Live Weekly Demo | Led by a Rev Workflow Specialist
Save Your Spot
FL v. Dwain Hall Day 2

FL v. Dwain Hall Day 2

Dwain Hall stands trial for the alleged murder of Sonia Exelby, day two. Read the transcript here.

Dwain Hall stands trial for the alleged murder of Sonia Exelby, day two.
Hungry For More?

Luckily for you, we deliver. Subscribe to our blog today.

Thank You for Subscribing!

A confirmation email is on it’s way to your inbox.

Share this post

Copyright Disclaimer

Under Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing.

Courtroom (00:00):

[inaudible 00:01:41]

Judge (02:20):

All right, lawyers, we're going to get the juror notebooks handed out then. We'll go ahead and bring them in.

Speaker 1 (05:34):

Yes, sir.

Courtroom (05:34):

[inaudible 00:05:34]

Judge (05:34):

Ladies and gentlemen, welcome back. Everyone go ahead and be seated. Thank you.

(05:37)
All right, jurors, yesterday when we broke for the day, I instructed all of you to not communicate about the case with any person or allow any person to communicate with you about the case. I also instructed all of you to not use the social media, your cell phone, or other electronic device to attempt to learn about the case or find out information about the case. I also instructed all of you to avoid social media, streaming, and YouTube services, and things of that nature. Have all of you been able to follow those instructions? If so, nod your head in the affirmative. Okay. For the benefit of the record, have you been able to follow those instructions, ma'am?

Juror (06:08):

Yes, sir.

Judge (06:08):

Okay. All the jurors have nodded their head in the affirmative or answered out loud, so thank you.

(06:13)
Members of the jury, we're going to go ahead and resume the trial. Mr. Buxman, if you can go ahead and start the video.

Mr. Buxman (06:21):

Yes, Your Honor. For the record, I'm beginning the video. I backed up about 30 seconds beginning at 1:15:54.

Judge (06:27):

Okay. Thank you, sir. Yes, sir.

Video Dwayne (06:27):

[inaudible 00:06:27].

Video Interviewer 1 (06:27):

Now you said that the Saturday night, so I guess the third time that you went to the building, that there was some sort of disturbance and you thought that maybe it involved the woman that you had picked up from the airport. Can you tell me more about that?

Video Dwayne (07:01):

There's not much to tell. It was just some screaming and yelling, and it was just really suspicious in hindsight after getting a phone call [inaudible 00:07:10] for a service call. Then all of a sudden there's this fight on the property where there's not supposed to be anybody to fight.

Video Interviewer 1 (07:27):

So you were at that property with the cars while you got the call?

Video Dwayne (07:27):

Yeah.

Video Interviewer 1 (07:27):

From the person? The woman that wanted help?

Video Dwayne (07:27):

Fuck yeah, I guess. Yeah.

Video Interviewer 2 (07:40):

The exit 364, when you mentioned exit 364 earlier, you got a phone call.

Video Dwayne (07:45):

Yeah.

Video Interviewer 2 (07:54):

Okay. So you were on that property, a big barn with all the cars lined up, taking [inaudible 00:08:01].

Video Dwayne (08:00):

I was outside the building itself.

Video Interviewer 2 (08:00):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (08:00):

That's the only place I had anything concerning anything was signal.

Video Interviewer 2 (08:00):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (08:00):

Because I was already done inside and we was waiting for him to come back from there.

Video Interviewer 1 (08:01):

Okay.

Video Interviewer 2 (08:01):

But then how were you talking to your wife though?

Video Dwayne (08:09):

Like I said, I got out there and got away from the building where I had virtually no signal. [inaudible 00:08:17].

Video Interviewer 2 (08:09):

Oh, okay.

Video Dwayne (08:19):

Okay? It wasn't registering. The GPS was shut down. Everything was shut down. I couldn't get anything to fucking pull up. I was like, "It probably ain't going to go through." Saw I got a bunch of calls from the wife real quick. [inaudible 00:08:32] I want to talk to my wife. Then that happened and I told her about that. I'm not sure if she could hear it in the background or not because it was a very bad connection.

(08:43)
But I hung up real quick after that and hid my phone again. [inaudible 00:08:50].

Video Interviewer 2 (08:43):

Stuck it down my pants, man.

Video Dwayne (08:53):

But basically, I mean, for all intent and purposes, stuck it back down the pants and pull the shirt back over so you can't tell it's there. I didn't want to lose the money on what ended up being the last night. Then there was some screaming and yelling going on too, and then I got really freaked the fuck out. That's about the same time I called my wife.

Video Interviewer 1 (09:12):

Okay. Can you tell me about the voices?

Video Dwayne (09:17):

I believe it was written on the script. I was supposed to wear hearing aids, I think. I was supposed to wear hearing aids and they've been broke since the beginning of the month. I have been [inaudible 00:09:28] fixed. As you can tell, I'm not carrying anything right now.

Video Interviewer 2 (09:36):

The payment for $1, 200?

Video Dwayne (09:37):

Yeah.

Video Interviewer 2 (09:39):

You said you described him reading the card number to you. What name did you put on there?

Video Dwayne (09:43):

We don't require a name.

Video Interviewer 2 (09:45):

It doesn't? Okay. Because I thought it required a name on the-

Video Dwayne (09:47):

This is the way this processing works.

Video Interviewer 2 (09:49):

Yeah.

Video Dwayne (09:49):

Card number, expiration date, associated zip code.

Video Interviewer 2 (09:54):

Okay. That's all it takes? Okay.

Video Dwayne (09:56):

Now I have the option to put a bunch of other shit in there if it's told to me.

Video Interviewer 2 (09:58):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (10:01):

[inaudible 00:10:01] shit.

Video Interviewer 1 (10:02):

So he read it off to you? Did you see him over the phone?

Video Dwayne (10:08):

I never seen him again after Friday.

Video Interviewer 1 (10:11):

Okay. So you saw him initially Friday night, but you did not see him Saturday afternoon or Saturday night?

Video Dwayne (10:16):

No [inaudible 00:10:17].

Video Interviewer 1 (10:17):

Okay. So when did he call you to pay you for the car?

Video Dwayne (10:28):

It was after the big blow up. It was after the big blow up. The driver popped back up shortly, about five minutes after it started getting a little bit quiet, dropped him back off. Then I got a phone call from him telling me about the other car hauler won't make it on time, and she paid me.

Video Interviewer 2 (10:52):

That was all when you were at that house or whatever, [inaudible 00:10:57]

Video Dwayne (10:56):

[inaudible 00:10:58]

Video Interviewer 2 (11:01):

Okay. Then what happened after that? You mentioned earlier [inaudible 00:11:04] saying that, "I even told you you could stay the night or something."

Video Dwayne (11:06):

Went back out the next morning. Did everything like I was supposed to do, got my shit and got. When I left, after a little bit, I noticed there was a weird car following me.

Video Interviewer 2 (11:19):

Oh, yeah. Okay. So is that what you were talking about before when that car was following you? Okay.

Video Dwayne (11:27):

Yeah. So like I said, when you put all that shit together, I had no way to fucking prove any of this until I was asked directly. I don't want to say anything the fuck about it because I don't know what the fuck is going on. I don't want any fucking part of it. Literally, I don't want any part of this either. But if it helps you find a missing person or something like that or whatever the fuck this is all about. Sorry, the car accident fucking [inaudible 00:11:55].

Video Interviewer 2 (11:54):

You're fine. Would a blanket help, to sit on a blanket or something?

Video Dwayne (11:58):

No.

Video Interviewer 2 (11:58):

A little more cushion?

Video Dwayne (11:58):

No.

Video Interviewer 2 (12:05):

Okay.

Video Interviewer 1 (12:05):

Some water or anything like that?

Video Dwayne (12:06):

I would appreciate some fucking water. I really would because I'm getting really bad headache from being stressed and then my back's hurting on this side so fucking bad.

Video Interviewer 2 (12:12):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (12:16):

But yeah, I don't know. Any other questions or anything? Anything I can help you with? Are we done with this shit? I mean-

Video Interviewer 2 (12:21):

I'm going to grab you a water. I don't know if you have any more questions.

Video Dwayne (12:26):

Like I said, I'm doing my best to be as cooperative as possible, guys.

Video Interviewer 1 (12:28):

So when Calvin talked with you, he told you that we were trying to look for a missing person?

Video Dwayne (12:42):

Yeah, he told me he was looking for a missing person and that I was not, I don't know, a suspect or suspected. I don't fucking know now.

Video Interviewer 1 (12:53):

Okay. So you described the person that you picked up at the airport and I have a picture.

Video Dwayne (12:54):

Yeah. You do? Show me.

Video Interviewer 1 (12:54):

I am hoping that maybe you can tell me that's who it was.

Video Dwayne (12:54):

That is who it was.

Video Interviewer 1 (12:54):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (12:54):

I don't need my glasses to know.

Video Interviewer 1 (12:54):

You don't even need your glasses.

Video Dwayne (13:06):

I mean, the face is kind of fucked up, but yeah, that's the dress.

Video Interviewer 1 (13:09):

That's the dress?

Video Dwayne (13:09):

That's the dress. The [inaudible 00:13:13]

Video Interviewer 1 (13:09):

Okay. The legs, like you said?

Video Dwayne (13:09):

Yeah.

Video Interviewer 1 (13:09):

Are you sure? You want to look at the legs again? Is that good? Okay.

Video Dwayne (13:23):

I don't [inaudible 00:13:19], now I'm just absolutely fucking disgusted. I don't even like ... Seriously though. Yeah, that's her.

Video Interviewer 1 (13:26):

That's her? Okay. So this-

Video Dwayne (13:32):

If you had a picture, fuck, a long time ago, I could have told you. "Oh my God, fuck. Yeah, that's her."

Video Interviewer 1 (13:33):

Yeah, we recently got this, but it's also one of those things where we have to make sure that we're talking about the right person because we don't want to accidentally think that we're looking for the wrong person. So once you started to describe her, I was like, "Okay, I think we're [inaudible 00:13:46]."

Video Dwayne (13:46):

[inaudible 00:13:46] I could have saved you, "Yeah, that's her. I dropped her off from there and then took her ..."

Video Interviewer 1 (13:46):

Well, you were talking about cars and you were really excited about talking about cars, so I didn't want to-

Video Dwayne (13:54):

I like cars. I like cars. No, that's it. That's her, huh? Oh my God. She was in my fucking vehicle.

Video Interviewer 1 (14:06):

So let's talk about that. So you picked her up from the airport.

Video Dwayne (14:11):

Picked her up from the airport.

Video Interviewer 1 (14:12):

You said that she was, I think you called her a prude. You tried to engage her in conversation. She didn't want to talk. That's quite a bit of a drive, right? From the airport to that place on, what was it you said?

Video Dwayne (14:23):

It was. It was. 122nd.

Video Interviewer 1 (14:23):

122nd.

Video Dwayne (14:29):

Or something like that.

Video Interviewer 1 (14:30):

Right. Tell me more about that drive.

Video Dwayne (14:30):

It was quiet. I was listening to music.

Video Interviewer 1 (14:30):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (14:30):

I had Spotify on. I just, fucking don't want to talk to me, I don't want to talk to you anyway. Fuck you.

Video Interviewer 1 (14:30):

No, no, I hear that.

Video Dwayne (14:45):

I'm here to do a job. I don't give a shit about myself at this point anyway. I have a wife and I ain't interested in other women in any fucking way.

Video Interviewer 1 (14:51):

Yeah. So very little conversation. Did she know where you were driving to?

Video Dwayne (15:06):

This seemed really prearranged.

Video Interviewer 1 (15:10):

Okay. So you had the address ahead of time or she gave you the address?

Video Dwayne (15:15):

I had the address.

Video Interviewer 1 (15:16):

Okay. So there was no discussion about, "Hey, we're driving to this address." You were told to pick her up?

Video Dwayne (15:41):

This seemed super prearranged and it was planned. Me and wife bumped heads about it. The thing is is what [inaudible 00:15:39], what if they do this every year? What if this [inaudible 00:15:43]? What if he does find some small company that is some sort of company that does mechanical [inaudible 00:15:57] what if he really does that? What if that's real? What if there's a different person that goes missing every year that is related to that? Because that's fucked up. That's fucked up.

(16:11)
Then there was a big thing, and then the phone call about money, and this, that, and the other. When you start connecting dots like me and her did, what if this some kind of underground fucking thing where they get unsuspecting people, especially like Calvin told me she was suicidal anyway? What if she signed up for something and they predator these young women or men that are suicidal like that and then just they vanish?

Video Interviewer 1 (16:51):

Yeah, that's interesting.

Video Dwayne (16:52):

I mean, I've heard worse shit. I mean, especially since he name-dropped, it's really weird that he name-dropped shit like this and they make me sign [inaudible 00:17:06], but he name-dropped that he was storing vehicles with [inaudible 00:17:12], Terry Belay, the [inaudible 00:17:12], and Tom Cruise. What if it's some kind of fucked up Scientology bullshit behind the scenes and going and working on cars, which is a cover story?

Video Interviewer 1 (17:24):

To get you involved.

Video Dwayne (17:27):

Yeah. What am I going to do? I'm nobody. I don't have corporate lawyers. I have nothing. What if I'm just being played as a patsy, scapegoat? Who they going to look for? Seriously, who are you going to look for? You going to look for some Iranian looking guy, some Middle Eastern guy with big, white, fucking teeth, with a really big, fucking creepy smile? That describes half the fucking people on [inaudible 00:17:57].

Video Interviewer 1 (17:55):

I'm not from here. [inaudible 00:17:59].

Video Dwayne (18:00):

I mean, let's be reasonable.

Video Interviewer 1 (18:02):

Yeah. So you mentioned that you were told that she was suicidal and that maybe there was something that was prearranged?

Video Dwayne (18:13):

Calvin.

Video Interviewer 1 (18:13):

Told you. Right. Calvin told you that she was suicidal.

Video Dwayne (18:13):

Me and my wife were talking about this and it seemed really weird because she didn't question anything. She didn't talk to the help. Didn't question about where I was driving, nothing. Got out, walked up, gave a hug, bounced in his fucking big ass car.

Video Interviewer 1 (18:29):

This was Harold that ...

Video Dwayne (18:29):

Harold.

Video Interviewer 1 (18:29):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (18:29):

Well, I don't think that's a real name either. Me and the wife been wondering if that's a real name.

Video Interviewer 1 (18:42):

Okay. Do you know her name? Did she introduce or did Harold tell you her name?

Video Dwayne (18:48):

Client.

Video Interviewer 1 (18:48):

Client? Okay.

Video Dwayne (18:48):

To pick up a client that wanted to buy a car.

Video Interviewer 1 (18:56):

Oh, so he said client that's going to buy a car.

Video Dwayne (18:58):

Mm-hmm. That's why she had to be picked up and didn't have her own car, didn't rent a rental or anything, because she was going to be there to buy a car.

Video Interviewer 1 (19:05):

Okay. Okay. So to talk a little bit about these transactions, so the transactions that you're talking about, we were able to look into them and show that there were transactions that were declined, like you said.

Video Dwayne (19:28):

Yeah. Yeah, that's the only reason why I know about anything about any of this I remember is I had two conversations with Calvin, and I've been able to do some thinking, put some shit together, talk to the wife, bumpy heads a little bit and see what we come up with. But yeah, so about some transactions.

Video Interviewer 1 (19:44):

Try to piece it together.

Video Dwayne (19:44):

Yeah.

Video Interviewer 1 (19:45):

So that was accurate about the car being run multiple times?

Video Dwayne (19:55):

Yeah. Oh, yeah. The car was ran multiple times for varying miles, and it's declined every time. Then once we started getting down into the lower numbers, there was ... "I swear there's money in the car. Swear, swear, swear. Be quiet, just do as I told you to."

Video Interviewer 1 (20:05):

Okay. So did she have to read it off to you each time?

Video Dwayne (20:17):

Yeah.

Video Interviewer 1 (20:17):

Or does it store it? I don't know if there's a process for this.

Video Dwayne (20:23):

No, no, no. No. You had to go in and change everything. I had to basically cancel off on amount to the new amount. It's a big pain in the fucking ass.

Video Interviewer 1 (20:30):

Yeah, I bet it is. Yeah.

Video Dwayne (20:33):

It's for security though. Okay. It's a pain in the ass, but I'd rather have it be secure like that than not because if it's not, then anybody can just, if they have my phone, do whatever the fuck they want.

Video Interviewer 1 (20:43):

Yeah. Sure. It makes sense.

Video Dwayne (20:43):

I try to run a legit business.

Video Interviewer 1 (20:43):

Yeah. It seems like it. I read your Yelp reviews. You're right. You have good Yelp reviews. I believe you're very helpful.

Video Dwayne (20:43):

I'm knowledgeable about what I fucking do.

Video Interviewer 1 (20:44):

Yeah. That's big in this world, especially in that with mechanics because I feel like that's a dying profession.

Video Dwayne (21:10):

The other thing is, and not just that, not only do you have to be good at what you do, but you have to be super, super trustworthy. That's why I got upset again. I'm getting upset about it again because now my name's going to spread with this fucking shit. I've tried so hard to fucking be a trustworthy individual. Who wants somebody, if this was to get out in the wrong light, who wants somebody like me to show up to help their college-aged daughter after that? It's going to cripple my business. Then thinking about it from the perspective that I just explained to you about this seems like a setup, that'd be easy to fucking do. They just ruined my business and they ruined my credibility.

Video Interviewer 1 (21:58):

Then be gone.

Video Dwayne (22:01):

Then be gone. Just bang, [inaudible 00:22:01], gone. Nothing.

Video Interviewer 1 (22:02):

Yeah. Well, the good thing is, I know you were saying that a lot of this digital footprint, as you call it, is gone, but we were able to verify the transactions that you were talking about, which is good.

Video Dwayne (22:16):

Which is not, I mean, to be clear, that would not be stored on my phone. That would be stored with-

Video Interviewer 1 (22:25):

The company.

Video Dwayne (22:25):

Yeah. With the process card reader company or however you say that. But on my phone, yes, it's gone. It doesn't save declined transactions on my phone. It only saves successful transactions.

Video Interviewer 1 (22:40):

Well, we were able to verify exactly what you told us, and then we were also able to verify the $1,200 transaction that you talked about.

Video Dwayne (22:52):

Now you're going to tell me that you verified that and it came back to her too.

Video Interviewer 2 (22:57):

Why would you say that?

Video Interviewer 1 (22:57):

What makes you think that?

Video Dwayne (22:58):

Why would you bring up that you verified the $1,200 transaction, not the other transactions that were there?

Video Interviewer 1 (23:03):

Because those were the transactions that happened around the time that you said that she [inaudible 00:23:08].

Video Dwayne (23:06):

Okay. All right.

Video Interviewer 1 (23:06):

So that would be why-

Video Dwayne (23:06):

Okay. Well, still. [inaudible 00:23:15]

Video Interviewer 1 (23:06):

[inaudible 00:23:15] I feel like you should be sitting in this chair. So you are-

Video Dwayne (23:06):

I'm too smart for my anger sometimes

Video Interviewer 1 (23:06):

Yeah?

Video Dwayne (23:06):

But yeah, am I right though?

Video Interviewer 1 (23:24):

Yep.

Video Dwayne (23:24):

I'm a bitch. I need the money. I already spent it and I can't pay it back.

Video Interviewer 1 (23:31):

I'm sure you spent it on things that were important because you're taking care of your wife. So can you help me explain how that happened, what you think, how that happened? Because you said you felt like you were pretty set up.

Video Dwayne (23:53):

In hindsight, you got to remember this is all in hindsight. Okay? When I talked to my wife about it, she has a very calming effect on me and allows my brain to function properly. Okay? Mostly because we've been together for over 20 years. People pretty much know each other's ins and outs and she knows exactly what to say to make me stop and think.

(24:06)
Because all on the same night, this all happens in the same night. I get a call, a bunch of declined transactions. There's a big fucking blow up on the fucking property. All of a sudden my contract is finished. "Here's the payment." If I was going to do something like that with somebody, that's exactly what I'd do. I'd use this other person's card to pay the money that I fucking promised, and now they're not looking in my direction. I didn't have to spend any of my own money. Nobody's looking my way. Nobody knows who I am. I'm gone. The bitch is gone. Sorry. But-

Video Interviewer 1 (24:49):

Did you say bitch is gone?

Video Dwayne (24:50):

Yeah.

Video Interviewer 1 (24:53):

The one that was rude to you?

Video Dwayne (24:55):

Yeah.

Video Interviewer 1 (24:59):

I want to make sure we're talking about the same person.

Video Dwayne (25:01):

Yeah, yeah, yeah.

Video Interviewer 1 (25:01):

That's from the picture.

Video Dwayne (25:01):

Yeah, Yeah.

Video Interviewer 1 (25:01):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (25:01):

Yeah.

Video Interviewer 1 (25:01):

I want to make sure because I didn't know if you were talking about Harold because he put you in this mess.

Video Dwayne (25:04):

Well, he's an asshole, but I'm sure he won't get what's coming to him. People who have a lot of money never fucking get it. Grain of salt. Grain of salt. Okay. But anyway, so in my mind, as soon as you said you verified 1,200 too, I just knew because it's too much of a coincidence. I could not [inaudible 00:25:25].

Video Interviewer 1 (25:31):

Your transactions were, yeah, [inaudible 00:25:32] right in a row. Yeah. So that $1,200 transaction was in between those other declined transactions, one declined transactions.

Video Dwayne (25:44):

See, again, that timeline doesn't make any fucking sense. Like I said, when I looked at that, when I looked at when that paid, it showed an afternoon, not afternoon. I don't know how the fuck it got [inaudible 00:26:40] the afternoon. I don't know how the timestamp became an afternoon timestamp.

Video Interviewer 1 (26:40):

For which one?

Video Dwayne (26:40):

For the 1,200.

Video Interviewer 1 (26:40):

For the 1,200.

Video Dwayne (26:40):

Yeah.

Video Interviewer 1 (26:40):

So the 1,200, you're saying that the declined transactions, what time did those happen?

Video Dwayne (26:40):

I want to say around nine, 10 o'clock. I don't know. I'd have to look at my phone.

Video Interviewer 1 (26:40):

Then the transaction that went through?

Video Dwayne (26:40):

Was 11 to 12.

Video Interviewer 1 (26:40):

At night?

Video Dwayne (26:40):

At night.

Video Interviewer 1 (26:40):

Okay. So it was after the declined transactions, but it was in the evening, not the afternoon.

Video Dwayne (26:40):

That's right.

Video Interviewer 1 (26:40):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (26:42):

Which is why I said I don't know how the timestamp on that changed. I don't know how that was affected. I don't know what the fuck, because that was the first thing to keep me off of that because after I talked to Calvin the second time, when I got home and finally got my thing to work, I went through to the paid transactions or the closed transactions, and I looked, and sure enough, there was that $1,200 transaction that said 1:09 PM or, yeah, PM.

Video Interviewer 1 (27:11):

So that was said on your end, that transaction?

Video Dwayne (27:20):

Uh-huh. Yep. It said that on my end.

Video Interviewer 1 (27:20):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (27:20):

So I don't know how the fuck that happened.

Video Interviewer 1 (27:20):

Okay. Man, I don't know how that ...

Video Dwayne (27:21):

How did you get in there and fucking change that? How did that timestamp fucking change that day? Fuck me. That makes absolutely zero sense.

Video Interviewer 1 (27:36):

How that happened.

Video Dwayne (27:36):

That was at night.

Video Interviewer 1 (27:36):

Yeah.

Video Dwayne (27:36):

I don't get it. It was at night. That's one of the things that cued me off about it too. I'm looking at that, it's like that, and then all of a sudden we've got this PM instead of AM payment or at least too early of PM. At the very least it should have been like 11, 11 to nine maybe. Have you seen that? But on my end, that transaction posted at 1:09 PM, that's an afternoon. That's not ...

Video Interviewer 1 (28:11):

Yeah.

Video Dwayne (28:11):

It's not when the job is done.

Video Interviewer 1 (28:13):

But you did do a job. You did get paid for it. The money did-

Video Dwayne (28:16):

$1,200 I got paid and yeah.

Video Interviewer 1 (28:20):

How does that work when it goes through that?

Video Dwayne (28:21):

Just deposits on the business account.

Video Interviewer 1 (28:26):

Okay. So do they take a fee out or it just goes straight into it?

Video Dwayne (28:30):

No, I have a really good card processing company. I do have to pay them once a month for $25.

Video Interviewer 1 (28:35):

That's not bad.

Video Dwayne (28:35):

It's not bad.

Video Interviewer 1 (28:36):

Because usually it's a percentage.

Video Dwayne (28:41):

Yeah. I basically, like I said, really good card for your company. I did my homework and I set this business up, and I've done everything I could possibly do to have a very positive, secure, reputable fucking company and do something that I'm passionate about.

Video Interviewer 1 (28:54):

Okay. So some of the other things that I want to talk to you about is we were able to ... Part of when we have a missing person is we try to find them. We try to figure out where they may be. The UK provided us locations within the state of Florida that she may be staying at. So we sent people out to look to see if she had stayed at those locations. One of the reasons why we were asking about the location that you said that you stayed at and what it looked like was because that was one of the locations that she stayed at.

Video Dwayne (29:49):

No wonder she didn't ask questions.

Video Interviewer 1 (29:49):

So tell me about that.

Video Dwayne (29:50):

Well, what is there to tell you about?

Video Interviewer 1 (29:56):

What do you mean she didn't ask questions?

Video Dwayne (29:58):

When she got in the car and told me to shut the fuck up, no wonder she didn't ask questions.

Video Interviewer 1 (30:13):

Oh, okay. So she is the one that rented that Airbnb. So her information is attached to that Airbnb.

