30):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:31:31):
And what you're talking about, if you could just look at it.
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:31:37):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:31:38):
And don't touch it if you don't mind, because we're not wearing gloves, but that cylinder, the end of the cylinder almost looks like it touches almost the equivalent to the end of the gun.
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:31:49):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:31:49):
Okay. Your Honor, can we show the jurors?
Judge (07:31:56):
Yeah.
Mr. Steel (07:31:56):
Would you mind helping me? Doctor, would you mind coming down?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:32:00):
Yes, sure.
Mr. Steel (07:32:07):
We'll just do it in two phases, if that's okay.
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:32:09):
Okay.
Mr. Steel (07:32:11):
The gun here, if it were to lock, is it fair to say that that cylinder we're talking about in the muzzle of it on the end of the gun, they almost look like they end it the same way. Is that true?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:32:25):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:32:26):
And can you show the replica gun? And the replica gun is not really great because the cylinder is just, you said about an eighth of an inch shorter than the muzzle of the gun. Is that true?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:32:37):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:32:37):
Can we do it to the next set of jurors?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:32:37):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:32:44):
And it's going to be the same thing. If this was closed the way it would be, if it was functioning on the night of the killing, the bottom, the farthest part of that cylinder is almost equivalent to the farthest part of the muzzle. Is that fair to say?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:33:03):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:33:03):
And then can you just show on the replica? And just show that little space that you're talking about, the eighth of an inch.
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:33:12):
Yeah. It looks like on that gun, the ejector rod goes all the way to be equal to the end of the barrel.
Mr. Steel (07:33:21):
And then at the end of the rod on the real gun, State's Exhibit 173, it's a silver piece and there's no graving to it smooth looking.
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:33:33):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:33:36):
All right. I want to ask you some questions if I can. So if I am... Would you mind helping me? Request permission. If I am Mr. Akers and you are, if you don't mind, Ms. Boles, hypothetically, if I'm like this when you come into the room with the gun and you come at me and pull my arm anywhere around here, tell the jury that it's possible I can just turn my wrist over.
Mr. Lale (07:34:15):
Judge, I'm going to object if that's outside... This line of questioning is outside the scope of the expertise of the witness. He's not an accident reconstructionist, a shooting, senior reconstructionist, et cetera. His specialty and his knowledge and expertise is forensic pathology. Now we're getting into reconstruction. We're acting out [inaudible 07:34:31] possibilities. I believe the defense has some expert on that and that's not Dr. Lehman.
Judge (07:34:37):
Well, I haven't heard your question yet, Mr. Steel, just [inaudible 07:34:40] his area of expertise.
Mr. Steel (07:34:41):
Absolutely. I'm talking about the range of fire that you talked about on direct examination. Okay? You understand the [inaudible 07:34:49]?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:34:47):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:34:50):
So if I'm like this and you come at me, which I'm going to ask you with the court's permission and with your permission, if you don't mind, to just grab my arm. Is there a way I can just turn my wrist, have the 12 inches of this gunfire?
Mr. Lale (07:35:04):
Again, that's calling for scene reconstruction, shooting reconstruction, actually subbing in this witness, Dr. Lehman, as the defendant, how this might have unfolded. That's for an expert in scene reconstruction, accident reconstruction. And Mr. Steel's trying to tie it to range of fire. Dr. Lehman gave range of fire in the terms of mathematical figures. This is possible. He didn't talk about locations of weapons acting out. This is how it may have happened. So it can't be tied to range of fire.
Judge (07:35:35):
Well, let me hear the question and then I'll make a ruling on whether I believe it's outside of his range of expertise.
Mr. Steel (07:35:41):
So if I'm like this and then you come at me and I go back and I just turn, can you make that 12 inches?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:35:49):
Yes, it's physically possible.
Mr. Steel (07:35:50):
Okay. And if it's 12 inches, maybe 10, 18 inches, I'm just using the 12 because it's shorter and that's what the ruler is. That would show no soot, no stippling, and we can make the shot. True?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:36:04):
Yeah. I would expect at 12 inches, it may not have any stippling. And by the time you get to 18 inches, it very likely you wouldn't have any stippling.
Mr. Steel (07:36:14):
Okay. Understood. And that's what you testified to earlier?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:36:18):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:36:19):
And these are estimates. You're saying 12 inches or more?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:36:24):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:36:24):
More likely once you get to 18, no more stippling. So that's what you can testify.
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:36:28):
Right.
Mr. Steel (07:36:33):
Okay. So I said 12. I'm just using 12. Now, same question. Remember how you were discussing the abrasion on the outside of the nostril?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:36:42):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:36:43):
I'm now going to interject the cylinder rod. Remember discussing with the prosecutor on direct examination about the cylinder rod?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:36:51):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:36:52):
And the abrasion?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:36:54):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:36:55):
And how do you believe it's the bullet? Remember all those questions?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:36:57):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:36:58):
And you didn't believe it was a cylinder rod, remember all those questions?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:37:00):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:37:01):
Okay. I want to ask you about that, okay?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:37:01):
Okay.
Mr. Steel (07:37:06):
If, again, I'm like this and you come at me, grab my hand or my arm. If I go like this and I shove that gun muzzle into my nose, does a cylinder rod touch approximately where the abrasion is?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:37:21):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:37:23):
And if the gun muzzle of the gun, the end of the gun, the arms piece, if that goes into my nose, would that jam put the real gun, the cylinder rod into the area where there's that circular abrasion?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:37:36):
Yes. The way you had the gun positioned, that would position the end of that cylinder rod right where the abrasion was present. If it's a contact range wound, you could have it caused that abrasion.
Mr. Steel (07:37:49):
Right. And if it was a contact wound, then you wouldn't have any stippling, true?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:37:59):
That's correct.
Mr. Steel (07:38:00):
And if it's a contact wound, all of the soot that comes out of the gun would go into the nasal cavity, true?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:38:09):
Not necessarily. With contact range wounds, you'll often have soot around the edge too.
Mr. Steel (07:38:19):
I'm not trying to interrupt. You can sit. Can you explain that? Once you get back to your seat, can you explain what you just said?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:38:27):
It's possible that all of the soot goes just inside, but oftentimes you'll have searing of the outer edges of the wound as we saw in the previous photograph where you can see on the skin surface that there was soot deposition of searing. So you often see it on the skin, but sometimes the vast majority of it can go in, especially if it's a hard contact wound.
Mr. Steel (07:38:54):
We're going to talk about searing in a minute. I promise you I'll come right back to it. Okay? But under what I just asked you, according to your answer, and track me because I'm not trying to misstate you, if the gun is my left hand, the gun is rotated, I forget your word, but not typical. I forget what word you used, but upside down, that abrasion mark you said is consistent with where the rod is, the cylinder rod, fair?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:39:29):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:39:30):
And then if it's discharged, the gun is discharged while the muzzle gun is into the nose, you said there may be some soot on the outside of the nostril. That's what I think you said.
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:39:42):
Yes. Yeah. The gun... Yeah.
Mr. Steel (07:39:50):
Okay. And then you already said it, but that soot could have been washed away in the cleanup phase.
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:39:56):
Certainly some of the soot could. I think it's very unlikely that you'd be able to wash all of it away, but I can't say it's impossible.
Mr. Steel (07:40:03):
I know. I know. Okay. Do you still have the pictures of the searing? And if you need, I could help find them. Yes.
Mr. Lale (07:40:26):
It's over here.
Mr. Steel (07:40:26):
Thank you, sir.
Mr. Lale (07:40:35):
If I can just let the record reflect I'm showing Mr. Steel State's 241 to 242 that were used for demonstrative only.
Mr. Steel (07:40:43):
May I approach?
Judge (07:40:43):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (07:40:44):
I'm just going to show you from the book examples that you looked at earlier, and it's the same number that the prosecutor just announced. Tell me which one we're going to use to show the jurors what you were just talking about when you mentioned searing.
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:41:02):
Yeah. 242.
Mr. Steel (07:41:02):
May I take it?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:41:05):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:41:06):
Your Honor, may we [inaudible 07:41:07]?
Judge (07:41:06):
Yes. This investigator?
Mr. Steel (07:41:13):
And help us orient. Nobody's trying to confuse the jury. This is clearly just... This is for teaching purposes. This is not Mr. Akers' body, fair?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:41:26):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:41:27):
Okay. Okay. So if the lights can be dimmed, Your Honor, if that's okay.
Judge (07:41:34):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (07:41:36):
So these are two... You talked about searing, correct? Because they're contact wounds, right?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:41:42):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:41:43):
Okay. And what part of the body is either or both of these gunshot wounds touching?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:41:54):
It doesn't say.
Mr. Steel (07:41:54):
Well, it doesn't matter, but let me say it differently. It's not the nose, fair to say?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:42:03):
I think it's probably not the nose.
Mr. Steel (07:42:07):
Because it's continuous skin.
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:42:09):
[inaudible 07:42:10] nasal opening, yes.
Mr. Steel (07:42:10):
It's continuous skin, right?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:42:12):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:42:13):
Because the nose is different because if somebody put a gun to my forearm and touched it, like these are contact, right?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:42:23):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:42:24):
That's what you believe? And fired, my skin would get that searing around it, true?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:42:32):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:42:33):
But my nose has an opening, true?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:42:37):
That's correct.
Mr. Steel (07:42:37):
That's how I breathe, right? It's like my mouth, right?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:42:44):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:42:44):
I could breathe through my mouth too. So this searing is on the actual skin without an opening. That's an example of that, true?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:42:55):
That's right.
Mr. Steel (07:42:56):
Because in the nose, if I have the gun, and I'm just using the replica, this is the replica. And if I have the gun into my nose, all that soot, burning gunpowder, that actually goes into my head, right? Towards back, I have an opening there.
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:43:15):
Yes. There would be a lot of it that went there.
Mr. Steel (07:43:20):
Well, it depends, I guess, on the gun, but it goes into my nose. I mean, this isn't tricking. It's not like the skin where the skin is covered and now the skin is being burrowed apart. I already have the opening if the gun is into my nose and the trigger is pulled.
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:43:36):
But in this case, you know the opening of the muzzle is right there adjacent to the skin because the graze wound that you see on the inside of the nose when it's created by the bullet extends all the way to that abrasion. And so you know that that opening has to be adjacent to the skin there. So it's possible that you might have... So you're going to either have soot on the... You're going to have it at the edge. Now, whether it's just barely inside the edge, I guess that's possible that you don't have it on the skin surface, but there's a good chance you're going to have it on the skin surface as well. But it may just be inside the nose too. Either way, I don't think you'd be able to wipe all of that soot away, whether the searing is on the skin or whether it's just inside the nose, either way.
Mr. Steel (07:44:41):
And a lot of that is, you're basing it on the graze wound, which we're going to talk about too. Fair to say?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:44:47):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:44:47):
Okay. And I'm just putting that aside because this is complicated, fair?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:44:52):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:44:53):
This is a complicated exercise, right? Or examination or analysis. Fair to say?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:45:01):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:45:02):
I mean, you have cases... We've had other cases together that's not complicated. I'm not saying the cases are complicated, but the wound path is not complicated, right?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:45:12):
Yes. Yeah. There are other types of wounds where the wound itself is simpler to evaluate.
Mr. Steel (07:45:19):
I mean, this one takes a lot of time, correct?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:45:23):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:45:23):
I mean, the prosecutor asked you some questions about would it have been easier to say and determine... I mean, we don't sign up for easy, right? We sign up for doing our best we can.
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:45:34):
That's correct.
Mr. Steel (07:45:36):
So I want to go back, and I promise you I'll come back to the graze wound. I promise you. But if the gun at the time that it discharged was inside, I'm saying inside the nasal cavity of Mr. Akers, the abrasion could be made by the cylinder rod and the soot could go into the head.
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:46:00):
Well, what do you mean by inside?
Mr. Steel (07:46:03):
Just like I'm doing.
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:46:05):
You'll have to come closer. I can't see exactly where it is.
Mr. Steel (07:46:07):
May I approach, Your Honor?
Judge (07:46:08):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:46:11):
Just like a finger can go in the nose, right? True?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:46:16):
Yes. But the difference is this gun, you can put it inside the nose because the cylinder rod doesn't go all the way to the end of the barrel on this replica, but on the other gun, it did. And so you wouldn't be able to... To get the cylinder to line up to the skin, you wouldn't be able to put the gun inside the nose.
Mr. Steel (07:46:43):
But the nose skin moves. It's flexible, right?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:46:46):
It is.
Mr. Steel (07:46:47):
And we have the abrasion, so the skin gave way to something, right?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:46:53):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:46:54):
You're saying a bullet... I'm suggesting, I'm just asking questions that it's the cylinder rod, but either way, there's some object that ripped that skin, true?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:47:04):
Yeah. Yes. So either the bullet or the cylinder rod given the two choices.
Mr. Steel (07:47:12):
Yeah. And they're equal choices. I mean, it may be the cylinder rod, right? I mean, you're not discounting that. You're saying that's a possibility. It's not your opinion, but that is a possibility, fair?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:47:24):
I would say it's very unlikely, but I can't say it's impossible.
Mr. Steel (07:47:27):
Okay. With regards to the graze wound, I want to... You mentioned... I told you, I promise we'd come back to that. It is your... Can you put up the one with the nose being opened, if you don't mind, and announce which exhibit number it is when you get a chance?
Judge (07:47:51):
State's 239.
Mr. Steel (07:47:57):
And Doctor, you have a pointer and you are much more gifted than me, so don't let me... You just take over. But what I'm understanding from you is the bullet strikes the outside of the nose. So I'm just... I'm moving over. I'm moving to the left nostril. And to be fair, we are not saying that the left nostril has to be identical to the right nostril, true?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:48:23):
Correct.
Mr. Steel (07:48:24):
I mean, people's nostrils could look identical, but some people's nostrils do not look identical, fair?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:48:29):
That's correct.
Mr. Steel (07:48:31):
But just for simplicity, I'm just using as a hypothetical example, you're saying that somehow if it was on this side, the bullet strikes somewhere here and then goes into the nose, and then we come over here to the right nostril, and you're saying that the bullet itself took out this skin and then skipped here. I'm using the word skipped, but shows a path here, and that's your bullet path, right?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:49:00):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:49:00):
Okay. And if that is the bullet path, when the tweezers are not on the nose, the bullet doesn't change direction. It didn't hit any bone at this point, right? This is just skin.
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:49:19):
That's correct.
Mr. Steel (07:49:20):
So the bullet would... At that point, we would believe, would just keep going right here, true?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:49:28):
Well, it's a little misleading because what we've done is we've changed-
Mr. Steel (07:49:33):
And do me a favor. I'm going to interrupt you. Just show the jury this, if you don't mind.
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:49:38):
Yeah. So we've taken the nose and we've changed the position. So we've changed the direction of the wound path. And so it looks like the wound path's coming down, but if you put this back down to its normal position, this wound path goes up into the nose.
Mr. Steel (07:49:55):
Do you have any photograph of that, just a microscopic camera?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:50:00):
No.
Mr. Steel (07:50:01):
Okay. Okay. So this right here, what we're calling... I'm adopting your statement, this graze path here?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:50:16):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:50:18):
That could also be the gun. A gun can make that type of... If the gun is inside the nose, that can make that type of rip in the skin, true?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:50:32):
No, but I don't think that's the case here because you can follow this wound. You could follow it all the way up into the nose. That's evidence that the bullet caused that.
Mr. Steel (07:50:43):
Do you have any pictures of that?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:50:48):
I don't know.
Mr. Steel (07:50:50):
Well, if you find them, just let us know, okay?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:50:53):
Can I look at my autopsy photos?
Mr. Steel (07:50:55):
Yeah.
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:51:01):
I've got a device here with the photos on them.
Mr. Steel (07:51:03):
It's okay with me as long as the court gives permission.
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:51:48):
No, I don't have any additional photos other than this photograph to show that wound path.
Mr. Steel (07:51:53):
And beyond what Mr. Lale just said to me, this is probably a reasonably good example. This nostril is being forced. That's my word. You tell us if that's too strong of a word, but forced to be open wider than it typically is in this photograph, which is state's exhibit number...
Judge (07:52:15):
239.
Mr. Steel (07:52:16):
Is that true?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:52:17):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:52:19):
But it's demonstrative because the nose can be malleable or open wide if forced, right?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:52:29):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:52:30):
Just like if I shoved the gun into my nose, it could open. The gun is harder than my nose, true?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:52:37):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:52:45):
Okay. Now, I want to ask you a couple of questions. If you need to stand, please stand, but otherwise you could sit if you're more comfortable. You said, and it's State's Exhibit number 229, in your opinion at the very end, the bottom two lines on page four of five, you wrote that based upon the autopsy findings and the reported circumstances surrounding the death, the manner of death is classified as a homicide. True?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:53:24):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:53:25):
And the autopsy findings is what we've been talking about. That's the scientific analysis of Mr. Akers' person.
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:53:35):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:53:38):
And that just is what it is. It doesn't have any veracity determination. You don't need any truth. It's just there's soot there, there's stippling there, there's searing there, there's tattooing there or there's not. There's a bullet in the brain or there's not. I mean, these are just objective findings, right? Some subjective, but...
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:54:00):
I'm not sure I understand the question.
Mr. Steel (07:54:01):
The body, when it's analyzed, you can take photographs of it and x-rays of it, but the body itself has no agenda. It's just, it appears in the disaster bed, God forbid, and you do your work and other people can review the work and look at photographs and reports, right?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:54:19):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:54:21):
But you also reached out to law enforcement and you wanted to know specifically was there any depression, any signs of depression or suicidal tendencies by Mr. Akers? Remember those questions?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:54:35):
Yeah. I mean, that would've been part of it, but we want to know a lot more than that, but including that.