Video Dwayne (30:16):

This sounds more and more like I'm getting set the fuck up and I am not liking it at all, but it's-

Video Interviewer 1 (30:23):

Well, so far you're giving us [inaudible 00:30:26]

Video Dwayne (30:26):

It's like what me and my wife came up with is just being so accurate. I'm really hating all of it right now because I can't prove the other side of this. Any digital footprint that I have is missing. What am I supposed to do with that? How am I supposed to make you guys believe my part of the thing in this when everything looks like I had something to do with this right now?

Video Interviewer 1 (30:54):

Well, what it comes down to is the reason why I'm sitting across from you right now is that we have a family that is looking for their family member.

Video Dwayne (31:08):

Of course, it would be the same way if it was me.

Video Interviewer 1 (31:08):

So that's what this is about. This isn't about trying to get you or trying to get you set up.

Video Dwayne (31:14):

When you come and you search my vehicle, and you pull me over on the side of the fucking highway to confiscate my vehicle, that makes me feel ... That makes me feel like there's more to this than meets the eye. Okay? Then with what me and the wife were talking about, how the timeline kind of slides together, and what it looks like from mine and her perspective.

Video Interviewer 1 (31:38):

I think though that you can understand why we're sitting across from you and why we've got to ask.

Video Dwayne (31:38):

Yeah, yeah, yeah. You have to ask these questions and-

Video Interviewer 1 (31:38):

I want to be able to go back to the family and say-

Video Dwayne (31:53):

I'm being as cooperative as I possibly can now and I'm trying to give you as much pertinent information.

Video Interviewer 2 (31:59):

So Dwayne, you said a couple of things, okay? You said your phone's in the car. You said that you want to be as helpful and cooperative as possible.

Video Dwayne (32:08):

Yeah.

Video Interviewer 2 (32:08):

Would you allow us to dump your phone, to do a phone extraction of the whole phone? We can try to find these things that maybe, because a lot of times when we do a ...

Judge (32:24):

For the benefit of the record, I've had the State pause the recording. Mr. Peters, are you falling asleep?

Mr. Peters (32:30):

No. My neck hurts.

Judge (32:34):

Okay. All right. I saw you with your head back, eyes were closed, but you leaned forward. I just wanted to make sure. I understand that sometimes when watching media in a dark room, folks can get tired. We're going to go ahead and resume the video. Does anybody need a break? Any of you jurors need a break? Okay. If any of you at any point in time feel that you need a break, just get my attention and we can take a break. If you feel like you need to stand ...

Speaker 2 (33:00):

... just get my attention, and we can take a break. If you feel like you need to stand up, at any point in time, to stay awake, just do that in a quiet way. If you're in the front room, just be mindful you got folks behind you. We'll probably move to look around, and watch the video here. Everybody stay alert. If you feel like you're tired ,and you need a break simply to keep paying attention. Again, let me know. We can take a break, get you all coffee. We're under no time constraint to get this done here this morning, okay? §

(33:29)
It's more important that you all pay attention. Okay? All right. I will make a finding for the record that Mr. [inaudible 00:33:38].

Video: Speaker 2 (33:45):

... lies. Sometimes we can find things that people delete. So people delete text messages and things get deleted. But if you're retained on the phone, on the hard drive, it's just that the space is reallocated to empty space. So you don't see that it's deleted. You see that it's deleted, but it's still on there. Would you be willing to do that?

Video Dwayne (34:04):

Well, I mean, I don't really see a problem with it, but I don't really-

Video: Speaker 2 (34:08):

Okay. I'm just asking.

Video Dwayne (34:08):

I don't really like it.

Video: Speaker 2 (34:08):

Because I just.

Video Dwayne (34:14):

If I say no, what are you going to do? You're going to turn around, you're going to get a warrant. You're going to go take a look any fucking way.

Video: Speaker 2 (34:20):

I'm just asking because you mentioned you want to be helpful. You're saying this-

Video Dwayne (34:23):

I do want to be helpful.

Video: Speaker 2 (34:25):

I know. And let me finish though. You're saying stuff is vanished from your phone, so I want to try to get to the bottom of that if that's-

Video Dwayne (34:31):

[inaudible 00:34:30] what you want. What do you want? What do you want? If you want something specific, I have no fucking problem with it. If you want to dump my call logs and you want to dump my text feeds and you want to dump my emails, I might not have a problem with that.

Video: Speaker 2 (34:49):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (34:54):

But the rest of my stuff, that's my personal shit. [inaudible 00:34:56]. Okay? [inaudible 00:34:56] my porn.

Video Interviewer 1 (34:55):

[inaudible 00:34:56].

Video Dwayne (34:55):

Who's looking at porn, man?

Video: Speaker 2 (34:55):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (34:55):

But fucking, and-

Video Interviewer 1 (34:59):

[inaudible 00:35:00] ask, is it porn that you made or is it porn that you just look at it?

Video Dwayne (35:11):

It ain't nothing that you want to see.

Video Interviewer 1 (35:12):

I'm just saying because is the wife going to be in these videos?

Video Dwayne (35:12):

Yeah. You know what I'm saying? You're okay. But a little bit, I want to share [inaudible 00:35:22].

Video: Speaker 2 (35:24):

But you do some weird stuff?

Video Dwayne (35:26):

Well, what do you think? If I don't want you to say it, then probably just [inaudible 00:35:31].

Video: Speaker 2 (35:34):

Why do you think I'm asking? I interview a lot of different people, so-

Video Dwayne (35:35):

[inaudible 00:35:36].

Video: Speaker 2 (35:38):

You can tell me [inaudible 00:35:39] I'm sure.

Video Dwayne (35:41):

Heard and/or seen about all of it. I'm not a big fan fucking with my phone and I'm going to be very fucking honest with you. I'm just not.

Video: Speaker 2 (35:48):

I just wanted to ask.

Video Dwayne (35:50):

But at the same time, if I seriously thought there was anything there that would actually be helpful to you in any way, shape or form, if it comes down to it that I have to try to prove my innocence somehow, some perceived crime, something like that, if you don't mind, we can approach it then.

Video: Speaker 2 (36:12):

Okay. If in the meantime we decided to get a search warrant, what would the password be to get into your phone? Because right now it's in the car, so right now-

Video Dwayne (36:20):

Do you already have a search warrant for my phone?

Video: Speaker 2 (36:23):

We have a search warrant for some preliminary information in your phone, yes. To help with the initial statements, because obviously there's a fraud that's involved in all this. So with some of the preliminary information you had provided to Calvin when you talked [inaudible 00:36:40]-

Video Dwayne (36:39):

Are you talking about your preliminary for my fucking partner stuff, right?

Video Interviewer 1 (36:39):

Yes. [inaudible 00:36:45].

Video Dwayne (36:39):

[inaudible 00:36:44].

Video Interviewer 1 (36:39):

Because of the financials.

Video: Speaker 2 (36:55):

Yeah. And then that's what-

Video Dwayne (36:55):

I was [inaudible 00:36:56].

Video: Speaker 2 (36:56):

Obviously that's why I'm asking though. If you wanted to do the whole thing, then we would do the whole thing. But obviously we have what we have and we get more, I'd love to get more to try to corroborate what you're telling me. But if you don't want to, I don't want you to because it's your right to have this.

Video Dwayne (37:07):

I feel like that we're in a very fine line at this point where I'm not going to say the dirty words or anything at this moment, but at the same time I feel like that's right up against that line.

Video: Speaker 2 (37:19):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (37:22):

I'm sorry.

Video: Speaker 2 (37:22):

[inaudible 00:37:23].

Video Dwayne (37:24):

But like I said, if for any reason going forward that we think that anything in my call log or my text log, I would not have a problem with that per se.

Video: Speaker 2 (37:36):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (37:37):

Okay? Calls and texts, I don't have a problem with. You can check that shit all day. I don't care. But the rest of my phone, I feel like that's right on that line.

Video: Speaker 2 (37:46):

Understood. Yes, sir. Understood.

Video Dwayne (37:49):

And while I don't really approve, but in the interest of some other things, as long as you limit your search to said call logs and said text logs, password's [inaudible 00:38:01].

Video: Speaker 2 (38:01):

Okay. Any capital or lowercase or anything?

Video Dwayne (38:06):

Doesn't matter how you put it in there.

Video: Speaker 2 (38:08):

Doesn't matter how? Okay.

Video Dwayne (38:09):

Just put it in there and it'll pop right up for you.

Video: Speaker 2 (38:10):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (38:17):

Okay. But like I said, I can't be more adamant about the fact that it's limited to just call log and text log.

Video: Speaker 2 (38:19):

Okay. Call log, text log.

Video Dwayne (38:19):

Okay?

Video: Speaker 2 (38:19):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (38:22):

Everything else though, I feel like I have a reasonable expectation of privacy on, civil right or whatever the hell that is. And that's when we might have to get something a little more [inaudible 00:38:34] conversation involved.

Video: Speaker 2 (38:34):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (38:35):

I don't want to do that because I want to be helpful.

Video: Speaker 2 (38:37):

Yes, sir.

Video Dwayne (38:38):

I don't want to have to deal with a dumb ass trying to tell me what to say or not to say. But at the same time, if you feel like my call logs, my text logs are helpful, be my guess guys.

Video: Speaker 2 (38:50):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (38:51):

But everything else is completely off the table unless we have to go about it more.

Video: Speaker 2 (38:55):

Okay. Okay?

Video Dwayne (38:57):

Okay. But yeah, sir. So like I said...

Video: Speaker 2 (39:08):

I don't really have anything I can really add to help you out.

‍

Video Interviewer 1 (39:11):

Well, so we were talking about checking locations. So there were multiple locations that were provided to us then. Ultimately, the location that you're talking about matches up. So we did go out there and we did find out that our missing person who you've identified in this picture, that she is the one that-

Video Dwayne (39:33):

You're telling me she's the one paid for it.

Video Interviewer 1 (39:37):

She's the one who paid for it and had the [inaudible 00:39:39]-

Video Dwayne (39:40):

And she's in my theory so fucking hard that somebody's trying to set me up for a long ride to nowhere.

Video Interviewer 1 (39:48):

So was she ever there at any point? Did she ever go in at any point, spend any time there?

Video Dwayne (40:00):

She was not there at the same time I was.

Video Interviewer 1 (40:00):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (40:03):

Okay? When I was there, I was there, period.

Video Interviewer 1 (40:06):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (40:08):

She was never there when I was there. Okay. So if she was inside there or something like that, it would line up to the same thing me and wife were already thinking about in regards to that.

Video Interviewer 1 (40:22):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (40:22):

Like I already said, if somebody wanted to fuck with me really fucking hard to get away with something that they're into that they do annually or even that day.

Video: Speaker 2 (40:29):

When you say you and the wife, what you were thinking, what do you mean by that? What were you and your wife thinking?

Video Dwayne (40:29):

This is what I was telling her. We weren't in here, [inaudible 00:40:33].

Video: Speaker 2 (40:29):

Oh no, I might have missed that.

Video Dwayne (40:33):

Me and my wife was thinking that what if this guy, especially since he name dropped people like Tom Cruise and John Travolta, people like that. And these are people that are typically mixed up with Scientology and they're into some weird fucking shit, man. What if they prey on suicidal people and they pick a single target every year? And then if they really do how I got involved in this, we pick a company that knows what they're doing every year and have them service our show vehicles. What if that's just a cover? What if that's just to have a scapegoat? Think about it. They paid me with a card that wasn't theirs, so it didn't come out of their money. Made me leave my phone behind so I couldn't have the actual GPS track to where the actual building was. Went so far, just found out that the woman is the one that paid for the B&B. They paid for nothing. They had no footprint whatsoever. And then the digital footprint came from my phone from them. So where else do you guys get to look? And this is what we were joking about. It looks like everybody else in Ocala, right? But where you going to look at where else you look, you can only look at me and I only have so many answers to you.

Video Interviewer 1 (42:21):

So it's possible that she wasn't physically at that Airbnb because there were times that you weren't there, but you two were never there at the same time?

Video Dwayne (42:38):

At the same time. No, not at the same time. I don't think that's why, but it would make sense that that's why that it was so tightly scheduled too. I was at the same time every night. Now, I go fast. I know a hell I'm doing. I'm good at what I do, so it don't take me very long to get shit done. I can do two cars an hour, you know what I mean?

Video: Speaker 2 (43:08):

Let me ask you this. When you were staying in the Airbnb, which you described living room, kitchen combination, and then you said something about a hallway, a bedroom, a bathroom, and then a bedroom and a bathroom or something?

Video Dwayne (43:20):

Yeah.

Video: Speaker 2 (43:20):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (43:20):

Yeah, basically.

Video: Speaker 2 (43:23):

What part of the house did you stay in?

Video Dwayne (43:28):

[inaudible 00:43:29].

Video: Speaker 2 (43:28):

Well, I mean, what bedroom did you stay in?

Video Dwayne (43:29):

I tried the little beds [inaudible 00:43:30] uncomfortable because my back hurts.

Video: Speaker 2 (43:35):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (43:36):

All my door locks. I got them all, okay? But I ain't going to play. I got them all. I didn't like the little beds.

Video: Speaker 2 (43:37):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (43:40):

But yeah, so we're going to pretend this is the front porch and the sliding door. And you come in and you have this little half bar right here. You had the fridge, stove, I think stove right here, the sink. Okay. And then you had the center bar there and then you come down, you had a little bedroom here with a little half bath here. And then in the back you had full bedroom and then right outside that you had full master bathroom.

Video: Speaker 2 (44:20):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (44:20):

So that's the way I put it.

Video: Speaker 2 (44:20):

So what was the bed you tried to stay in first and then what?

Video Dwayne (44:20):

The little tiny one.

Video: Speaker 2 (44:20):

The little tiny one?

Video Dwayne (44:20):

The half bath.

Video: Speaker 2 (44:20):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (44:21):

I didn't like that at all.

Video: Speaker 2 (44:22):

And then when you slept in the back room, I'm assuming, or did you sleep on the couch or something?

Video Dwayne (44:26):

I slept in the back room.

Video: Speaker 2 (44:27):

Okay. When you would wake up in the morning-

Video Dwayne (44:31):

This side. This side of the bed.

Video: Speaker 2 (44:31):

So if you're facing the-

Video Dwayne (44:31):

Facing the bed.

Video: Speaker 2 (44:31):

Left side.

Video Dwayne (44:31):

I slept on the sofa.

Video: Speaker 2 (44:39):

Okay. Tell me about your routine when you wake up in the morning.

Video Dwayne (44:43):

What's your routine when you wake up in the morning?

Video: Speaker 2 (44:47):

I get up, brush my teeth, make my bed.

Video Dwayne (44:48):

I didn't make my bed. It wasn't my bed. [inaudible 00:44:49].

Video: Speaker 2 (44:48):

[inaudible 00:44:49]. You tell me about what you do when you wake up.

Video Dwayne (44:49):

It's almost the same thing as yours. I got up, brushed my teeth, took whatever the heck else I was going to do, got ready for my day to start and that's it.

Video: Speaker 2 (45:03):

Okay. And you [inaudible 00:45:05]?

Video Dwayne (45:03):

Okay. I did take a shower.

Video: Speaker 2 (45:10):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (45:10):

I was only there for long to take one shower, but I took a shower.

Video: Speaker 2 (45:34):

Okay.

Video Interviewer 1 (45:34):

Did they prearrange the time they were going to pick you up so you knew or how did you...

Video Dwayne (45:34):

Mm-hmm.

Video: Speaker 2 (45:34):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (45:34):

Yeah. Yeah. It was pre-arranged every day.

Video Interviewer 1 (45:34):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (45:34):

I was usually out of there by 10, 11 o'clock in the morning, usually. I drive into town Saturday and get something to eat. Stuff to eat time to eat, which I'm fine with.

Video Interviewer 1 (45:34):

Where did you go?

Video Dwayne (45:34):

I don't know.

Video Interviewer 1 (45:34):

Do you remember what you ate?

Video Dwayne (45:34):

I went to the truck stop. I put the Wendy's down there, but I think it's 364.

Video Interviewer 1 (45:34):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (45:34):

364, 268, something like that.

Video Interviewer 1 (45:34):

So did you eat at the Wendy's then or no?

Video Dwayne (45:34):

[inaudible 00:45:58].

Video Interviewer 1 (45:34):

A spicy chicken sandwich.

Video Dwayne (45:58):

I just went in and got something at the truck stop.

Video Interviewer 1 (46:06):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (46:07):

I stopped at Dollar General, [inaudible 00:46:07] so I got some junk food there and did a couple of eights and went on down to the truck stop and then came back and then when I parked and went and they were already there waiting for me and pissed off.

Video Interviewer 1 (46:37):

So they were already at the Airbnb?

Video Dwayne (46:38):

Yeah.

Video: Speaker 2 (46:43):

And then when you came back to the Airbnb-

Video Dwayne (46:48):

That was the same day that all shit went fucking crazy. That was Saturday.

Video: Speaker 2 (46:48):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (46:50):

The accident day the shit went absolutely batshit crazy.

Video: Speaker 2 (46:55):

Okay. And when you came back to the Airbnb, how was the condition? Was it the same way you left it generally? Anything you remember that was different or out of place?

Video Dwayne (47:13):

I didn't pay too much attention to no shit like that. I was there to do the job.

Video: Speaker 2 (47:14):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (47:18):

This is just my job for doing the whole thing.

Video Interviewer 1 (47:27):

You mentioned at the very beginning you basically got ready and left and did what you needed to do. Were you talking about checkout instruction type things, like cleaning up before you left the Airbnb?

Video Dwayne (47:34):

Oh yeah, yeah.

Video Interviewer 1 (47:40):

Tell me about that.

Video Dwayne (47:40):

Take out trash.

Video Interviewer 1 (47:42):

Okay. Were there specific instructions?

Video Dwayne (47:45):

Yeah, take up trash, put the towels on the floor that we used, I think is what they said.

Video Interviewer 1 (47:51):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (47:55):

Turn off hot water heater.

Video Interviewer 1 (48:04):

Okay. Was there a book or how did you get those instructions?

Video Dwayne (48:04):

I was told.

Video Interviewer 1 (48:05):

You were told?

Video Dwayne (48:08):

I was told when I dropped off when I got paid, right?

Video Interviewer 1 (48:08):

On Saturday.

Video Dwayne (48:11):

When I dropped off the contract, they told me, "Well, okay, get out of there by X time. Do this."

Video Interviewer 1 (48:20):

Okay. They told you what to do?

Video Dwayne (48:27):

Yeah.

Video Interviewer 1 (48:42):

And do you know about what time you left there? I feel like you told us, but I don't remember.

Video Dwayne (48:43):

I got early in the morning, maybe around eight or nine, something like that. Eight or nine.

Video Interviewer 1 (48:46):

Okay. And you put the trash out. Was there anything else? You said towels on the floor, trash out?

Video Dwayne (48:50):

Yeah.

Video Interviewer 1 (48:51):

Was there anything else? Don't remember?

Video Dwayne (48:54):

No.

Video Interviewer 1 (48:54):

Just your standard, like if you're staying at a place?

Video Dwayne (48:57):

Mm-hmm.

Video Interviewer 1 (48:58):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (48:59):

Pick up after yourself [inaudible 00:49:01].

Video Interviewer 1 (49:07):

Okay. So I spoke with the Airbnb owner about... Because again, when we visited, he was out of town and when he got back in town, I asked him if we could take a look because again, we were trying to find our missing person and the Airbnb hadn't been cleaned, so we were able to get the trash and things like that out of the Airbnb. We were looking for anything that would tell us that our missing person was there, right?

Video Dwayne (49:49):

Mm-hmm. Yeah.

Video Interviewer 1 (49:52):

And we found some receipts and some food that was thrown out, and the food that was thrown out matches up with what you were saying you went to go get some food. The receipts go to Walmart that was in Gainesville. Do you know anything about those receipts?

Video Dwayne (50:13):

[inaudible 00:50:12] Gainesville. What was on it?

Video Interviewer 1 (50:15):

There were some, I think a paracord and maybe some deodorant and bug spray.

Video Dwayne (50:21):

Bug spray.

Video Interviewer 1 (50:21):

I think bug spray or some sort of aerosol spray and deodorant.

Video Dwayne (50:31):

Yeah, that would've been my purchase.

Video Interviewer 1 (50:38):

Okay. So that was your receipt?

Video Dwayne (50:39):

Yeah, that was my receipt.

Video Interviewer 1 (50:39):

Okay. Do you remember purchasing those?

Video Dwayne (50:43):

Yeah, absolutely. It was a paracord that I used for something else and ended up destroying that. I had something that I was planning on going with that this week related to spring compression, the coil springs. I didn't want to buy an actual tool. Paracord is cheaper.

Video Interviewer 1 (51:06):

Oh, okay.

Video Dwayne (51:06):

So what you did is you take and basically make your leap and with the jack underneath that with the compressors you can make loop, tie it around, do that, cut it up, put it in different places.

Video Interviewer 1 (51:15):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (51:15):

And then you pull out strut or whatever and replace the strut.

Video Interviewer 1 (51:22):

Okay. So that, and then there was...

Video Dwayne (51:24):

It was spray for my wife's gun.

Video Interviewer 1 (51:27):

For what?

Video Dwayne (51:27):

My wife's gun, which was in the car.

Video Interviewer 1 (51:30):

Oh.

Video Dwayne (51:30):

Yeah, and you'll find the sprays in there too and deodorant. And there's a different type of cord there that was on there. You'll find that unopened pack in the back seat too.

Video Interviewer 1 (51:39):

Okay. In the car?

Video Dwayne (51:39):

Mm-hmm.

Video Interviewer 1 (51:39):

Okay. So-

Video: Speaker 2 (51:39):

What else did you buy?

Video Dwayne (51:53):

[inaudible 00:51:51] at Walmart. I'm always buying shit.

Video Interviewer 1 (51:57):

So we found a second receipt that was used at Walmart for another item?

Video Dwayne (52:01):

Shovel.

Video Interviewer 1 (52:01):

Yep.

Video Dwayne (52:01):

Shovel?

Video Interviewer 1 (52:01):

Yeah. Tell me about that.

Video Dwayne (52:09):

I've been looking for a small shovel because sometimes you get on the side of the highway out here and you make flat spot for your jack.

Video Interviewer 1 (52:19):

Oh, if you're changing a tire?

Video Dwayne (52:29):

Mm-hmm.

Video Interviewer 1 (52:29):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (52:29):

And it's too big. And it's too big. So it ended up being [inaudible 00:52:29] back there. I took it out.

Video Interviewer 1 (52:29):

Okay.

Video: Speaker 2 (52:31):

Where's it now?

Video Dwayne (52:32):

In the garage.

Video: Speaker 2 (52:32):

In your garage?

Video Dwayne (52:32):

Mm-hmm.

Video: Speaker 2 (52:32):

Okay.

Video Interviewer 1 (52:34):

And you said that you were going to use the paracord?

Video Dwayne (52:41):

Mm-hmm.

Video: Speaker 2 (52:41):

[inaudible 00:52:42].

Video Dwayne (52:43):

[inaudible 00:52:42] set right by the garage door there with the back bumper. I'm not even playing. That's where it's sitting. But yeah, I did use paracord. We cut it all up already.

Video Interviewer 1 (52:52):

Okay. I thought you said you were going to use it, but you used it for something else?

Video Dwayne (52:58):

No.

Video Interviewer 1 (52:58):

I misunderstood.

Video Dwayne (53:00):

There was the other cord. There was a white cord.

Video Interviewer 1 (53:01):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (53:02):

We were going to use that, but I found the paracord instead.

Video Interviewer 1 (53:05):

Okay. So you had a white cord that you were-

Video Dwayne (53:13):

It's still there in the back of the truck, still in its original bag.

Video Interviewer 1 (53:15):

Okay. And you bought that at Walmart, the white cord?

Video Dwayne (53:19):

Yeah.

Video Interviewer 1 (53:19):

Okay. But then you bought paracord. I guess I completely misunderstood what you told me. Can you please-

Video Dwayne (53:25):

Yeah. Okay.

Video Interviewer 1 (53:25):

[inaudible 00:53:26].

Video Dwayne (53:28):

Paracord doesn't stretch. It doesn't stretch as much. It's more of a resilient tighter bind cord.

Video Interviewer 1 (53:33):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (53:34):

Okay? Found the other white cord. I went ahead and got that in any fucking way because I've always needed it for something or maybe I was going to have to tie the bumper up. I hadn't taken the bumper off yet, so I went ahead and got that anyway. If I remember that. But whatever the reason was, I bought it anyway, knowing that I probably need to take it on. And it was going to get cut up eventually anyhow. And just like the paracord, you take the paracord and tie it around after you use the jack to compress the coil spring that are on the struts. You take it and you tie it. Stay there. So when you drop the jack down, the spring doesn't really expand and you can pull the strut out.

Video Interviewer 1 (54:15):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (54:15):

And it gets all cut up when you do that.

Video Interviewer 1 (54:22):

Okay. So you did use that paracord for that?

Video Dwayne (54:22):

Yeah, I used it.

Video Interviewer 1 (54:27):

What vehicle was that used on?

Video Dwayne (54:27):

If I had my phone I'd be able to tell you.

Video Interviewer 1 (54:27):

Okay. So you used that one?

Video Dwayne (54:37):

It was a repair that if you already looked at the pelvic thing, it was in relation to the $35 cost that I did.

Video Interviewer 1 (54:44):

Okay. Do you keep those on hand because it's something you regularly use or how did you know that you needed it?

Video Dwayne (54:51):

We don't. I just happened to be in the market for it. And I was out there and I was looking around. I already knew that my vehicle thing, I might have to put the bumper back on. I might want to tie it back up to the collision center because they might've wanted me to put it back on. I wasn't sure. I don't deal with the insurance company or the company, the lady that hit me. I didn't know what they would want. And there were cracks developing on the other bumper, like the welds over here you can see where the baseplate, the anchor plate, the welds completely shattered. On the other side, a big crack developed down the other weld and I pulled it off, but I was going to have to put it back on and drive it over there, but I didn't. And then I had to call for...

(55:35)
I don't even know what the hell it was now, but it turned into a little bit of a maintenance thing that they asked me for help with. So I went ahead and did that. I had paracord already, made it nice and easy.

Video Interviewer 1 (56:01):

Okay. And so you used that paracord on that vehicle on Tuesday?

Video Dwayne (56:04):

Yeah. It might have been Tuesday. I don't know. Like I said, I'd have to look at my receipts for whatever these things were paid, but it was either Sunday, Monday or Tuesday. I don't fucking know what I have to work. It's just another fucking day. I had not too long ago. I showed up to do a tire change and the woman was telling me, "Oh, it's banging claiming everywhere." I picked it up and the whole tire is going this before I broke it loose. Well, before I took it off, I got underneath there and here one of the bolts and sub frames coming out. So I sat there for an extra hour putting the bolt back in the subframe. I had paracord, it would've made it easier [inaudible 00:56:37].

Video Interviewer 1 (56:36):

Seems like you should buy more of those.

Video Dwayne (56:36):

Yeah. I'm sure that's going to be a future purchase as long as I'm-

Video Interviewer 1 (56:36):

Seems like it could be helpful in a variety of ways.

Video Dwayne (56:50):

Yeah. Yeah. It's just utility cord to me. It's just something that occasionally I keep around.

Video Interviewer 1 (56:53):

Yeah. Okay. And do you remember when you made those purchases?

Video Dwayne (56:56):

It was either Thursday or Friday.

Video Interviewer 1 (57:03):

Okay. If I were to tell you that I got a copy of the receipt, I wasn't one that was out there. I asked for a copy of the receipt and it showed that it was Friday at about 5:45 PM.

Video Dwayne (57:22):

That wouldn't surprise me.

Video Interviewer 1 (57:22):

That wouldn't surprise you?

Video Dwayne (57:25):

Surprise me not because I was out on that in town anyway. I was right out there. I had a service call out there too, and I was like, "Ah, I need some shit from here. I need deodorant." It all started with deodorant, guys.

Video Interviewer 1 (57:37):

It's important, especially with what you do.

Video Dwayne (57:42):

Well, I knew that I was going to be gone all weekend and I ran out of deodorant earlier that morning.

Video Interviewer 1 (57:46):

So just so we know, we're talking about the same Walmart. Which Walmart was it?

Video Dwayne (57:55):

If I'm not mistaken, probably Waldo Road.

Video Interviewer 1 (57:55):

Waldo Road.

Video Dwayne (57:55):

Yeah.

Video Interviewer 1 (57:55):

Oh, 441-

Video Dwayne (57:55):

That's at Gainesville.

Video Interviewer 1 (58:03):

Yeah, this is Gainesville.

Video Dwayne (58:04):

Yeah, it's probably Waldo Road. 441 Gainesville.

Video Interviewer 1 (58:04):

So that would be... Waldo Road's different. So what was around it? Was there a Popeye's around it?

Video Dwayne (58:10):

I can' [inaudible 00:58:11].

Video Interviewer 1 (58:13):

You don't know? Okay.

Video Dwayne (58:13):

I don't know that many details. I just know I was out on that end of town, and that's why I went ahead and stopped. I was like, "Oh, how fortuitous? I needed this anyway."

Video Interviewer 1 (58:21):

Yeah. Okay. So you went there, and then that would've been about an hour before you went to the airport, if that's accurate.

Video Dwayne (58:38):

[inaudible 00:58:38]. Something like that.

Video Interviewer 1 (58:38):

Does that ring a bell? Does that sound-

Video Dwayne (58:39):

Something like that, but I know after I got out of there and before I actually left the area to where my job was going to be, I got contacted and asked to pick up a client at the airport. And I was like, " [inaudible 00:58:45] what they were fucking going to work out here?"

Video Interviewer 1 (58:46):

[inaudible 00:58:47].

Video Dwayne (58:47):

15 minutes away or whatever, something like that from the airport.

Video Interviewer 1 (58:49):

Okay. And you may have said it, and I may just not remember it. Where did you park at the airport?

Video Dwayne (58:59):

Down in the overflow parking. I didn't ask.

Video Interviewer 1 (59:04):

I didn't? That's what I said. I can't remember.

Video Dwayne (59:04):

No, you didn't ask. [inaudible 00:59:05] I parked out away from everything by myself. I was by a light post.

Video Interviewer 1 (59:12):

Okay. So a lot has changed with that airport over the past year?

Video Dwayne (59:15):

[inaudible 00:59:16].

Video Interviewer 1 (59:16):

Is the overflow, is that grass?

Video Dwayne (59:23):

[inaudible 00:59:23] the overflow, yeah.

Video Interviewer 1 (59:23):

Okay. Grass. Okay.

Video Dwayne (59:23):

Grass gravel.

Video Interviewer 1 (59:23):

So it's the overflow parking and then you just... How did you know?

Video Dwayne (59:32):

I didn't know. I was told what time the flight arrived.

Video Interviewer 1 (59:32):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (59:33):

And that they would know my vehicle. That's what I was told.

Video Interviewer 1 (59:36):

So that's right. So you said when you saw a plane coming in, it's around the time that you were told-

Video Dwayne (59:43):

I gave it a little bit. I got a little impatient because I was wanting to go get fucking shit done, sign the NDA and get to work. [inaudible 00:59:48]-

Video Interviewer 1 (59:47):

Get that money.

Video Dwayne (59:47):

Get that money. You damn right. And I drove around. I know as soon as I saw that came in, I waited for the taxi all the way back to fuck up and get up to the gate. And then I went out and I slow crawled through the front of the terminal and there wasn't nobody coming out. There was people going in, there weren't people coming out. So I slow crawled two, three times probably.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:00:17):

Until she came out?

Video Dwayne (01:00:18):

Mm-hmm.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:00:19):

And then you said you didn't recognize her. She recognized you?

Video Dwayne (01:00:23):

Yeah, she saw the vehicle and walked right up to it.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:00:23):

Okay. And then...

Video Dwayne (01:00:27):

I pulled over. Basically I seen a bulk of people starting to come out. You can't park, cannot park. You pick people up and drop people off. You cannot park. So I pulled over and I stopped and I waited and I seen that grass and it lined up to my vehicle and got it.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:00:43):

Okay. And then when you tried to engage her in conversation-

Video Dwayne (01:00:44):

Try to fuck up, I don't fucking help.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:00:56):

Okay. So we were discussing Calvin calling you and talking to you about this missing person and that she was suicidal, and you were talking about how you and your wife were just talking about what was going on and what could be happening. And one of the theories is that this-

Video Dwayne (01:01:18):

[inaudible 01:01:21].

Video Interviewer 1 (01:01:21):

Your theory, yes, is that this guy Harold may have set up, this could have been a vulnerable person who was suicidal because Calvin told you that she was suicidal and that this may have been a setup to where he was preying on this suicidal person.

Video Dwayne (01:01:39):

That's what me and her was thinking because it seems the timeline's too [inaudible 01:01:46].

Video Interviewer 1 (01:01:46):

Yeah.

Video Dwayne (01:01:47):

It's too [inaudible 01:01:48] and then, the digital footprint. [inaudible 01:01:50]-

Video Interviewer 1 (01:01:51):

Yeah.

Video: Speaker 2 (01:01:53):

When you say prey on, what do you mean by that?

Video Dwayne (01:01:54):

Well, just what it sounds like. "Oh, don't kill yourself. Just come over here. I'll take care of you." And then it turned into something worse.

Video: Speaker 2 (01:02:16):

Okay. Why do you say that? I've never heard of that. "If you're going to kill yourself, come over here, I'll take care of it." What do you mean by that?

Video Dwayne (01:02:23):

Dude's got money. My money can fix anything mentally. And why not? Why not? I mean, timeline is too [inaudible 01:02:34]. It's just too [inaudible 01:02:34]. It's too close together. It's too coincidental. It just kind of...

Video: Speaker 2 (01:02:43):

How would the money fix...

Video Dwayne (01:02:47):

I'll take care of you. You don't have to want for anything.

Video: Speaker 2 (01:02:56):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (01:02:56):

And you wouldn't try that.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:02:56):

So-

Video Dwayne (01:03:05):

Babe, if you find I'm [inaudible 01:03:05].

Video Interviewer 1 (01:03:05):

Well, that's what I was going to say. If that's something that somebody wants to do, what are your thoughts on that?

Video Dwayne (01:03:08):

Some people aren't strong enough to fucking get it done.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:03:13):

And so if someone were to help him with that, they're just helping them do something that they want to have done?

Video Dwayne (01:03:22):

Who knows? Who fucking knows, man? That's what I'm saying. At the end of the day, it's the only thing that really makes sense if this woman really wanted to disappear, she can't compel the fucking country. So she really wanted to do what makes me think she really just wanted to disappear. Maybe she's suicidal, maybe she's going to pretend to be suicidal. Maybe she though this rich guy could give her a new start and whatever. And it turned into something [inaudible 01:03:52] because like I said, there's the decline payments. There was the big blow up, the shouting match, and then there's all of a sudden my contract is finished, my truck didn't show up. And get a couple days out away from that and get some clarity on it and you're like, oh God.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:04:13):

Yeah. And then we call you and then it makes you [inaudible 01:04:17]-

Video Dwayne (01:04:16):

[inaudible 01:04:17]. And then now I'm here and my truck's getting torn apart. Who knows where.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:04:21):

Yeah. So what are your thoughts though if somebody is like, "This is what I want to have happen. I don't want to do it myself. I want somebody to help me with that." What are your thoughts about that?

Video Dwayne (01:04:36):

What am I supposed to think about that?

Video Interviewer 1 (01:04:40):

Well, some people have feelings about that, like, no, you shouldn't help the person. And other people are like, if you're making a decision that you want to make.

Video Dwayne (01:04:52):

[inaudible 01:04:49] working in was helping people with that shit. And they were old people and they were terminally old people and stuff like that. So it's just not a black and white answer.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:04:56):

Right. There's lots of countries where it's okay to help somebody do that.

Video Dwayne (01:05:03):

Yeah, I'm sure there are. But at the same time, if that's the case, then why the fuck didn't she go there?

Video Interviewer 1 (01:05:07):

Yeah.

Video Dwayne (01:05:19):

She had to have been promised something here. So I don't really have a straight answer for you on that. I just don't. My feelings are conflicted on that.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:05:25):

Yes. It's a complicated issue. I guess it's-

Video Dwayne (01:05:36):

Yeah. [inaudible 01:05:37]. It's not black and white.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:05:36):

Yeah. So I've been speaking with people who know her and know things about her, and we know that she was communicating with people over here and had the intention of coming over here to end her life. And we know that was what-

Video Interviewer 1 (01:06:00):

And we know that that was what this trip was about. So we also know that you were one of the people that were communicating with her.

Video Dwayne (01:06:15):

What was her screen name?

Video Interviewer 1 (01:06:21):

What does that matter?

Video Dwayne (01:06:21):

I communicate with a lot of people.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:06:28):

Okay. Do you communicate with a lot of people about suicidal ideations?

Video Dwayne (01:06:33):

I communicate, I used to.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:06:35):

Used to.

Video Dwayne (01:06:37):

Used to communicate with a lot of people that it was porn site.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:06:39):

Mm-hmm.

Video Dwayne (01:06:41):

And there was a lot of fantasy role play that had it there. But if you tell me her screen name, maybe I'll have a better idea what you're talking about.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:06:48):

Which porn sites?

Video Dwayne (01:06:51):

Motherless.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:06:51):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (01:06:56):

Yeah.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:06:56):

So you communicated with her on Motherless?

Video Dwayne (01:06:56):

I don't know, but if you're saying that I communicated with her, there's a good possibility that's where it was. And if you tell me which one it was, then if you tell me the screen name, I'll be able to confirm and deny.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:07:12):

Okay. I'd like to talk more about the conversations that you have on Motherless and if you communicate-

Video Dwayne (01:07:25):

It was months ago. I lost my account there.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:07:25):

Okay. That's hard to do.

Video Dwayne (01:07:25):

No, it's not.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:07:26):

Really not on Motherless? I've been on Motherless, so I mean pretty much to me everything's fair game.

Video Dwayne (01:07:28):

You would think, right? I don't even know why. I always get banned for terms of service violation.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:07:33):

Huh.

Video Dwayne (01:07:35):

I tried three different times and it's like, I didn't even do anything. Why am I getting banned? This guy's over here blatantly posting pictures about this and he's not banned?

Video Interviewer 1 (01:07:48):

I know, that makes sense. So I've been in those chats and sometimes you can do it through location, trying to match up with people's location, but a lot of times it's matching up with people that are like-minded and having those discussions. And so what got you banned, whether fair or not?

Video Dwayne (01:08:05):

I don't know.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:08:06):

So what kind of stuff did you like to talk about on Motherless? And you're not going to shock me because like I said, I've been on Motherless.

Video Dwayne (01:08:09):

Well, let's see. On hard bondage.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:08:20):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (01:08:20):

I like hard bondage.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:08:25):

Okay. You think that's what got you?

Video Dwayne (01:08:26):

That's not what got me banned.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:08:26):

I was like, there's no way you got banned-

Video Dwayne (01:08:31):

I don't know. It seems like somebody took offense to something I might have said on a comment or something like that. Comment on pictures, or post, or have a conversation in live feeds or whatever, not live feeds, but comment feeds or whatever. I think something there might have gotten banned because there's certain words that you're not allowed to use, and that list seems to be ever-growing by the month. But like I said, I haven't been on it for a long time.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:08:58):

What are the words?

Video Dwayne (01:09:01):

Basically anything violent. Anything violent or aggressive, too aggressive.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:09:12):

Like snuff type stuff?

Video Dwayne (01:09:15):

Between snuff type stuff, and rape, and other sorts of violent stuff like that.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:09:19):

There are rape fantasies and as long as people are good with it then that's-

Video Dwayne (01:09:25):

But it doesn't matter. At the end of the day, it's essentially what I got the feel for of it. It seems more like it's more like Facebook where anybody can see your comment and then they can get [inaudible 01:09:35]-

Video Interviewer 1 (01:09:35):

And they report it.

Video Dwayne (01:09:37):

And then report it. And then [inaudible 01:09:38] because you used the forbidden word, that's why I think happened.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:09:42):

Okay. Again, there's tons of people out there that have rape fantasies, men and women, and I've seen that talked about on Motherless, incest, all sorts of things.

Video Dwayne (01:09:53):

All kinds of disgusting crap, but some of it's not so disgusting, but a lot.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:09:55):

Well, I don't necessarily consider it disgusting.

Video Dwayne (01:09:59):

Yeah, it's disgusting. When you get into certain aspects of it, it gets a little bit more out of my wheelhouse.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:10:06):

Well, what's disgusting to you may not be disgusting to me, right? What's disgusting to me may not be disgusting to you. It's all in preference and Motherless is full of people with preferences.

Video Dwayne (01:10:15):

Yep, it absolutely is.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:10:15):

Yeah.

Video Dwayne (01:10:17):

I enjoyed it while I was there.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:10:19):

You don't think you can get back on?

Video Dwayne (01:10:20):

I can't get back on. I ain't going to go through all that hassle and make a new profile, and make new emails and every kind of thing else. I ain't got time for that.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:10:29):

Once you get banned, it's not hard to get back on.

Video Dwayne (01:10:29):

How do I know that?

Video Interviewer 1 (01:10:35):

Because I've been banned from it.

Video Dwayne (01:10:37):

Very well. But like I said, I ain't trying to go.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:10:42):

So what type of things... You think you may know what got you banned. I know they don't tell you, they just banned you. You go in to log in and you can't log in, your shit disappears.

Video Dwayne (01:10:51):

Terms of service violation.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:10:55):

What kind of conversations were you having at the time that you got banned?

Video Dwayne (01:11:08):

I don't know.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:11:10):

Well, we talked about rape fantasies.

Video Dwayne (01:11:14):

That's not necessarily something that I talked about, but every once in a while I'd get in on with the group of them. They'd just be talking back and forth in the comments or whatever.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:11:30):

So bondage kind of plays into that.

Video Dwayne (01:11:30):

Yeah.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:11:30):

So is that your-

Video Dwayne (01:11:31):

I would throw a little bit into that that way, that's for sure.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:11:31):

Yeah, okay. So is that primarily what you would... You were trying to find people that were into bondage, rape fantasies?

Video Dwayne (01:11:44):

Not necessarily. [inaudible 01:11:47] Well, it's okay on paper.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:11:44):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (01:11:44):

[Inaudible 01:11:53]-

Video Interviewer 1 (01:11:54):

But is it really rape if it's consensual? On the outset like, "Hey, we're going to play this role." [inaudible 01:12:01]

Video Dwayne (01:12:10):

Yeah, [inaudible 01:12:11] why do they want to stop and you don't know if they actually want to stop [inaudible 01:12:18]?

Video Interviewer 1 (01:12:17):

Safe word.

Video Dwayne (01:12:17):

No.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:12:17):

No safe word?

Video Dwayne (01:12:17):

See, that's the problem. That's the problem with that kind of play.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:12:17):

Yeah.

Video Dwayne (01:12:17):

I'm okay with safe word and whatnot.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:12:17):

You are okay with safe words? So that's what I'm saying.

Video Dwayne (01:12:17):

That's just bondage. That's just rough play. That's not the [inaudible 01:12:19] rape.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:12:19):

So you're saying kind of beyond the role playing of rape, these are people that actually do want to rape, and then the person is consenting to it but not really consenting to it, because they don't have the ability to go, "I don't want to do this anymore."

Video Dwayne (01:12:36):

That's right.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:12:38):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (01:12:38):

I'm not into that in any way, shape, or form. I may occasionally have the violent ideations or whatever.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:12:45):

Mm-hmm.

Video Dwayne (01:12:46):

But at the same time it's better left on paper.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:12:53):

Yeah. No, I hear you. And there's a lot of people that leave it on paper. So what type of violent ideations?

Video Dwayne (01:12:58):

Don't feel comfortable discussing that with you.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:13:02):

Would you feel comfortable discussing it with him? [inaudible 01:13:04].

Video Dwayne (01:13:02):

I do not.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:13:05):

Is that part of the privacy that you want to keep with your phone? Is that what... Okay, good enough.

Video Dwayne (01:13:09):

[inaudible 01:13:14] it's just part of privacy.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:13:09):

So the reason why I'm having this-

Judge (01:13:21):

All right ladies and gentlemen, we're going to go ahead and we're going to pause the video. I think it's about two hours and 21 minutes and 18 seconds on the timestamp. So what we'll do, we have about two hours left to watch. We're going to take about a 10 or 15 minute break now. We'll get you all back in after that and then we'll watch about another hour of the video. Take another 10 or 15 minute break, then we'll watch the remaining hours [inaudible 01:13:42]. Take this time to get a drink of water, brew some coffee back there. It's the Keurig so one cup at a time. May take a few minutes. Okay? We'll see you back shortly. Don't discuss the case with one another. Y'all can be seated, thank you.

(01:14:56)
All right. Deputy Miguelle let me know one of the jurors needs to phone call to work and was concerned. She didn't want anyone thinking that she was making a call about the case, so I told her just bring her down to the end of the hall so she has cell phone reception and it'll be fine. I'm told by our ECR people that they need to access the ECR system, something with their feed. I don't know what it is, so they're going to do that. So I don't know how long this break will be. We'll aim for 10 or 15 minutes, but we have someone from ECR right outside the door to tinker with it. Yes, sir. All right. We'll see you all back. Mr. Hull take the opportunity to use the restroom, get a drink of water, okay? You need my laptop?

Speaker 3 (01:16:17):

No, sir.

Judge (01:27:36):

Okay. [inaudible 01:16:23].

Speaker 4 (01:28:10):

Yes, Your Honor.

Judge (01:28:10):

Okay. As we were breaking and the jury was filing out of the courtroom and that door was open, I heard what sounded like a cell phone alarm going off. The alarm that goes off on the iPhone. I think it's like the default noise for the alarm function. I don't know if it was anybody's phone in the audience, but it may have been somebody out in the back hallway. We have security stations out there. It could have been anywhere. But if anybody does have a cell phone with them and they're not an officer of the court, or member of the news media, I'd ask now that you just take a moment, just make sure your cell phone is off, not on silent or vibrating mode, just so we don't have any distractions. Like I said, I don't think it was anybody here, but I thought it was a good reminder just to everyone check their phone. Okay. Are we ready to bring the jury back in state defense?

Mr. Buxman (01:28:51):

Yes, Your Honor.

Speaker 4 (01:28:52):

Yes, Your Honor.

Judge (01:29:55):

Okay. Let's bring them in.

(01:29:55)
Ladies and gentlemen, welcome back. Everyone can go ahead and be seated. We're going to go ahead and resume the video. Mr. Buxman, will you rewind into about 2:21 and zero seconds or so? Where do you have it at? 2:21.

Mr. Buxman (01:30:06):

That's hard to do because it's so long.

Judge (01:30:11):

Just back it up just a hair.

Mr. Buxman (01:30:12):

20:44. Does that work?

Judge (01:30:34):

Yes, sir.

Video Dwayne (01:30:34):

-at the same time it's better left on paper.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:30:45):

Yeah. No, I hear you. And there's a lot of people that leave it on paper. So what type of violent ideations So what type of violent ideations?

Video Dwayne (01:30:49):

Don't feel comfortable discussing that with you.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:30:53):

Would you feel comfortable discussing it with him? [inaudible 01:30:54].

Video Dwayne (01:30:53):

I do not.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:30:55):

Is that part of the privacy that you want to keep with your phone? Is that what... Okay, good enough.

Video Dwayne (01:31:00):

[inaudible 01:31:05] it's just part of privacy.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:31:08):

So the reason why I'm having this discussion with you is that our missing person is also involved in those types of fantasies and violent ideations as well as-

Video Dwayne (01:31:17):

That does somehow surprise me.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:31:17):

Right?

Video Dwayne (01:31:29):

Especially if you're telling me that I actually had communication and she was actually communicating with me at one point or another, I'm sure we had some rather nasty discussions.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:31:38):

Yeah.

Video Dwayne (01:31:38):

I'm not even going to play, I'm sure we had some right nasty discussions.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:31:41):

And between consenting adults is absolutely okay, right?

Video Dwayne (01:31:45):

Yeah. I mean, like I said, there's a lot, but yeah, good point.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:31:52):

Yeah. So if she came over here with the intention of fulfilling some of those fantasies, violent sexual fantasies, I'm not saying necessarily rape, but definitely violent sexual fantasies. And then at the end of it, she wants to end her life.

Video Dwayne (01:32:15):

If you're trying to put me in line with something like that, I'm going to tell you right now, it's been all about my wife since she dang near died. I have no interest in anything, to do anything like that with another woman. I barely even have an interest in tying my wife up at this point because she's been through so much. Okay? That killed that part. And when I seen her, when I seen her laying there, just not there, that killed that part of me.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:32:47):

Was that part of it? I know that this is a sensitive question, but it just helps me understand. Was that something that you and your wife...

Video Dwayne (01:32:55):

We like to play like, bondage.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:32:55):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (01:33:00):

There wasn't nothing wrong with a little bit of spanking here and there.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:33:01):

Little hair pulling.

Video Dwayne (01:33:04):

Tie her up, make her cum until she couldn't cum no more. That kind of thing I'm okay with that, I was okay with that with her. It was something that was just our normal date night. Okay. But yeah, after seeing her, dead, basically there's a part of me that, mm-mm, I'm sure after a certain point, after she [inaudible 01:33:29] up all the way and stuff, and she expresses the desire to kind of ease back into that, I won't have a problem with that. But at the same fucking time, for now, that part of me is dead. It's gone. It's dead.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:33:43):

[inaudible 01:33:43] really well.

Video Dwayne (01:33:43):

Yeah. I was upset. I was upset. I was happy, upset. I was upset because I was going to have to be gone away from her and had to spend the weekend away from her knowing that she just got out of that transplant because it was...

Video Interviewer 1 (01:34:01):

She goes daily right now?

Video Dwayne (01:34:03):

Well, two, three times a week.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:34:06):

Two to three times? Okay. And how long will that...

Video Dwayne (01:34:06):

It varies.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:34:06):

It just matters how she progresses after the transplant?

Video Dwayne (01:34:13):

Yeah, it varies. She's got about three months a day, [inaudible 01:34:23] once a week, and then once a month, and then once every six months. Just provided she doesn't show any signs of rejection [inaudible 01:34:32] stressing her out like that right now [inaudible 01:34:35]. Especially I can't even contact her. I can't even email. I don't even know if she's got a phone. I don't know if she got her pills. I don't know.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:34:42):

You made phone calls [inaudible 01:34:48] she's taken care of, yeah.

Video Dwayne (01:34:49):

She got her bag and her phone at least.

Speaker 5 (01:34:51):

I mean she got her pills and we can talk about the phone first, but I got her bag of pills.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:34:52):

But she'll be able to communicate, yeah.

Speaker 5 (01:34:52):

Phone I don't know about. I only specifically said the bag of the pills.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:35:05):

We were just trying to make sure her health... We were focused on her health and making sure that she was okay. We didn't want her to suffer any sort of medical issue.

Video Dwayne (01:35:13):

Yeah, trust me, she's got to take big fucking handfuls of pills three times a day and they're with her.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:35:18):

She has those pills. So we have these communications and we have very clear intention that was documented by our missing person, that that was what she was coming here to do. And there is no judgment from me about what you may be worried about talking about because you love your wife so much, and you don't want to stress her out anymore. But we know that she was with you. And we know that she came over here to carry out this bondage, these sexual fantasies, and ultimately to take her own life. We know all of these things, and we know that she was at the residence.