Mr. Steel (07:54:43):
And your response was... The response you got from law enforcement was that Mr. Akers was happy. Remember that?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:54:56):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:54:57):
And he had just bought a pig for one of the children for Christmas. Do you remember that?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:55:03):
That's correct.
Mr. Steel (07:55:04):
And it even said, the law enforcement officer wrote, "Who buys the pig and then buys the farm?" Remember that?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:55:11):
I don't remember that part of it.
Mr. Steel (07:55:17):
It's already in evidence, but let me just see if I could refresh your memory. May I have one moment, Your Honor?
Judge (07:55:27):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:55:49):
May I approach, Your Honor?
Judge (07:55:49):
You may.
Mr. Steel (07:55:52):
This is already in evidence. Dr. Lehman, there's a series of emails. If you want to see the whole thing, just say it, okay?
Mr. Steel (07:56:00):
... a series of emails. If you want to see the whole thing, just say it, okay? May I approach, Judge?
Judge (07:56:10):
You may.
Mr. Steel (07:56:10):
May I approach you, sir?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:56:11):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:56:13):
If you need to see the series of emails, if you feel more comfortable, no problem. I was referring to that. I may not have quoted perfectly, but you were told by Lieutenant Hill of the Paulding County Sheriff's Department in response to your question about is there any depression by Mr. Akers? He wrote something like... You could read it, I don't have any more, but something like, who buys a pig and then buys a farm or something like that?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:56:55):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:56:55):
What was the actual quote?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:56:57):
It says, "Not to mention that he bought a pig from Tractor Supply, who buys an animal and buys the farm that evening."
Mr. Steel (07:57:05):
And buys a farm, do you know that's an expression meaning kill themselves?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:57:11):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:57:12):
All right. So you were never told that there was no pig bought, were you? You were told the opposite, right?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:57:20):
That's correct.
Mr. Steel (07:57:21):
Okay. Did anyone ever tell you that there was no pig bought?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:57:23):
No.
Mr. Steel (07:57:24):
All right. And did anyone ever tell you that Mr. Akers had problems, much like the prosecutor was asking you? That he wrote that he may be going to prison for four-plus years? It was 2019, so he said until 2024. You were not told that, were you?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:57:46):
I don't recall being told that.
Mr. Steel (07:57:48):
And you weren't told that he had said that he was going to potentially bury him and his wife and have the children taken to foster care, you weren't -- live in foster care, you weren't told that?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:58:06):
I'm sorry, could you repeat that?
Mr. Steel (07:58:07):
Yeah. That he was potentially going to... He wrote that if circumstances happened, he would bury him and his wife and the children would have to live in foster care. You weren't told that?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:58:19):
No.
Mr. Steel (07:58:20):
And you weren't told that he said that he's depressed, lonely, concerned how people would look at him because he can't afford to support the family. You weren't told any of that, were you?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:58:33):
No.
Mr. Steel (07:58:34):
Okay. And when the prosecutors asked you the questions about these other reported circumstances that you were told by law enforcement, did that change the scientific findings of the autopsy? Of course they don't change your scientific findings because they're separate things, correct?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:59:00):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:59:00):
I mean, he asked you a series of questions the same way and you said, "No, the autopsy is different than what I'm being told." True?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:59:08):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:59:10):
And they're really separate parts, but you being a scientist, want to get as much information as you can because it may be important background, it may not be, true?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:59:20):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:59:21):
And you can discount some things that you're told and you could increase some things you're told, but the bottom line is you kind of take it all together and then you made your finding in this case, right?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:59:31):
That's correct.
Mr. Steel (07:59:34):
When you were asked about to a degree of medical certainty, are you sure that it's a homicide, you're a professional and you said, "Look, this is a tough case," right?
Dr. Keith Lehman (07:59:50):
This is a tough case.
Mr. Steel (07:59:52):
And this may be exactly... And you believe it. You would not be here. You're a great person in our community. You believe that under all the circumstances that you were told and what you saw, this appears to be not a contact or near contact wound and you classify as a homicide for the reasons you already told the jury, true?
Dr. Keith Lehman (08:00:25):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (08:00:26):
But you're also a fair person and you've also made it clear this could be a contact wound and it could be a suicide attempt with an accident component to it, true?
Dr. Keith Lehman (08:00:40):
I can't rule out that possibility.
Mr. Steel (08:00:46):
And that's really what scientists do, right? I mean, scientists don't just... They're not advocates for anything but, "Is my hypothesis, does it work all the way through or are there alternative hypotheses," right?
Dr. Keith Lehman (08:01:02):
Yeah. What we do is we evaluate a case, we give an opinion, and then we come to an idea, we come to an opinion to a certain level of confidence.
Mr. Steel (08:01:22):
And in this particular matter, the truth is you are leaning, however far, heavily, I don't know, almost heavily, maybe just 51%, but you're leaning towards this is not a suicide, but you do understand that this could be a suicide with a component of accident, somebody trying to stop the person from killing themselves, right?
Dr. Keith Lehman (08:01:51):
I can't rule out that possibility.
Mr. Steel (08:02:04):
Okay. Thank you.
Lawyer 2 (08:02:10):
You can't rule out that possibility because you weren't in the room, is that right? You're not an eyewitness.
Dr. Keith Lehman (08:02:17):
Yes, that's correct.
Lawyer 2 (08:02:18):
So there's a number of possibilities in the universe that you can't rule out as a scientist because you don't have absolute certainty to exactly what happened. Is that right?
Dr. Keith Lehman (08:02:29):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (08:02:30):
But based on your knowledge of the case, your scientific evaluation and your examination of the physical evidence on the body, did you list accident... Or excuse me, did you list suicide with accident component as the manner of death?
Dr. Keith Lehman (08:02:48):
No.
Lawyer 2 (08:02:49):
Why? Why not? You could have put suicide and I guess suicide is one of the five findings, right?
Dr. Keith Lehman (08:02:58):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (08:02:59):
And maybe you could have put in parentheses, with accident component. Maybe just that's a Lehmanism, you can just add to that, by Keith Lehman. Why didn't you make that finding?
Dr. Keith Lehman (08:03:14):
Because the evidence in the case supported homicide.
Lawyer 2 (08:03:20):
Is that still your opinion today?
Dr. Keith Lehman (08:03:21):
Yes. I think the evidence in the case supports the homicide as a matter of death.
Lawyer 2 (08:03:31):
You were shown a picture of the decedent on the floor. You said you had seen it. I'm going to show what's been previously admitted into evidence as defense or Ms. Boles 41. Do you remember being asked about this photograph on direct examination?
Dr. Keith Lehman (08:03:54):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (08:03:54):
And you said you actually seen this photograph as part of your overall comprehensive investigation. You've seen it before today, is that right?
Dr. Keith Lehman (08:04:02):
Yes, I have.
Lawyer 2 (08:04:03):
And I want you to remember, please. Do you remember the defense attorney asking you, Mr. Steel, the honorable Mr. Steel, asking you if momentum from a bullet projectile, momentum from a gun could have caused, could that have been the momentum that caused the decedent to go backwards and fall just like this? Do you remember being asked that?
Dr. Keith Lehman (08:04:27):
Well, I remember him mentioning momentum, but I didn't understand that the momentum was meant to have been coming from the bullet.
Lawyer 2 (08:04:35):
Okay. He may have said force. He may have said the force or momentum, I think. What is force? Momentum times mass or whatever it was back in physics class. But he said force or momentum could have possibly caused the body to fall this way. Do you remember him asking you that?
Dr. Keith Lehman (08:04:54):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (08:04:54):
You said it's possible?
Dr. Keith Lehman (08:04:54):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (08:04:56):
You said there's a number of variables that could cause the body to fall certain ways, right?
Dr. Keith Lehman (08:05:01):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (08:05:02):
Okay. Is it possible that that force or momentum, sir, that may have caused the body to come to this final resting place could have been caused by somebody backing up from the shooter?
Dr. Keith Lehman (08:05:19):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (08:05:40):
Did you have access to, or did you watch any part of the video interrogation or interview of this defendant in law enforcement? Is it a part of your investigation or your findings in this case?
Dr. Keith Lehman (08:05:52):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (08:05:54):
Do you remember when the defendant herself acted out or gave a recreation of how this happened according to her?
Dr. Keith Lehman (08:06:04):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (08:06:05):
I think it was Detective Nick Hardy and you remember seemed to be kind of a notable point in that video where he actually asked her to come up and be standing, much like he did here with Mr. Steel. They were opposing each other and Detective Hardy asked the defendant to recreate how this happened. Did you watch that as part of your investigation?
Dr. Keith Lehman (08:06:28):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (08:06:29):
And do you remember if at any time, whether this defendant indicated with her recreation of how this happened, that the weapon was inverted or upside down?
Dr. Keith Lehman (08:06:42):
I don't remember. I don't remember from the video the orientation of the gun as it was depicted.
Lawyer 2 (08:06:51):
Okay. Would it surprise you, sir, if she did not ever indicate that this gun was upside down or inverted?
Dr. Keith Lehman (08:06:57):
No, wouldn't surprise me.
Lawyer 2 (08:07:05):
You said, on direct examination, that it's not impossible for all sooting to be wiped away during this cleansing of the face. You said it's not impossible. But sir, Dr. Lehman, is it probable that all soot would've been just washed away with this light cleansing of the face?
Dr. Keith Lehman (08:07:24):
No.
Lawyer 2 (08:07:36):
You said that it's not impossible for this abrasion to have been made by the ejection rod or the cylinder rod. You said that's not impossible, but Dr. Lehman, is that probable?
Dr. Keith Lehman (08:07:51):
No.
Lawyer 2 (08:07:57):
You said it would not have been impossible for this entire muzzle to be inserted into the decedent's right nostril at the time of discharge of the projectile. Sir, is that probable based on your findings?
Dr. Keith Lehman (08:08:18):
No, it's not probable.
Lawyer 2 (08:08:21):
And about the cylinder rod, I believe I heard you say that it's not probable that that abrasion, that marginal abrasion that we see on the nose was caused by the cylinder rod because they're not... Those two rods, the muzzle rod and the cylinder, the cylinder ejector rod, they're not exactly... They're almost exactly equal on the shooting weapon, right? But on Mr. Steel's replica, the ejector rod is, you said an eighth an inch longer than the muzzle. Do you remember that?
Dr. Keith Lehman (08:08:59):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (08:09:23):
Based on your findings, your investigation, your physical, your actual physical examination of the body, do you believe this weapon was inserted into the right nostril of Daniel Akers at the time projectile was expelled from the muzzle?
Dr. Keith Lehman (08:09:38):
No.
Lawyer 2 (08:09:43):
Do you think it's more likely, sir, that this was a longer range shot than contact?
Dr. Keith Lehman (08:09:49):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (08:09:50):
Do you think it's likely, sir, that this was a longer range shot than intermediate contact, that it was intermediate or more?
Dr. Keith Lehman (08:10:00):
It's my opinion that it was distant range wounds, so farther away than contact or intermediate range.
Lawyer 2 (08:10:06):
So even farther than intermediate?
Dr. Keith Lehman (08:10:07):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (08:10:15):
When you talked about peer review, that there was a peer review process that the GBI is formal and that you have to follow this certain practice, did you do that in this case?
Dr. Keith Lehman (08:10:27):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (08:10:27):
And was that the process where you were talking and took it and one other medical examiner reviewed the report?
Dr. Keith Lehman (08:10:33):
That's correct.
Lawyer 2 (08:10:34):
But did you, yourself, do any kind of informal peer review, take your findings to other physicians at the GBI?
Dr. Keith Lehman (08:10:43):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (08:10:44):
After doing that, sir, did your manner of death finding, ultimate finding on manner of death change at all?
Dr. Keith Lehman (08:10:54):
Well, I presented it to the group during one of our afternoon meetings. At that time, the manner of death had not been determined.
Lawyer 2 (08:11:08):
And ultimately, was your manner of death... After that peer review, was your manner of death still homicide?
Dr. Keith Lehman (08:11:11):
Yes.
Lawyer 2 (08:11:11):
I don't have anything further. Thank you.
Judge (08:11:11):
Anything else from the defense?
Mr. Steel (08:11:19):
Can I just have one second, Your Honor?
Judge (08:11:20):
Sure.
Mr. Steel (08:11:50):
With the court's permission and the doctor's permission, can I ask the doctor to step down one more time?
Judge (08:11:56):
Do you mind doing that?
Dr. Keith Lehman (08:11:56):
Okay.
Mr. Steel (08:12:08):
This is the toy. Doctor, if I'm something like this and you get scared that I'm going to hurt myself, and you come at me and grab me and I do that. Which way am I going, the way I'm going now? Which is my momentum?
Dr. Keith Lehman (08:12:27):
You're going backwards.
Mr. Steel (08:12:29):
Okay. And the gun discharged, is it consistent with the way you see Mr. Akers in the photograph?
Dr. Keith Lehman (08:12:37):
Yeah. It's possible that as he was being shot, he fell backwards.
Mr. Steel (08:12:44):
And you know that Ms. Boles announced that she fell on top of Mr. Akers. Are you aware of that?
Dr. Keith Lehman (08:12:51):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (08:12:53):
And if you fall on top of somebody, I assume they're falling one way and you're falling on the same way? So you're falling backwards and you're falling on top of them?
Dr. Keith Lehman (08:13:01):
Yeah, I don't know exactly. I don't recall exactly what she described, but it's certainly possible if she were close to him when the shot was fired, if he goes backwards that she may go on top of... It's certainly possible.
Mr. Steel (08:13:14):
Okay. Thank you, sir. Thank you, Your Honor.
Lawyer 2 (08:13:16):
I don't have any further questions, Your Honor. Thank you.
Judge (08:13:16):
You said no further?
Lawyer 2 (08:13:16):
Nothing else, Your Honor.
Judge (08:13:24):
Okay. Can he be excused?
Lawyer 2 (08:13:26):
No objection. Thank you.
Judge (08:13:27):
All right. Thank you for being here, doctor.
Dr. Keith Lehman (08:13:28):
Thank you, Your Honor. [inaudible 08:13:29].
Judge (08:13:35):
All right. Tonight is going to be similar to last night. I think just after 5:00, we're going to have dinner here. Can y'all go until 5:00 or do you need a break now? Good?
Eric Warren (08:13:42):
(No audible response).
Judge (08:13:44):
All right.
Lawyer 2 (08:13:44):
May I approach opposing counsel about scheduling [inaudible 08:13:48] order?
Judge (08:13:48):
(No audible response).
Lawyer 2 (08:14:04):
[inaudible 08:13:55] minute to check the availability of some witnesses.
Judge (08:14:05):
Go right ahead.
Lawyer 2 (08:14:07):
May we step out?
Judge (08:14:08):
Sure. I think this will be quick, so we'll leave you all right here, okay?
Mr. Steel (08:15:22):
Your Honor, can we approach just for a moment?
Judge (08:15:25):
All right. And you're fine doing that without your client present, right?
Mr. Steel (08:15:27):
Yes.
Judge (08:17:18):
... means is the State has not rested their case yet, but because these lawyers are both all so accommodating to each other, they've agreed, even though they haven't rested their case yet, they're going to take a defense witness. Normally, the State would have to rest, and then if the defense had any evidence, they don't have to present any evidence, but if they did, that would be their opportunity. So that's what's happening now.
Mr. Steel (08:17:42):
We call Dr. Eric Warren, E-R-I-C W-A-R-E-N. [inaudible 08:17:50].
Eric Warren (08:17:51):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (08:17:52):
Thank you.
Judge (08:17:56):
All right, sir. Do you swear to tell the truth, the whole truth, nothing but the truth, so help you God?
Eric Warren (08:18:00):
Yes, sir. I do.
Judge (08:18:01):
I understand you're in a hurry, so we'll try to make this quick.
Eric Warren (08:18:03):
Thank you.
Mr. Steel (08:18:05):
Please state and spell your name for this honorable court.
Eric Warren (08:18:09):
My name is Eric, E-R-I-C, last name Warren, W-A-R-R-E-N.
Mr. Steel (08:18:16):
And can you do me a courtesy and explain to the jury your education, your training, your background, and your occupation, please?
Eric Warren (08:18:28):
Yes. So I'll start backwards. I'm currently co-owner of SEP, that's S-E-P, Forensic Consultants, based out of Memphis, Tennessee. Prior to that, I was employed by the Tennessee Bureau of Investigation as a special agent forensic scientist. And then prior to that, as a requirement to be hired by the TBI, I obtained my bachelor's degree in molecular and cellular biology and my doctorate degree in biochemistry. Both of those were from Vanderbilt University.
Mr. Steel (08:19:05):
And what do you do as an occupation right now? What's your business?
Eric Warren (08:19:17):
Yes. So as co-owner of SEP Forensic Consultants, my area of specialty is firearms identification, crime scene reconstruction, and shooting incident reconstruction. In that regard, I routinely work cases for the prosecution and the defense and criminal cases for plaintiff and defendant and civil cases as well as military cases as well. In addition to working cases and if needed, coming to testify at court I also do research in the field and routinely give lectures and talks and workshops in those areas that I mentioned earlier.
Mr. Steel (08:20:01):
Can you explain what a crime scene response team is and what your knowledge and experience is with that as well as collection of evidence?
Eric Warren (08:20:12):
Yes. So when I was first hired by the TBI, I went through a two-year on the job training program. The first part of that was reading textbooks and journal article type materials on the forensic areas. Also included towards the beginning of that two year program, excuse me, was a crime scene processing school. It was four to six weeks long. I don't recall the exact length at this moment. And that was so that I could be assigned to a violent crime response team. That was essentially where if a local agency in the state of Tennessee had a potential crime and they needed assistance with working that scene, they could call the TBI and we would be dispatched to assist and to essentially take control of the scene itself.