Video Dwayne (01:36:19):

Yeah. Yeah. You were telling me she was there, yeah.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:36:23):

Yeah.

Video Dwayne (01:36:23):

And yeah, well, we had had conversations before, I'm sure, like you said.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:36:26):

Yeah.

Video Dwayne (01:36:27):

And then seen a picture of it there. No, that's definitely [inaudible 01:36:31] in my fucking vehicle.

‍

Video Interviewer 1 (01:36:32):

Yeah. So part of what I want to make sure that I'm doing, is giving you an opportunity to talk to us about what happened. Because again, it's just a matter of, did she end up doing what she came over here to do? And if that's the case, then that was a decision-

Video Dwayne (01:36:55):

She got in another vehicle.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:36:56):

That's the decision-

Video Dwayne (01:36:57):

She got in another vehicle. Me and her wasn't in that building at the same damn time, anytime that I was there.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:37:05):

Okay. So that was a decision she made, right? If she came over here, she got on that plane on her own, she bought the tickets, she bought the Airbnb. She did all of that. She got in the car with you, you drove her to the Airbnb. That Airbnb, and this is why I'm asking you about, if you all may have done some role playing, because again, that was her intention to come over here and do that, because that Airbnb is being forensically processed.

(01:37:35)
And do you know what that means? Basically, if there are some bodily fluids, we're going to be able to tell who is in there, and what those fluids were. And so if there is indication of sexual activity, and we can get it from a couch, we can get it from a shower. We get it from anything, right? I mean, that's the beauty of forensic science. Again, she came over here on her own. So I am not sitting here saying she did anything that she didn't want to do, but she came over here to meet you, and you guys were at that Airbnb, and that is going to be proved forensically.

Video Dwayne (01:38:25):

Yeah you already found that she was there. You already told me that, right?

Video Interviewer 1 (01:38:28):

Yeah.

Video Dwayne (01:38:33):

So you know what you just said? You said you fucking proved that she was there.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:38:33):

And if you were there-

Video Dwayne (01:38:35):

I was there.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:38:35):

You guys were there at the same time.

Video Dwayne (01:38:35):

We were not there at the same time.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:38:35):

Your phones were there.

Video Dwayne (01:38:35):

Phones were there at the same time. What?

Video Interviewer 1 (01:38:35):

Neighbors.

Video Dwayne (01:38:35):

Neighbors?

Video Interviewer 1 (01:38:54):

Mm-hmm. You wouldn't think, right? Because it's kind of out in the middle of nowhere, right? It is. But yeah, there's a neighbor behind, there's a neighbor beside-

Video Interviewer 1 (01:39:00):

But yeah, there's a neighbor behind, there's a neighbor beside, and then there's a neighbor that's actually building next door. She goes out there every day.

Video Dwayne (01:39:08):

Yeah. I've seen that neighbor next door coming back.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:39:11):

Yeah. So this is, to me, it's not concerning if you're like, "Yep, this is what the plan was." And then it's like, "Okay, he shut down."

Video Dwayne (01:39:30):

Why don't you just level with me the rest of the way and tell me what you got? And then I'll just confirm, non-aggressive way out of that. And if I feel like I need that dirty word, I'll have to get that dirty word.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:39:35):

I just told you. We have [inaudible 01:39:37].

Video Dwayne (01:39:38):

Yeah, but you keep leaving out extra stuff, extra stuff, extra stuff, leaving me alone. That's your-

Video Interviewer 1 (01:39:40):

I don't think I'm leaving you alone.

Video Dwayne (01:39:40):

It's your job to do, okay?

Video Interviewer 1 (01:39:41):

Yeah.

Video Dwayne (01:39:47):

But I need to know what you have in order to know what you need.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:39:48):

We have-

Video Dwayne (01:39:56):

You have at the same time, you have witnesses that we were there at the same time.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:39:58):

And devices that put you there at the same time.

Video Dwayne (01:39:59):

Okay.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:40:03):

We have processed that house and when those results come back, because again, forensically, and you've already told us you were all over that house.

Video Dwayne (01:40:12):

Yeah. All over that house, yeah.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:40:12):

We know that she was. We are going to put you guys at that house. And so she came over here with the intention of carrying out these role playing scenarios. We know that she documented it. She actually sent a letter to herself while she was on the airplane talking about meeting somebody and what the outcome of that meeting was going to be. And so we know that. But again, this was somebody who was doing it. She was consenting to this. This is something that she wanted. And so I just want you to tell me how that went down.

Video Dwayne (01:41:05):

You want me to tell you that we fucked? Is that what you want?

Video: Speaker 3 (01:41:12):

No, we want you to be honest with us. We want you to tell us the truth. We don't want you to make anything up or just tell us what you think we want to hear.

Video Dwayne (01:41:18):

She did get in the vehicle with somebody else. There's a certain point she did get in the vehicle with somebody else that happened after. Okay? The fact that I didn't want to have anything to do with the whole fucking thing to begin with is the whole reason I got to sleep in the second fucking bed.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:41:38):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (01:41:40):

Okay? I couldn't do that and fuck next day. I did end up being in the same bed as her on the other side of the bed from her.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:41:45):

Okay. And what happened?

Video Dwayne (01:41:46):

What do you think fucking happened?

Video Interviewer 1 (01:41:48):

Well, I know what happened.

Video Dwayne (01:41:49):

What do you think fucking happened?

Video Interviewer 1 (01:41:49):

You tell me. I can't read minds.

Video Dwayne (01:41:49):

We ended up having sex.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:41:49):

Okay. Tell me about that sex.

Video Dwayne (01:41:49):

Pretty vanilla.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:42:01):

Vanilla for you or vanilla for the average person?

Video Dwayne (01:42:05):

Vanilla for me.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:42:05):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (01:42:05):

Pretty vanilla for me.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:42:11):

So her communications were very like, hey, these are things that she was up for it. Did she change her mind when she got here? Were you guys easing into it? How did that happen?

Video Dwayne (01:42:22):

I didn't want anything to do with it.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:42:22):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (01:42:22):

I didn't want anything to do with it.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:42:22):

Were you having second thoughts? Tell me about that.

Video Dwayne (01:42:23):

I love my wife. I want [inaudible 01:42:37] fucking wife.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:42:41):

Yeah.

Video Dwayne (01:42:42):

[inaudible 01:42:41]. I had a job to do out there any fucking way with cars and everything else. [inaudible 01:42:48] do that. I want to go home.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:43:01):

Okay. I'm sorry. So you guys get to the house. You said she ultimately leaves, but what happens? Tell me about what you guys talk about. What happens while she's at the house?

Video Dwayne (01:43:13):

We didn't want to talk about anything.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:43:13):

She didn't?

Video Dwayne (01:43:20):

We didn't want to talk about anything, especially after it became clear that I wasn't driving.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:43:27):

So was she talking to you about, "Hey, we talked about this, this is what the plan was," and you just in that moment you're like, "That's not the kind of sex I want to have right now." Or...

Video Dwayne (01:43:43):

I didn't want to have sex, period. Okay. I didn't want anything to do in any way, shape or form.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:43:52):

Sometimes the body responds, right? And she's laying next to you.

Video Dwayne (01:43:55):

Yeah.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:43:58):

So tell me about that.

Video Dwayne (01:44:06):

We had sex.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:44:08):

Sex means a lot of different things. We already talked about that.

Video Dwayne (01:44:12):

Okay. So we had sex. We had sex, a little bit of light choking or whatever. Just regular firm grip kind of shit every once in a while.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:44:22):

Light bondage.

Video Dwayne (01:44:23):

Very, very light. Didn't even involve any ropes or anything like that.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:44:34):

Okay. So just the hands. Okay. Anything else?

Video Dwayne (01:44:34):

What do you want?

Video Interviewer 1 (01:44:34):

So you said light choking, and I know this-

Video Dwayne (01:44:34):

We had sex, sex.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:44:45):

So what does that mean to you?

Video Dwayne (01:44:46):

It means I put my dick in her.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:44:46):

Okay. What part of her?

Video Dwayne (01:44:51):

Yes.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:44:52):

Every part?

Video Dwayne (01:44:53):

Yes.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:44:53):

Okay. So mouth?

Video Dwayne (01:44:55):

Yes.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:44:56):

Vagina?

Video Dwayne (01:44:56):

Yes.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:44:56):

Anal?

Video Dwayne (01:44:56):

Yes.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:44:56):

Okay. What order?

Video Dwayne (01:44:56):

Yes.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:44:56):

Okay. So lots of different things, hey.

Video Dwayne (01:44:56):

Yes.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:44:56):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (01:44:56):

But yeah, I didn't come.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:44:56):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (01:44:56):

I didn't want happened.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:45:18):

Okay. Condoms?

Video Dwayne (01:45:19):

No.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:45:24):

Okay. Was she wearing anything or were you guys going to bed? How did you guys get into the bed to begin with?

Video Dwayne (01:45:35):

She's in bed. She was in bed. Okay.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:45:39):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (01:45:43):

She was in bed wakes, and sleeping in bed.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:45:48):

Okay. Was she clothed?

Video Dwayne (01:45:48):

No.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:45:48):

Completely nude? Okay. What about you?

Video Dwayne (01:45:48):

I had underwear on.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:45:53):

Okay. What type?

Video Dwayne (01:45:54):

I think I ended up slipping my underwear off after a little bit, after I relaxed my brain relaxed, and I wanted to get comfortable and go to sleep.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:46:05):

Once you were in the bed, underwear came off?

Video Dwayne (01:46:05):

Yeah.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:46:05):

What kind of underwear do you wear? I mean, you don't got to lip them out for me right now, but-

Video Dwayne (01:46:09):

Hanes.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:46:09):

Like boxers, brief-

Video Dwayne (01:46:09):

Yeah, boxers.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:46:09):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (01:46:09):

A boxers style. Yeah.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:46:19):

Okay. So you came into the room in boxers?

Video Dwayne (01:46:22):

I was dressed.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:46:23):

Oh, you were fully dressed. Okay. What were you wearing?

Video Dwayne (01:46:26):

Basically pretty close to what I'm wearing right now.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:46:37):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (01:46:37):

Blue jeans.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:46:37):

Blue jeans. The same blue jeans or...

Video Dwayne (01:46:37):

No, no. No, no, not the same blue jeans, but they basically look the same.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:46:37):

So it's like your uniform. Blue jeans. What about shoes?

Video Dwayne (01:46:41):

Same shoes.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:46:42):

Same shoes. Do you remember what shirt you were wearing?

Video Dwayne (01:46:44):

Different color one of these.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:46:46):

T-shirt? Okay. So you go in there, you're like, "I can't sleep in this other bed. Let me..." And she was fine with you getting in the bed with her?

Video Dwayne (01:46:57):

Mm-hmm.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:46:58):

So you take everything off but your boxers?

Video Dwayne (01:47:01):

Initially.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:47:01):

Initially. And then you're in bed until-

Video Dwayne (01:47:05):

I finally got relaxed and I wanted to go to sleep, go to sleep. And I took my boxers off.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:47:06):

Okay. And how did you get boxers off?

Video Dwayne (01:47:14):

Pretty much she wanted it.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:47:17):

How'd she let you know that she wanted it? Because there's lots of ways that happens. She grabbed your dick?

Video Dwayne (01:47:32):

Yeah.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:47:32):

With her hand?

Video Dwayne (01:47:32):

Yep.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:47:32):

And?

Video Dwayne (01:47:32):

And then her face. [inaudible 01:47:33].

Video Interviewer 1 (01:47:32):

And then her face. What does that mean?

Video Dwayne (01:47:32):

The whole fucking thing.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:47:32):

So she basically put your entire dick in her mouth?

Video Dwayne (01:47:36):

She put my entire dick in her mouth.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:47:39):

Okay. And...

Video Dwayne (01:47:39):

Went from there.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:47:43):

Went from there. And at that point, you were like, "I'm in this now." Your head was probably fighting your body, but your body was responding when you're thinking about your life.

Video Dwayne (01:47:50):

Yep.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:47:53):

I don't get that. Okay. So blow job. Well, first she grabbed your dick by her hand, blow job. Then what happened from that point?

Video Dwayne (01:48:07):

She's the one that guided [inaudible 01:48:08].

Video Interviewer 1 (01:48:12):

Okay. Did she get on top of you? You get on top of her?

Video Dwayne (01:48:14):

I just let her on top of me.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:48:15):

Tell me about that.

Video Dwayne (01:48:15):

My back and hips were too fucking bad from the fucking car accident. I didn't want to fuck with [inaudible 01:48:22]. "Hey, you want to fuck?"

Video Interviewer 1 (01:48:15):

Okay. So did you have to do it from behind then off the bed or laying-

Video Dwayne (01:48:15):

In the bed.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:48:15):

Were you standing?

Video Dwayne (01:48:15):

In the bed on my knees.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:48:15):

On your knees on the bed?

Video Dwayne (01:48:40):

So that way, I can pull and try to take pressure off of my fucking hips and back if I wanted to.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:48:41):

Okay. And she was on fours, face down?

Video Dwayne (01:48:45):

Mm-hmm.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:48:45):

Okay. So vagina first?

Video Dwayne (01:48:51):

Mm-hmm.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:48:53):

Then anus, or did you-

Video Dwayne (01:48:57):

I don't see what this part of it has anything to do with it. I already feel bad enough about the whole fucking thing.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:49:02):

Okay. Well, you said... Here's what it comes down to, is you said that you did come once.

Video Dwayne (01:49:10):

Yeah.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:49:10):

So I'm trying to figure out at what point... Did that happen after the oral, the vaginal and the anal?

Video Dwayne (01:49:21):

Yeah, yeah, yeah.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:49:22):

And then where did that-

Video Dwayne (01:49:22):

Pussy.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:49:23):

Where did that go? Pussy. You want me to say pussy? I'll say it. Try not to offend.

Video Dwayne (01:49:24):

No, pussy, that's all right. Yeah.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:49:24):

So-

Video Dwayne (01:49:24):

I don't know how to put it that way, but yeah.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:49:24):

So you come in pussy?

Video Dwayne (01:49:24):

Yep.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:49:24):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (01:49:24):

And that was it.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:49:24):

And that was it. Okay.

Video Dwayne (01:49:24):

And it was pretty obvious from there I just wanted to be left alone.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:49:24):

Okay. Did you stay in bed?

Video Dwayne (01:49:24):

I did. [inaudible 01:49:45]. I did.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:49:59):

Okay. All right, that makes sense. So you guys fall asleep?

Video Dwayne (01:50:00):

Mm-hmm.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:50:01):

And then tell me about when you wake up.

Video Dwayne (01:50:03):

Not much to tell. Not much to tell.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:50:03):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (01:50:12):

Same scenario. Yeah. I fucking went to work.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:50:14):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (01:50:16):

I come back. She's still there. Went to go to work that evening. She left in another car.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:50:31):

Okay. Ever have sex with her again?

Video Dwayne (01:50:31):

Once, I think.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:50:31):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (01:50:31):

[inaudible 01:50:32].

Video Interviewer 1 (01:50:31):

So I know-

Video Dwayne (01:50:37):

No, I did not come again.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:50:37):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (01:50:42):

And then I did not come again. I was bad enough the first one.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:50:44):

Yeah. No, I get it. Sometimes the body does shit that your brain doesn't want. Yeah. It just isn't what it is. There's a response.

Video Dwayne (01:50:44):

Yeah, there is.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:50:44):

I get that.

Video Dwayne (01:50:44):

I didn't appreciate any of that.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:50:44):

Yeah. I hear that.

Video Dwayne (01:51:03):

I didn't want to be around any of it. I didn't want [inaudible 01:51:00]. I just barely got over it.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:51:11):

Almost losing your wife.

Video Dwayne (01:51:12):

Yeah. I wasn't in no state of mind. Ended that shit.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:51:18):

Sometimes too though, it's a break from it, right? Because you probably it wasn't in that situation.

Video Dwayne (01:51:29):

I'm very in love with my wife, and I didn't want anything to do with that. I just wanted [inaudible 01:51:30] get the fuck out of there.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:51:29):

I can tell you love her, that you love your wife and care about her. Clearly how concerned with her medications and how upset you were with everything.

Video Dwayne (01:51:37):

I'm still upset with everything. I'm [inaudible 01:51:39] right now.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:51:41):

Yeah.

Video Dwayne (01:51:41):

I'm just so fucking fed up a while ago, but I don't know. I don't know if I had to.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:51:48):

Okay. So you mentioned light bondage.

Video Dwayne (01:51:49):

[inaudible 01:51:50].

Video Interviewer 1 (01:51:51):

Now, we found some packaging and rope that was left in the Airbnb that was open, which means there was rope in it. It was taken out.

Video Dwayne (01:52:05):

There was rope, but we didn't do anything with it.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:52:05):

Okay. What happened with that rope?

Video Dwayne (01:52:13):

I was untangling from the original package.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:52:13):

Okay. What'd you do with that rope then?

Video Dwayne (01:52:13):

I told you. I used that on the car later on.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:52:13):

I thought you said you used paracord.

Video Dwayne (01:52:13):

Paracord, yeah.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:52:13):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (01:52:27):

Oh, you're talking about rope too?

Video Interviewer 1 (01:52:37):

Yeah. There's a rope in there, like utility.

Video Dwayne (01:52:37):

How did the fucking rope get in there?

Video Interviewer 1 (01:52:37):

A package.

Video Dwayne (01:52:38):

How the fuck did package rope get in there? The only package of rope I have is literally in the back of my vehicle right now.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:52:43):

It's called utility line, but it... Yeah.

Video Dwayne (01:52:52):

Yeah, it's utility line. It's for tying off anchors and stuff like that for boats. And it has a little bit of stretch to it, and it works really well for fucking tying up bumpers and whatnot.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:52:59):

Well, that's why I figured because you both were into bondage and you said light bondage. If it did progress to-

Video Dwayne (01:53:09):

No. No, I didn't. No, I swear. The only fucking package of rope that I had is still unopened in the back of my vehicle.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:53:12):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (01:53:16):

The package of rope that I literally bought is still in the back of my vehicle.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:53:20):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (01:53:25):

And paracord, I didn't... paracord was up there too because the paracord was always tangled around itself when you first get it because of the way they wrapped it up. You can never find the right [inaudible 01:53:32] to pull it.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:53:32):

So maybe the paracord package was there. So did you use paracord in bondage?

Video Dwayne (01:53:39):

Like I said, that was used for a different thing later on. There's actually a 30 some dollar charge that is related to that.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:53:48):

So in this, I guess I need help understanding because if you didn't use it till Tuesday, why are we opening it and probably doing all that?

Video Dwayne (01:54:03):

Because I wanted to prep. I was prepping it.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:54:04):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (01:54:05):

I told you I didn't want nothing to do with it. Right? So I was preoccupying my mind. I was in there. I was in my own fucking bedroom, and I was doing my own thing, going about doing my own shit. I was prepping shit up and getting shit ready for my own fucking work and things I was in the vehicle later because that would've gone on the back of the seat.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:54:20):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (01:54:26):

But I used it before it had a chance to hang for really long.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:54:27):

Okay. So was it paracord-

Video Dwayne (01:54:34):

It's in my vehicle right now, they can see that there's actually where I hang my coils of stuff are over the back seat, the headrest. I use the headrest in the back seat for that stuff.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:54:43):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (01:54:43):

I was just getting-

Video Interviewer 1 (01:54:43):

You're answering my questions for me. We're getting this out here.

Video Dwayne (01:54:52):

I was just getting it ready because I knew I'd have to use it sooner or later and I want it to be all detangled and not in its original condition where I looked like a fucking dummy who didn't know where fucking I was going.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:55:01):

Yeah, on the side of the road.

Video Dwayne (01:55:04):

Yeah. I ain't going to fuss with that shit. I've had to do that before, and it's not fun.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:55:09):

Okay. So she talked about dying by suicide, having somebody maybe help her. What were those conversations like? How did she say she wanted to die?

Video Dwayne (01:55:26):

She would talk about that. We talk about that. It became very apparent. It became very apparent. Didn't think anything like that. Apparently wanted to deal with her presence.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:55:41):

What did you guys talk about? Because again, everyone has the ability to change their mind, but there were conversations about it, even if it was in person.

Video Dwayne (01:55:49):

Yeah, there was conversations about it.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:55:50):

So tell me about those conversations.

Video Dwayne (01:55:55):

She said she had tried many times. She said that it's a really beautiful state and she couldn't think of a better place to end at all.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:56:06):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (01:56:06):

And that's pretty much the extent of it. There was no elaboration one way or another, except for the fact that it became very obvious that I was not about this life. I didn't want it. I didn't want the mess. I didn't want the scrutiny. I didn't want to be involved in any way, shape or form at that point. I didn't want to have sex.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:56:30):

Yeah. So what ways did she tell you that she tried before?

Video Dwayne (01:56:38):

We never really got into that, just that she met up with a few guys or she was supposed to meet up with a few guys, and they always stood her up and coward it out or fell in love with her. It's just exactly what they...

Video Interviewer 1 (01:57:00):

So they couldn't follow through with it?

Video Dwayne (01:57:00):

They wouldn't follow through with it.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:57:00):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (01:57:00):

That's basically what that came down to.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:57:03):

Okay. So she came to you with the hopes that you could follow through with it?

Video Dwayne (01:57:10):

Apparently.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:57:10):

Yeah.

Video Dwayne (01:57:11):

Apparently that was the original plan, but I told her, I said, "It's not... I'm not even even over damn near losing my wife."

Video Interviewer 1 (01:57:39):

So how did she want you to do it? Or how did she want you to help her do it?

Video Dwayne (01:57:39):

We never really talked about it. It never got to that.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:57:39):

I'm talking about prior to her getting here.

Video Dwayne (01:57:39):

I said, "I don't know what the fuck the you're talking about because I don't know what the fuck you're talking about." [inaudible 01:57:44].

Video Interviewer 1 (01:57:39):

Okay. Respectfully.

Video Dwayne (01:57:39):

Yeah.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:57:39):

I hear you.

Video Dwayne (01:57:46):

I went through a whole, whole fucking bad thing with my wife, and I blinked.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:57:46):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (01:57:46):

I blinked. I mean, I was-

Video Interviewer 1 (01:57:46):

So you don't... The conversations-

Video Dwayne (01:57:59):

I was not mentally stable enough to retain a lot of memory from when my wife passed away and the several weeks following that where she was struggling, coming back. Everything was about her and everything about that. I don't even think I even talked to her during those couple of weeks.

Video: Speaker 3 (01:58:23):

What platforms altogether did you talk to her on?

Video Dwayne (01:58:27):

Now that we know who the fuck we talking about. There was some sessions called Sessions.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:58:37):

Can you tell me her name?

Video Dwayne (01:58:39):

Sonya Blade on Sessions. I think we spoke a few times on there.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:58:46):

And Sonya Blade is the person you said [inaudible 01:58:51].

Video Dwayne (01:58:46):

Yep, yep, yep.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:58:46):

That's Sonya.

Video Dwayne (01:58:46):

That's Sonya.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:58:46):

And you know her as Sonya Blade?

Video Dwayne (01:58:46):

I know her as Sonya.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:58:46):

Okay. Do you know her as anything other than Sonya and then her scream name was Sonya Blade?

Video Dwayne (01:59:07):

I feel that dress looks familiar. It's already yours on Mother's List.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:59:13):

Mother List?

Video Dwayne (01:59:14):

Yeah. Screen name on there already yours. That's why I asked you this. Just tell me what you got and I can just tell you what I got, and see whatever you put the pieces together.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:59:24):

Well, sort of like how I explained to you, I didn't initially show you the picture.

Video Dwayne (01:59:28):

Sure.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:59:29):

But the thing is you could have easily have said, "Oh, that's her." But because you described her to me, it's like, "Oh, she was wearing a floral dress, she had cleavage, she had nice legs." Then I'm like, "Okay, I feel like we're talking about the same person." And now I can show you the picture.

Video Dwayne (01:59:43):

Yeah, I shouldn't do that because you got to show it.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:59:43):

Well, no, because I have to be able to save it.

Video: Speaker 3 (01:59:43):

We don't want to be accused of feeding information.

Video Interviewer 1 (01:59:43):

Feeding the information. Yeah.

Video: Speaker 3 (01:59:43):

Sometimes we need you to.

Video Dwayne (01:59:55):

Page 20 fucking two.

Video: Speaker 3 (01:59:56):

Yeah. I know you said that sometimes you got memory problems. It's our job to help you recall and get those details out so that we can say [inaudible 02:00:13].

Video Dwayne (02:00:12):

Yeah, it's not about that I have memory problems, but I have them as well.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:00:12):

Yeah.

Video Dwayne (02:00:12):

It's because of the trauma that I've already gotten into.

Video: Speaker 3 (02:00:15):

So Sessions, the other one, and then anything else that you talked her on?

Video Dwayne (02:00:19):

No.

Video: Speaker 3 (02:00:22):

Okay. Did you ever record any of the sex that you guys had or anything?

Video Dwayne (02:00:25):

Oh, no.

Video: Speaker 3 (02:00:27):

Anything that you did with her that you recorded?

Video Dwayne (02:00:35):

I deleted it.

Video: Speaker 3 (02:00:35):

Okay. Tell me more about that.

Video Dwayne (02:00:36):

I told her that I wanted her to tell me what it was that she was there for. Then I wanted her to go into detail and she basically just locked up on everything. And I ended up deleting it because it was absolutely no use to me. In case something like this fucking happened, I just... Here.

Video: Speaker 3 (02:01:03):

What'd you record it on?

Video Dwayne (02:01:05):

Phone. It's not on there anymore.