(08:21:07)
And along those lines, I was trained in the documentation of crime scenes, the identification of potential evidence, as well as the preservation, collection, and if needed, field testing of that evidence. So it could be any number of types of evidence from footprints in the dirt, to fingerprints on an object, to swabbing an item for DNA, to making a firearm safe, to determine a trajectory of a bullet through an object, pretty much any of those things. My specific specialty was in all things firearms. Some people call that forensic ballistics, but we were all trained so that we could swap out as needed for whatever the scene dictated and everybody would pitch in to be able to... On the team could pitch in to get the scene processed and worked.
Mr. Steel (08:22:02):
And did you ever swab or collect evidence for DNA and fingerprints to be used to compare to a known firearm?
Eric Warren (08:22:13):
So I have in my job at the TBI, but actually my co-owner with SEP Forensic Consultants is a DNA expert herself. So generally, if we were to respond to a scene together, that's going to be her area, that's going to be her primary focus, whereas mine would be on the firearms. But yes, I have multiple times had to swab different items and have also taught others how to do so.
Mr. Steel (08:22:40):
And you're saying SEP, that's S-E-P?
Eric Warren (08:22:44):
That is correct.
Mr. Steel (08:22:45):
Okay. And have you published any books, treaties, articles related to your training and experience in firearms identification and shooting scene reconstruction?
Eric Warren (08:22:55):
Yes, I have.
Mr. Steel (08:22:57):
And have you taught any training or coursework in this area of expertise?
Eric Warren (08:23:02):
Yes, again. I have taught numerous law enforcement agencies as well as attorneys in these fields. Some of it is lecture-based courses. Some of it is actually workshops or practical exercises. And then I also, of course, teach that at a collegiate level as well. I'm an adjunct professor at a local university in Tennessee where I help them develop the curriculum for a forensic science degree program and teach the forensic science specific courses.
Mr. Steel (08:23:34):
Are you a member of any professional organizations pertaining to your areas of expertise?
Eric Warren (08:23:39):
Yes, I am.
Mr. Steel (08:23:40):
And which ones?
Eric Warren (08:23:42):
A number of different organizations. The Association of Crime Scene Reconstruction, the Association of Firearm and Tool Mark Examiners, the American Academy of Forensic Sciences, just to name a few.
Mr. Steel (08:23:54):
Have you ever testified in a court in the area of crime scene reconstructionist?
Eric Warren (08:24:03):
Yes, I have.
Mr. Steel (08:24:04):
Approximately how many times?
Eric Warren (08:24:06):
I am frequently qualified as an expert in multiple fields. Again, firearms identification, crime scene reconstruction, shooting incident reconstruction. I don't have a specific number of where I've just been qualified in one or the other, but in total as an expert, I've testified somewhere in the neighborhood of a hundred times in courts across the U.S.
Mr. Steel (08:24:26):
And does crime scene reconstruction also include things like gunshot residue analysis, analysis of trajectory of the bullet, collecting evidence of DNA, fingerprinting, soot, stippling, tattooing for analysis, including DNA and fingerprint analysis?
Eric Warren (08:24:47):
Yes. Generally, not every case will have all of those or may just have one or two, but generally a lot of the things that you just mentioned would all be encompassed in that.
Mr. Steel (08:24:58):
Have you ever testified as an expert in Georgia, state courts of Georgia, Superior Court?
Eric Warren (08:25:05):
Yes, I believe I have.
Mr. Steel (08:25:07):
Have you testified in the Southeast as an expert in these fields?
Eric Warren (08:25:11):
Yes, I have.
Mr. Steel (08:25:12):
Federal court as well as state courts?
Eric Warren (08:25:14):
Yes, and federal and state.
Mr. Steel (08:25:17):
Your Honor, I move for Dr. Warren to be admitted as an expert in the field of crime scene reconstruction, gunshot residue analysis, analysis and trajectory of bullets, collecting of evidence of DNA fingerprint analysis, soot, stippling, tattooing for ballistics.
Judge (08:25:41):
Any objection?
Lawyer 2 (08:25:43):
No, Yo Honor.
Judge (08:25:44):
Thank you.
Lawyer 2 (08:25:44):
No objection.
Mr. Steel (08:25:47):
Your Honor, may I approach?
Judge (08:25:48):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (08:25:49):
May I approach you?
Eric Warren (08:25:49):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (08:25:51):
I'm going to show you Ms. Boles number 148, just make sure that that is complete and as updated as you believe it is. And then tell me if you recognize it.
Eric Warren (08:26:12):
Yes, this is an accurate copy. I do believe I have a slightly newer one, but the only difference would potentially be additional testimonies and maybe an additional training course or two. But what is here is accurate as of probably September of this year, if I had to guess.
Mr. Steel (08:26:33):
Your Honor, I move for the admission of Ms. Boles number 148 as the CV of Dr. Warren.
Judge (08:26:39):
Any objection?
Lawyer 2 (08:26:40):
No, your Honor.
Judge (08:26:41):
Admitted.
Mr. Steel (08:26:42):
And you can just place it in front of you if you don't mind. All right. Dr. Warren, let me ask you some questions. What materials did you utilize to reconstruct the shooting incident in this case?
Eric Warren (08:26:56):
So provided to me, and the items that I analyzed would be photographs of the evidence that was recovered from the scene, scene photographs themselves. So photographs of the actual scene, not just the evidence collected, a video of the scene or might have been a multi-part video of what we call a walkthrough video. I also reviewed the autopsy report and autopsy photographs, a scene diagram, as well as statements from Ms. Boles.
Mr. Steel (08:27:29):
How about officer supplements or reports?
Eric Warren (08:27:32):
Yes, that is true. I also reviewed the case file or supplements of the investigating officers.
Mr. Steel (08:27:40):
And are you getting paid for this work?
Eric Warren (08:27:42):
Yes, this is my full-time job.
Mr. Steel (08:27:44):
And in this case, who asked you to do this review?
Eric Warren (08:27:48):
I was engaged by Mr. Steel's law firm.
Mr. Steel (08:27:51):
And can you tell the jurors how much you're getting paid?
Eric Warren (08:27:54):
Yes. My hourly rate is $350 an hour, and that would apply to anybody that would engage me for this type of case.
Mr. Steel (08:28:00):
What scientific methodologies did you utilize to reconstruct the shooting incident in this case?
Eric Warren (08:28:07):
So for that, the physics of a firearm functionality, how a firearm would discharge and function. Included in that would be interior and exterior ballistics. So what is happening to the bullet as it is being fired inside of the gun and as it exits the firearm itself, as well as gunshot residue and distance determination would be specific forensic methods.
Mr. Steel (08:28:32):
Examining the autopsy photographs, what did you observe regarding... Do you remember an abrasion being on the right nostril area of Mr. Aker (sic)?
Eric Warren (08:28:44):
Yes, that is correct. So that is, I would say, one of the predominant findings in the review of those autopsy photographs. Essentially in Mr. Akers' right nostril on the outside, leading onto the inside of the right nostril, what would be called the Ehler (phonetic) ridge, so this outer portion of skin on your nose moving towards the tip of the nose, there was an abrasion. It measured approximately seven millimeters or three eighths of an inch in diameter.
Mr. Steel (08:29:16):
I'd like to show you... Your Honor, may I approach the witness?
Judge (08:29:17):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (08:29:19):
May I approach you, sir?
Eric Warren (08:29:20):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (08:29:21):
I'm showing you what's already in evidence. It's State's exhibit number 173. There are gloves if you want to handle it, right in front of you. Yes, sir. And I'm just opening 1738. If you take a look at that when you can, there is a safety lock on it, so you can't put the cylinder on. I also ask, with the Court's permission, the honorable investigator to put up Ms. Boles 146.
Mr. Steel (08:30:15):
Dr. Warren, you'll see right here. And if you need the pointer, because I'm not trying to control this. Is this the abrasion you just referred to?
Eric Warren (08:30:30):
Yes. You were pointing with the red laser to that approximately three-eighths inch abrasion that I just referred to.
Mr. Steel (08:30:36):
Okay. And can you explain the significance of that abrasion compared to that firearm to the jurors from your analysis?
Eric Warren (08:30:46):
Yes. So the abrasion itself, generally for a gunshot wound, if you have a bullet defect, you have a nice hole punched in an individual. The abrasion is generally called an abrasion ring, and it's just around the periphery of that gunshot wound or bullet defect. In this case, we do not have a clear circular bullet defect. And this abrasion is actually larger in diameter than the bullets or projectiles that would be fired in this revolver, which is unusual. But what drew my attention to it is when looking at the revolver that's currently labeled State's Exhibit 173A, it has what's called a cylinder pin that is approximately that exact same three-eighths of an inch in diameter that would correspond quite nicely to this abrasion ring.
Mr. Steel (08:31:43):
And would you explain just now that the bullet itself that comes out of that gun is smaller than that abrasion? Is that what you said?
Eric Warren (08:31:54):
Yes, sir. So the revolver in question is a High Standard is the brand and Sentinel is the model. It is chambered in or designed to fire an ammunition that is 22 long rifle caliber. So that designation tells me that that bullet is approximately 0.222 inches in diameter or just under a quarter of an inch, which is less than three-eighths of an inch.
Mr. Steel (08:32:23):
And this abrasion?
Eric Warren (08:32:25):
Yes. Again, it was a little over seven millimeters, which the closest, if you were to translate that on a ruler, you're looking at about three-eighths of an inch.
Mr. Steel (08:32:35):
And can you show the jurors the cylinder, what do you call it? The cylinder, the ejection rod, the cylinder rod?
Eric Warren (08:32:44):
Cylinder pin. In this particular revolver, it also serves as the ejector rod.
Mr. Steel (08:32:50):
Can you show the jurors, raise the weapon and just show them what the size of that cylinder rod is?
Eric Warren (08:32:59):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (08:33:00):
With the court's permission, Your Honor, can Dr. Warren come off the witness stand?
Judge (08:33:03):
Yes.
Eric Warren (08:33:04):
So before I step down, I just want to note that the cylinder, which I will explain in a second, is empty. The gun is safe. Not only is it unloaded, but as you mentioned before, it has the safety lock through it so that it couldn't be closed even if it was loaded to fire.
Mr. Steel (08:33:19):
Would it help using a ruler also or you don't need a ruler?
Eric Warren (08:33:22):
I don't think I need a ruler for this.
Mr. Steel (08:33:24):
Okay.
Eric Warren (08:33:24):
Thank you, Your Honor. So I'm going to keep the revolver pointed down just for safety reasons.
Mr. Steel (08:33:30):
Can you do me a favor? [inaudible 08:33:31]
Eric Warren (08:33:34):
Yes, absolutely. So on the revolver, this is considered the barrel right here, which I'm pointing it out would be on the top. And then below the barrel, if this portion, which is called the cylinder were closed, you have the cylinder pin here that I have referred to previously. So this cylinder pin has a rough or textured pin so that the user can grab it and push rearward on it. And doing that lifts a portion of the cylinder up so that the rounds that would be in it could be ejected out of the cylinder. So I'm using a lot of terms on the revolver. You've got the hole that the bullet travels down, that's rifle. That's your barrel. At the end of the barrel, you have what's called the muzzle. So that's where the bullet would be exiting out into the air, beginning its flight outside of the revolver.
(08:34:35)
Just below that, you have the cylinder. This piece rotates or revolves inside of the revolver. That's why it's called a revolver, is as you either pull the hammer back or pull the trigger, this cylinder is revolved to place the next round in one of these chambers or holes in line with the barrel to fire it. And importantly, the part that I was talking about being approximately three-eighths inch in diameter is this part right here. And if it could be closed, if this lock were not present, you can see it lines up essentially with the end of the muzzle or the end of that barrel.
Mr. Steel (08:35:17):
And when you say that the cylinder is approximately how big?
Eric Warren (08:35:23):
The cylinder pin itself is essentially three-eighths of an inch in diameter.
Mr. Steel (08:35:29):
And that's the very tip of it?
Eric Warren (08:35:31):
Yes. That is just this portion here that is textured or checkered is sometimes what it's called.
Mr. Steel (08:35:37):
And according to the autopsy report, is that the same size of this abrasion right here?
Eric Warren (08:35:43):
It is the same approximate size as that abrasion, yes.
Mr. Steel (08:35:46):
It's your opinion, what made that abrasion?
Eric Warren (08:35:49):
So that abrasion would be consistent with what is called a hard contact shot and that abrasion would essentially be caused by the skin slapping up against the cylinder pin itself.
Mr. Steel (08:36:26):
What does the abrasion that we're talking, the same abrasion in Ms. Boles number 146 and the cylinder rod that you just talked about, the seven-eighths, what does that tell you about the orientation of the weapon, if it made this abrasion?
Eric Warren (08:36:52):
Sure. So as described in the autopsy report, the trajectory or path that the bullet took through Mr. Akers' body would be from front to the back, from right to the left and upward. And when you take that angularity or that trajectory into account with the abrasion itself, again, kind of that as you see in the photo in State's Exhibit 146, that would necessitate that the revolver would have to be upside down at this moment, at the moment of discharge.
(08:37:28)
So if I were to use my finger to point more safely and my thumb would be the hammer on the back of the revolver, and imagine these two fingers were about the same length, the barrel would be on top in a normal orientation holding the revolver as I had it pointed down to the right. And that cylinder rod would be below the barrel. And if in fact the correspondence between the cylinder rod and this three-eighths inch approximate abrasion would necessitate that the revolver is upside down. So what I mean by that is instead of this way, the revolver would essentially be with the cylinder pin or cylinder rod above the barrel itself.
Mr. Steel (08:38:14):
Dr. Warren, this is a replica gun. This is a toy gun. Your Honor, may I display?
Judge (08:38:16):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (08:38:16):
Using this replica gun, toy gun, tell me if this is what you just described, something like that.
Eric Warren (08:38:34):
Yes, that is ... I was actually going to mimic it with my hand, but that is pretty much what I was describing.
Mr. Steel (08:38:40):
May I approach?
Judge (08:38:41):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (08:38:41):
May I approach?
Eric Warren (08:38:43):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (08:38:44):
If you need it, if you don't need it, that's fine. Just put it down. If you need it throughout your testimony or if you want to show the jurors now what you're discussing, please do so.
Eric Warren (08:38:54):
May I step down, Your Honor?
Judge (08:38:55):
Yes.
Eric Warren (08:38:55):
Thank you. So this is the toy revolver. The muzzle has an orange insert to indicate that it is a toy gun. And essentially, just like the revolver in question in this case, you have the barrel on top and the cylinder pin or the ejector rod down below. So in a normal aiming position, again, you have the barrel on top and the ejector rod or cylinder pin, as I call, it on the bottom. So in order for it to be inverted the way I've described it previously, essentially just coming up like this and you have the cylinder rod on that outer, the [inaudible 08:39:49] surface of the nose, and now the muzzle is essentially pointing right into the nostril itself. Sorry, I'll step back a little. Like this.
Mr. Steel (08:39:56):
Can you show the jurors at the other end?
Eric Warren (08:40:01):
That's where I'm heading. I've never done this before.
Mr. Steel (08:40:20):
Dr. Warren, in your field of expertise, have you had the opportunity to see or review gunshot wounds and the physical effects caused by the gunshot wounds from different distances?
Eric Warren (08:40:34):
Yes, sir. I have.
Mr. Steel (08:40:35):
Can you briefly explain what those physical effects are from the different distances?
Eric Warren (08:40:41):
Yes. So when a firearm is discharged, the bullet is not the only thing that comes out of the end of the barrel. Out of the orifices of the gun itself all around the cylinder and also behind the bullet as it exits the barrel, there are products of combustion that also exit. The product of combustion
is the gunpowder is being burned and that comes out as essentially a cloud of smoke or soot. In addition to that, there are gunpowder particles that are currently burning but have not been completely consumed and turned into that soot. And then also there can be particles of gunpowder that are not burning yet, that maybe the barrel is too short and that hasn't had time to ignite. So all of these materials come out of the muzzle of the gun and travel in a cone shape.
(08:41:37)
So if you imagine taking a flashlight and shining it onto a surface, when that flashlight is in contact, you essentially have a very dense, small beam of light. But as you move that flashlight farther and farther away, that beam of light opens up and becomes bigger in diameter, but more diffuse. It's the same concept for gunshot residues when we're discussing a firearm being fired at different distances or the equivalent forensic test called distance determination.
(08:42:09)
And so by looking at the types of residues and their patterns that are deposited, we as experts can determine an approximate range at which that firearm was discharged. And those ranges are broken down into what are the physical effects that are present in and around the wound itself and then what chemicals are deposited, whether it's that soot or the gunpowder that is commonly called stippling or the result of which is called stippling. And those are generally broken down into hard contact, which you've already heard me mention. Contact, which is sometimes called loose contact, close range, intermediate range and distant or sometimes called indeterminate range.
Mr. Steel (08:42:59):
Can you break that down starting with hard contact?
Eric Warren (08:43:03):
Yes. So with hard contact, there is actually force pressing the object or pressing the firearm against the object being shot. And it is that pressure that as that gun is discharged, the gases that come out behind the bullet essentially make the skin slap up against the end of whatever is being pressed into that surface. And so what you see there is generally all that soot and gases that are materials that are there, they can be blown into the wound and then you generally get a mirror image or a negative impression of the end of that firearm.
(08:43:40)
When you have loose contact, essentially the end of that gun, the muzzle is still touching the surface, but it's not forcefully being pressed into it. It's essentially hovering right at the surface. In those cases, you frequently see what's called stellate or star-shaped tearing. So it's not just a clean, like I described earlier, circular bullet hole. You get almost a cross tear in and around the gunshot wound. You also end up with a lot of gunpowder and smoke in the form of soot being blown into the wound and right around the outside edge of the surface of that wound. That's that holding a flashlight just off of the wall. You can see that dense area of light right around where the flashlight is touching the wall.
(08:44:29)
Then you get to close range. So in this particular case, now with close range, you don't see the tearing, the stellate tearing, you don't see the muzzle imprint, but you do get a very dense cloud of soot surrounding the gunshot wound. Generally, a rule of thumb is that this close range can span anywhere from just off the surface out to 6 or 12 inches, depending on the firearm and ammunition combination that is used.
(08:45:03)
As you continue moving farther, you go from this close range regime to the intermediate regime. Now you're starting to see little to no soot. So that soot, the lightest cloud of material is dropping off, but now you're seeing that stippling from the slightly heavier gunpowder that has traveled that distance and is now striking the skin, leaving punctate abrasions or little pointy abrasions like you took a ballpoint pen and dabbed it all over the skin. And again, it depends on the firearm and ammunition combination, but that generally can go from that 12-inch distance out to three or four feet.
(08:45:44)
When you get beyond that four foot distance, again, as a general rule of thumb, you get to the distant range, and that's characterized by having a lack of your soot and your stippling. Essentially, you just have the bullet wound or the gunshot wound with a faint abrasion ring around that periphery or outside edge of it. Now, sometimes that is called indeterminate because it is possible that scenarios cannot be ruled out that there would be an intervening object. And so essentially what that means is the firearm could be closer to the surface or person being shot than beyond four feet. It could be closer than that, but there's an intervening object. Maybe it's a heavy article of clothing and they could have been shot through a doorway. So even though that firearm was much closer, that intervening object basically blocked those residues from being deposited. So that's why sometimes a distant range shot can be called indeterminate because that may not be able to be ruled out.
Mr. Steel (08:46:49):
There's been discussion in this case. With the court's permission, can we put up the demonstrative from the Demayo book?
Judge (08:46:57):
Yeah.
Mr. Steel (08:47:02):
Do you know who an author Demayo is?
Eric Warren (08:47:06):
Yes. I'm very familiar with him and his work.
Mr. Steel (08:47:07):
Okay. Do you have the other one? May I approach, Your Honor?
Judge (08:47:08):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (08:47:17):
May I approach you, sir?
Eric Warren (08:47:20):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (08:47:25):
It's just for demonstrative. It comes out of the book. State's Exhibit Number 242. Just orient yourself and tell me when.
Eric Warren (08:47:35):
Okay.
Mr. Steel (08:47:37):
May I approach, Your Honor?
Judge (08:47:38):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (08:47:38):
May I approach you, Doctor?
Eric Warren (08:47:40):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (08:47:40):
We'll put it on the big screen. It's on this humble court's screen, the demonstrative. It's not this case. It's just the demonstrative from the book.
Eric Warren (08:48:12):
Correct.
Mr. Steel (08:48:15):
Can you just tell jurors if you recognize what these are?
Eric Warren (08:48:18):
So these are your typical contact or what I would say loose contact shots. So again, you see the gunshot wound or bullet defect, there's actually two of them side by side. And then there's the very dark blackening or soot deposition on the skin in and around the wound itself.
Mr. Steel (08:48:40):
The defect that, God forbid, came into Mr. Akers' right nostril, does that have anything to do with what you're looking at on the screen?
Eric Warren (08:48:51):
No, it does not.
Mr. Steel (08:48:52):
Can you explain to jurors why?
Eric Warren (08:48:54):
Yes. So again, this has the soot or the blackening on the skin appearing on the external surface and surrounding the actual gunshot wound itself. In the case of a hard contact wound where you have this type of the abrasion that is essentially a mirror image of the object being pressed into it, that would have all of the soot be blown into the wound itself generally.
Mr. Steel (08:49:25):
And can you put up Ms. Boles Exhibit Number 146, if you don't mind? How would you describe this wound?
Eric Warren (08:49:45):
So again, we've talked a lot about the abrasion mark that is there on the nose, but that in combination with the consistent size and diameter of the cylinder pin and the presence of a gray material that you can't see in this photograph that's inside of the nostril. It's the combination of those two items to me that suggests that this would be consistent with a hard contact shot.
Mr. Steel (08:50:16):
So you would never see what was just shown on a demonstrative, Mr. Demayo-
Speaker 27 (08:50:20):
Objection, leading.
Mr. Steel (08:50:22):
Would you see ... Sorry, I'll rephrase. Would you expect to see what was just shown on the Demayo book to the ladies and gentlemen of the jury in this case, a hard contact?
Eric Warren (08:50:34):
So for hard contact, no, I would not expect that.
Mr. Steel (08:50:38):
Does it also matter that this is not just skin, but there's an opening?
Eric Warren (08:50:43):
Yes. It actually matters that it is a skin with an opening to the whole sinus passage, as well as the fact that the firearm involved is a revolver.
Mr. Steel (08:50:54):
Explain that to the jury, please.
Eric Warren (08:50:56):
Sure. So a revolver has many different openings. I mentioned that earlier, as opposed to a semi-automatic pistol. In a semi-automatic pistol, it actually generally harnesses the gases of the discharge to perform several steps automatically, and that would be the extraction and ejection of the just fired round to clear it out of the gun so that it can load the next round automatically from the magazine. In a revolver, that doesn't happen, so there are a lot more open spaces in and around the cylinder. That barrel is not sealed off from rearward escaping gases once the bullet passes from the cylinder through what's called the forcing cone of the barrel and then into the barrel. So there's a lot more opportunity for gases to escape out into the environment and less of it ends up coming out of the muzzle of the firearm to be deposited on the object that was shot.
(08:51:56)
In addition to that, again, I mentioned earlier the ammunition and firearm combination in this particular case with a .22 long rifle, that is a very low powered, low pressure, therefore low gunpowder amount round. So it already is going to be limited as to the amount of potential soot and stippling that it can deposit as compared to let's say a more common nine millimeter caliber cartridge. It's much bigger.
Mr. Steel (08:52:24):
Would you expect to find any stippling if the gun was inside the nose, like you described?
Eric Warren (08:52:29):
No, I would not.
Mr. Steel (08:52:33):
Okay. Do you know the term searing?
Eric Warren (08:52:36):
I am familiar with that, yes.
Mr. Steel (08:52:38):
And can you tell the jurors what searing is?
Eric Warren (08:52:40):
Again, there is a several thousand degree muzzle flash that happens as those pressurized gases traveling down the barrel, pushing the bullet down range. As soon as it hits the open cool air, you get essentially a muzzle flash, and it is this very rapid, high pressure situation along with all of those burning gases and soot that can essentially cause a searing or burning of the skin at the location of the gun shot.
Mr. Steel (08:53:14):
The way you describe the gun being inverted and making the mark, the abrasion with the cylinder rod, would you expect to find any searing in this case if the bullet was fired or discharged while the muzzle of the gun was inside the nasal cavity?
Eric Warren (08:53:34):
So again, with this combination of the ammunition and the gun itself, and as I said, given the lower pressure and the lower amount of powder, I wouldn't generally expect to see that, but also I wouldn't be surprised if it were there. It really just depends on the gun and ammunition combination. And in this case, with the nasal cavity, having that additional expansion area for that material to cool off and expand into, that, again, would make me not expect there to be searing there.
Mr. Steel (08:54:08):
With regards to stippling, the way you understand that the gun was positioned inside the nasal cavity, would you expect to find any stippling?
Eric Warren (08:54:27):
Again, not as ... As I testified earlier, I would not. So that stippling would be once that firearm is multiple feet away from the individual before I would expect to see stippling.
Mr. Steel (08:54:39):
You mentioned star-shaped. Do you remember that?
Eric Warren (08:54:42):
Yes, I do.
Mr. Steel (08:54:44):
Can you explain to the jurors what you're talking about, star-shaped? And would you expect to see it here, if the gun is the way you positioned it from your expert analysis?
Eric Warren (08:54:54):
So the star shape or stellate tearing, again, it does depend on where on the body the gunshot wound is and how elastic that skin is, and also whether it's a very bony part of the body, such as most of the structures in the face. There's not a lot of material between the skull and our face, the skin on our face. And so if you have that close contact range shot, you would expect to see that type of stellate or star- shaped tearing because essentially those gases are being forced into the space between the skin and the bone, and the skin has nowhere to go and it's elastic, so it will tend to essentially tear under the high pressure of that discharge. But again, here in this case, because A, I believe that it has hallmarks of being that hard contact shot, and B, because again, we have all of the airspace in the nostril and into the sinuses for that pressure to essentially dissipate. I would not expect to see a lot of heavy stellate tearing here, again, with this specific gun and ammunition combination.
Mr. Steel (08:56:14):
How many cases would you estimate you've worked where the gunshot wounds were part of your analysis?
Eric Warren (08:56:22):
That is not a metric that I keep track of, so I will do my best to give you an educated approximation. And I would say that's probably around or exceeding a hundred different cases where I've looked at gunshot wounds and the physical features associated with them.
Mr. Steel (08:56:42):
Now, you're not present when Dr. Lehman did the autopsy?
Eric Warren (08:56:45):
I was not. I'm typically not present during the autopsy in these cases.
Mr. Steel (08:56:49):
Does that prevent you from doing an analysis, an expert analysis, on the distance from which this firearm was discharged?
Eric Warren (08:56:58):
No, not typically. So as long as the wound itself is properly documented and photographed with a scale and the physical features that are present are in those photographs, it does not prohibit me from then going forward and making a determination on the distance of discharge.
Mr. Steel (08:57:16):
Were you able to, from the autopsy photographs that were taken at the direction of Dr. Lehman, were you able to make any determinations concerning the shooting, Mr. Akers?
Eric Warren (08:57:32):
Again, we've kind of been talking about that and actually demonstrated it earlier. When you take into account the totality of the evidence with this foreign gray material in the right nostril, it's not present in the left, the abrasion towards the tip of the nose, consistent in size and shape with the cylinder pin, to me, my opinion is that it is indicative of a situation. Essentially, if you think about when you're holding a firearm, again, in that normal orientation with the barrel on top of the cylinder pin, and really it doesn't have to be the firearm. It could be, let's say your child has grabbed your key fob to your car off the counter and you are going towards that individual to take that object from them because they don't need to have it or for whatever reason. A natural reaction is essentially to retract the arm to prevent that person from getting the item that you're holding. And so in the process of retracting that arm, you're automatically inverting that firearm and inverting it in such a way also reproduces the abrasion, you would expect soot to be present inside of the passage, and you could also reproduce the trajectory again, that general forward to back, upward and right to left.
Mr. Steel (08:59:03):
You mentioned gray material. Is there a photograph you can show the jurors what you're talking about?
Eric Warren (08:59:08):
Yeah, there were a couple of the autopsy photographs that showed a foreign gray material inside of Mr. Akers' right nostril.
Mr. Steel (08:59:17):
I'd like to display, it's already in evidence, Your Honor, with the court's permission, Ms. Boles Number 147.
Judge (08:59:22):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (08:59:23):
Is this a helpful photograph of what you're talking about?
Eric Warren (08:59:28):
Yes, it is.
Mr. Steel (08:59:30):
I could give you the pointer if you want. Can you explain to jurors what you're looking at?
Eric Warren (08:59:37):
Sure. If I could stand.
Mr. Steel (08:59:40):
Your Honor, can Dr. Warren stand?
Judge (08:59:41):
Sure.
Mr. Steel (08:59:42):
Thank you. Would you like this or you have one?
Eric Warren (08:59:46):
So this would be the abrasion ring we've been talking about. Essentially, the technician or the pathologist, whoever's taking this photos, generally it's an autopsy technician. They've used four forceps to basically open up the nostril to show what's inside of it. And if you notice here, there is a gray material. I have asthma and I've had lots of sinus infections. I've never come across this type of gray material naturally in the nose. Maybe if you're working in a coal mining facility or dealing with changing out brake pads where you're breathing in a lot of dark gray dust. But given the abrasion ring and its consistent size and shape, as I've said, this to me has the appearance of that dark gray soot from the combustion process of that gunpowder.
Mr. Steel (09:00:41):
What are the standard forensic and histological procedures recommended when evaluating a potential contact wound with possible soot?
Eric Warren (09:00:54):
Sure. So it doesn't have to just be a contact wound. Anytime there's the potential for a foreign material, especially with soot, one of the common practices is to take a tissue sample and do histology or a histological analysis, essentially looking at that tissue sample under a microscope, under that magnification to see if you can determine better visually what that is. Alternatively, you can do chemical testing called sodium or desminate testing. I've actually done that in conjunction during an autopsy in conjunction with our medical examiner in Memphis. It's basically an orange liquid that when applied in the presence of lead, which is a major component in soot, it will turn bright pink. So that is another way to confirm whether or not something is consistent with soot. And then much less frequently, but also discussed in literature is to take that tissue sample and do SEMEDS, which stands for scanning electron microscopy with electron dispersive x-ray spectroscopy. It's a mouthful. That's why we call it SEMEDS.
Mr. Steel (09:02:09):
Do you know whether in this case the medical examiner did anything to observe the tissue or do biopsies or any of the tests you just talked about?
Eric Warren (09:02:21):
Of everything that was provided to me, I did not see any indication that any type of testing to confirm the presence or absence of soot was done.
Mr. Steel (09:02:31):
Part of your shooting reconstructionist analysis, were you able to determine a scenario that would be consistent with the abrasion and possible soot, if it is soot, the gray area in this case?
Eric Warren (09:02:45):
Yes, that was the scenario I was just describing. Essentially retracting one's arm, essentially if you're holding the firearm and somebody is coming to and potentially take that firearm away and you're retracting your arm to keep it away from them, essentially this type of action would account for the different variables and the evidence that we've talked about today.
Mr. Steel (09:03:11):
How about collecting DNA or fingerprints for analysis of a firearm? Can you tell the jurors whether you said that that's what you and your partner have done and you've collected it? Can you tell the jurors what could be done?
Eric Warren (09:03:25):
Yeah. So generally when a firearm is submitted to the crime laboratory or if we get a firearm in our lab and the request is for both latent prints and DNA, or more generally the request is to determine who potentially held or fired that firearm is typically a joint process. DNA is going to go first because theirs is the most sensitive and the types of chemical processing that latent prints is going to use could contaminate that DNA. So generally we would use a double swabbing technique. Essentially what that is you take two sterile swabs, so big-
Eric Warren (09:04:00):
Usually what that is, is you take two sterile swabs, so big long Q-tips with only the cotton on one end. The first swab, you will add one or two drops of sterile water onto it to moisten it. You'll then take that swab, and you will sample... Generally, you selectively pick the areas that are rough, because those rough edges like the grip, like the trigger, like the hammer or the cylinder pin, they are going to abrade or scuff up the surface of your skin, and that's where you're most likely to trap what we call trace DNA. And so using that wet swab technique will basically rehydrate any of those cells and pull some of those out.
(09:04:46)
You will then immediately take a dry swab, that second swab, and go over those same areas to collect up the remaining material and then air dry those, package them and secure them for further testing. And that's not... The testing part, I do not do.
(09:05:04)
And then latent print processing would proceed, and again, you would focus on the larger, smoother areas because those areas are going to be the ones that are more likely to retain the oils and material from fingerprints.
Mr. Steele (09:05:21):
Can you summarize the opinions that you hold in this case after review of all the information you've done?
Lawyer 2 (09:05:29):
That would just be asked and answered, a summary of what he just testified to.
Judge Bucci (09:05:32):
Have you asked for anything new?
Mr. Steele (09:05:32):
That's fine, Your Honor.
Judge Bucci (09:05:32):
Okay.
Mr. Steele (09:05:37):
I have no other questions. Thank you, Doctor.
Eric Warren (09:05:39):
Thank you.
Judge Bucci (09:05:39):
[inaudible 09:05:42].
Lawyer 2 (09:05:41):
Yes, sir.
(09:05:41)
I'm going to try to go fairly quickly, Doctor. I know you have to get a plane somewhere.
Eric Warren (09:05:56):
I appreciate that.
Lawyer 2 (09:05:57):
Are you going somewhere else to testify after this?
Eric Warren (09:06:00):
Yes, sir. I'm going to a hearing in Kansas City.
Lawyer 2 (09:06:03):
Okay. So you're basically... You said your primary or your only source of income at this point is professional testimony, right?
Eric Warren (09:06:13):
No. So it is a full-time job that I work as a co-owner for SEP Forensics, but again, some of that is teaching, some of that is the adjunct faculty, and then I would say, though, the majority of it is reviewing discovery, and if needed, testifying.
Lawyer 2 (09:06:28):
Professional testimony and counseling with attorneys, that's your primary focus of SEP forensics?
Eric Warren (09:06:34):
That would be the majority. Yes, sir.
Lawyer 2 (09:06:35):
And you even have a flight today to go somewhere else and testify for money again this week, or coming up?
Eric Warren (09:06:41):
Yes, that is correct. Starting tomorrow.
Lawyer 2 (09:06:44):
Starting tomorrow, you'd be in another courtroom just like this one, giving opinions on this same type of subject matter?
Eric Warren (09:06:50):
Potentially, yes, sir.
Lawyer 2 (09:06:51):
And how much have you been paid to come here today, total?
Eric Warren (09:06:56):
My retainer was the only thing that I've been paid, and that was $ 2,400.
Lawyer 2 (09:07:02):
And then you'll add an hourly rate after that?
Eric Warren (09:07:05):
Yes. I bill against the retainer, and then anything over that would be in the next invoice.
Lawyer 2 (09:07:09):
You have a witness testimony fee? Is that different than the 350 an hour?
Eric Warren (09:07:15):
No. No, sir. It's all the same.
Lawyer 2 (09:07:15):
Are they the same?
Eric Warren (09:07:16):
Yes, that is correct.
Lawyer 2 (09:07:17):
Now if you had worked with these gentlemen here, and you had an opportunity to review all the materials in this case, investigate the case, and give your professional opinion on the case, if it had been inconsistent with the defense theory in this case, you wouldn't have been hired to come testify?