Video: Speaker 3 (02:01:07):

It's not on there?

Video Dwayne (02:01:09):

No, I deleted it. I mean, obviously you say that it can be recovered.

Video: Speaker 3 (02:01:12):

We can try. That's why-

Video Dwayne (02:01:12):

You can recover it or whatever.

Video: Speaker 3 (02:01:17):

Yeah, that's why I'm asking. But she didn't respond to you when you asked her [inaudible 02:01:19].

Video Dwayne (02:01:26):

She was not responsive very much. I don't know what the fuck her problem was in that regard. I think she was just disappointed because I didn't want her. I didn't want her.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:01:39):

When was that video taken?

Video Dwayne (02:01:50):

You're asking me that question. I don't fucking know. It was when she was here.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:01:57):

Was it at the beginning of the trip, at the end of the trip?

Video: Speaker 3 (02:01:58):

Where were you?

Video Dwayne (02:02:00):

About half-way to the [inaudible 02:01:58]. We were in that, the end of it.

Video: Speaker 3 (02:02:00):

Okay. That's what I'm asking. Did she do it at the airport, in the car? You know what I mean? That's why I'm-

Video Dwayne (02:02:07):

No. We hardly even had a conversation other than, like I said, talked [inaudible 02:02:12] initially it was I don't talk with [inaudible 02:02:14].

Video: Speaker 3 (02:02:15):

So that video was at the Airbnb?

Video Dwayne (02:02:18):

Yeah. And it's just not... I don't fucking know. I don't know. I don't know.

Video: Speaker 3 (02:02:26):

Did she have any phones with her?

Video Dwayne (02:02:29):

She seemed to, but it was shut off. She never... I don't know.

Video: Speaker 3 (02:02:39):

How so?

Video Dwayne (02:02:39):

Yes, I-

Video: Speaker 3 (02:02:39):

What do you mean? You said did she seem to, but it was shut off? So I'm trying to-

Video Dwayne (02:02:42):

She had one, but it's not like she got on it or anything. And she was real happy about shutting it off for the last time.

Video: Speaker 3 (02:02:51):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (02:02:56):

Saturday, Friday night, Saturday morning, something like that.

Video: Speaker 3 (02:03:04):

And tell me exactly from what you remember of how that came about that she shut it off for the first time or for the last time that you said.

Video Dwayne (02:03:25):

Yeah, it's just out of the blue. "I'm so happy to be shutting this off for the last time." And that's all it was. I don't know if she turned it back on or she ever turned it back on after that.

Video: Speaker 3 (02:03:28):

What kind of phone was it?

Video Dwayne (02:03:32):

I didn't look at it. It was smaller than mine.

Video: Speaker 3 (02:03:33):

Smaller than your... Okay.

Video Dwayne (02:03:36):

Burner phone. That's how she described it.

Video: Speaker 3 (02:03:40):

Did it look like a typical phone nowadays with a digital screen or was it a flip phone?

Video Dwayne (02:03:44):

Yeah. [inaudible 02:03:46].

Video: Speaker 3 (02:03:48):

Could you tell if it was an iPhone or Samsung?

Video Dwayne (02:03:48):

I didn't even ask her. I had no idea [inaudible 02:03:54]. She claimed it was a burner phone. She finally [inaudible 02:04:00] apparently.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:03:48):

I don't think she claimed anything. I think she had in her mind what she wanted to have happen, and her intention was to make sure that that happened and find somebody to help her.

Video Dwayne (02:04:14):

Yeah. Unfortunately, my wife had passed. So I wasn't going to be afraid of anything that... Otherwise, I would've just put it down. If it would've been, if I was actually going to be going to fucking finalize all that shit, and I can say this honestly because I've considered it before because I'm not so getting blood on my hands. I will say it again. It's not something that I intended to do outside of the life and death circumstance. Okay? So if it would've been me, I would've gone down Aligator Alley and dropped her off and told her to pick a direction and walk. Because if you don't want to do it yourself and I don't want to fucking do it, go to the wildlife. We have a ton of that here.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:04:59):

What's her thought on that?

Video Dwayne (02:05:04):

I never said it to her. I never said it to her. I never said it to her. Like I said, if it was going to be me that was going to be the one that did it, I would've done it like that. That was my though initially. She does come here before life got really bad. Initially, I though she does come here and she does want me to help with it, that's how I'll help her with it.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:05:29):

[inaudible 02:05:28]. It's not particularly violent though, so it doesn't really feed into how she wanted it to happen.

Video Dwayne (02:05:34):

I could have very well accommodated her on that end of it at the very end and just sent her off in in a daze and [inaudible 02:05:40]. But that's it before.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:05:50):

Yeah.

Video Dwayne (02:05:50):

When my wife came to die, my priorities shifted in a very unexpected way.

Video: Speaker 3 (02:05:52):

Did you call it Alligator Alley?

Video Dwayne (02:05:53):

Yeah. Yeah.

Video: Speaker 3 (02:05:55):

Where was that?

Video Dwayne (02:05:56):

You know where that's at? It's Alligator.

Video: Speaker 3 (02:05:56):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (02:05:56):

It's the Everglades.

Video: Speaker 3 (02:05:56):

Oh, okay. You talking about the Everglades.

Video Dwayne (02:05:56):

[inaudible 02:06:04].

Video: Speaker 3 (02:05:56):

Okay. That's why-

Video Dwayne (02:05:56):

I've been calling it Alligator Alley.

Video: Speaker 3 (02:05:56):

Honestly, I've never heard that said, man.

Video Dwayne (02:05:56):

What?

Video: Speaker 3 (02:05:56):

Sorry.

Video Dwayne (02:05:56):

[inaudible 02:06:10].

Video: Speaker 3 (02:05:56):

This alligator in the end, [inaudible 02:06:13] down there. I'm not from the South, so I don't know.

Video Dwayne (02:05:56):

Yeah. [inaudible 02:06:16].

Video Interviewer 1 (02:06:20):

So you said you could have helped her along with the violent part of it because she wanted to die violently. How would you have done that?

Video Dwayne (02:06:29):

I got them hands. Yeah, that's what you do. [inaudible 02:06:33] at one point before priorities completely shifted. I've seen it come for a long time where the violent tendency was slowly happening.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:06:48):

What do you mean?

Video Dwayne (02:06:57):

And then my wife getting so bad, it just killed me. I really have zero interest in anything like that anymore. I used to.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:06:58):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (02:07:07):

It does something to you when you take your wife into the hospital and come from that generation of people don't come home from the hospital. They basically died right in front of you without dying. It fucks you up. It fucks you up. It makes you try to appreciate everything you have. And even if you wanted to be an idiot and do something stupid all of a sudden, in my case. It's like they say, I stumble [inaudible 02:07:57]. I don't know what to do. [inaudible 02:08:02].

(02:07:39)
I can't take care of my wife. I felt bad, but next to that shit, [inaudible 02:08:13] and different vehicles and gone and bought two vehicles and the sexy-ass [inaudible 02:08:18] vehicles and the rat rod. Yeah. And she approved. She approved. And she did get into the vehicle.

Video: Speaker 3 (02:08:27):

What kind of vehicle?

Video Dwayne (02:08:27):

I told you it was a Cadillac. It was an old Cadillac Eldorado.

Video: Speaker 3 (02:08:27):

Do you remember what color it was?

Video Dwayne (02:08:52):

It was like this color, the bottom part there.

Video: Speaker 3 (02:08:52):

So it was gray.

Video Dwayne (02:08:52):

Hand cream color.

Video: Speaker 3 (02:08:52):

Oh, I see. The tail end.

Video Dwayne (02:08:55):

Yeah. Maybe it was just a little bit lighter color than that.

Video: Speaker 3 (02:08:58):

I told you I'm not a car guy. This Cadillac Eldorado, what kind of car is that?

Video Interviewer 1 (02:09:00):

[inaudible 02:09:05].

Video: Speaker 3 (02:09:00):

Well, I've not even heard of it. [inaudible 02:09:06].

Video Dwayne (02:09:08):

No. There's one Cadillac. This thing is a boat. This is a land tank. It's huge. This thing probably fit 12 people and six more in a trunk. I don't think that's an exaggeration. They were old-ass luxury cars back in the day.

Video: Speaker 3 (02:09:25):

Like an SUV?

Video Dwayne (02:09:26):

No, this is a land boat. I know you don't know what that is, but it's basically, it's about one door and a trunk short of a limousine. They are long. They always had big 454s with bigger in them. They're just beautiful fucking piece of machinery that they don't make like that anymore.

Video: Speaker 3 (02:09:51):

When did that car pick her up?

Video Dwayne (02:10:03):

Middle of the night. Middle of the night. I don't know. I get my times fucked up. I want to say Saturday night. I want to say Saturday night because that's when the whole blow up happened, the big yelling, screaming happened. [inaudible 02:10:34].

Video: Speaker 3 (02:10:39):

Where was she when you were there working on those cars? Where was she at the time?

Video Dwayne (02:10:42):

I have no idea.

Video: Speaker 3 (02:10:44):

Where had you left her last?

Video Dwayne (02:10:46):

Anytime I ever seen her, she was in Airbnb except for that Saturday night. So really only the one time. Okay? One time in the afternoon that she was at the B7. She was there when I got back.

Video: Speaker 3 (02:10:59):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (02:11:02):

And then Saturday night, when's the last time I seen her.

Video: Speaker 3 (02:11:05):

And where did you see her last Saturday night?

Video Dwayne (02:11:10):

Getting into the rod.

Video: Speaker 3 (02:11:10):

At the Airbnb or somewhere else?

Video Dwayne (02:11:10):

At the Airbnb.

Video: Speaker 3 (02:11:10):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (02:11:18):

And it wasn't a loud car either. It was quieter. It wasn't like [inaudible 02:11:24] cars or anything. It was more of a quiet running luxury.

Video: Speaker 3 (02:11:31):

Which way did it travel?

Video Dwayne (02:11:36):

That, I don't know because I don't know. If you were facing the Airbnb and you're facing the main road to the left.

Video: Speaker 3 (02:11:44):

To the left. Okay. That helped us. Perfect.

Video Dwayne (02:11:46):

Went out to the car.

Video: Speaker 3 (02:11:47):

Okay.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:11:47):

So when her cars were running, we both were at the-

Video Interviewer 1 (02:12:00):

... we both were at the Airbnb. So tell me about the cards being run because [inaudible 02:12:09] run cards.

Video Dwayne (02:12:15):

The cards being run, like I said, her was not there at that time. The cards being run, they were her cards at the time. Okay?

Video Interviewer 1 (02:12:18):

Mm-hmm.

Video Dwayne (02:12:18):

Got to be very clear about that [inaudible 02:12:25]. Like I said, keep quiet in the background. Everything I've told you so far is exactly what I'm telling you. The fact that they were her cards, I only learned after the fact. The fact that the call did come in, there was some ridiculous amount offered. Guys ran the cards, the cards were declined. It was in the evening. Shortly after that, I don't know how long after that. Shortly after that, the big blow up happened between those guys. [inaudible 02:13:02] who the fuck they were? I didn't see them or hear them, which means they were close enough by that I could hear them. So probably on the same property that they were taking me out to. [inaudible 02:13:10].

(02:13:10)
And then from there, shortly after that, I got called back and told my contractors, dada dada da. And then another card to run and I got paid and I left the next morning.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:13:24):

Okay. So you talked to Sonia on the phone. So we can now... The person that you talked to on the phone, because we now know that you talked to Sonia.

Video Dwayne (02:13:38):

Sonia yeah.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:13:39):

It was Sonia on the phone.

Video Dwayne (02:13:44):

It didn't sound like Sonia on the phone.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:13:45):

It didn't sound like her-

Video Dwayne (02:13:45):

It did not sound-

Video Interviewer 1 (02:13:45):

... but she provided Sonia's information.

Video Dwayne (02:13:48):

Yeah. It did not sound like her.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:13:50):

What does Sonya sound like?

Video Dwayne (02:13:51):

Meek.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:13:51):

Okay. Accent?

Video Dwayne (02:14:01):

Not in person. Not in person.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:14:09):

Okay. Is the phone, there was an accident?

Video Dwayne (02:14:09):

No, no. Not in person. When I say not in person, it's because I've heard her voice before on... We had a phone call and we had a phone call together about seven, eight months ago, and she definitely had an accent over the phone, but in person, she don't have an accent.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:14:16):

Okay. So it was a phone call or it was like a video?

Video Dwayne (02:14:17):

No no, no. It was a phone call. We had an in-person phone call at the time.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:14:38):

To see if you were real?

Video Dwayne (02:14:38):

Yeah. Six or seven months ago.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:14:38):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (02:14:38):

Well before everything went to hell in my life and well before my priorities in life changed.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:14:38):

Yeah. What was that phone call like?

Video Dwayne (02:14:58):

‍

It was pretty casual. We just got to know each other a little bit. She told me about her boyfriend, husband and stuff and I was kind of making fun of her saying, "Well, why don't you fuck him?" I was just kind of messing around.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:15:13):

Was he not into that kind of stuff? Is that what the problem was?

Video Dwayne (02:15:15):

He was not into that kind of stuff.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:15:18):

Okay. And she told me many times where she [inaudible 02:15:23] just a little bit in full stops.

Video Dwayne (02:15:21):

Okay.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:15:26):

So she was trying to get him to...

Video Dwayne (02:15:27):

Play.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:15:27):

Play and he wasn't interested.

Video Dwayne (02:15:30):

He wasn't about playing like that. But it is what it is.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:15:35):

Yeah.

Video Dwayne (02:15:39):

This was messed up. I do remember a little bit of that phone call because it's the first time I ever heard a real person from the UK verified that I knew was in the UK.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:15:47):

Wait, did you say Mexico?

Video Dwayne (02:15:49):

Huh?

Video Interviewer 1 (02:15:51):

I misheard. You said something and I was like, "Did he say Mexico?" So UK, prior to you saying UK, you said that this was...

Video Dwayne (02:16:00):

I've never heard anybody British before. [inaudible 02:16:05] was really in the UK.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:16:06):

UK? Okay. I don't know where I got Mexico from.

Video Dwayne (02:16:12):

But yes. No.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:16:12):

So she had a British accent?

Video Dwayne (02:16:16):

Yeah, yeah. She had a very pretty British accent at that time. And it was kind of cool. I felt safe because I was [inaudible 02:16:28] taking a phone call. We left the sexual aspect completely out of it because I wasn't comfortable with it because it's one thing to play online. It's another thing...

Video Interviewer 1 (02:16:34):

It's a real person now, right?

Video Dwayne (02:16:37):

Yeah, it's a real person now.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:16:41):

So did you guys go back to playing online once you had the phone call?

Video Dwayne (02:16:48):

For a little bit and then my wife's health started to drop really significantly. We still messaged but it wasn't like it was before. It should have been pretty obvious that my desire had been refocused to something else. I know for a fact I mentioned at least once, my wife was really sick.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:17:14):

Mm-hmm.

Video Dwayne (02:17:14):

I don't feel like talking with you.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:17:16):

Yeah.

Video: Speaker 2 (02:17:22):

I think you gave her the girls' usernames for those two, for sessions and for-

Video Dwayne (02:17:31):

SessionsforSoniaUA, all one word, and then Already Yours for [inaudible 02:17:36].

Video: Speaker 2 (02:17:36):

Okay. What are your usernames for those accounts that you would've been talking to her on?

Video Dwayne (02:17:45):

I don't even fucking know. I don't even know. I'm just drawing a blank. Usually something sadist probably Alpha, Alpha Sadist or something like that.

Video: Speaker 2 (02:17:54):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (02:18:00):

I'm just drawing a blank right now. I'm just a little bit stressed and now I'm regretting shit that is making me [inaudible 02:18:07].

Video Interviewer 1 (02:18:23):

I know that she is not alive anymore. I know that. You know that. And I want to find her.

Video Dwayne (02:18:25):

No, I don't know that.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:18:36):

I think you do.

Video Dwayne (02:18:39):

I don't know that. I suspect that. I strongly suspect that.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:18:42):

Yeah. And I need your help to help me find her because you are the person that was with her and you were the one-

Video Dwayne (02:18:54):

That was the last one to see her alive.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:18:57):

And you were the one to help her and to communicate with her and you were the one that picked her up from the airport. And we know this, this isn't something that we're guessing.

Video Dwayne (02:19:22):

No, no, no. You and I have already had this conversation.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:19:22):

Yes.

Video Dwayne (02:19:22):

We already discussed.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:19:23):

Yeah, we know this. And it's time to just... You had this conversation. I understand how you all met and the conversations and what the expectations were. And I also know that those expectations were met and that you helped her. And I want to find her so that I can tell her family that she's been found because she deserves that. And you just helped her do something that she wanted to do and has been trying to do for a very long time. She has been trying to do this for a very little time.

Video Dwayne (02:19:55):

[inaudible 02:19:55]. She went off with somebody else.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:20:01):

We know she didn't.

Video Dwayne (02:20:20):

I don't know where she went. I have no idea where she went.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:20:21):

You do know where she's at.

Video Dwayne (02:20:21):

I have no idea where she went.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:20:22):

And you know that she's not alive anymore.

Video Dwayne (02:20:25):

I have a very strong stinking suspicion that she ain't alive anymore based on the phone call that happened. I don't know what to tell you from that point. I know she probably got what she wanted because she doesn't want to take anything else.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:20:43):

Right. I know that.

Video Dwayne (02:20:48):

I want to know where the fuck she went. I don't know where she's at. I don't know where she moved up. I don't know anything else.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:21:09):

I know that you were the one that helped her get what she wanted and she was an adult and this is what she wanted.

Video Dwayne (02:21:16):

I only got-

Video Interviewer 1 (02:21:16):

And that's okay.

Video Dwayne (02:21:16):

I only got a good sex friend and I didn't want that.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:21:20):

You helped her to get what she wanted and what she wanted as an adult, she has the right to want that and she reached out to you to help her.

Video Dwayne (02:21:31):

And I failed her.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:21:31):

You didn't. You didn't.

Video Dwayne (02:21:31):

I failed her. In that regard, I failed her. I'm not the one that you are so delicately trying to go around.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:21:45):

Not delicately.

Video Dwayne (02:21:45):

Let me explain.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:21:45):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (02:21:50):

You're the one that's delicately trying to go around and explain and trying to get the thing that I'm the one that killed her. I'm not the one. I didn't have anything to do with that. I barely had anything to do with her after she got here. I didn't want her here. I wanted to do my job, look after my wife and everything like that.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:22:11):

I said that you helped her. You know where-

Video Dwayne (02:22:13):

I don't even know where she'd been. I don't know where.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:22:18):

You helped her, whether that means you helped her die or you helped put her somewhere after she did what she wanted to do. You helped her. We know that.

Video Dwayne (02:22:42):

See, we're getting into a dangerous territory here.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:22:44):

Why is this dangerous?

Video Dwayne (02:22:48):

Because no matter what I say, I feel myself getting roped in further and further and further into something that I had no part of that you guys need answers for.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:22:55):

I just want to find her so that I can let her family know that she's been found. And I know that she is not alive, and I know that you helped her in some way to do what she wanted to have done. And there's a huge difference between someone doing something against somebody's will, but I have the messages. I have the letter that she wrote and she wanted this to happen. And so I don't think that you're a bad person because you helped her do what she wanted to have done.

(02:23:58)
I actually think you are a person that regardless of those thoughts that you said that you had, the violent tendencies and things like that, you saw a person who was in pain who needed help to do something that she didn't have the ability to do for herself and she had been trying for a very long time. And I actually think that, that comes from a place of compassion.

Video Dwayne (02:24:25):

I tried to talk her out of it many times over the last year or so that she and I have talked many, many times. I even refocused her to such a degree before my wife got sick. Before my wife got sick, I'd even refocused her to a degree that she said it's the first time she ever enjoyed living. So I'm sorry. You want to find her? I understand you guys have a job to do. You think that I have something to do with that and okay, I'm-

Video Interviewer 1 (02:25:08):

But I'm not Saying it in a negative way.

Video Dwayne (02:25:09):

Listen, listen. I'm the last one who's seen her alive and I get that. And I'm the only link that you guys have to anything tangible. I get that also. If I was sitting where y'all were sitting, I'd be looking at me the same fucking way. We are not on a separate page here in that regard. However, I do not know where she's at.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:25:19):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (02:25:20):

I don't know what happened to her. I strongly suspect that she's no longer with us but I can't tell you anything else. I don't know.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:25:29):

Did she have discussions of where she wanted to end up?

Video Dwayne (02:25:45):

No. That in itself did not happen. The only thing that even came close to that was she kept saying how beautiful Florida is and she couldn't pick a better place to die. That was the extent. If I had anything else at this point, I'm so tired of dealing with this shit and I just want it to be the fuck over, I'd tell you. But I don't know. [inaudible 02:26:08].

Video: Speaker 2 (02:26:08):

How'd that car come pick her up?

Video Dwayne (02:26:10):

What do you mean?

Video: Speaker 2 (02:26:10):

The Cadillac El Dorado, how did she arrange for that? How did that car-

Video Dwayne (02:26:19):

I told you there's something between her and that other guy. The guy that hired me to come and do the thing. I told you that in the beginning. There was something there. There was something there. There was already a prearranged thing there. Okay? I think she had a backup plan. I'm not really sure. I'm sure if she really went to the expense to get the fuck here.

Video: Speaker 2 (02:26:39):

Can I be honest? I don't believe you on that.

Video Dwayne (02:26:43):

And you don't have to.

Video: Speaker 2 (02:26:45):

You've given this whole thing about tangible things that just disappear.

Video Dwayne (02:26:51):

I know.

Video: Speaker 2 (02:26:52):

And people that exist but don't exist and look like everybody in Marion County.

Video Dwayne (02:27:02):

[inaudible 02:27:03] time.

Video: Speaker 2 (02:27:02):

The thing is you're trying to create this elaborate story that gives you-

Video Dwayne (02:27:09):

I'm not.

Video: Speaker 2 (02:27:10):

... all cleanliness of nothing to do with this and any wrongdoing. I just don't believe you.

Video Dwayne (02:27:16):

Okay, that's fine.

Video: Speaker 2 (02:27:19):

I think that-

Video Dwayne (02:27:20):

I already told the wife that nobody had ever fucking believed that this fucking happened. I already know. I already knew, which is why until the direct questions were asked, I didn't even bother bringing it the fuck up.

Video: Speaker 2 (02:27:28):

Yeah.

Video Dwayne (02:27:33):

Why would I? Why would I? [inaudible 02:27:37].

Video: Speaker 2 (02:27:36):

Because if you know what the end result is of this whole thing, just be upfront with the information that you know. You indicated that you didn't know her at all, that you had never even met with her when this first came up. And now you're talking about having sex with her, recording things and then deleting them. And I guess from my perspective, if you can try to understand it, it doesn't look great.

Video Dwayne (02:27:58):

I already know it doesn't look great. And there's a whole big reason for why that information comes about the way it does from me at this particular juncture. Okay? There's a huge reason for that because one, I already knew nobody would fucking believe me. I already knew. I already knew. Me and my wife already talked about that part. Nobody would ever believe what happened. Nobody. Nobody would ever believe me.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:28:22):

I think the fact that you recorded her...

Video Dwayne (02:28:25):

I tried to record her. I wanted to get her side of the story on the fucking thing.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:28:30):

Which is really important because it's support, which is what I'm telling you is that I know that you helped her. The recording would help prove that to us, but I don't need that recording to believe you that she was asking for your help. I 100% know that she was asking you for your help. That recording doesn't give me anything that I need to believe what you're telling me. Do you understand?

Video Dwayne (02:28:58):

Yeah, I get you but it's-

Video Interviewer 1 (02:28:58):

But I believe it.

Video Dwayne (02:28:58):

I deleted it.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:28:58):

But I also know-

Video Dwayne (02:28:58):

[inaudible 02:29:03].

Video Interviewer 1 (02:29:03):

Well, the video to me doesn't matter because I believe you that she came to you and that you probably wanted that video because you felt like you may not be believed by us.

Video Dwayne (02:29:15):

Yeah. [inaudible 02:29:15]. Yeah. 100%.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:29:15):

I have her communications though, so I know what she was doing and I know what she was asking of you to do. And so I don't need that video to prove that she was the one that wanted this to happen because I know that in her own words, not taken by you, but in her own words that she sent out on her way here. Do you understand that? That video, you took it to protect yourself, but you didn't really need to take that video to protect yourself because I know she asked you to do it. Does that make sense?

Video Dwayne (02:29:45):

And that is why at the end of the day, I still don't know where the fuck she ended up. I still don't know what happened to her.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:30:02):

It does not make any sense that right before you picked her up, you bought rope and a shovel and tires.

Video Dwayne (02:30:10):

Yeah, I know that doesn't make any sense.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:30:15):

Help me make sense of that. Why would you buy a shovel?

Video Dwayne (02:30:19):

It was actually a thing that I was already there. I was actually planning on going any fucking way, and the time was just really retarded on my behalf because I hadn't fucking actually thought about it. I realized how bad it was stupid asking me for that little fucking thing. And I actually absolutely did not [inaudible 02:30:44].

Video Interviewer 1 (02:30:44):

You went back for it though you didn't even originally buy it?

Video Dwayne (02:30:44):

No.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:30:44):

So why in that moment were you like, "I need this?"

Video Dwayne (02:30:44):

That was because it wasn't where... No, I didn't actually go back for it. What happened was when I went to go look at the camping supplies for the shorter shovel that I wanted in my vehicle as part of my kit that I've been looking for, for months, it wasn't there. And then I realized that I though it was all Christmas shit. Okay, it's Walmart. I though it was all Christmas shit. And then I realized the Garden Center was still open, so I went back there and checked what they had there. That's why there's two receipts, one for sporting goods and then one from home and garden.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:31:15):

Do you see why right before you pick up a person that you initially claimed you didn't know?