Eric Warren (09:07:38):
No, that's not true. So I'm generally hired before any review or before I express an opinion. And in fact, my engagement agreement specifies that you're paying me regardless of whether what I say helps you or not.
Lawyer 2 (09:07:51):
Yeah. I may have asked a bad question, and I apologize.
Eric Warren (09:07:53):
No, I apologize.
Lawyer 2 (09:07:55):
I apologize. That's my fault. So what I'm saying is that you had... I know you're going to get paid because you're valuable. Your services are valuable.
Eric Warren (09:08:05):
Thank you.
Lawyer 2 (09:08:05):
Nobody else has this kind of knowledge like you, who put in a lot of time and effort to get to this point. But what I'm saying is, if you had used your training, knowledge, and experience, and your education at Vanderbilt, and set forensic experience, and TDI experience, but if you had rendered an opinion that was inconsistent with the defense theory of the case, you would not have been brought to testify, right?
Eric Warren (09:08:22):
That is generally my experience, is if my opinion ends up not being helpful, there have been multiple cases where I've not been asked to testify, and I submit a final bill and move on.
Lawyer 2 (09:08:36):
So you're not going to get the type of travel... You got travel fees coming, I guess, right?
Eric Warren (09:08:42):
The expenses and time, yes, sir.
Lawyer 2 (09:08:45):
[inaudible 09:08:46]. You get the trial testimony time, but if you render an opinion that's inconsistent with the defense theory of the case, or that's consistent with Dr. Lehman, you're not going to get the money to testify, and travel, and all that. Is that fair?
Eric Warren (09:08:56):
If they do not ask me to come and testify, yes, that would be fair.
Lawyer 2 (09:09:03):
Do you know Dr. Lehman personally?
Eric Warren (09:09:05):
No, sir. I do not.
Lawyer 2 (09:09:08):
Okay, sir. Do you know he's a forensic pathologist?
Eric Warren (09:09:10):
Yes. I am aware of that.
Lawyer 2 (09:09:11):
Do you have any reason to doubt his training at South Carolina Medical School, or anything like that?
Eric Warren (09:09:20):
I have no knowledge of his background or training, so I couldn't say one way or the other.
Lawyer 2 (09:09:26):
Did you know he's done 7,000 autopsies?
Eric Warren (09:09:30):
That would not surprise me. Pathologists stay pretty busy.
Lawyer 2 (09:09:34):
How many autopsies have you done?
Eric Warren (09:09:37):
I am not a trained pathologist. I've not been in medical school, so the answer to that would be zero.
Lawyer 2 (09:09:43):
And tell the jury, please, if you will, Doctor, when you physically examined the Dan Akers body in this case, personally.
Eric Warren (09:09:51):
Oh, I did not personally examine Mr. Akers' body.
Lawyer 2 (09:09:58):
You're relying on photographs?
Eric Warren (09:10:00):
Yes, that is correct.
Lawyer 2 (09:10:04):
Did you know that Dr. Lehman did personally and physically examine the decedent?
Eric Warren (09:10:10):
I do not know if he personally examined it, or how his process works with his technicians.
Lawyer 2 (09:10:16):
Well, you read his autopsy report, right?
Eric Warren (09:10:18):
Yes, sir. I did.
Lawyer 2 (09:10:19):
And saw all the things that he noted in the autopsy findings?
Eric Warren (09:10:22):
Yes, I did.
Lawyer 2 (09:10:23):
Okay. Would you think it's likely that he physically examined the body to make all those findings?
Eric Warren (09:10:30):
Yes. There are certainly parts of the autopsy where they would have to be involved as the pathologist. I just am unaware with the level of which, whether the technician was the one weighing the organs, who made the Y incision, those types of things. I do not know that.
Lawyer 2 (09:10:45):
And did you know that... Would you agree with me, sir, that Dr. Lehman had the ability to manipulate the nose... I won't ask a compound question. Let me just ask that question first. Did you know... Would you agree with me he had the opportunity to physically manipulate the nose?
Eric Warren (09:11:04):
Certainly I would expect he had the opportunity, yes, sir.
Lawyer 2 (09:11:05):
Would you agree with me, sir, that he had the opportunity to physically examine personally the right nostril or nasal cavity of Mrs. [inaudible 09:11:12]?
Eric Warren (09:11:12):
Yes, I would certainly agree that he had that opportunity.
Lawyer 2 (09:11:16):
But you did not?
Eric Warren (09:11:18):
That's correct. I did not.
Lawyer 2 (09:11:37):
Do you agree, or do you understand... Is it your understanding, sir... Have you been told at all, prior to this hearing today... Did you know that Dr. Lehman, who's not being paid for his testimony as an expert professional witness, he does not agree to your finding that the marginal abrasion is the injector rod? Do you know that?
Eric Warren (09:11:59):
I have not heard that, and I would be shocked that a pathologist wouldn't be paid a salary for their time.
Lawyer 2 (09:12:05):
I'm sorry. I may have asked the wrong question. What I'm saying is, are you aware that Dr. Lehman does not share your opinion that that marginal abrasion on the right nostril is caused by what I called... I call it an injector rod? He doesn't share that opinion.
Eric Warren (09:12:19):
No, I'm not aware of that.
Lawyer 2 (09:12:30):
Okay. You said that the...
(09:12:32)
May I have a picture published, Your Honor, not specifically State's Exhibit. It's not marked. Oh, here it is, marked on the front. I apologize. Defense Exhibit 146, please.
(09:12:45)
If I have you to take a look at that, sir. So the marginal... It's hard to see, I know, Doctor. So can you move it up, Investigator Burt? Or should be on your monitor, Doctor, or you-
Eric Warren (09:13:02):
Yeah.
Lawyer 2 (09:13:02):
... can stand up.
Eric Warren (09:13:03):
I can see it.
Lawyer 2 (09:13:04):
See, is that the marginal abrasion that's of interest to you in this case?
Eric Warren (09:13:08):
Yes, it is.
Lawyer 2 (09:13:10):
You said it's the same size as a cylinder injection rod?
Eric Warren (09:13:13):
Yes, sir. Approximately.
Lawyer 2 (09:13:15):
But you don't have medical training of any kind, do you?
Eric Warren (09:13:19):
Not from a pathology standpoint, no. My PhD was through the medical school at Vanderbilt, but no, I'm not a... as I said earlier, a trained pathologist.
Lawyer 2 (09:13:29):
Did you obtain a medical degree, a doctorate of medicine from Vanderbilt Medical School?
Eric Warren (09:13:34):
No, sir. I did not.
Lawyer 2 (09:13:36):
So you don't know the characteristics of a hematoma or a bruise, and how it expands, such as this abrasion? You wouldn't have any idea, medically, how an abrasion like that might expand throughout the nose, do you?
Eric Warren (09:13:53):
Right. No, I am familiar with the terms, but I would not have that medical expertise to talk about how a human body reacts to a hematoma.
Lawyer 2 (09:14:07):
Excuse me. I apologize. Sir, did you have an opportunity to... As part of your preparation in the case, you said you reviewed a lot of materials. Is that fair?
Eric Warren (09:14:20):
Yes, sir. That's fair.
Lawyer 2 (09:14:22):
Did you have an opportunity to review a police interrogation or interview video with this defendant?
Eric Warren (09:14:30):
Yes, sir. I did.
Lawyer 2 (09:14:30):
Possibly more than one?
Eric Warren (09:14:33):
That's correct, yes.
Lawyer 2 (09:14:34):
Do you remember reviewing, sir, as part of your investigation, or your analysis in this case, a March 5th, 2020, interview with this defendant, with a detective Dick Hardy?
Eric Warren (09:14:45):
I don't recall the date, but I don't have a reason to doubt that if that's one of the ones you're referring to.
Lawyer 2 (09:14:51):
Do you remember... And specifically I'll kind of orient you to it. Do you remember a video in which this defendant was... Do you see the defendant? Do you remember seeing her in the video?
Eric Warren (09:15:00):
Yes, sir. I do.
Lawyer 2 (09:15:01):
It's the same person we're talking about, seated here, in the video?
Eric Warren (09:15:05):
I couldn't say.
Lawyer 2 (09:15:06):
Okay. Did you see a female in a video, with a police officer asking her questions, and looked like some kind of camera from a listed roof or the ceiling?
Eric Warren (09:15:13):
Yes, sir. I did.
Lawyer 2 (09:15:15):
And did you see on the video, sir, at any time where the detective said, "Hey, just get up, ma'am," or Ms. Boles, or Interviewee, and recreate how this happened? Do you remember seeing that?
Eric Warren (09:15:27):
I do recall seeing that. Yes, sir.
Lawyer 2 (09:15:28):
Actually, Detective Hardy, he requested of this defendant to, "Show me how it happened," right?
Eric Warren (09:15:33):
That is my recollection. Yes, sir.
Lawyer 2 (09:15:35):
And do you recall then that this defendant, or the person you saw on the video, at no time did they indicate that this weapon was turned upside down? At no time did that person indicate? Do you remember that?
Eric Warren (09:15:45):
Yeah. I do remember that there not being an indication that it was turned upside down, but also my recollection was it was a general... like they weren't sure. This was their best recollection, and this was them acting it, but they weren't saying it was exactly this way.
Lawyer 2 (09:16:05):
You don't remember this defendant just, when asked to recreate or show exactly to Detective Hardy how this shot happened... You have that toy gun?
Eric Warren (09:16:16):
Yes, sir.
Lawyer 2 (09:16:18):
May I approach the witness?
Judge Bucci (09:16:19):
Yes, sir.
Lawyer 2 (09:16:20):
Let me show that toy gun to you. Now, this defendant, or this person you saw in the video, she didn't have a toy gun in her hand. You don't remember that, do you?
Eric Warren (09:16:28):
No, there wasn't a toy gun.
Lawyer 2 (09:16:29):
Okay. Well, it's probably not fair for me to use a toy gun. I'm going to use what she did in the video. She used her finger, remember?
Eric Warren (09:16:33):
Yes, sir.
Lawyer 2 (09:16:33):
Do you remember that?
Eric Warren (09:16:33):
I do.
Lawyer 2 (09:16:36):
She just said that this happened like this, and just pointed it at the face of the would be victim, sir, right?
Eric Warren (09:16:44):
Yes, I do recall that on that statement.
Lawyer 2 (09:16:46):
She didn't point it upside down or invert it, did she?
Eric Warren (09:16:49):
No, not in that... She did not mimic or give that as an example.
Lawyer 2 (09:16:54):
She didn't say anything about... Because you've theorized that... She didn't say anything about like, " He was trying to avoid me getting the gun, so he was backing up and pointing it backwards in an upside down fashion." She didn't say that either.
Eric Warren (09:17:09):
No, I do not recall her making that statement.
Lawyer 2 (09:17:11):
So the only person that's alive, that was in that room, and tell us how it happened, according to her, she didn't even say that, right?
Eric Warren (09:17:20):
That is correct, yes.
Lawyer 2 (09:17:21):
She didn't even say what you're saying, right? You weren't there, right?
Eric Warren (09:17:25):
That's correct. I was not there.
Lawyer 2 (09:17:46):
Okay. A couple more points. On the weapon itself... You still have it there?
Eric Warren (09:17:50):
Yes, sir.
Lawyer 2 (09:17:51):
I understand that what you said, and please correct me if I'm wrong, Dr. Warren, but I believe what you said is with a revolver, more so than a semi-automatic pistol, revolver, sometimes you can have... or most times, all the time perhaps, you can have escaping gases from the cylinder itself, right?
Eric Warren (09:18:06):
Yes, that is correct.
Lawyer 2 (09:18:07):
Because the revolver, the structure of the frame of the revolver and where the cylinder fits the frame, we're not talking about an incredibly low tolerance between the surfaces, right?
Eric Warren (09:18:18):
Yes, that is correct. So there has to be tolerance, there has to be space so that that cylinder can freely revolve as either the hammer is cocked or the trigger is pulled.
Lawyer 2 (09:18:27):
But are you telling the jury, sir, that... You're not telling the jury that it's impossible to get sooting because it's a revolver, are you?
Eric Warren (09:18:36):
No, sir. I'm not.
Lawyer 2 (09:18:37):
It's just that some gases may escape the cylinder area, right?
Eric Warren (09:18:42):
Yes, sir. That is correct. My testimony was with it being a revolver, you have those spaces for the gas to escape, and with it being a smaller caliber, there's fewer gases and fewer powder particles to begin with.
Lawyer 2 (09:18:56):
And similar to that vein, sir, you said... In this type of a scenario that you described for the jury, you said that you would not, as the expert yourself, you would not expect, quote, "heavy stellate tearing." Is that what you said?
Eric Warren (09:19:15):
I don't recall if those were my exact words, but again, that sounds correct. I don't have a reason to doubt that.
Lawyer 2 (09:19:21):
Well, we were talking about the... or you were discussing the location of the entry wound with the honorable Mr. Steele, and you were talking about it being in the nose or nasal passage, and there being a passage upward to the brain, the sinuses. I think you mentioned the word "sinuses". Do you remember that?
Eric Warren (09:19:37):
Yes, sir. That is correct.
Lawyer 2 (09:19:38):
And would you doubt me if I just... Am I not accurate in saying you would not expect to see necessarily, quote, "heavy stellate tearing"?
Eric Warren (09:19:43):
No, I would agree with that.
Lawyer 2 (09:19:50):
But it's not impossible for there to be a stellate... a partial stellate tear, or some type of stellate tearing, even in that area. It's not impossible.
Eric Warren (09:19:58):
No. In general for a shot, if it is hard or loose contact, that is a possibility. Again, as I mentioned, it really depends on where on the body that shot occurred.
Lawyer 2 (09:20:10):
But in this case, you didn't... From the photographs you looked at, you didn't see stellate tearing of any kind, right?
Eric Warren (09:20:16):
That is correct.
Lawyer 2 (09:20:27):
And you understand, or do you, sir, that the... Did you know the GBI was asked to do DNA testing from the weapon in this case? Do you remember reading that?
Eric Warren (09:20:36):
I do remember reading that. Yes, sir.
Lawyer 2 (09:20:38):
And they returned the weapon. For reasons unknown, it appears that they would not do that. They would not undertake that testing. Did you know that?
Eric Warren (09:20:47):
I don't recall reading that anywhere, but I might have known that at some point.
Mr. Steele (09:20:52):
I'll also object, Your Honor. I don't think that's in evidence, and that's hearsay.
Lawyer 2 (09:20:56):
One of the -
Judge Bucci (09:20:56):
Sustained.
Lawyer 2 (09:21:00):
Your Honor, one of the previous witnesses indicated as admissible evidence that the GBI would not undertake the testing.
Mr. Steele (09:21:05):
Still hearsay.
Judge Bucci (09:21:08):
Well, it's in evidence. I mean, to be honest with you, I don't recall the testimony.
Lawyer 2 (09:21:14):
That's fine. I'll move on to another question.
(09:21:15)
Do you have any indication, as part of your investigation, comprehensive review of the case, why GBI could not do the testing? Do you know?
Eric Warren (09:21:21):
I do not know.
Lawyer 2 (09:21:26):
Okay. And even in your vast experience, I know you have worked in a biological lab with the Vanderbilt and all this, but would you agree with me, sir, sometimes there may be circumstances where DNA testing is not possible?
Eric Warren (09:21:39):
I would say it's not that it's not possible. Generally, it's a policy that prohibits it, or there's some scenario that prohibits that testing.
Lawyer 2 (09:21:49):
Maybe contamination of the subject that you're trying to test. Could be any number of reasons why an accurate result might not be able to be obtained, so there's no testing. Is that right?
Eric Warren (09:22:00):
Yes, there could be contamination, and that may be the reason it could be returned, or that test could be rejected. It wouldn't prevent the testing from being done, but it may prevent the quality of the results obtained.
Lawyer 2 (09:22:13):
It may affect the qualities of results obtained. I couldn't use that language. That's perfect. Thank you for that.
Eric Warren (09:22:18):
Yes, sir.
Lawyer 2 (09:22:19):
Quality of results obtained. But we don't know why it wasn't done here?
Eric Warren (09:22:22):
I do not know.
Lawyer 2 (09:22:23):
Okay, okay. I want to ask you one more question. It's about a particular exhibit that you looked at.
(09:22:31)
And if I can approach and publish once more, this picture, Defendant's Exhibit 147, okay?
(09:22:44)
Are you aware that Dr. Lehman, he didn't find any soot inside the nasal cavity? Did you know that?
Eric Warren (09:22:53):
I'm not aware of any indication that he actually attempted to find soot. I think that this documentation is the only thing that was provided to me, that I've seen.
Lawyer 2 (09:23:02):
So you would be surprised if he... You would be surprised to learn, I guess, that he testified earlier that he specifically looked for soot with a magnifying glass all over the area of the face.
Mr. Steele (09:23:13):
I don't think that was the testimony, plus I'll object to answering.
Lawyer 2 (09:23:17):
I'll rephrase it. Would you be surprised if a forensic pathologist went over a body in this type of scenario with a magnifying glass, looking for soot?
Mr. Steele (09:23:26):
I don't remember any of that. I'll object to the form of the question.
Lawyer 2 (09:23:29):
He testified that he looked over the face with a magnifying glass. That is a fact.
Judge Bucci (09:23:35):
Well, he can ask hypothetically, regardless of what the other testimony was.
Lawyer 2 (09:23:40):
All right. So you don't know if Dr. Lehman looked for soot at all? You don't know, I guess, is your testimony?
Eric Warren (09:23:46):
Beyond the photographs that were provided in the autopsy report, no.
Lawyer 2 (09:23:51):
Okay. All right. And the autopsy report said that he didn't see sooting, right?
Eric Warren (09:23:54):
That is correct.
Lawyer 2 (09:23:55):
So wouldn't you suppose that if he says he didn't see sooting, he wouldn't look? Isn't that like a...
Eric Warren (09:24:01):
Yes. I would expect to see histology, or sodium, or desonate testing to confirm whether or not an object that is clearly foreign to the body, whether or not it would be soot.
Lawyer 2 (09:24:12):
Okay. And you said... I want you to look at this State's Exhibit 147 here. You may have to stand up again. But is this the area that concerns you, of grayish in color, that you think may be soot?
Eric Warren (09:24:25):
Yes, sir. That's correct.
Lawyer 2 (09:24:27):
Okay. And you said you wouldn't necessarily expect to see that type of matter in the nasal passage. Do you remember saying that?
Eric Warren (09:24:34):
I would need more context.
Lawyer 2 (09:24:38):
Well, the context you gave a moment ago, sir, was you wouldn't expect to see that type of foreign matter in the nasal passage unless you're something like maybe a coal miner or working with brake dust. Do you remember saying that?
Eric Warren (09:24:48):
Yes. Yes, I do.
Lawyer 2 (09:24:50):
Well, what if this guy was a steel worker, like with the sheet metal union, the sheet metal workers union, and he was around cutting metals, metal fabrication, and the cutting of metals all the time for his job, six days a week? Is that possible that that could introduce foreign matter like that, gray in color, to the nasal passage?
Eric Warren (09:25:12):
Yes. So again, as I mentioned earlier, being in coal miner, or around break dust, where you're breathing in material like that, it is certainly a possibility if there weren't N95 masks or the appropriate precautions being taken, that that could lead to something like that.
Lawyer 2 (09:25:28):
No further questions. Thank you.
Judge Bucci (09:25:29):
Anything else?
Mr. Steele (09:25:38):
Just one question.
(09:25:38)
I just want to ask you one question. When you were asked about whether you saw on any of the statements of Ms. Boles, whether she said that the gun was inverted, and you gave the example of a child holding the key fob, and the parent trying to get it back, and the child... How fast can somebody take a gun like this and put it to their nose? How quick can that happen?
Eric Warren (09:26:10):
I mean, you just demonstrated it, so less than a second. It could be very quick.
Mr. Steele (09:26:15):
And would the person... You know Ms. Boles said that she fell on top, so she was moving too? She fell on top of Me. Akers, you remember that?
Lawyer 2 (09:26:21):
Objection. A series of leading questions that you're not on redirect.
Mr. Steele (09:26:24):
Hypothetical. I'll rephrase.
Judge Bucci (09:26:24):
All right.
Mr. Steele (09:26:28):
Do you remember from the video, anything about Ms. Boles falling?
Eric Warren (09:26:34):
Again, just what we've already talked about, mimicking the movement of the firearm, and then falling onto Mr. Akers, and then the subsequent actions thereafter.
Mr. Steele (09:26:45):
How quickly can a gun go from the position that you saw Ms. Boles hold it in the video to up the nose, and gunfire go off, and the bullet-
Eric Warren (09:26:55):
Sure. Again, a fraction of a second. Studies, I think in 2010, have shown that the typical person can pull the trigger three to four times a second, and we're only talking about one shot here. So at longest, potentially a third of a second.
Mr. Steele (09:27:11):
Thank you, sir. Thank you.
Judge Bucci (09:27:12):
Anything else?
Lawyer 2 (09:27:16):
No, thank you, Your Honor.
Judge Bucci (09:27:16):
May he be excused?
Mr. Steele (09:27:16):
Yes.
Judge Bucci (09:27:16):
All right. Thank you.
Mr. Steele (09:27:16):
Thank you, Judge.
Judge Bucci (09:27:24):
All right. We're going to take a break. Before we do, let me just say that I just made some rulings, and in doing so, I'm not commenting on the evidence. If I said I don't recall the evidence, it's for you to recall whether or not there was that evidence or there wasn't. I'm not commenting on it, so that's entirely for you, okay? Does that make sense? Entirely for you to recall what the evidence was. Let's take a half hour dinner.
Judge Richards (10:05:00):
Looks like there's one more sandwich left in there. Looks like there's one more sandwich in there you didn't eat. You ate?
Speaker 28 (10:05:05):
[inaudible 10:05:08].
Judge Richards (10:05:10):
Okay.
Speaker 28 (10:05:10):
[inaudible 10:05:16].
Judge Richards (10:05:15):
Well, take that one home. Don't let it sit there and go to bad.
Speaker 28 (10:05:18):
[inaudible 10:05:23].
Judge Richards (10:05:24):
Well, give it to Bonnie or something. Well, give it to somebody. Don't let it go bad.
Speaker 28 (10:05:28):
[inaudible 10:05:33].
Judge Richards (10:05:41):
Gentlemen ready?
Speaker 29 (10:05:44):
Yes, sir.
Lawyer 2 (10:05:44):
Yes, sir.
Speaker 29 (10:05:45):
We cannot get any more witnesses here, but we've narrowed down our witnesses to just Ross Gardner, Dr. Downs, Dr. Terry, Lacy Boles.
Judge Richards (10:05:58):
Well, I'm told y'all have two witnesses that won't take very long, so we'll do that. And then since we have some time, maybe we start looking at a request to charge and get started on those.
Speaker 29 (10:06:08):
That'd be great.
Judge Richards (10:06:09):
All right.
Speaker 29 (10:06:10):
And then Your Honor, I don't know who the witnesses are, but if it is... Can I just have one second?
Speaker 28 (10:06:28):
Judge Richards, [inaudible 10:06:29] run upstairs because this is going to take a while?
Judge Richards (10:06:28):
Okay. It is?
Lawyer 2 (10:06:29):
Yeah, there's like 30 pages for per packet.
Judge Richards (10:06:30):
What?
Speaker 29 (10:06:30):
With regards to-
Judge Richards (10:06:30):
All right, go, let's do it.
Speaker 29 (10:06:31):
May I just ask the Court with regards to the former husband, Jeremiah Boles I believe is the name, the State's intending to call him. And he sent a post after the trial that we tried to undertake. He said something like, "Who's the monster now?", and Lacy's picture, or something like that. We're moving to exclude any character evidence. Ms. Boles did not place her character in issue whatsoever.
(10:07:06)
And to my knowledge, he really doesn't... To my knowledge, he can only talk about her character, what it was like living with her, whether he believes that she's a truthful person. Everything would be character to me.
(10:07:22)
However, I don't know what the state's going to ask him, so he might have other information, but I'm just... Same thing that we did before. We will be diligent to object, and potentially not willingly, but move for a mistrial if he starts talking about character.
Judge Richards (10:07:39):
All right. Any response?
Lawyer 2 (10:07:42):
No, Your Honor.
Judge Richards (10:07:46):
All right. Let's have the jury.
Speaker 29 (10:08:05):
And Your Honor?
Judge Richards (10:08:06):
Yes.
Speaker 29 (10:08:06):
While the jurors are coming, Mr. Lowell was kind enough to get the Cobb County-
Speaker 30 (10:08:14):
The jurors are coming.
Speaker 29 (10:08:24):
We'll talk about it.
Judge Richards (10:08:24):
Can we talk? We'll talk there?
Speaker 29 (10:08:25):
Yes. We'll talk about it.
Judge Richards (10:08:43):
All right. Welcome back, ladies and gentlemen. Hope you enjoyed the dinner. I know it wasn't a gourmet meal, or anything, but we appreciate you staying late. We'll see how far we get. We won't go past 8:00, okay? The State have another witness?
Lawyer 2 (10:08:56):
Yes, Your Honor. If it please the Court, State calls Jeremiah Boles.
Speaker 30 (10:09:28):
Good evening, sir. I'll swear you in. Could you please raise your right hand to the left? Do you swear or affirm the testimony you're about to give in the matter before the Court will be the truth, the whole truth, nothing but the truth, so help you God?
Jeremiah Boles (10:09:36):
Yes, sir.
Speaker 30 (10:09:36):
Please have a seat.
Lawyer 2 (10:09:46):
Good evening, sir. Can you tell the jury your name, please?
Jeremiah Boles (10:09:46):
Jeremiah Boles.
Lawyer 2 (10:09:48):
Just common spelling, Jeremiah?
Jeremiah Boles (10:09:50):
Yes, sir.
Lawyer 2 (10:09:50):
Can you tell the jury how you're employed nowadays?
Jeremiah Boles (10:09:56):
Yes. I'm in commercial roofing as a project manager.
Lawyer 2 (10:10:00):
You live local into Palm County?
Jeremiah Boles (10:10:02):
Lithia Springs.
Lawyer 2 (10:10:07):
Have you ever had an occasion to come to know a person that you may know and you see in this Court as Lacy Boles?
Jeremiah Boles (10:10:14):
Yes, sir.
Lawyer 2 (10:10:15):
How do you know that person?
Jeremiah Boles (10:10:16):
That's my ex-wife.
Lawyer 2 (10:10:18):
All right. At any time when you were... How long were you married to her?
Jeremiah Boles (10:10:23):
Roughly six years, I believe.
Lawyer 2 (10:10:25):
Do you have kids together?
Jeremiah Boles (10:10:26):
Yes, two children.
Lawyer 2 (10:10:27):
All right, sir. Did you at any time have any knowledge of her, this offense? Do you see her in this room?
Jeremiah Boles (10:10:35):
Yes, sir.
Lawyer 2 (10:10:36):
All right. At any time during your marriage, sir, did you have an opportunity to have an opinion on her familiarity with firearms and the use of firearms?
Jeremiah Boles (10:10:45):
Oh, yeah, I was familiar. I had a-
Lawyer 2 (10:10:47):
Come up to the mic if you would.
Jeremiah Boles (10:10:49):
Oh, I'm sorry. Yes. I mean, we had firearms that we shot at her... She has a cabin in Blue Ridge, so we would shoot up there often.
Lawyer 2 (10:10:54):
Did you ever go to a shooting range?
Jeremiah Boles (10:11:00):
No, no.
Lawyer 2 (10:11:00):
Just outdoors?
Jeremiah Boles (10:11:01):
Yes, sir.
Lawyer 2 (10:11:03):
Do you know what kind of pistol that, or I shouldn't say pistol, what kind of firearm was it?
Jeremiah Boles (10:11:06):
It'd be a Glock 40.
Lawyer 2 (10:11:08):
So, a pistol?
Jeremiah Boles (10:11:09):
Yes, sir.
Lawyer 2 (10:11:09):
Okay, sir. Did you ever know a person named Daniel Akers?
Jeremiah Boles (10:11:17):
Yes, sir.
Lawyer 2 (10:11:17):
Did you know that person to be the Defendant's spouse after your marriage ended?
Jeremiah Boles (10:11:23):
Yes, sir.
Lawyer 2 (10:11:24):
Did you ever have an opportunity to see Daniel Akers on or about mid to late December of 2019?
Jeremiah Boles (10:11:32):
Yes, sir, I did.
Lawyer 2 (10:11:33):
Can you tell the jury when you think you might have seen him for the last time?
Jeremiah Boles (10:11:36):
I dropped my son off this... That was the Friday. I think that would've been like the 19th, or... I think this all occurred on the Saturday into Sunday, and it was the Friday before.
Lawyer 2 (10:11:47):
So, if we say that the 21st of December 2019 was a Saturday, are you talking about the very day before?
Jeremiah Boles (10:11:53):
Yes, the Friday before.
Lawyer 2 (10:11:53):
The 20th?
Jeremiah Boles (10:11:53):
Yes, sir. A day ago.
Lawyer 2 (10:11:57):
And you said that you just happened to see him while you were dropping your son off with Mrs. Boles?
Jeremiah Boles (10:12:02):
No, she wasn't there. I just-
Brian Steel (10:12:00):
... while you were dropping your son off with Mrs. Boles?
Speaker 31 (10:12:02):
No, she wasn't there. I just met Dan alone.
Brian Steel (10:12:05):
Okay. But it was at the house they shared, I guess?
Speaker 31 (10:12:05):
No, it was at a church off Pine Valley.
Brian Steel (10:12:10):
Okay. Sorry. You had a custody exchange at a church with Dan.
Speaker 31 (10:12:14):
Yes, sir.
Brian Steel (10:12:14):
Did you have any kind of... Was this a tumultuous custody exchange or bad blood with you and Dan or anything like that?
Speaker 31 (10:12:20):
Not at all. No, sir.
Brian Steel (10:12:22):
Were you on good terms with Mr. Akers?
Speaker 31 (10:12:24):
Yeah, at this point we were upset. Everything's good.
Brian Steel (10:12:28):
Did you have an opportunity to... Don't tell me what he said if he did, but did you have an opportunity to speak with him on December 20th, the Friday?
Speaker 31 (10:12:35):
Yes, sir. We had some casual conversation.
Brian Steel (10:12:38):
Okay. Were you concerned about that conversation that... Anything about that conversation might have caused you to be concerned about his mental state?
Speaker 31 (10:12:44):
No, not at all.
Brian Steel (10:12:47):
Anything that caused you to maybe think you might need to inform somebody, "Hey, something's not right for this guy," or anything like that?
Speaker 31 (10:12:53):
No, sir. I wouldn't let my son go if I thought that.
Brian Steel (10:12:58):
You let your son go into his sole custody?
Speaker 31 (10:13:01):
Yeah.
Brian Steel (10:13:03):
How old was your son? Excuse me. How old was your son at that time?
Speaker 31 (10:13:05):
At that time, I would imagine... I can't remember, honestly. So he's 22 now, so whatever that age would be.
Brian Steel (10:13:14):
Teenager?
Speaker 31 (10:13:14):
Yes, sir.
Brian Steel (10:13:15):
Mid-teen. If there was anything wrong-
Speaker 31 (10:13:16):
Mid-teen, yeah.
Brian Steel (10:13:20):
If there anything out of sorts or concerning to you with Mr. Akers on Friday... Did you exchange him at nighttime?
Speaker 31 (10:13:26):
It was evening, probably five-ish. Yeah.
Brian Steel (10:13:29):
If there was anything concerning to you about Mr. Akers' behavior, would you have then let your son go?
Mr. Steel (10:13:34):
Asked and answered.
Speaker 31 (10:13:36):
No, sir. I would not have.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:13:54):
I think the question is a little different, so overruled.
Brian Steel (10:13:59):
That's all I have.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:13:59):
Cross.
Brian Steel (10:13:59):
Thank you. [inaudible 10:14:00] lawyers might have something.
Speaker 31 (10:13:59):
All right.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:13:59):
No? Sir, thank you for being here. You free to go. Next witness.
Lawyer 1 (10:13:59):
State calls Hope Allen.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:15:14):
Do you swear or affirm the testimony you're about to give in the matter before the court will be the truth, the whole truth, nothing but the truth, so help you God?
Hope Allen (10:15:15):
I do.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:15:15):
Please have a seat.
Lawyer 1 (10:15:23):
Could you state your name please, ma'am?
Hope Allen (10:15:25):
Yes. My name is Hope Allen.
Lawyer 1 (10:15:27):
And how are you employed?
Hope Allen (10:15:29):
I'm a registered nurse at Emory Healthcare.
Lawyer 1 (10:15:33):
And how long have you been a registered nurse?
Hope Allen (10:15:36):
Since 2012.
Lawyer 1 (10:15:39):
Did you know an individual by the name of Daniel Akers?
Hope Allen (10:15:43):
Yes, sir.
Lawyer 1 (10:15:44):
How did you know Mr. Akers?
Hope Allen (10:15:46):
Dan lived in my neighborhood when I was in high school.
Lawyer 1 (10:15:52):
When you were in what?
Hope Allen (10:15:52):
High school.
Lawyer 1 (10:15:54):
Okay. And how did you know him besides being in your neighborhood when you were in high school?
Hope Allen (10:16:01):
We were friends. We had a close neighborhood group, so we all hung out together.
Lawyer 1 (10:16:07):
And were you friends with him his whole life or would you do stuff with him or see him from time to time?
Hope Allen (10:16:15):
Just through high school when he moved to Georgia.
Lawyer 1 (10:16:19):
Okay. So how often would you see him during the course of a year normally?
Hope Allen (10:16:26):
I mean, during that time, we were together probably almost every day, at least every weekday. We rode the same school bus and things like that.
Lawyer 1 (10:16:34):
And what about after high school?
Hope Allen (10:16:38):
After high school, I didn't really see him. I moved away from the neighborhood.
Lawyer 1 (10:16:42):
Did you have any contact with him after high school?
Hope Allen (10:16:45):
Very infrequently, just like social media.
Lawyer 1 (10:16:51):
And how often would you contact him on social media?
Hope Allen (10:16:58):
In the course of probably a year, maybe once or twice.
Lawyer 1 (10:17:08):
So you went from seeing him almost every year till he got to be an adult and then you saw him once or twice a year. Did you live in this area at that time?
Mr. Steel (10:17:17):
I don't think that was the testimony. I'm going to object to last statement.
Lawyer 1 (10:17:21):
Okay. I'm sorry if I misspoke. How many times would you see Mr. Akers during the course of the year or have contact with him?
Hope Allen (10:17:31):
I didn't see him really after high school. Just contact through social media.
Lawyer 1 (10:17:35):
Okay. And how many times would you have contact with him with social media during this time?
Hope Allen (10:17:40):
Maybe once a year.
Lawyer 1 (10:17:41):
Okay. Now, did you have an occasion to come in contact with him in December of 2019?
Hope Allen (10:17:55):
I ran into him at a bar in Dallas.
Lawyer 1 (10:18:03):
When was that?
Hope Allen (10:18:05):
December 21st of 2019.
Lawyer 1 (10:18:11):
December 1st of 2019. You met him at a bar?
Hope Allen (10:18:15):
No, December 21st.
Lawyer 1 (10:18:17):
I'm sorry?
Hope Allen (10:18:18):
December 21st.
Lawyer 1 (10:18:19):
Okay. December 21st of 2019, is that right?
Hope Allen (10:18:23):
Yes, sir.