Video Dwayne (02:31:22):

Yeah, I know. I know.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:31:22):

You're picking up items for bondage, which we know both of you were into.

Video Dwayne (02:31:27):

Yeah.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:31:27):

Extreme bondage.

Video Dwayne (02:31:29):

Yeah.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:31:29):

You get a shovel.

Video Dwayne (02:31:32):

Yeah. And like I said-

Video Interviewer 1 (02:31:33):

Get some bug spray.

Video Dwayne (02:31:33):

It was not bug spray.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:31:33):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (02:31:37):

I told you already.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:31:38):

Oh, gun spray.

Video Dwayne (02:31:39):

Yeah, yeah. Lube and clean.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:31:42):

Okay. Tell me about that. Why in that moment did you need that?

Video Dwayne (02:31:45):

Because my wife's firearm that I usually keep in my truck was developing rust on the trigger and the rear safety, and I didn't have any ammo.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:31:57):

Did she use your gun?

Video Dwayne (02:31:58):

Who? No. Oh, hell no. No. No, fuck no. Nobody touched that gun but me and my wife.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:31:58):

Did you use it?

Video Dwayne (02:32:10):

No, no, no. I'm not dumb. If I was going to kill somebody, I sure as fuck won't do it with a fucking bullet that can be traced back to the gun and then take my wife's gun away. No, fuck no. That is a whole nother set of fucking charges now.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:32:21):

It'd be your hands.

Video Dwayne (02:32:24):

Excuse my French-

Video Interviewer 1 (02:32:26):

No, I understand. I got to ask.

Video Dwayne (02:32:26):

But get the fuck out of here with that.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:32:26):

I got to ask, you said the gun was in the car and you bought gun stuff.

Video Dwayne (02:32:26):

Like I said-

Video Interviewer 1 (02:32:32):

So I wouldn't be doing my job.

Video Dwayne (02:32:33):

... because there was rust on the trigger. There was developing rust on the trigger and there was developing rust on the rear safety. So I wanted to clean that up when I was going to have a chance.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:32:43):

When's the last time you used the gun?

Video Dwayne (02:32:47):

That gun hasn't been fired in probably about a year.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:32:48):

Okay. Loaded?

Video Dwayne (02:32:50):

Oh yeah, it's loaded.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:32:51):

What kind of-

Video Dwayne (02:32:54):

No, no, no. Hold on. Let me rephrase, okay?

Video Interviewer 1 (02:32:55):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (02:32:56):

Yes, it is loaded currently. Yes, it is loaded. It is loaded with hollow points and it's chambered 45 ABC. It's [inaudible 02:33:08].

Video Interviewer 1 (02:33:02):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (02:33:02):

It's my fucking [inaudible 02:33:10].

Video Interviewer 1 (02:33:02):

Okay. Do you have any other guns?

Video Dwayne (02:33:02):

My wife does. I don't have guns. My wife has guns.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:33:15):

Okay. So it's your wife's gun?

Video Dwayne (02:33:16):

Yeah.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:33:16):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (02:33:20):

It's my wife's gun, but I carry it because it's a M1911 that I love.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:33:20):

Okay. So when's the last time that you fired it?

Video Dwayne (02:33:29):

Oh, man. We went to the Ocala gun range 18 months or more ago.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:33:31):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (02:33:34):

They don't get fired very often anymore because she's sick.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:33:36):

Okay. So you got the cleaner. Have you used the cleaner?

Video Dwayne (02:33:36):

Yeah.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:33:36):

When did you use the cleaner?

Video Dwayne (02:33:36):

I cleaned it up this weekend, this past weekend.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:33:45):

While you were at the Airbnb?

Video Dwayne (02:33:49):

Mm-hmm. Actually, you're going to find I was sitting in my truck while I was doing it. You're going to find sliders and that oil all over the rocker panel.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:34:00):

Okay. And did you unload and load it while you were there? How did you clean your gun? Tell me about that.

Video Dwayne (02:34:04):

Oh yeah, I always unload.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:34:05):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (02:34:05):

Always unload and reload. Same bullets. Same bullets. Same everything.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:34:05):

What's the capacity of the 19?

Video Dwayne (02:34:16):

I'm thinking that one is... I always get confused because I always run out of bullets when I'm shooting it. It's either six or 18. Not 18. [inaudible 02:34:20]. I think standard load is eight. There's always one in the chamber, so [inaudible 02:34:34].

Video Interviewer 1 (02:34:38):

Okay. So you understand that when we find her, and we will find her, that if you helped her and you're not telling us the truth about that now, that it's going to make her really bad. It's sort of like the sex, how I was telling you.

Video Dwayne (02:34:54):

Yeah, yeah.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:34:54):

So this is why I'm telling you that we know that, that DNA and all of that kind of stuff is going to be in that Airbnb. And if you sat here and you tried to say that all of those things that we knew happened, because that's why she came here, didn't happen, and then we get the forensics. Then you're trying to explain your way out of it, and then you look like a liar, right?

Video Dwayne (02:35:18):

Yeah.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:35:18):

And then it becomes something different. Was it rape? Did she not want it?

Video Dwayne (02:35:20):

Right.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:35:20):

Right?

Video Dwayne (02:35:20):

No, it's like I already told you. You leveled with me about what you're doing. I leveled you with you about what happened.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:35:21):

Right. So same thing goes for a body, right?

Video Dwayne (02:35:21):

Did you find her?

Video Interviewer 1 (02:35:37):

What I'm saying is-

Video Dwayne (02:35:40):

Did you find her? But at the same time, like I said, I don't fucking know about that. I don't know what happened, where it happened. I don't know anything about anything about what happened to her. My last contact with her was later that fucking night [inaudible 02:36:01].

Video Interviewer 1 (02:36:02):

And how did that contact go?

Video Dwayne (02:36:05):

She just left.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:36:08):

When?

Video Dwayne (02:36:08):

Like I said, she left me around about the same time that I was in the back room to that [inaudible 02:36:16] on Saturday, I want to say.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:36:22):

Mm-hmm.

Video Dwayne (02:36:22):

Yeah, Saturday night because I left Sunday morning.

Video: Speaker 2 (02:36:25):

How'd she leave again?

Video Dwayne (02:36:27):

El Dorado.

Video: Speaker 2 (02:36:29):

And I'm telling you that's a lie because we've already checked, there's no El Dorados anywhere near here in the last three months.

Video Dwayne (02:36:37):

No El Dorados anywhere near here in the last three months?

Video: Speaker 2 (02:36:39):

Uh-huh. License plate readers all over the state of Florida, not a single El Dorado anywhere in the last three months.

Video Dwayne (02:36:46):

I'm telling you, man.

Video: Speaker 2 (02:36:51):

I'd like it if you tell me the truth because I think it's just another thing that you're not being honest about. This whole thing, you started at the beginning with never heard of her, no idea what's going on. Then it's, "Oh, we had sex, but first I was in the thing alone. She might have been there. I don't know. She wasn't there when I was there, but then she was there because we were having sex together and then I tried to record a conversation with her, but then I deleted that." And then all these phone calls that you received that would clear you of everything and all these transactions that would clear you of everything, but it's all just got deleted because of this guy that looks like an average guy everywhere, but just made it all disappear.

Video Dwayne (02:37:38):

I know that part of it-

Video: Speaker 2 (02:37:38):

It sounds really ridiculous.

Video Dwayne (02:37:38):

Yeah, it does.

Video: Speaker 2 (02:37:38):

Honestly, it sounds ridiculous.

Video Dwayne (02:37:38):

I agree with you. I agree with you though.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:37:46):

We'll have your phone records and it's going to show that none of those calls happened and you know that. We're both sitting in here. We know that those calls didn't happen.

Video Dwayne (02:37:53):

I'm telling you that shit is gone out of my phone.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:37:55):

Maybe out of your phone, but Verizon tracks it. So Verizon is saying those calls never happened.

Video: Speaker 2 (02:38:02):

The cell towers themselves log with Verizon every time a phone connects to them.

Video Dwayne (02:38:06):

Yeah, I'm well aware that that's how that works. I'm telling you that it's gone. I don't know where the fuck it went. It makes absolutely no sense that I would've only received so few fucking calls. Okay?

Video: Speaker 2 (02:38:18):

You not being honest with us.

Video Dwayne (02:38:23):

You can look at my call logs. You can see that all my call logs are extensive. There's just 15, 20 calls a day coming in.

Video: Speaker 2 (02:38:27):

Because something happened that day out of the ordinary that doesn't happen at the times around all of that. You picked her up from the airport. She came here to see you. You guys prearranged it. And yes, you were out there. It was a weekend that was out of the ordinary, and so you made less phone calls because it was something that was not part of your normal day-to-day schedules. That's what I'm saying. To me, that-

Video Dwayne (02:39:00):

That makes the most sense. I'm sorry. That makes the most sense. But I didn't close my business down.

Video: Speaker 2 (02:39:08):

I didn't say you closed your business down.

Video Dwayne (02:39:10):

But that's where all the phone calls normally come from. Why is there no call logs for that day? They're gone. They're gone.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:39:13):

The call logs aren't gone. They don't exist.

Video Dwayne (02:39:13):

Again, they don't exist. They're gone.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:39:23):

You know why? Because if you put your phone on airplane mode, you don't receive them, and you did put your phone on airplane mode.

Video Dwayne (02:39:29):

No, I didn't.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:39:29):

Or close the cellular service so you couldn't get call logs. We have that from Verizon.

Video Dwayne (02:39:36):

No.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:39:36):

Yes.

Video Dwayne (02:39:36):

I don't know what you have from Verizon, but I never did anything like that. That, I can guarantee you. I had to leave my phone available. I had to be able to be available to be contacted.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:39:47):

Unless something happened that you needed to be able to focus on what was happening and not be dealing with phone calls coming in and nobody being able to see.

Video Dwayne (02:39:59):

Well, I understand where you're going with that line and with that line of thinking, I absolutely get on both of your parts. I do. That simply was not the case. The phone never went to an airplane mode or a shutdown mode or anything like that. My phone never did that. Not once. My phone hardly ever even gets restarted. It got restarted the other day because-

Judge (02:40:23):

Okay. Ladies and gentlemen, we've been going for about another hour and 10 minutes. We're going to take another recess here. We've got about an hour and 10 minutes left to go. So leave your notepads here, face down, close them up. On the recess, don't speak with one another about the case. Don't use electronic devices to research the case or learn about the case or communicate about the case. We will see you back probably about 11:10 or so. As soon as you all have gotten coffee, use the restroom. We'll be ready to get you all back. Okay?

(02:40:46)
The record should reflect the jury has left the courtroom. Is there anything we need to take up before we take a recess?

Speaker 6 (02:41:38):

Not from the state, Your Honor.

Speaker 7 (02:41:39):

Not from the defense, Your Honor.

Judge (02:41:40):

Okay. Now for everybody in the audience, I'm going to try to keep this break as short as possible. So we're at about 10:02, 10:03 right now. I'm sorry, 11:02, 11:03 right now. I'm trying to be back in here by 10 after if y'all can. We'll start quickly. Okay.

Speaker 10 (02:41:52):

All rise.

Judge (02:47:55):

Y'all remain seated. Thank you. Just one moment. Okay. For benefit of the record, parties are back in the courtroom. Mr. Hall is at counsel table. Are you ready for the jury, State?

Speaker 9 (02:48:00):

We are, Your Honor.

Judge (02:48:00):

Defense?

Speaker 9 (02:48:00):

Yes, your Honor.

Judge (02:48:00):

Okay. Let's go ahead and bring them in. You know what, lawyers? Hold on one second. One second. I have them wait one second. Lawyers all can be seated. There's something I did want to bring up.

Speaker 11 (02:48:00):

[inaudible 02:48:58]

Judge (02:49:32):

Yeah. I tell all the jurors they can all have drinks, snacks [inaudible 02:49:05], that's fine.

(02:49:32)
All right. As we were getting into the interview there, Detective Miller at one point said to the defendant something to the effect like, "I don't believe you." I think it would be appropriate for the court to instruct the jury using instruction 2.8, recorded interview. And when I heard that... Obviously it's not been given yet, but I think I can give it now. It's being given probably 10 minutes after I first heard a statement to which this instruction is obviously applicable.

(02:50:06)
I'll give it now and I will tell them that they have been watching and they will be continuing to watch the recorded interview that contains opinions and statements by Detective Rebecca McKenzie or Special Agent Rebecca McKenzie and Sergeant Joseph Miller, that their opinion and statements that have been made in the interview and that may be made from this point forward are pertinent only to explain the reactions and responses that they elicit, that they're not to consider these statements or opinions as true, but only to establish the context of his reactions and responses. State, any objection to the court giving that instruction?

Speaker 8 (02:50:42):

Not at all, Your Honor.

Judge (02:50:43):

Defense, any objection?

Speaker 9 (02:50:45):

No, Your Honor.

Judge (02:50:45):

Okay. Is there anything else you would want me to do as sort of a curative for the opinions and statements that have already been made by Detective McKenzie and Sergeant Miller, aside from what I'm intending to do here that they've already heard?

Speaker 9 (02:51:02):

No, sir.

Judge (02:51:03):

Okay. All right. Very well. Let's go ahead and bring in the jury.

(02:51:06)
Ladies and gentlemen, welcome back. Parties, you all can be seated. Thank you. Members of the jury, we're going to begin watching the interview again in a minute. I did want to read another instruction to you that I need you all to consider and follow. Okay. You are about to continue hearing and watching a recorded interview that contains opinions and statements by Special Agent Rebecca McKenzie and Sergeant Joseph Miller, law enforcement officers, to Mr. Dwain Hall. And you're going to continue watching that interview and obviously you have been watching it.

(02:52:42)
The opinion and statements made by Detective or Special Agent Rebecca McKenzie and Sergeant Joseph Miller are pertinent only to explain the reactions and responses they elicit. You are not to consider these opinions and statements by the police officers as true, but only to establish the context of Mr. Hall's reactions and responses. So with that being said, we'll go ahead and resume the interview.

(02:53:06)
Oh, sorry, Mr. Buxman.

Video Dwayne (02:53:17):

My wife was in the car at the same fucking time.

Judge (02:53:20):

And I want to be clear that instruction applies to statements made by the police officers that you will hear going forward in the remainder of the interview and statements that they have made up to this point. And that governs you in your consideration of this evidence. So with that said, you can play. I'm sorry, Mr. Buxman.

Video Dwayne (02:53:37):

And it just was spreading all over the place on GPS. There was something wrong. And that was shortly after everything. So like I said, something happened that I don't know what happened. I don't know how it happened. I have no explanation for it. I don't just not get phone calls.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:53:52):

You said you and your wife had conversations about what happened over the weekend and that you [inaudible 02:53:55]. Did you tell her that you were meeting with this person?

Video Dwayne (02:53:54):

What did you say? No, I didn't tell her.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:54:11):

No, I'm just curious because you said she was-

Video Dwayne (02:54:17):

No, I described a few outcomes about whole fucking-

Video Interviewer 1 (02:54:18):

Weird things that happened.

Video Dwayne (02:54:19):

Yeah, the weird shit that happened.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:54:21):

Yeah.

Video Dwayne (02:54:23):

I told her about the weird shit that happened. And then she's like she agrees with me. There ain't no way that they fucking ever [inaudible 02:54:39].

Video: Speaker 2 (02:54:38):

Are you being threatened by anyone to be here? Or not to be here, but to... Are you being threatened by anyone to not be completely honest with us here? Is what I'm trying to say. Is anyone threatening you?

Video Dwayne (02:54:43):

And how in the would I tell you that if I was?

Video: Speaker 2 (02:54:49):

Did they ask, did these guys, these mysterious people that wipe phone logs and do all these things, did they ask you to hide a body?

Video Dwayne (02:54:55):

No. Yeah, 100% no. 100% no.

Video: Speaker 2 (02:55:04):

I mean, you bought a shovel.

Video Dwayne (02:55:05):

Yeah, yeah.

Video: Speaker 2 (02:55:05):

You bought [inaudible 02:55:07].

Video Dwayne (02:55:09):

I made some bad choices there in regards to everything that was going on.

Video: Speaker 2 (02:55:14):

So if they made you do something or asked you to do something, if they paid you to do one thing and then were like, "Hey, you're going to do this too." I mean, I can understand that, but we're missing something here with everything that you're telling us.

Video Dwayne (02:55:26):

I'm missing something here too, apparently. I don't have the whole fucking thing. Either way it goes. Sorry, [inaudible 02:55:39] where you fucking sit and stand. But here we are.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:55:37):

I don't know you can [inaudible 02:55:48].

Video Dwayne (02:55:37):

Barely.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:55:37):

You did it a few times and you said you did it all over the place.

Video Dwayne (02:55:37):

Yeah, absolutely.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:55:37):

So I feel like when you put your mind to something, you can make it happen.

Video Dwayne (02:56:02):

Yeah. I mean, I get where you're going with it at the same fucking time. I would have a very distinct feeling that it would be a lot fucking different when you're trying to pick up anything, like anything, because I had a hard time doing tire changes and stuff. I can barely lift the tires off the fucking spins and I can barely. I've always been a problem that I can't hold up. It's one thing to go in and out. It's one thing to lift.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:56:44):

But if you promised her that you would help her with it, motivation, right? Let's get it done, let me do... Plus probably the fear of, oh, shit, I promised to help her with this. And you guys did everything you could to make sure that nothing was tracked, but unfortunately we were able to track both of you. She did a pretty decent job, but there's technology that people aren't aware of. So there clearly was intention from both of you to not be seen with one another, not to be associated with one another, and because of what her intentions were, and she probably didn't want you to get cracked up in it because you were helping her out. So all of those things make sense.

(02:57:39)
What doesn't make sense and what isn't the truth is that you didn't finish out what you told her that you would be able to do for her because it happened. It happened. You did what she wanted you to do. And I don't have a problem with that. She's an adult.

Video Dwayne (02:58:04):

Well, see, the thing is you may not have a problem with that, you may not look down on me for that. If I did have anything to do with the ending of that kind of thing, you don't have to have a problem with it. Legally, there's a problem with it. And I've been trying my damnedest, like I've said, maintained from the beginning. I'm trying my damnedest to be an upstanding citizen, a good person. I have a job that helps people out. I'm not trying to be wrapped up in shit. I'm just not.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:58:35):

So you think coming out and saying, "You know what? Whether people morally agree with it or not, here's something that I did to help someone out," versus you don't get an opportunity to basically share your side of it, which is, I did this to help a person who was very clear, it's in writing, I've already told you that, that this is what she wanted to have happen versus after the fact, and then the narrative gets spun a different way.

Video Dwayne (02:59:04):

It's going to get spun a different way no matter what the fuck happens from here on out.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:59:05):

Why?

Video Dwayne (02:59:08):

I'm either a suspect or I'm not.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:59:12):

A suspect in what though? That's the question.

Video Dwayne (02:59:16):

Well, as far as I understand it, legally, isn't that if you end a person's life, isn't that murder? I'm either a suspect or I'm not. The rest of my life is gone. I'm never going to be able to help my wife. I'm never going to be able to do anything. She's going to have to live with the knowledge that all this fucking shit, are you crazy, why would I want to be anywhere involved in any of this shit at the end of it anyway? Why would I want anything to do with that at that point? I told you my whole perspective on life absolutely changed after watching my wife get here to fucking pass away.

Video Interviewer 1 (02:59:49):

But I think you had an opportunity because you met somebody that could fulfill what you clearly said are tendencies that you have, and you had somebody that was willing to consent to that.

Video Dwayne (03:00:02):

These things all fell away when my wife [inaudible 03:00:03] died. When she wasn't in there anymore, everything about everything changed here. Everything here changed everything. Even though I might have liked that at one point or thought it was cool or enjoyed talking about it, I rarely did after that. I rarely, rarely even talked about being aggressive or anything like that. Even the kind of porn I watched started changing because that broke something. [inaudible 03:00:37].

Video: Speaker 2 (03:00:36):

I think those feelings came back, honestly.

Video Dwayne (03:00:36):

You think what you need to think.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:00:54):

I mean the feelings did come back because she came here and she met you and that means that those feelings did come back.

Video: Speaker 2 (03:01:04):

Spent a weekend with her. She didn't get picked up by that car. You're saying you didn't have a body. Did you give her a ride somewhere?

Video Dwayne (03:01:19):

No matter what I do right now, I'm pretty much fucked. [inaudible 03:01:28].

Video: Speaker 2 (03:01:31):

I can't tell you what you are because you're not telling me everything. So to give you a direct answer, you have to give me a straight answer.

Video Dwayne (03:01:48):

I'm not sure. I'm thinking about that dirty word real fucking hard right now. I feel like, I don't know. I don't know what I feel like, to be honest. I think that whatever you guys are looking for, you've got plenty of time to find it in my vehicle.

Video: Speaker 2 (03:02:14):

Tell me more about the Eldorado that came. You said it was quiet.

Video Dwayne (03:02:16):

Yeah.

Video: Speaker 2 (03:02:16):

You said it was long.

Video Dwayne (03:02:16):

Super quiet. Yeah.

Video: Speaker 2 (03:02:25):

But there's no record of it.

Video Dwayne (03:02:25):

I know there's no record of it. You've been missing the whole entire damn thing. The entire damn thing, the entire fucking thing, the whole way. You missed the part about these cars. I told you, every time I went back to that garage, there was new cars there.

Video: Speaker 2 (03:02:39):

How did they get there? They just [inaudible 03:02:42] appeared?

Video Dwayne (03:02:43):

No, I'm thinking that there's a car carrier or more involved in transporting these vehicles. There's no way that they just... Obviously they just don't appear out of thin air and I wasn't there for a few hours, right? So what's happening is they're bringing a car carrier and loading them up, moving them off somewhere else. Why wouldn't the Eldorado be the same fucking?

Video: Speaker 2 (03:03:04):

There's no record of any car carriers moving in that area.

Video Dwayne (03:03:08):

In that area?

Video: Speaker 2 (03:03:08):

No, there's not. There's no Eldorado. There's no car carriers. That stuff didn't happen.

Video Dwayne (03:03:16):

I'm telling you that.

Video: Speaker 2 (03:03:16):

And I'm telling you-

Video Dwayne (03:03:16):

You're telling me that it didn't happen because you have proof and it's on... There's no measures and there's no readers and everything else. I'm not being aggressive. I'm just saying I understand where you're coming from because I do not know what-

Video: Speaker 2 (03:03:29):

We're just looking for answers. I'm looking for answers and I'm telling you the stuff you're telling me isn't fitting with what we know.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:03:35):

Dwain, why am I sitting here?

Video Dwayne (03:03:35):

Because you have evidence and you're going to lock me the fuck-up.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:03:35):

No. Why am I sitting here? I told you why I was sitting here. So why am I sitting here?

Video Dwayne (03:03:35):

I don't know.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:03:35):

You do know. Why am I sitting here talking to you?

Video Dwayne (03:03:35):

Because you want to find a missing person.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:03:35):

She has a name. What's her name?

Video Dwayne (03:03:35):

You want to find Sonia.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:03:35):

I want to find Sonia. And why do I want to find her?

Video Dwayne (03:03:35):

Because you want to return her to her family.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:03:35):

That is why I'm sitting here. This doesn't have anything to do with you in the way that you think that it has to do with you.

Video Dwayne (03:03:35):

I'm sure it fucking does though. I can't... Guys, I'm sorry. I can't trust you guys like that. I can't believe what you guys said.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:03:35):

What have we said that you don't believe?

Video Dwayne (03:03:35):

I don't know. I am quite literally broken like that. I just can't believe what you guys are telling me.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:03:35):

So do you not believe that why I'm sitting across from you right now is to find Sonia?

Video Dwayne (03:04:51):

No, I believe that 100%. I do, and I get it. If it was my family member, I would hope that they drove up someplace too. But at the same time, if it was my family member that said I'm leaving to go kill myself.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:05:07):

What do you mean [inaudible 03:05:12]?

Video Dwayne (03:05:12):

That would be the end of that. I would assume that I'm not going to find them because they finally followed through.

Video: Speaker 2 (03:05:16):

But people need closure. The average... And you may not personally, but the average person needs closure. If someone is dead, they need a body. They need something to let them know that, yes, this person is deceased. This person is dead. They're not going to stay up every night wondering if they're just going to walk through the door and come in one day.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:05:36):

They're not going to keep checking their phones to see if she's calling, right? That's what it's about. It's about closure.

Video Dwayne (03:05:36):

It's about closure, and then it's also about whoever helped her and whatever they need to help her, and then the administration justice after that. And this is where the trust breaks down for me. This is where my trust in law enforcement period breaks. I don't have anything that I can tell you.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:05:36):

You don't have anything that you can tell us or you won't tell us?

Video Dwayne (03:05:36):

I don't have anything I can tell you.

Video: Speaker 2 (03:05:36):

What would you tell her family? They're not law enforcement. What would you tell her family?

Video Dwayne (03:05:36):

I would tell her family that the last time I seen her, she looked like she was happy and going to get what she wanted.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:05:36):

And that's what they reported to me, that the last couple of weeks before she left, she was in a really good place. And we know-

Video Dwayne (03:07:07):

She was in a really good place because... And I'll tell you exactly why she was in a really good place. Well, I don't know. She may have had other reasons, but from my point of view, she was in a really good place because I literally helped her change her daily routines that put her in a really good place.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:07:15):

She was in a really good place because people who want to die by suicide, when the decision has been made, they've made that decision and they have taken steps in order to make it happen. A burden is lifted and they have something to look forward to. So those last couple of weeks that she was in the UK after she bought those flights, she was in a good place and she was happy because she had made a plan. She was relying on you and trusted on you to help her carry that plan out. And that burden that she was carrying around with her had been lifted. That's why she was in a good mood. That's what people who are suicidal, when that decision has been made and they get what they want, like you said, they're happy. That's why she was happy.