Lawyer 1 (10:18:23):
Okay. Now, what bar did you meet him at?
Hope Allen (10:18:28):
It was 278 South.
Lawyer 1 (10:18:35):
Now, was that a planned date that you had with him or meet him or anything?
Hope Allen (10:18:40):
No, it was random.
Lawyer 1 (10:18:42):
What brought you to that location at that particular time?
Hope Allen (10:18:50):
We just decided to go, me and my husband and one of our neighbors.
Lawyer 1 (10:18:56):
So you and your husband and a friend went to the bar at 278?
Hope Allen (10:19:02):
Yes, sir.
Lawyer 1 (10:19:03):
About what time did you get to the bar?
Hope Allen (10:19:06):
Right at 11:30 PM.
Lawyer 1 (10:19:13):
And was there something special going on that you were celebrating or anything?
Hope Allen (10:19:19):
No, sir.
Lawyer 1 (10:19:22):
Okay. So you're at the bar at 11:30 and what, if anything, do you notice?
Hope Allen (10:19:27):
Dan actually flagged me down right when we walked in the door. He was sitting at the corner of the bar.
Lawyer 1 (10:19:34):
And he was at the bar?
Hope Allen (10:19:38):
Yes, sir.
Lawyer 1 (10:19:40):
And what did you notice about any company he was with at the bar?
Hope Allen (10:19:47):
He was by himself.
Lawyer 1 (10:19:54):
And what did you do when he flagged you down?
Hope Allen (10:19:57):
Me and my husband and our neighbor went over to him and I introduced everybody and gave him a hug.
Lawyer 1 (10:20:08):
How long had it been since you'd seen him before you decided to walk over this particular evening and give Mr. Akers a hug?
Hope Allen (10:20:15):
It had probably been since I graduated high school, so that was in 2000. It's been a very long time.
Lawyer 1 (10:20:27):
Okay. So you're at the bar, you've introduced your husband and your friend to Mr. Akers. Did you have occasion to converse with Mr. Akers?
Hope Allen (10:20:42):
We talked for about 20 minutes or so.
Lawyer 1 (10:20:46):
Were you able to observe what he was drinking?
Hope Allen (10:20:50):
He actually ordered water.
Lawyer 1 (10:20:55):
Do you know why he ordered water?
Hope Allen (10:20:58):
He said that he had to drive home soon.
Lawyer 1 (10:21:02):
And what did you order?
Hope Allen (10:21:04):
I ordered a beer.
Lawyer 1 (10:21:09):
And then what, if anything, happened with regard to your meeting with Mr. Akers as far as a topic of conversation, that sort of thing? Do you recall what you were talking about?
Hope Allen (10:21:26):
Yeah, he showed me some pictures of the kids on his phone. He was telling me about his job and showing me some more pictures from that. And then I asked him to come to a table with us since he was there by himself, but he said that he had to get going. He was only staying for a little bit, that him and his wife had been kind of arguing and that's why he was there.
Lawyer 1 (10:22:01):
Did you have any indication about him and his wife arguing from what you observed when you were at the table talking to him?
Hope Allen (10:22:13):
I mean, he just said that they had been arguing and he left and that he was just heading back home.
Lawyer 1 (10:22:25):
Did you ever have occasion to observe any text messages?
Hope Allen (10:22:26):
I did, yes. I didn't really read them. He just kind of held up his phone and just kind of flipped like this, just showing me that they had just been kind of going back and forth via text.
Lawyer 1 (10:22:44):
When he showed you the text messages, what was his attitude at that time? What was his demeanor like?
Hope Allen (10:22:48):
He was just smiling. He didn't... I don't know. He was just regular Dan, the Dan that I remember.
Lawyer 1 (10:23:03):
You said regular Dan, what did that mean to you?
Hope Allen (10:23:08):
Dan always just seemed to be like a go with the flow kind of person and just happy.
Lawyer 1 (10:23:19):
And did you see him leave the bar that night?
Hope Allen (10:23:29):
I saw him leave inside of the bar, but after he walked out the door, I didn't see him after that.
Lawyer 1 (10:23:36):
So you saw him leave the bar?
Hope Allen (10:23:38):
Yes, sir.
Lawyer 1 (10:23:39):
Do you know approximately how long he was there at the bar?
Hope Allen (10:23:43):
He was there before me, but I don't know what time he got there, but he probably left close to midnight.
Lawyer 1 (10:23:59):
And so you got there approximately 11:30, did you say?
Hope Allen (10:24:04):
Yes, sir.
Lawyer 1 (10:24:05):
And he left at about midnight?
Hope Allen (10:24:08):
Yes, sir.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:24:42):
[inaudible 10:24:42] cross.
Brian Steel (10:24:45):
Thank you, Ms. Allen. No questions for her. Thank you, Judge.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:24:47):
Ma'am, you're free to go. Thank you very much.
Hope Allen (10:24:47):
Thank you.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:24:52):
State can have another witness.
Lawyer 1 (10:24:56):
The State rests.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:24:56):
Ladies and gentlemen, what that means is the State does not intend to present any more evidence. There may be rebuttal evidence later. I don't know. So at this point, I have to have a conversation with the lawyers. We may be done for the night, we may not, but would you please go back to the jury room? All right. State is rested. Does the defense have any motions?
Mr. Steel (10:25:55):
We do, Your Honor. Your Honor, we'd like the court to consider on all three counts, malice murder, felony murder, and aggravated assault, a directed verdict of acquittal based on the test that the court must apply. And the way I will summarize, I know the court's been very attentive, but the way I understand the case as its posture is right now is that Detective Ogden is a lead detective. I asked him whether he has any evidence to prove that Lacey Boles walked downstairs and introduced a gun at this time of the fatality. He said no. I asked him whether he has any evidence that Mr. Akers did not come in the house with the gun and introduced the gun. He said no, he doesn't have any evidence that that did not happen.
(10:27:04)
I asked the same exact questions to Detective Hardy and he said the same response. He said, "I don't have any evidence that Lacey Boles came downstairs with a gun." And he has no evidence to dispute the fact that Mr. Akers may have come in the house with a gun. I asked Dr. Lehman, who testified today, he did not. He said that it is possible, it's not his opinion, but it's possible that this was a self-inflicted wound as stated by Ms. Boles.
(10:27:51)
Your Honor, the law in Georgia that will be applied is that the court must instruct the jury at some point that circumstantial evidence must exclude every reasonable hypothesis, save the guilt of the accused. There is no evidence here pointing that Ms. Boles took the life of her husband, did anything but try to save his life. I'd ask you to consider based upon the law, and I know where we are now, I know it's a directed verdict and the facts that Ms. Boles be found not guilty by the court.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:28:41):
Response?
Lawyer 1 (10:28:42):
May it please the court, Mr. Steel. Your Honor, I think Mr. Steel said it pretty effectively. He said that the jury needs to be instructed, so I think he kind of concedes that there is a jury question as to the guilt or innocence of this defendant, and we would ask the court to pay attention to all the evidence that has been presented and allow this case to go to the jury for determination as to the verdict. Thank you.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:29:10):
All right. Court overrules or denies the motion for directed verdict. Let me ask you, Mr. Steel, is now an okay time for me to talk with your client about her right to testify?
Brian Steel (10:29:23):
Yes.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:29:24):
Ms. Boles, I'm going to have some questions for you, okay?
Lacy Jolee Boles (10:29:26):
Okay.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:29:28):
Ma'am, do you understand that you have a right to testify and that if you want to testify, nobody can stop you or prevent you from testifying?
Lacy Jolee Boles (10:29:36):
Yes.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:29:36):
You understand that?
Lacy Jolee Boles (10:29:37):
Yes.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:29:38):
You also have a right to not testify if you don't want to. And if you don't want to testify, no one can make you testify. You understand that?
Lacy Jolee Boles (10:29:49):
Yes.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:29:53):
Ma'am, do you understand that it's not your lawyers that make the decision on whether you testify? They can advise you, but you get to make the decision on whether to testify.
Lacy Jolee Boles (10:30:03):
Yes.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:30:04):
Or not testify. You understand that?
Lacy Jolee Boles (10:30:05):
Yes, sir.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:30:11):
If you do not testify, then upon request by you or your lawyers, the court will instruct the jury that your decision to not testify cannot be held against you in any way. Do you understand that?
Lacy Jolee Boles (10:30:24):
Yes.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:30:26):
If you do testify, then not only will your lawyers examine you on the witness stand, but the district attorney or assistant district attorney will cross-examine you. Do you understand that?
Lacy Jolee Boles (10:30:36):
Yes.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:30:38):
Have you had enough time to make a decision on whether to testify?
Lacy Jolee Boles (10:30:41):
No.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:30:42):
Do you want to think about it more?
Lacy Jolee Boles (10:30:44):
Yes.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:30:44):
Okay. I'll let you. Can we hand out?
Mr. Steel (10:31:05):
Your Honor, when it's convenient, can I, for the record, just ask the court to see if we could supplement the Exhibit... I forget what number it is, but it's the Cobb County indictment number 021480 dealing with Mr. Akers and Mr. Poag.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:31:29):
What do you want to do, add a page?
Mr. Steel (10:31:31):
Yes. There's... Mr. Lail was instrumental and I showed it already for prosecutors unless they need more time, but it was just simply the pages missing. It is here. The sentence is on prosecutors were challenging that count two really wasn't a guilty plea, but it's right here. The sentence, it must have been omitted the first time, but it is here that Mrs. Akers did in fact plead guilty to count two, as well as count three, just like it says on the front. Count one and four were...
Judge Dean Bucci (10:32:01):
State?
Lawyer 1 (10:32:01):
I don't have any objection to supplementing that page.
Mr. Steel (10:32:06):
Appreciate it.
Lawyer 1 (10:32:07):
[inaudible 10:32:07] Mr. Lail's efforts in getting that [inaudible 10:32:10].
Judge Dean Bucci (10:32:09):
Okay. Very good. We'll do that.
Mr. Steel (10:32:14):
Thank you. Thank you, Your Honor.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:32:15):
All right.
Mr. Steel (10:32:16):
And I think there's another record that I have the same exhibit number and I'm supposed to alert the court and ask you if I could change one to an A as in Alisa. So it would be the same number, but an A.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:32:28):
Okay. Any problem with that?
Lawyer 1 (10:32:29):
No, Your Honor.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:32:29):
Okay. That's fine with me.
Mr. Steel (10:32:33):
And I forget what number it is. If the court reporter can assist, I'll put it on the record.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:33:00):
All right. What everybody should have is a copy of the jury instructions, and what we have here is a compilation of you requested it. It's in this stack or a group of documents here, and we'll go through them and see where the problem is, and then we'll get them cleaned up and I'll make rulings where I have to. And then before you argue, you're going to get a clean copy of this, so you'll know in advance exactly what I'm going to say. The first request is 11010 indictment, which is a pattern charge. And so what I'll do is I'll leave in the first parenthetical there where it says, "The grand jury has indicted." I'll take out the district attorney has accused. And then instead of rereading the indictment, what I think I'll do is I'll say the indictment is as I read to you and you'll have it with you in the jury room.
Mr. Steel (10:34:02):
Okay. Your Honor, can we approach just one second?
Judge Dean Bucci (10:34:07):
Sure. Waive your client's presence, right?
Mr. Steel (10:34:10):
Yes. Yes.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:34:41):
Cut them loose. We're not going to need them anymore and we'll see them 8:30 Monday morning. They can... That's right.
Brian Steel (10:34:49):
Could we... [inaudible 10:34:52].
Judge Dean Bucci (10:34:51):
I'm sorry, one second, Diane.
Brian Steel (10:34:52):
I'm sorry, Your Honor. May I speak? Just in an abundance of caution, can we recharge the jury since this is a late [inaudible 10:35:00] weekend?
Judge Dean Bucci (10:34:59):
All right. Bring them back in and I'll give them some instructions.
Brian Steel (10:35:04):
Okay. Thank you.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:35:18):
All right. Thank you for reminding me, Mr. Steel. That what the bench conference was, just that we needed to address the jury. All right. We're not going to have any further witnesses this evening. I'm going to cut y'all loose and we're going to reconvene Monday morning. Y'all can be here at 8:30, right? Monday morning. This is going to sound familiar to you, but since we're about to have a long break, it's worth me reinstructing you. Do not conduct any research about this case or about any people or places mentioned during the trial. Do not visit any locations you've heard mentioned. Do not refer to any books or documents that were not admitted at trial. Do not use dictionaries or other reference materials to research anything related to this case. Do not search the internet, websites, blogs, or use any other media to get information about this case.
(10:36:42)
Do not research legal terms or the law, and you must avoid any accounts of this trial that might appear in the news media, whether online, in print, or on the radio. Remember that you are the ones who have been qualified as fair and impartial jurors in this case. No outside influence can affect your decision. For this reason, you may not discuss this case with anyone, including your family and friends or let anybody discuss the case with you or even around you. This includes discussing or sharing information by email, texting, blogging, or any form of social media. Until actual deliberations begin, you must not discuss the case even amongst yourselves in the jury room during breaks or anywhere else. There is a chance we finish Tuesday, but I can't promise anything. Okay? So we're getting there and we're grateful to all of you. So we'll see you next week.
Speaker 32 (10:37:44):
Judge, they want to know how likely would work Monday and Tuesday.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:37:47):
I think the note y'all sent out said you could go to eight Monday and Tuesdays. That still okay? And as you can see, like today and yesterday, especially today, we don't quite get to eight, but if necessary, we'll go to eight. Okay? And we'll get dinner for you as well. Okay. All right. So now we're up to the second submitted jury instruction. That's 1.10.20 issue and plea of not guilty. I assume there's no problems there. Y'all stop me or shout out when you have a problem with one of these. The third submitted jury instruction is 1.20.10, presumption of innocence. I will give that. There's one parenthetical on the second page kind of towards the top when a defense accept insanity is raised by the evidence. I'll just strike accept insanity and leave the rest of that satisfactory. Then grave suspicion. That always seems to be an argument. What's State's position?
Lawyer 1 (10:39:23):
State contends that reasonable doubt and the totality of the court's charge covers the concept in this case.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:39:33):
All right. Any argument from the defense?
Brian Steel (10:39:36):
Yes. It's a pattern charge. We'd ask for it. I would like grave suspicion to be given by the court.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:39:45):
I typically don't give it, but that doesn't mean I never give it. So I'll consider it and I'll let you know.
Brian Steel (10:39:53):
Thank you.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:39:54):
Yes, sir. Then there's 1.20.30, jury, judges of law and facts. I will give that. Then we have 1.30.10, evidence generally. There are some parentheticals here. I think I can strike the one on the third line that says, or the equivalent such as depositions, because we don't have depositions.
Brian Steel (10:40:17):
Agreed.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:40:18):
I did hear y'all say you stipulate to something once or twice, but then the evidence was admitted. So I can leave stipulations in there if y'all want it. It's up to you.
Lawyer 1 (10:40:36):
State don't believe it's necessary. What it was about was the photographs and we just admitted them in.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:40:39):
Okay. I'll take it out unless you want it, Mr. Steel.
Brian Steel (10:40:45):
You can take it out.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:40:46):
Okay. Then I'm also going to take out matters in which the court has taken judicial notice that doesn't apply. The next one is 1.30.20, direct and circumstantial evidence. There's two versions. I don't have a preference. Do y'all?
Brian Steel (10:41:11):
We usually like the long version.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:41:13):
Okay. Any argument there?
Lawyer 1 (10:41:14):
No, Your Honor.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:41:27):
All right. I can take out 1.30.12, right? Stipulations?
Mr. Steel (10:41:32):
Yes, sir.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:41:33):
All right. That is out. I've got the limiting instruction on transcripts, which may be non-pattern, but I really don't see a problem with it.
Mr. Steel (10:41:49):
That's fine, Your Honor.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:41:58):
I plan to give 1.131.10. Do y'all want any of those factors removed?
Mr. Steel (10:42:11):
I'm okay with their intelligence. It doesn't matter to me.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:42:17):
Okay. All right. I'm just going to read... All right, I'll just read the whole list. Next is 1.31.40. I'm not sure who requested it, but...
Mr. Steel (10:42:29):
It was me, Your Honor.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:42:30):
Okay. What is your suggestion? Because...
Mr. Steel (10:42:34):
We don't need character for untruthfulness.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:42:47):
How do you want to handle bias towards a party?
Mr. Steel (10:42:49):
I think that applies.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:42:51):
Okay. So I'll charge bias towards a party shown by... How would you like me to read that?
Mr. Steel (10:43:17):
So you're talking about for bias?
Judge Dean Bucci (10:43:19):
Right. There's a bullet point that says bias towards a party, period. And then there's some parentheticals so some of that can come out. I'm just wondering how you want me to charge that.
Mr. Steel (10:43:33):
I just think it would be...
Judge Dean Bucci (10:43:35):
Bias towards a party period?
Mr. Steel (10:43:37):
Yeah. Bias towards a party specific instances of conduct of the witness that may relate to the witness's bias towards a party. I think that's the code section. So instead of the first bias towards the party, just...
Judge Dean Bucci (10:43:53):
Bias towards a party shown by specific instances of conduct of the witness.
Mr. Steel (10:43:58):
We can just use bias of a party. I see what the court's saying. That's fine.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:44:03):
All right. So bias towards a party, period. Any problem with that, State?
Lawyer 1 (10:44:05):
No, Your Honor.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:44:07):
And then the next option that they give us is criminal convictions, which...
Mr. Steel (10:44:17):
We don't need that, Your Honor.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:44:18):
Okay. Next charge that's been submitted is pattern charge 1.31.45. I think that's fine, but I have an option first for the second part.
Mr. Steel (10:44:37):
I'd like the first part.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:44:39):
What's the State say?