Video Dwayne (03:08:10):

I'm glad she was happy. I don't know but she was loud and happy in her life. And I know what it's like to live with depression like that.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:08:18):

But what's left behind is a family that needs closure. The family also understands what she was asking for and what was going on. So it's not like they think that she was near over here and had no idea what was going to happen. They're very well aware, but they need that closure so that they can go... Have you ever expected something, but you know that it's not going to happen, but in the back of your mind you're like, "Maybe it will happen. Maybe I will get that phone call." And people who have loved ones that are missing, even if they know in their heart that person is dead and they're not coming back, if we don't give them that closure, they are up at night.

(03:09:06)
They can't sleep because that little part of their brain that hooks, there's some sort of miracle that that person, that we're confused or we made a mistake is still there until we can say no, then here she is. She's not coming home. You can quit checking your emails. You can quit checking her accounts. You can quit checking her phone.

Video Dwayne (03:09:33):

And of course you got to have proof that she's not coming home in order to be able to tell them that too. [inaudible 03:09:39] your proof in this case would be her.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:09:46):

Right.

Video Dwayne (03:09:46):

It really sucks.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:09:46):

It does.

Video: Speaker 2 (03:09:50):

This doesn't have to be as black and white as I think you're interpreting it from us. I mean, there's lots of things that I see could have happened, right? You could be a cold-blooded murderer that just took her out, shot her, did whatever, killed her in some way. You described using her hands, you talked about having a gun. I don't know if it was any of those. It could have been an accident. It could have been something that you two were engaging in your bondage and something went too far. It could have been something that she wanted and you did it for her. It could have been something as you drove her somewhere and she killed herself and you just don't give her a ride. There's options to all this. It's not just black and white murder or not murder.

Video Dwayne (03:10:42):

So humor me. Through those options in the same order, basically. What's the penalty for any one of those?

Video: Speaker 2 (03:10:55):

Depends on the circumstances around it.

Video Dwayne (03:10:57):

Okay. So go ahead. Just humor me. Tell me what's the penalty? What would a person be looking at?

Video: Speaker 2 (03:11:05):

It depends on all the circumstances. You could go to jail, you may not go to jail.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:11:20):

You can have anything from a misdemeanor to, like he said, you came after off the street and committed capital, but that's not what this is.

Video Dwayne (03:11:20):

Right. So in your opinion on what this is, you tell me what I'm looking at. What kind of fine am I looking at?

Video: Speaker 2 (03:11:24):

You're not telling me what it is that's happening. So I can't give you an answer as to what I think that's happening. I've had homicide cases closed with letters where the state attorney's office won't prosecute it because the facts don't line up to the statute of murder.

Video Dwayne (03:11:39):

Yeah, but that's not what I'm asking you about.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:11:41):

No, what you're asking us is to answer a question without conduct-

Video: Speaker 2 (03:11:49):

I've had people tell me the truth right here in this room and I've had them walk out of here because the state attorney's office won't file... It's happened in mine. And let me tell you, the surprise that I have when these things happen is astronomical. So I'm telling you, when I told you earlier that there isn't a thing you could tell me that wouldn't surprise me or wouldn't shake me, I'm telling you. Whatever you tell me is not going to surprise me.

Video Dwayne (03:12:08):

Okay. If you were me, I don't understand. Nevermind. That's a dumb ass idea. Just like mine shovel.

Video: Speaker 2 (03:12:08):

Is she buried somewhere?

Video Dwayne (03:12:08):

What the fuck do I know? How am I supposed to know that?

Video Interviewer 1 (03:12:08):

You know. You're just afraid to tell us because you're afraid of... You don't know what the consequences of telling us are.

Video Dwayne (03:12:08):

No, if there was anything in relation to that, if there's any kernel of truth to what you just said, what you just said, it's not afraid of the consequences.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:12:08):

If there are consequences-

Video Dwayne (03:12:08):

There's a cold side of you that don't give a fuck about consequences once it gets to a certain point.

Video: Speaker 2 (03:12:08):

Does it go against what she wanted?

Video Dwayne (03:12:08):

Either way I answer that is like an admission of some kind of guilt, no matter what it is. And I'm being reported right now. So whatever I say, like I said, can't use against me in the court of law. So answering that question is not in my best interest.

Video: Speaker 2 (03:12:08):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (03:13:37):

Okay?

Video Interviewer 1 (03:13:38):

But you understand there's a difference between helping somebody do something that they wanted to do as a consenting adult versus not asking?

Video Dwayne (03:13:38):

No, not where the law is concerned. I do not understand that, not in the slightest, which is exactly why I was asking you to tell me what the reciprocal charge would be, not about all the other hindrance bullshit that goes along with it. Yes, if you pick somebody up off the street and you got them [inaudible 03:13:51] or whatever, okay, you snuff them out. That's got to be murder. The murder one, murder two. If you hit somebody with a car and there's an accident and they die, it's manslaughter. What are those other things that you were talking about?

Video: Speaker 2 (03:14:06):

As far as which one? Which one-

Video Dwayne (03:14:14):

I don't know. I don't know. You're fucking up my head right now, and this is when I'm under stress is when I have a hard time remembering shit. It's like immediate short term. Okay.

Video: Speaker 2 (03:14:24):

Was it an accident? Because that's one of the options that I mentioned. I mentioned an accident-

Video Dwayne (03:14:33):

Obviously an accident, I already covered that. That's manslaughter.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:14:36):

Not necessarily.

Video: Speaker 2 (03:14:37):

It may fall under that as far as the general statute potential is concerned, but it doesn't mean someone goes to jail over it.

Video Dwayne (03:14:46):

Yeah, I'm not asking. I'm not asking about jail time. See, my problem is no matter what I say, no matter how, what, where, when, why, at the end of the day, my only concern is a twofold concern. Obviously, one, obviously I'm not a murderer. Okay? Not like you would Ted Bundy style. Not a murderer. I'm worried about being able to keep my business over and keep the lifeline going for my wife. She literally has a subscription to life right now. It's like 50 some fucking dollars a month in copays. We got lucky that way. And obviously you know what the other side of that is, being able to take care of my wife. I cannot do that from behind bars no matter what. And there's nothing that I can tell you right now that's not going to land me there either circumstantially or any other way because it all looks so shit and bad.

(03:15:46)
It's just like you said, there's no Eldorado. There's no Eldorado. There's no car haulers. There's nothing. Nothing that I'm telling you makes any fucking sense right now. You're telling me that Verizon said that no calls happened that day, that my phone run into airplane mode mysteriously or miraculously or some shit like that. I'm at loss on all of that end of it. Okay?

Video: Speaker 2 (03:16:09):

As far as accidents go, I've seen cases where guns accidentally go off. You asked for some examples, so I'm giving you an example.

Video Dwayne (03:16:19):

Just tell me that right now [inaudible 03:16:22] a gun and been fired in over 18 years.

Video: Speaker 2 (03:16:25):

Okay. Gun going off if someone's cleaning it, if someone's just messing with it. I've seen guns go off, kill their best friends, and they don't face jail over it. Yes, there's an investigation to make sure that everyone gets cleared, but in the end they didn't go to jail over it.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:16:42):

Another potential rough sex, right? Rough sex, choking, not realizing I'm about to cum and I'm squeezing a little bit too hard.

Video Dwayne (03:16:54):

That is a very irresponsible and inexperienced dom that does that.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:16:59):

But it happens.

Video Dwayne (03:16:59):

It does happen.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:16:59):

So I'm giving you an example of-

Video Dwayne (03:16:59):

Yeah, I'm just saying that no.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:17:06):

But you're experienced, so that wouldn't happen.

Video Dwayne (03:17:08):

I'm very experienced. Not that it wouldn't happen because like you said, accidents do happen, but I can promise you she was alive when I was done. She was alive when I was done, that didn't happen. But yeah, I asked for examples and shit like that. Right now I just feel like no matter what I say, what I don't say or anything like that, my freedom's over, my life is over.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:17:41):

‍

Can you help me understand that, why you feel that way?

Video Dwayne (03:17:45):

Because no matter what I say, it's going to lead to something far more drastic. And if it doesn't result in me losing my lifeline and all that, then I'm going to lose my wife because I cheated on her already. Something I haven't even been able to bring myself...

Video Dwayne (03:18:00):

I cheated on her already. Something I haven't even been able to bring myself to tell her. I hate the way it goes. I'm fucked anyway, no matter what happens. And while obviously my faith prevents suicide or anything like that. My faith prevents suicide or anything like that because you can't go to the good place if you kill yourself. It just is what it is. You get sent to a purgatory or a hell.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:18:35):

A lot of people don't believe that though.

Video Dwayne (03:18:36):

No.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:18:36):

And Sonia didn't believe that.

Video Dwayne (03:18:39):

I know. I'm pretty sure she didn't. But yeah, or else she would've been trying somewhere to fucking quit.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:18:40):

Where is she?

Video Dwayne (03:18:40):

I can't even tell you that.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:18:40):

[inaudible 03:19:13] Don't let her sit out there. Let me get her back to her family before that happens.

Video: Speaker 2 (03:19:12):

You know what I think, Dwain?

Video Dwayne (03:19:13):

I would love to hear it.

Video: Speaker 2 (03:19:15):

I've been thinking about a lot of this. I think when you give that story about you leaving Sunday and a car following you and you ducking in the woods for a set amount of time and a car driving by, I think that's you accounting for your phone that you already knew at that point we had your locations and such. And I think that you did something with her there at that spot, or that she did something and you were there helping her like she wanted at that spot.

Video Dwayne (03:19:58):

And either way that goes. Okay, let's just use your premise, your scenario there. No extras, no I've seen this or I've seen that. What are the associated charges?

Video: Speaker 2 (03:20:09):

[inaudible 03:20:12].

Video Dwayne (03:20:12):

No, no, no. Just your column A and your column B, okay? Either I help or I did.

Video: Speaker 2 (03:20:21):

Well, it is murder.

Video Dwayne (03:20:23):

Yeah. So what would you want me to tell you?

Video: Speaker 2 (03:20:30):

Just the truth.

Video Dwayne (03:20:31):

Why? So I can throw my fucking life away if I did anything wrong, or if it looks suspicious and you've got enough to build a fucking case.

Video: Speaker 2 (03:20:41):

Were you defending yourself when she was killed? Is that a possibility?

Video Dwayne (03:20:49):

No matter how I answer any of these kinds of questions, it's not going to look well, right? Isn't that the way this goes?

Video: Speaker 2 (03:20:57):

You continuing not to answer questions and not to be upfront about it isn't making you look well.

Video Dwayne (03:21:02):

It's not making anything look well. At the same fucking time, am I not 100%, 150% [inaudible 03:21:11]? Because I'm already here. You have my vehicle. You've got my phone records. You've got everything.

Video: Speaker 2 (03:21:16):

And we now have the multiple stories that you've given us, the inconsistencies. Hang on. So if you're not going to fill in the gaps and help us complete this story, we're going to go with what we have and we're going to move forward.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:21:35):

We just want to return her to her family.

Video: Speaker 2 (03:21:41):

We're searching the woods and we've already identified multiple spots where we're starting to look. And when we find her, it's going to look even worse for you. So that's why I'm telling you right now, give us so we can help explain it.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:22:00):

Because we know it happened, but it matters how it happened. Because if it was something that she wanted, which I've already told you, I have documentation that says so, that changes the story.

Video Dwayne (03:22:18):

I don't even know how that would change the story. Okay?

Video Interviewer 1 (03:22:24):

Because intention matters.

Video Dwayne (03:22:26):

Because what?

Video Interviewer 1 (03:22:26):

Intention. Your intention. You didn't kidnap her, right?

Video Dwayne (03:22:32):

So if I'm following along what everybody's saying here, I think that I want to recant basically my entire statement.

Video: Speaker 2 (03:22:38):

You want to recant your entire statement?

Video Dwayne (03:22:38):

Yes. No, because I need to clear my questions.

Video: Speaker 2 (03:22:38):

Okay.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:22:38):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (03:22:38):

Okay?

Video Interviewer 1 (03:22:49):

We're here to listen.

Video: Speaker 2 (03:22:49):

You said you wanted to recant everything.

Video Dwayne (03:22:52):

I was going to recant literally everything from the past freaking week.

Video: Speaker 2 (03:22:57):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (03:22:57):

And then you're going to hear right now everything as it happened.

Video: Speaker 2 (03:23:02):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (03:23:03):

I met Sonia on Motherless and we started talking. I don't even remember what my screen name was at that particular time. I know that there was a point that I had a couple different screen names and I kept getting the first shift that I didn't understand in terms of service violation, et cetera, et cetera. I think it was a picture that I was posting. I think it was getting flagged. I think the one that was in it is my picture. It's from my friend, but she might have been too close to 18 and it was flagging her as being too young. So it's a terms of service violation because she's small. Okay. I think that's what it might have been. I don't know because you're right, she said damn near anything on there, right?

Video Interviewer 1 (03:23:46):

Yep.

Video Dwayne (03:23:48):

So her and I started talking and whatnot and she was telling me about all of her stuff and things like that. So I started kind of mentoring her and this was probably about two years ago. And I wanted to make her life better. I didn't want her to kill herself. And she met a couple of guys that flaked out on her and decided not to. Like I said, she's always had the luck that they were falling in love with her and couldn't do it or they fight. They got to a certain point this past year, sometime in the past year where she actually offered me to help me with the IRS loan money and she offered to help me with that. She offered to help me with that and I said yes. And from there I started mentoring her a little bit further and she seemed to be getting better.

(03:24:57)
And I'm so stressed right now, my brain is just kind of taking shit on me. I apologize. But it came along, came along and eventually my wife got really sick, really, really fucking sick. And that's when it started working out like a cover story. A cover story that was solid to fall through. But that was the cover story she wanted. It was the cover story she insisted that I stick to. I can't stick to that story. I can't. It's no good at this point. You guys already know that's not part of the [inaudible 03:25:51] anyway. Talk to the neighbors, you did this, you've done that. So I don't even know where the fuck I was at.

Video: Speaker 2 (03:26:05):

Whose cover story was it? I'm sorry.

Video Dwayne (03:26:08):

Hers. Well, we came up with it together.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:26:19):

You mentioned your wife. Are you talking about your wife?

Video: Speaker 2 (03:26:20):

Or Sonia.

Video Dwayne (03:26:20):

Sonia.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:26:20):

Sonia. Okay.

Video: Speaker 2 (03:26:20):

So this is Sonia's cover story that you told us previously?

Video Dwayne (03:26:21):

Yes. It was what we came up with together. She insisted that she did not want to be a burden to me or my wife in the process of getting her needs met. [inaudible 03:26:40]. And I was very appreciative of that and I just wanted to help her. And I'm still going to keep my promise to her that I already made to her prior. She just didn't want to be disturbed anymore, basically. It's the only way I can do that. I'm sorry, I'm going to keep that promise.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:27:06):

Who didn't want to be disturbed?

Video Dwayne (03:27:15):

Her. Sonia.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:27:15):

Sonia didn't want to be disturbed.

Video Dwayne (03:27:18):

Didn't want to be disturbed anymore. After she came here, she wanted that to be it. She didn't want to be bothered by the trappings of humanity, so to speak, anymore. She wanted it to be done. She wanted it to be over. She didn't want to be bothered. That's why I can't tell you anymore after that. Okay? I can't tell you.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:27:38):

So you're keeping a promise to-

Video Dwayne (03:27:51):

Keeping the promise. I failed some shit in my life. I'm not going to fail in that one. I've already failed in my vows to my wife with trying to help somebody. And now she's probably in the fucking hospital panic attack or God knows what. You guys have probably been to my house. The kid's probably fucking losing his mind. I fucked up every fucking thing. I fucked up my entire life and I'm already planning on never being able to go home again. And even if I do, what do I have to go back home to? I won't make money. I won't be able to take care of anything. I'm forever stained because I helped somebody. We did play a little bit. It's true. We fucked a couple of times, but I only got off once because I was not into it. I couldn't. I couldn't help but think I was betraying my wife every time I tried.

(03:29:04)
And I couldn't, like you said, body will react whether mine wants to or not sometimes.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:29:10):

And it's stressful when you have a spouse who you guys had a relationship, you had a sexual relationship with you guys-

Video Dwayne (03:29:16):

No we didn't.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:29:18):

... before she got sick, you said she played. That's what I'm saying is that you had that and then she got sick and then you didn't have that.

Video Dwayne (03:29:29):

And then somebody came along and basically offered me a small outlet, and that sounded nice at the time and it was nice while it was online.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:29:40):

Did you play with ropes?

Video Dwayne (03:29:45):

[inaudible 03:29:46] I'm very honest with you. [inaudible 03:29:49] rope. I'm still confused as to how the second container there for real. And the rope thing's real. I didn't fuck with that shit. I did [inaudible 03:30:04] and I did consider it and I thought this would be fun. And then I was like, I can't. I already feel like I'm betraying my wife to no end. And if I tie somebody else up, I've done the trade all the way, all the way, all the way. So I just coiled it up, [inaudible 03:30:27] package and I coiled it up and I put in the backseat until I needed it a couple of days later actually. And I think it was that Monday, Monday, Sunday. I don't fucking know this time before because that's when Alden called, I think it was on Monday. From there she's been nothing but one big fucking heartache. And then she didn't do what she was supposed to do. She didn't do what she was supposed to do.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:31:02):

What was she supposed to do?

Video Dwayne (03:31:05):

She was supposed to bring cash. She wasn't supposed to bring cards. She was supposed to bring cash because [inaudible 03:31:19] I don't think it would've mattered at the end of the fucking day anyway because she still left with him. She was still being [inaudible 03:31:25]. You still had that picture. There's something about it that wouldn't matter.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:31:33):

Help me understand what was the cash supposed to be for?

Video Dwayne (03:31:42):

To help me pay off the IRS. I owed the IRS almost $10,000 for the last two years. And she volunteered to help me pay that off some of my financial stress because we went through a really bad period.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:32:04):

Was your wife sick?

Video Dwayne (03:32:04):

Yep. I couldn't work as much. Appointments almost every other fucking day. And she kept getting sicker and sicker and sicker. We got blessed with getting her lungs and her [inaudible 03:32:12] and I threw mine away.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:32:20):

You said that you all initially connected a couple years ago on Motherless. How did you connect on Motherless?

Video Dwayne (03:32:30):

I don't even remember, to be honest. I don't remember. It was just she called me on a few [inaudible 03:32:30] and just casually started chatting.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:32:40):

Did you, because there's different things in Motherless. Did you go into a group chat?

Video Dwayne (03:32:42):

I think we might have went into a group chat once or twice, but I think she had sessions. [inaudible 03:32:56].

Video Interviewer 1 (03:32:48):

Where did you meet her first?

Video Dwayne (03:32:48):

What do you mean? No, Motherless.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:32:48):

Okay. And then sessions within Motherless? The group? I'm confused because there's-

Video Dwayne (03:33:10):

Sessions is a separate thing. It has nothing to do with Motherless. You have to have a password like this long to talk to somebody. It's like 15 or 20 numbers and you put that in and they don't even give you their name unless they put it up there for you.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:33:25):

So that's what I was saying. Did you come across her in Motherless first and then you guys went over to Sessions and talked in Sessions?

Video Dwayne (03:33:31):

Yeah.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:33:31):

So did you meet in a... I know you said you're not sure if you remember, but you guys were like-minded in what you liked. So did you-

Video Dwayne (03:33:49):

I think it was more that I think she liked a couple of the things that I commented about or something. And then we kind of used comments under some of the pictures or whatnot, that other people posted, that kind of flirt, I guess you would say. The equivalent of online flirting basically.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:34:02):

Did you go into any other platforms to chat? Just Sessions and Motherless?

Video Dwayne (03:34:03):

Mm-hmm.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:34:14):

Okay. Can you tell me how the plan came about for her to come here?

Video Dwayne (03:34:24):

I wish I could. I really wish I could. There was a lot of talk back and forth. It's going on for two years probably. At first, I got the impression that she was kind of joking and then she told me that a couple of dudes stood her up and one kept robbing her, digitally taking money. And that caused a whole big bunch of problems for her.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:34:58):

Was she trying to pay him to help her die?

Video Dwayne (03:35:08):

I don't know what the story was. I don't. That was on her personal side. I just know that she was telling me that baby man, she's gotten the baby man. And I kept stalking her digitally and then charging her account all this money and it drove her basically in pretty serious debt. And she finally got it stopped. After I gave her some advice on how to get it stopped, she finally got it stopped and then shortly after that she wanted to leave.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:35:40):

So you were up for it?

Video Dwayne (03:35:46):

I thought it would be okay.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:35:46):

Yeah.

Video Dwayne (03:35:46):

I wanted to help. That's pretty much that.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:35:46):

When did the planning for that start?

Video Dwayne (03:36:04):

About a year ago. I know we had a couple of failed attempts because my wife kept taking very bad turns. I said, no, I'm not doing this right now. No, I'm not doing this right now. I don't have time for this right now. I want you to work on this. She knew that is what I was telling her. I kept instructing her to have really good sex with her husband because it seemed like when I do that, she'd get a little better and look better every time. She'd feel better. And then of course her husband was obviously appreciated the attention, you know what I mean?

Video Interviewer 1 (03:36:49):

When you say better sex, what does that mean?

Video Dwayne (03:36:55):

I encouraged her to... One time I encouraged her to give him a really good blow job and actually swallow and then let him fuck her. Don't bring off, just let him fuck you. And then of course that worked out for all. She was in a hurry for a couple of days or more. And then of course she was just not happy because her boyfriend and husband was super happy with it because it's something that she couldn't do.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:37:24):

So you were trying to teach her how to, I guess, connect with her husband?

Video Dwayne (03:37:24):

How to connect so she'd want to live. It didn't work.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:37:24):

It didn't work?

Video Dwayne (03:37:24):

It didn't work. It worked, but it didn't work.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:37:24):

Just temporarily.

Video Dwayne (03:37:24):

It was a bad day. [inaudible 03:38:00].

Video Interviewer 1 (03:37:24):

Do you want to talk about what happened Saturday and Sunday?

Video Dwayne (03:37:24):

I can't really talk too much about that, but you can ask questions and if I feel comfortable answering them, I will.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:37:24):

Is it because of this promise that you made to Sonia?

Video Dwayne (03:37:24):

Yeah.

Video: Speaker 2 (03:38:29):

Explain to me how did Sonia ask you to make this promise? What did she ask you?

Video Dwayne (03:38:32):

She did not want to be found. She did not want to be returned home. She wanted to be gone, gone, gone.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:38:45):

So you feel like you would be breaking that promise if you told us where she was?

Video Dwayne (03:38:51):

I can't confirm or deny that, but I can't break my promise about anything regarding that. I can't tell you where she went. I can't tell you anything about it.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:39:07):

And you can't tell us because of the promise?

Video Dwayne (03:39:21):

Yes. I can't break that promise. I've been breaking promises and being a piece of shit for too long, and that's why I want you guys to come back in here. I can't keep being a piece of shit, but I can't break that promise either.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:39:37):

Well, if we told you that we found her, would you be able to talk about it then because you wouldn't be telling us where she was at?

Video Dwayne (03:39:37):

No.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:39:37):

Is there anything else that you want to talk to us about then?

Video Dwayne (03:39:48):

I don't know. I don't know what else leading up to that. I just had to clear the air.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:39:54):

I appreciate that.

Video Dwayne (03:40:02):

Because I can't continue to be a piece of shit. I just can't. And I'll be honest with you, I'm super worried about my wife right now. I don't know where she's at. I don't know if she's still in the hospital. I don't know if she was able to get her phone because that's how she keeps track of her sugar. When it goes to the bottom, if the phone lets her know. I've already come to terms that I'm probably never going home.

Video: Speaker 2 (03:40:28):

Why do you say that?

Video Dwayne (03:40:30):

I can't imagine ever being able to ever go home. If I don't die in prison, then I probably... I don't really see myself making it very long.

Video: Speaker 2 (03:40:44):

Why do you talk about dying in prison?

Video Dwayne (03:40:56):

Because I'm physically [inaudible 03:40:52] and you got to be [inaudible 03:40:57] in prison.

Video: Speaker 2 (03:40:57):

The reference to going to prison.

Video Dwayne (03:40:58):

What do you mean?

Video: Speaker 2 (03:41:03):

Why do you think you're going to prison?

Video Dwayne (03:41:04):

Because that's usually what happens when shit happens. I've been here all day. If there was nothing, I'd be going home already.

Video: Speaker 2 (03:41:24):

Did you kill Sonia?

Video Dwayne (03:41:25):

I can't tell you that.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:41:26):

Can you talk about the sex that you had with Sonia? Are you willing to talk about that?

Video Dwayne (03:41:29):

We can try.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:41:29):

So you said that you had some light bondage.

Video Dwayne (03:41:36):

Yeah.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:41:36):

Can you tell me about that? Because sometimes bondage, there can be injuries.

Video Dwayne (03:41:36):

There's probably a few bruises at her insistance.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:41:53):

Okay. Where would the bruises be?

Video Dwayne (03:41:53):

Most of the body, I'm sure.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:41:53):

But you had mentioned when we talked earlier that there was some choking?

Video Dwayne (03:41:53):

Some.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:42:06):

So would the bruising be where the choking or on other places?

Video Dwayne (03:42:09):

Maybe a little bit of both. Some where the choking is.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:42:20):

And some on other parts?

Video Dwayne (03:42:20):

Yeah.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:42:20):

Okay. Can you tell me about the sexual activities that led to that bruising?