Lawyer 1 (10:44:39):
I have no objection to the first part. Okay.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:44:39):
That's what we'll do. Then we have 1.31.30 dealing with expert witnesses. I will give that for sure, assume there's no objection. Next one is 1.31.47, prior statements. I think I'll give that. Any objection?
Mr. Steel (10:45:15):
No, I think that people... We talked about their prior statements. I think that's appropriate.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:45:21):
1.31.90. Any problem there?
Mr. Steel (10:45:26):
I'm objecting to it. I think that the court doesn't need to [inaudible 10:45:32] about a single witness.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:45:35):
Want to argue about that, Mr. Cole?
Lawyer 1 (10:45:37):
Yes, Your Honor. I think it applies because we could put up 100 witnesses, but if they believe one beyond a reasonable doubt, that's sufficient.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:45:48):
All right, I'll let you know. 1:32: 10, defendant's choice not to testify. I guess we'll
Judge Dean Bucci (10:46:03):
I guess we'll come back to that.
Mr. Steel (10:46:12):
Yes, sir.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:46:15):
1.32.16, any objection?
Mr. Steel (10:46:19):
I'm going to withdraw it. I know I challenged the statements, but at this point, and I understand the ruling, I'm not waiving, but we don't need a jury instruction on voluntariness and-
Judge Dean Bucci (10:46:33):
You want it out?
Mr. Steel (10:46:34):
Yeah.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:46:34):
Okay, so if you want that out.
Mr. Steel (10:46:37):
I would think all this comes out.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:46:38):
Okay. So that means 1.32.17 would come out. Yes, sir.
Mr. Cole (10:46:45):
Judge, I would have a problem with that, because we still have to show that any statement made by the defendant is voluntarily given, whether in custody or not. And I think the jury needs to be apprised of that. I'm not so sure you have to say the "in-custody statement" because I don't believe there were any statements that were entered while this defendant was actually in custody or under arrest. I do not believe there was one.
(10:47:13)
So that part does not apply, but it is still part of the state's duty to show that the statement was freely and voluntarily made. That's why when those statements were issued, that we made sure that the statement was freely and voluntarily given. I mean, just the other side of that coin is if you can bludgeon someone into a statement, and it comes in, that would not be right. So we have to show that it was freely and voluntarily made, and the jury needs to know that.
Mr. Steel (10:47:45):
I respectfully disagree because this is voluntariness. I'm not challenging voluntarily. I'm not saying that anybody bludgeoned Ms. Boles, and the jury instruction could, I'm not saying the jury would do this, but they could find that, "Oh, that wasn't a voluntary statement because she was under the stress of the situation," and then they ignore the entire statement. That's what the law is. I'm not asking for this. So if I did, I think I did ask her, but ... I don't know if I asked for it actually. I'd have to check my charges. But I don't want this to be given to the jury.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:48:22):
All right. So the defense doesn't want 1.32.16, 1.32.17, 1.32.18, stop me if I'm wrong, 1.32.19, 1.32.21, 1.32.40, 1.32.50, I guess. You want all that out?
Mr. Steel (10:48:42):
Yes.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:48:42):
And the State wants all that in?
Mr. Cole (10:48:46):
No, Your Honor. I do not believe that she was required to have her constitutional rights given to her. I don't think that was part of it, because that only applies if she's in custody.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:48:57):
All right. So 1.32-
Mr. Cole (10:48:58):
There has to be proof of voluntariness.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:49:01):
All right. So the State wants those ones I just mentioned, except for 1.32.21.
Mr. Cole (10:49:07):
Well, and I don't think 1.32.18, about a detention of the defendant would apply because she was never in detention. So I don't think that would apply.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:49:20):
So y'all agree on that one. Okay. So just to be clear, State wants 1.32. 16, 1.32.17, 1.32.19, right?
Mr. Cole (10:49:42):
Okay. So can you say those again, Your Honor?
Judge Dean Bucci (10:49:51):
Yes, sir. The state wants pattern charges 1.32.16, 1.32.17, 1.32.19, right so far? Okay.
Mr. Cole (10:50:04):
Yes, Your Honor.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:50:05):
But you don't want 1.32.21 and I'm not sure about the next two, if you want those, 1.32.40 and 1.32.50.
Mr. Cole (10:50:20):
I don't think 1.32.40 and 1.32.50 would [inaudible 10:50:30]-
Judge Dean Bucci (10:50:31):
Okay. All right. So I'll get you-
Mr. Cole (10:50:32):
... constitutional rights, because they were not required.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:50:35):
All right. So I'll get you a decision on 1.32.16, 1.32.17 and 1.32.19. Then I have 1.34.20. I guess there's been some evidence of prior difficulties between Ms. Boles and Mr. Akers. And I think-
Mr. Steel (10:51:17):
I don't think it applies. I agree that there's been free discussion about their marriage, and volatile I guess is the right word. But this is a limiting instruction that the evidence illustrates such matters. And what matters are we referring to? That they are volatile? I don't think we need that.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:51:49):
State wants it?
Mr. Cole (10:51:50):
Yes, Your Honor.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:51:54):
Well, I'm kind of inclined to give that, Mr. Steele. There was evidence of it.
Mr. Steel (10:51:59):
Okay.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:52:01):
And I think if I do give it, it's evidence of prior difficulties between, let's take out the first parenthetical there, or lack thereof, that would come out between the defendant and the alleged victim, and then take out "a witness", and do the same thing in the next part of the sentence. Take out witness. "The reasonableness of ..." I'm reading this parenthetical. "The reasonableness of any alleged fears by defendant or alleged victim." I don't know about that.
Mr. Steel (10:52:37):
I just don't know why we have it.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:52:40):
Yeah. I think that would come out. Okay. So I plan to give that 1.35.11, identification. Any problem there?
Mr. Steel (10:52:55):
No.
Mr. Cole (10:52:59):
No, Your Honor.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:53:02):
I think I can take out "or was a party to it", which is in that charge there.
Mr. Steel (10:53:11):
I don't think identification is part of the case. We're not saying Ms. Boles wasn't in the room, and called 911, and interviewed with the detective. So we're okay removing ... But if the State wants it, it's not harmful.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:53:24):
You want it?
Mr. Cole (10:53:25):
Yes, Your Honor. I believe we proved that in the burden.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:53:30):
Okay. All right. What about 1.37.10, character of the defendant?
Mr. Steel (10:53:35):
We have not put counter an issue as far as I'm concerned.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:53:37):
Can it come out? Yes.
Mr. Steel (10:53:39):
As far as I'm concerned, yes.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:53:40):
Okay. Then I'll give 1.40.10, but I'll take out where it says "or omission to act or criminal negligence".
Mr. Steel (10:53:52):
Okay.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:53:53):
Then I've got 1.41.10, intent. I will give that charge. That brings us to 2.10.10, malice murder, which we may have to adjust a little. Any suggestions?
Mr. Steel (10:54:13):
I would ask that the parentheticals on the third line, the second full paragraph, last line, we ask that the Honorable Court charge them off. So without justification, excuse, or mitigation.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:54:31):
Any argument from the State?
Mr. Cole (10:54:32):
Your Honor, I'm not sure how the evidence applies to the parentheticals in the first paragraph. I don't know that it was ever addressed that there was justification or excuse or mitigation.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:55:16):
All right. So the State wants all that out? I'm just asking.
Mr. Cole (10:55:33):
Yes, Your Honor.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:55:35):
Okay. And the defense wants those three in.
Mr. Steel (10:55:38):
Yes, sir.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:55:52):
I'll let you know.
Mr. Steel (10:55:52):
Okay.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:55:59):
2.10.12, any objection to motive?
Mr. Steel (10:56:02):
Yes, I would not like motive to be charged.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:56:06):
Any argument?
Mr. Cole (10:56:07):
I'm sorry. I didn't understand what the-
Mr. Steel (10:56:09):
I don't want motive to be charged. I know it's a pattern charge.
Mr. Cole (10:56:14):
Well, State wants it, obviously. State [inaudible 10:56:17].
Judge Dean Bucci (10:56:21):
All right. I think I'll give that.
Mr. Steel (10:56:23):
Okay.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:56:27):
2.10.20, any suggestions?
Mr. Steel (10:56:40):
It follows the indictment and the indictment's aggravated assault. I believe that the line should be aggravated assault, and I just want to make sure that I'm saying it right, so I'm fine with that.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:56:53):
With the indictment?
Mr. Steel (10:56:53):
I think I have it right here. I have it right here, Your Honor.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:56:53):
Okay.
Mr. Steel (10:56:53):
Thank you. [inaudible 10:57:23]?
Speaker 33 (10:56:53):
[inaudible 10:57:25].
Mr. Steel (10:57:26):
It's with a a deadly weapon, a revolver, by shooting Mr. Akers in the head. So I will get, I'm sure it's in here, the definition of agg assault. Okay. I just fill in the aggravated assault as a felony, and then we would like the causation. And again, it would be aggravated assault in the law.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:57:59):
All right. Any argument about 2.10.20? Mr. Steele wants me just to put agg assault in the blank, and then leave the rest, I think.
Mr. Cole (10:58:11):
No objection.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:58:14):
And then that brings us to 2.10.30, and that would be agg assault as well, right?
Mr. Steel (10:58:21):
Yes, sir.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:58:27):
And then we have a definition of aggravated assault at 2.20.21.
Mr. Steel (10:58:34):
And division two. I think that the Court removes the second parentheses, because it's charged. I just looked at it, it's with a deadly weapon.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:58:45):
Okay. And then we have a couple options in the immediately following paragraph as well.
Mr. Steel (10:58:53):
I think that the way it's charged, both of them apply the attempted to cause a violent injury to the person or committed an act that placed the person in reasonable apprehension and fear of receiving a bodily injury.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:59:05):
Okay.
Mr. Steel (10:59:05):
I think they both apply. If the State wants one of them, that's fine. Either one is fine.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:59:10):
All right. Any comment from the state?
Mr. Cole (10:59:15):
State's content.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:59:17):
Content. 2.20.21, I'll give that.
Mr. Steel (10:59:25):
I think that we remove, though, if I can go back to 2.20. 21?
Judge Dean Bucci (10:59:32):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (10:59:32):
The second paragraph, doesn't that need to be removed, since it was charged with a deadly weapon? And then just flips to a firearm when used in a way. A firearm is a deadly weapon. There's no reason to talk about an offensive weapon, I don't believe.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:59:46):
All right. So take out "an offensive weapon as an object," et cetera, et cetera, and then just go straight to 2.20.22?
Mr. Steel (10:59:53):
That's what I believe would be under the indictment, yes.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:59:57):
Okay. Any problem with that?
Mr. Cole (10:59:58):
No objection.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:59:59):
Okay. All right. 2.23.10, reckless conduct. What do y'all want to do?
Mr. Steel (11:00:08):
We'll withdraw, Your Honor. I believe I asked for that, so I would want it.
Judge Dean Bucci (11:00:16):
Okay. Then we have a charge for voluntary manslaughter, the pattern charge.
Mr. Steel (11:00:20):
I have to talk with Mr. Leo and Ms. Boles because she has not been consulted on whether she wants that lesser [inaudible 11:00:26].
Judge Dean Bucci (11:00:27):
I'll hold. Hold on that.
Mr. Steel (11:00:30):
Can you just give us time, Your Honor?
Judge Dean Bucci (11:00:32):
Sorry?
Mr. Steel (11:00:32):
Can you give us some time?
Judge Dean Bucci (11:00:33):
Of course. Yeah. So I'll hold on that.
Mr. Steel (11:00:37):
Same thing with the next one.
Judge Dean Bucci (11:00:44):
I'll hold on 2.10.44. We'll come back to it. And we have the same situation at 2.10.45?
Mr. Steel (11:00:49):
Yes. We've never discussed any of the lesser proof.
Judge Dean Bucci (11:00:49):
Okay. We have a charge on proximate cause at 1.41.60.
Mr. Steel (11:01:08):
Can we talk about that later too?
Judge Dean Bucci (11:01:10):
Sure.
Mr. Steel (11:01:10):
I think we better go over that.
Judge Dean Bucci (11:01:12):
Okay.
Mr. Steel (11:01:14):
Thank you.
Judge Dean Bucci (11:01:15):
Yes, sir. Next charge I have is 3.00.00, affirmative defense, burden of proof.
Mr. Steel (11:01:25):
We would like that. It's going to be accident.
Mr. Cole (11:01:29):
At this particular moment, I don't believe that's adjusted to the facts. I believe State will be objecting to it at this point.
Judge Dean Bucci (11:01:49):
All right. I'm not making a ruling. I'm just asking if the defense wants it on the second line to say what, justify, excuse, mitigate?
Mr. Steel (11:01:59):
Yes. We want all three of them because it's justification and accident.
Mr. Cole (11:02:06):
She has to admit that she committed the act, Your Honor. So I'm not so sure how want to do that.
Mr. Steel (11:02:13):
Well, it's not self-defense. It would be a defense of others. She's trying to help the man not kill himself.
Judge Dean Bucci (11:02:37):
I understand both of y'all's positions, and I'll look at some cases, and figure it out.
Mr. Steel (11:02:47):
And I'll look at it as well, Your Honor.
Judge Dean Bucci (11:02:48):
Okay.
Mr. Steel (11:02:48):
Or we will look at it.
Judge Dean Bucci (11:02:55):
3.01.10, justification generally.
Mr. Steel (11:02:57):
That's what we would ... We're going to look at that closely, if that's okay?
Judge Dean Bucci (11:02:58):
Okay.
Mr. Steel (11:02:58):
And then accident.
Judge Dean Bucci (11:03:12):
Okay. You want me to hold on justification generally?
Mr. Steel (11:03:15):
Yes. And then we would like accident, definitely.
Judge Dean Bucci (11:03:48):
That's a charge already got on accident?
Mr. Steel (11:03:56):
Yes. And it would just be an act, not failure to act.
Mr. Cole (11:03:57):
Your Honor, at this point, the State would contend that it doesn't apply to the facts that were presented to this jury.
Judge Dean Bucci (11:03:57):
Accident?
Mr. Cole (11:03:57):
Correct.
Judge Dean Bucci (11:04:03):
Okay. Let me back up a second. So 3.01.10, justification, Defense wants me to hold on that. Then 3.10.10, you don't want that. Justification in the use of force and defense.
Mr. Steel (11:04:24):
If we can hold on that, please.
Judge Dean Bucci (11:04:26):
Hold on that.
Mr. Cole (11:04:27):
He asked for those to be held, Your Honor.
Mr. Steel (11:04:28):
Yes.
Judge Dean Bucci (11:04:29):
Okay.
Mr. Steel (11:04:29):
If that's okay.
Judge Dean Bucci (11:04:29):
Yep.
Mr. Steel (11:04:29):
Accident would be definitely there.
Judge Dean Bucci (11:04:38):
Okay. 1.51.10, venue, I'll give that, and I think I'll take out "indicted" and just say "tried" in the first sentence. And I'm not sure why I would need to say "except as otherwise provided by law", right?
Mr. Steel (11:04:52):
That's fine.
Judge Dean Bucci (11:04:53):
So that can come out.
Mr. Steel (11:04:54):
No objection. I would ask, in the fourth line from the bottom, you have it say venue, then open parentheses. That is the, I would say supposed crime or alleged crime or indicted crime was committed in Collier County, rather than crime. Same thing, second line too says "in which the crime was committed." It should say "the alleged crime was committed".
Judge Dean Bucci (11:05:27):
Any argument?
Mr. Cole (11:05:29):
Your Honor, these are boilerplate languages charges, and the State would ask that the court follow the charge. If there's no crime, there will be no worry about it being here.
Judge Dean Bucci (11:05:38):
All right. I tend to agree with you, Mr. Cole. 1.60.10, verdict generally. We'll clean that up, and y'all will see it. I think Mr. Steele says he wants to talk to his client about 1.60.11, lesser offenses, so we'll hold on that. I'll give 1.70.10. I will give 1.70.11. Does anybody have any objection to reading that whole list of factors? Want any of them out? Any 1.70.11?
Mr. Steel (11:06:20):
I don't really object, but I don't think many of them apply, but whatever the Court-
Judge Dean Bucci (11:06:27):
Any thought on that, Mr. Cole?
Mr. Cole (11:06:36):
Your Honor, the danger is when you start eliminating them, you never know what the jury may be picking up on that we are not picking up on. And so I'm kind of afraid to-
Judge Dean Bucci (11:06:49):
You want them all.
Mr. Cole (11:06:49):
... eliminate any of these ones.
Judge Dean Bucci (11:06:49):
Good. All right.
Mr. Steel (11:06:53):
Mr. Leo said we probably don't need the corporate.
Mr. Cole (11:06:57):
I will agree with Mr. Leo that, corporate status would not apply.
Judge Dean Bucci (11:07:03):
All right.
Mr. Steel (11:07:04):
I rest my case.
Mr. Cole (11:07:04):
Me too.
Judge Dean Bucci (11:07:08):
All right. 1.70.20, I'll give that. 1.70.30, I'll do that. 1.70.40, I will give. 1.70.50, I'll do that. And 1.70.60, I'll give that, and we'll have some more time next week to address this again.
Mr. Steel (11:07:36):
Thank you, sir. We will talk about it, Mr. Boles and myself.
Judge Dean Bucci (11:07:43):
Okay. Anything else before we split?
Mr. Cole (11:07:47):
Nothing by the State, Your Honor.
Mr. Steel (11:07:50):
I don't think so. And we will have all witnesses here, to just roll throughout the [inaudible 11:07:56].
Judge Dean Bucci (11:07:58):
Okay. We'll see y'all 8:30, Monday morning. Enjoy the rest of your week.
Mr. Steel (11:08:02):
Thank you, Your Honor. [inaudible 11:08:06].
Speaker 34 (11:08:02):
It'll be locked up. Don't leave anything in here.
Speaker 35 (11:08:02):
[inaudible 11:08:12].