Video Dwayne (03:42:32):

I don't understand your question.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:42:34):

So for instance, you said that you were having sex with her from behind. Sometimes people, when they're having sex from behind, they may smack the other person's ass or that sort of thing.

Video Dwayne (03:42:48):

There's that sort of thing.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:42:52):

So that's what I'm saying is were those types of things happening that would cause bruises?

Video Dwayne (03:42:58):

Maybe.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:43:00):

Possibly.

Video Dwayne (03:43:00):

Possibly.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:43:03):

Okay. So that's the type of activity that I'm talking about. During this encounter or a couple of encounters, I think you said twice, where there was this light bondage and this rough sex, what type of activity specifically would've happened that could potentially cause the bruising that you said that she may have?

Video Dwayne (03:43:25):

There's a lot. I have very calloused hands.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:43:25):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (03:43:25):

So sometimes a lighter smack may be bruising and sometimes it's not such a light smack and I don't notice it because calluses.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:43:33):

You don't feel it as much?

Video Dwayne (03:43:44):

And I think it's like... But yeah, there was some of that.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:43:51):

Okay. So smacking on the ass?

Video Dwayne (03:43:51):

Front, back.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:43:55):

Okay. Smacking on the face?

Video Dwayne (03:43:59):

Yeah. She had me smack her face a couple of times.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:44:01):

Okay. Breasts?

Video Dwayne (03:44:05):

Yeah.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:44:05):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (03:44:05):

I said front and back.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:44:10):

No, like how we talked about before, I'm just trying to have an understanding of the sexual activity.

Video Dwayne (03:44:17):

She definitely made it very clear that she wanted really rough, aggressive sex.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:44:26):

Okay. Was there... Because you talked about people that were experienced doing it, that you're very experienced with this. Did you have a safe word?

Video Dwayne (03:44:35):

She decided that because of her situation, she didn't want a safe word.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:44:43):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (03:44:44):

There was no safe word.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:44:44):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (03:44:47):

There was my restraint, and I wasn't feeling it all that much.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:44:56):

Feeling the restraint or feeling the sex?

Video Dwayne (03:44:57):

The sex.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:44:57):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (03:45:08):

I said my wife's the most important thing to me, person, life, the whole thing, and wouldn't be possible without her. I fucked up it all. I don't really want details of this to be leaked to the public, to be honest. I don't want her to ever find out, to be honest.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:45:13):

I can understand that.

Video Dwayne (03:45:13):

I don't want her to [inaudible 03:45:42].

Video Interviewer 1 (03:45:43):

So the rough sex, did you have a conversation about a safe word?

Video Dwayne (03:45:48):

In person. There's no record of that at all.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:45:54):

Okay. How did that conversation go?

Video Dwayne (03:45:56):

She's like, "I don't need a safe word. Whatever happens, happens."

Video Interviewer 1 (03:46:03):

Okay. Was there at any point, if she wanted whatever was to happen to stop, how would that have played out for you?

Video Dwayne (03:46:18):

Oh no, that's immediate. That's immediate. You get to experience and not know when to stop.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:46:31):

Now, you've never played with her before, so since you've never played with her before, it may be difficult when you get a new partner to figure out what that line is.

Video Dwayne (03:46:42):

It's always-

Video Interviewer 1 (03:46:43):

How do you figure out what that line is?

Video Dwayne (03:46:45):

The pull away. The flinch or the pull away. Either way, it calls for an immediate stop and you don't just keep going. If they flinch or start to pull away, you stop. You still respect the person, you know what I mean? Even if they don't want to have a safe word, even if they say they're okay, you stop.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:47:10):

What went through your head when she said that she didn't want a safe word?

Video Dwayne (03:47:10):

I already kind of expected it. It wasn't nothing new [inaudible 03:47:19] safe word.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:47:10):

It's not a new thing?

Video Dwayne (03:47:10):

Well, that's something that I'm used to.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:47:26):

That's what I'm saying. You said your experience status, so it's not something that you would be uncomfortable with.

Video Dwayne (03:47:28):

It's not something I'm uncomfortable with.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:47:33):

Did she ever do anything during the time that you spent with her, where it seemed like maybe she had changed her mind?

Video Dwayne (03:47:43):

No. Actually, she got really upset with me because I quit. I was not into it whatsoever, and I quit. I didn't want to sleep with her. I didn't want to play bondage games with her or anything. I just wanted to be done. She got upset.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:48:14):

How did you know that she got upset?

Video Dwayne (03:48:17):

Her demeanor changed. While she didn't show, she was disappointed because I didn't want to keep going.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:48:34):

What was her level of experience?

Video Dwayne (03:48:34):

I have no idea. I have no idea.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:48:34):

Because you mentioned she was kind of submissive, her voice was... So is that her thing to be submissive?

Video Dwayne (03:48:36):

Yeah, that's what I got from her when she talked to me.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:48:45):

So is that kind of the turn on because she was submissive and online you're telling her to be more assertive with her husband or her boyfriend, and trying to get her to be more sexually aggressive with him? Or what was the appeal of giving her direction to have sex with someone?

Video Dwayne (03:49:08):

To control. Just to control.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:49:09):

Controlling her? So that's what kind of just fed you, turned you on, that you could get her to try something that maybe she wasn't comfortable with because you said it wasn't how she typically had sex and you were able to push her to do those things.

Video Dwayne (03:49:36):

Yeah. It was with her husband. Why not? It made things better for her in every single while.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:49:36):

And you got something out of it?

Video Dwayne (03:49:39):

Not really, but this kind of happiness of somebody listening to me, I guess. Somebody wants something.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:49:46):

At your direction?

Video Dwayne (03:49:47):

Yeah.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:49:47):

Yeah. Would she tell you about it?

Video Dwayne (03:49:54):

No. I'd ask her how it went and she would tell me, "Good. He was very surprised. [inaudible 03:50:01]." I don't follow the mechanical.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:50:04):

I forget what that's called.

Video Dwayne (03:50:05):

[inaudible 03:50:10].

Video Interviewer 1 (03:50:09):

What about the other way?

Video Dwayne (03:50:11):

The other way?

Video Interviewer 1 (03:50:14):

You care if people watch?

Video Dwayne (03:50:18):

It wouldn't be the first time.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:50:20):

Yeah. You just don't want to be the person watching? You want to be the person that's doing it?

Video Dwayne (03:50:23):

Yeah.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:50:23):

That's fair.

Video Dwayne (03:50:23):

But yeah, it's like...

Video Interviewer 1 (03:50:41):

So during your interactions with her during the first time you guys had sex, was that first night after you picked her up from the airport, you got checked in the AirBnB? That was the first time. And then when was the second time? Did you say it was Saturday night?

Video Interviewer 1 (03:50:59):

[inaudible 03:51:00]?

Video Dwayne (03:51:06):

Think it was early Saturday, because that was around about the same time I was done. I couldn't [inaudible 03:51:11].

Video Interviewer 1 (03:51:14):

So, her cards, you said that she was supposed to pay cash, but she didn't bring cash, so she had cards. And so how did the cards play out?

Video Dwayne (03:51:24):

She still wanted to help me out financially, so she had me run one card over and over and over again because she swore down there's money in there. She swore down there was money on there, [inaudible 03:51:38]. And then we ran the other card and she was extremely short of what she'd promised, which is why the other card got brought in.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:51:51):

How much had she promised?

Video Dwayne (03:51:55):

I still swear that that was in the middle of the night when we did that. I don't understand.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:52:00):

Yeah.

Video Dwayne (03:52:01):

That was when the sun went down. I don't understand why it was showing it all blank again. I don't.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:52:10):

So, did she have the physical cards? Did you swipe them?

Video Dwayne (03:52:10):

No, they were on [inaudible 03:52:11].

Video Interviewer 1 (03:52:11):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (03:52:11):

Just like I said, they were on [inaudible 03:52:11].

Video Interviewer 1 (03:52:11):

She just [inaudible 03:52:11] them off to you?

Video Dwayne (03:52:11):

Hm.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:52:11):

Okay. Do you know where her stuff is? I know you don't want to talk about where she is, but do you know where her stuff is?

Video Dwayne (03:52:32):

No. No. Legitimately, I don't know where the hell her stuff is now.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:52:32):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (03:52:32):

Her stuff is there, maybe.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:52:32):

What do you mean, "there, maybe"?

Video Dwayne (03:52:32):

There [inaudible 03:52:38].

Video Interviewer 1 (03:52:32):

Here?

Video Dwayne (03:52:32):

No.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:52:32):

Before she came over?

Video Dwayne (03:52:32):

No. Put it in a clothing box and donated it.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:52:32):

Oh, you did?

Video Dwayne (03:52:32):

Me.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:52:32):

You put it in a clothing box and donated it?

Video Dwayne (03:52:32):

Yeah.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:52:32):

Okay. When did you do that?

Video Dwayne (03:52:32):

Huh?

Video Interviewer 1 (03:52:37):

When did you do that?

Video Dwayne (03:53:05):

Sunday, I think. Probably Sunday. Because she didn't want me to have any other... Well, it's not that she didn't want me to have anything, but she wanted me to make what was good use of it. So, [inaudible 03:53:16].

Video Interviewer 1 (03:53:16):

Okay. What specifically did you have?

Video Dwayne (03:53:16):

I don't know, to be honest. It looked like mostly makeup.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:53:16):

Okay. Was it in the bag?

Video Dwayne (03:53:16):

It was in the backpack.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:53:16):

In the backpack.

Video Dwayne (03:53:16):

Mm-hmm.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:53:16):

With the backpack? Okay.

Video Dwayne (03:53:45):

Black. [inaudible 03:53:42] black backpack.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:53:45):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (03:53:45):

Just dropped it in a random clothing box. I figured there was some clothes stuck down in there too, so not like I really went scrounging through it or anything.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:53:56):

Yeah. But it would be put to good use.

Video Dwayne (03:53:56):

[inaudible 03:54:01].

Video Interviewer 1 (03:54:04):

Okay. Okay. Do you remember the general area that you were at when you did that?

Video Dwayne (03:54:06):

Gainesville.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:54:06):

Okay. Okay. [inaudible 03:54:07]?

Video Dwayne (03:54:06):

It was Gainesville.

VIDEO: Speaker 3 (03:54:06):

What part of Gainesville?

Video Dwayne (03:54:32):

Just happened while I was out [inaudible 03:54:33].

VIDEO: Speaker 3 (03:54:34):

Which road, [inaudible 03:54:35]?

Video Dwayne (03:54:34):

Huh?

VIDEO: Speaker 3 (03:54:35):

Which road? Did you say a road? I'm sorry, I couldn't hear you.

Video Dwayne (03:54:37):

No, I said when I was out and about [inaudible 03:54:39] seen clothing box and dropped it off, [inaudible 03:54:44].

Video Interviewer 1 (03:54:43):

But that was on the Sunday?

Video Dwayne (03:54:46):

I think so.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:54:48):

Do you remember what the clothing box looked like or-

Video Dwayne (03:54:54):

Yellow. Or, not yellow, green. It just said clothing drop box across it.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:54:54):

Okay. Do you know where it was around, like a store or anything that it was next to?

Video Dwayne (03:54:54):

No. [inaudible 03:55:02].

Video Interviewer 1 (03:55:12):

The second time you guys had sex, was it bondage too?

Video Dwayne (03:55:13):

Kind of.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:55:13):

Tell me about that, what you mean by "kind of".

Video Dwayne (03:55:47):

It was a lot less aggressive on my end. I was feeling really guilty. I wasn't kind. It wasn't hitting the right notes for me. I didn't have that aggressiveness, it's just... I told you, that part of me all died when my wife almost died. And I tried, but it wasn't there. And went to do a bad thing, I just-

Video Interviewer 1 (03:55:51):

How'd she feel about that?

Video Dwayne (03:55:51):

I don't know, she didn't say.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:55:51):

Okay. Is there anything else you wanted to share with us?

Video Dwayne (03:56:23):

I don't really know what else I could actually share.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:56:28):

That you're willing to share?

Video Dwayne (03:56:34):

Like I said, I don't know what else I could really share. I just wanted to include Harold on the other shit. And-

Video Interviewer 1 (03:56:35):

So, Harold and all that, that's all bullshit?

Video Dwayne (03:56:37):

That was all fucking bullshit, because that's what we came up with. And she wanted to try to make sure that I didn't end up... She was trying to protect me.

VIDEO: Speaker 3 (03:56:51):

How did that planning take place?

Video Dwayne (03:56:51):

What do you mean, "How did that planning take place?"

VIDEO: Speaker 3 (03:56:57):

Was it via messages or something that we could potentially corroborate or was it something in person?

Video Dwayne (03:57:11):

[inaudible 03:57:03]. We had discussed having some kind of a plan, but we didn't get into too many details digitally for just that reason.

VIDEO: Speaker 3 (03:57:15):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (03:57:16):

Okay? But we actually had that conversation in person.

VIDEO: Speaker 3 (03:57:24):

Were you at the Airbnb address or somewhere else?

Video Dwayne (03:57:27):

Had it on the way.

VIDEO: Speaker 3 (03:57:27):

Okay.

Video Dwayne (03:57:27):

I'm fucked.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:57:27):

I can tell it's laying heavy on you.

Video Dwayne (03:57:27):

I'm so fucked. I hurt her in a way that can never be forgiven. [inaudible 03:58:06] trying to get out from fucking the IRS, just to get fucked that way, too.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:57:27):

How much was she going to give you for the IRS?

Video Dwayne (03:57:27):

About four grand.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:57:27):

And she only ended up having the $1,200?

Video Dwayne (03:57:27):

Yes.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:58:30):

And how did that... I mean, it seems to be pretty... That's pretty impactful for you. You're expecting something that may cut your IRS debt almost in half.

Video Dwayne (03:58:41):

Yep.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:58:41):

And then she doesn't have it.

Video Dwayne (03:58:47):

It even further deteriorated [inaudible 03:58:51] even further. I mean, I was supposed to be helping and receiving help in kind, and then it was half-assed.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:59:05):

So, that was kind of what the agreement was, is that you would help her and she would help you, and that money was part of her helping you, but when she showed up, she didn't have all the money she said that she was going to?

Video Dwayne (03:59:17):

No, she didn't. She didn't do that, and she didn't have cash on hand, and it just-

Video Interviewer 1 (03:59:27):

So, she was supposed to bring cash so it couldn't be traced?

Video Dwayne (03:59:31):

Yeah.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:59:31):

Yeah? Did she say why she didn't bring cash?

Video Dwayne (03:59:35):

No. And if she did, I don't remember. All I know is right now, [inaudible 03:59:50] is completely fucked. I just feel very aggreviated. I don't like lying to you. I still can't remember any other details. Sorry.

Video Interviewer 1 (03:59:58):

Okay. Is there anything else?

Video Dwayne (03:59:58):

I don't know. Is there anything else?

VIDEO: Speaker 3 (04:00:16):

I'll say this, Dwain. Your mood has changed completely from when we first talked. And what I mean by that is what I can see now in you is remorse, compassion.

Video Dwayne (04:00:30):

It's all there ever was, is compassion now. My remorse is for my family.

VIDEO: Speaker 3 (04:00:37):

Yes. And you have expressed that, directly and indirectly. And I'll tell you this, I know that you feel like you may be betraying her or not upholding your promise to Sonia by... If you were to tell us... I can tell you this, we've located her, so you're not going to be telling us something that we don't-

Video Dwayne (04:01:06):

[inaudible 04:01:07].

VIDEO: Speaker 3 (04:01:06):

Hang on. And I know you said you don't want to talk about it. You don't have to say anything. Just listen to me, okay?

Video Dwayne (04:01:11):

Okay.

VIDEO: Speaker 3 (04:01:14):

So, you wouldn't be telling us anything that we don't already know. The point being, I think in a way you're being a little bit too harsh on yourself because, in my opinion, from what you've just told me, Sonia asked for your help, you tried to help her, and she did not hold her end of the bargain either, by her shorting you and not keeping her word. So, I guess in a way it's admirable of you to still keep your word, even though she didn't keep hers, as far as giving you what she promised she would give you. If you decide that you want to tell us and help fill in some of the blanks, we can kind of guess some of it, but okay.

Video Dwayne (04:02:02):

I still have to have a chance of reclaiming my life and that's not [inaudible 04:02:08].

Video Interviewer 1 (04:02:13):

Okay. So, is there anything else before we walk out? If there's anything-

Video Dwayne (04:02:15):

No, I need to know my wife is okay.

VIDEO: Speaker 3 (04:02:19):

And I'll be honest with you there, Shands won't give us an update because we're not her next of kin. However, from what I can tell, she's there. The deputy was up there. So, when we talked about it last, the deputy drove her up there. The deputy, after we talked, they had already left with her. So then after we talked, we got her meds to a deputy who brought those meds up there. And the deputy was waiting there until she was discharged, however, they said that she was going to be admitted and they couldn't give us an ETA, so the deputy has since left. As far as-

Video Dwayne (04:02:54):

But you guys are going to bring her home, right?

VIDEO: Speaker 3 (04:03:01):

I can try to get updates, but they don't give us updates. We're not her next of kin.

Video Dwayne (04:03:05):

Did you guys give her a card or something to call?

VIDEO: Speaker 3 (04:03:10):

I'm not sure. I personally did not. I don't know if the deputy did.

Video Dwayne (04:03:17):

Are you able to get her phone?

VIDEO: Speaker 3 (04:03:22):

Describe her phone to me, because we found a phone in the car, and so I don't think she has it, but if it's not the phone you're describing, then-

Video Dwayne (04:03:33):

It has an earbuds thing attached to it.

VIDEO: Speaker 3 (04:03:33):

What color case or what color is the phone?

Video Dwayne (04:03:35):

Purple.

VIDEO: Speaker 3 (04:03:35):

Okay, I don't know.

Video Dwayne (04:03:35):

Mine's this-

Video Interviewer 1 (04:03:46):

There's a red phone. Whose phone is the red phone?

Video Dwayne (04:03:46):

Red one? That's probably hers, then.

Video Interviewer 1 (04:03:46):

The red phone is hers?

Video Dwayne (04:03:46):

[inaudible 04:03:47].

Video Interviewer 1 (04:03:46):

What kind is it?

VIDEO: Speaker 3 (04:03:46):

[inaudible 04:03:48].

Video Dwayne (04:03:46):

It's a Galaxy.

Video Interviewer 1 (04:03:50):

Do you know what kind?

Video Dwayne (04:03:51):

No.

VIDEO: Speaker 3 (04:03:55):

It's like a red and black case.

Video Dwayne (04:03:56):

That's probably hers [inaudible 04:03:58]. Oh no, mine has red, blue, and white all over the case. [inaudible 04:04:01].

Video Interviewer 1 (04:04:00):

And this one's red, like a darker red, almost like maroon.

Video Dwayne (04:04:12):

That would've been hers.

VIDEO: Speaker 3 (04:04:15):

Whose? Your wife's?

Video Dwayne (04:04:17):

Yeah.

Video Interviewer 1 (04:04:17):

Is there anything else that you want to share with us?

Video Dwayne (04:04:32):

Anything as far as I know, as far as I understand, I think everything else has to do with [inaudible 04:04:33].

Video Interviewer 1 (04:04:33):

Okay.

VIDEO: Speaker 3 (04:04:33):

Okay.

Video Interviewer 1 (04:04:33):

[inaudible 04:04:33]. Thank you, Dwain, for calling us back and clearing the air.

Judge (04:04:58):

Ladies and gentlemen, I'm told that your lunches have arrived, so we're going to go ahead and take a lunch break. Let's plan to probably start back... It's 12:25 right now, not later than 1:15. Okay? So, after y'all are done eating, y'all want another downstairs break today to go outside, get a breath of fresh air? Okay. 50/50. One vote gets it. All right. So, after you guys are done eating, just knock on the door, let Deputy McGillicuddy know, and then he can bring y'all downstairs. Okay? See you back at 1:15.

(04:05:30)
The same rules govern you on this recess as in the others. Do not discuss the case with one another or any other person. Do not use your electronic devices or cell phones to communicate about the case or attempt to do research or learn about the case. See you back in a little while. Leave your notepad [inaudible 04:05:44].

Speaker 12 (04:05:54):

Oh, [inaudible 04:05:55].

Judge (04:06:29):

Jury's left the courtroom. Y'all can be seated. Mr. Barrett, would 45 minutes be sufficient for y'all to get lunch?

Mr. Barrett (04:06:35):

Yeah, that's fine, Judge. I normally don't eat lunch during trials anyway.

Judge (04:06:39):

A lot of lawyers don't. State, 45 minutes sufficient for y'all?

Speaker 13 (04:06:44):

Yes, sir.

Judge (04:06:45):

Let's group up then about... Not later than 1:10. I'd like to get them out a little bit early, but I think they'll probably need about 30, 45 minutes to eat, get downstairs and all that. Anything we need to take up before the recess?

Speaker 13 (04:06:56):

No, sir.

Mr. Barrett (04:06:57):

No, Your Honor.

Judge (04:06:57):

Okay. I'll see you all back then. Thank you.

Judge (04:49:12):

Ten after 1:00. State, Defense, are y'all ready for the jury?

Rich Buxman (04:49:17):

Yes, sir.

Junior Barrett (04:49:17):

Yes, Your Honor.

Judge (04:49:18):

Okay. Anything we need to take up before we bring them back in?

Rich Buxman (04:49:21):

No, Your Honor.

Junior Barrett (04:49:21):

No, Your Honor.

Judge (04:49:22):

Can we give them the two-minute [inaudible 04:49:24]?

Bailiff (04:49:23):

Yes, sir.

Judge (04:49:24):

Thank you. The record should reflect that counsel for the parties are back in the courtroom as well as Mr. Hall. Let me turn this thing up [inaudible 04:49:46].

Bailiff (04:49:45):

Your Honor, the coffee is freshed up.

Judge (04:49:46):

Very good. They're freshening up their coffee and we'll get them out.

Rich Buxman (04:49:48):

Judge, we do plan on bringing the smart board in to play one other video, probably four or five witnesses from now. It is right outside the hall, so it won't take long to bring in, boot up.

Judge (04:50:05):

Would we be able to accomplish that with the jury in the room? We say four or five witnesses. About how long?

Amy Berndt (04:50:12):

About an hour.

Rich Buxman (04:50:14):

Probably before we would need a break, but yeah, we can do it.

Judge (04:50:16):

Okay. An hour after lunch is a good break time.

(04:50:20)
Bring us a large cup of [inaudible 04:50:23] water.

Rich Buxman (04:50:24):

Yeah, that'll work.

Judge (04:51:15):

Can we check on them again?

(04:51:15)
Okay. Perfect.

(04:51:15)
Ladies and gentlemen, welcome back. Everyone can be seated. State, Defense, my understanding is that we're going to have Ms. McKenzie come back to the witness stand, correct?

Amy Berndt (04:52:31):

Yes. Okay.

Judge (04:53:28):

Can we get Rebecca McKenzie?

(04:53:28)
Why don't you set that down, ma'am? If you could raise your right hand, face the clerk. You will be placed under oath.

Clerk (04:53:34):

Do you swear or affirm the testimony you're about to give will be the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so help you God?

Rebecca McKenzie (04:53:37):

I do.

Judge (04:53:38):

You go ahead and be seated, ma'am.

Rebecca McKenzie (04:53:39):

Thank you.

Amy Berndt (04:53:39):

Good afternoon.

Rebecca McKenzie (04:53:39):

Good afternoon.

Amy Berndt (04:53:42):

Can you please state your name again for the record?

Rebecca McKenzie (04:53:44):

My name is Rebecca McKenzie.

Amy Berndt (04:53:46):

Judge, I believe you wanted to inquire if the jurors had any questions.

Judge (04:53:49):

Yes, ma'am.

(04:53:49)
First, Mr. Barrett, do you have any additional cross-examination?

Junior Barrett (04:53:52):

No, Your Honor.

Judge (04:53:53):

Okay. Members of the jury, as I explained to you yesterday, you all have the opportunity to ask witnesses questions. Ms. McKenzie, we had step down from the witness stand so she did not have to remain here for the approximately five-hour interview.

(04:54:04)
If y'all have questions now of her, you can ask them in the manner I explained you could. Do we have any questions of this witness from any of the jurors by a show of hands? Okay. Seeing no hands, make sure she step down.

Amy Berndt (04:54:16):

She may step down. She'll be recalled tomorrow.

Judge (04:54:18):

Okay.

Amy Berndt (04:54:19):

Thank you.

Rebecca McKenzie (04:54:19):

Thank you.

Judge (04:54:20):

Thank you, ma'am.

(04:54:20)
Mr. Barrett?

Junior Barrett (04:54:21):

No objection.

Judge (04:54:23):

Thank you, ma'am.

(04:54:27)
All right. State, you can call your next witness.

Rich Buxman (04:54:28):

State calls Madison Osthed. And if the Court could give me a presentation [inaudible 04:54:32].

Bailiff (04:54:32):

Where is she at?

Rich Buxman (04:54:46):

Oh, she's actually out there. Yes.

Judge (04:54:47):

Madison Osthed, please. Osthed.

Rich Buxman (04:54:51):

‍

She should be sitting right in the right.

Bailiff (04:54:54):

Madison Osthed.

Amy Berndt (04:54:57):

I saw that she was in the back. She's in there.

Rich Buxman (04:55:06):

Thank you.

Judge (04:55:09):

Jurors, we have multiple places we stage witnesses. Although we lose jurors, like on Monday morning, we can't lose a witness. Bear with us a moment here.

Bailiff (04:55:37):

Come on in, ma'am.

Judge (04:55:39):

Raise your right hand to be sworn in.

Clerk (04:55:39):

Do you swear or affirm the testimony you're about to give will be the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so help you God?

Madison Osthed (04:55:39):

Yes.

Judge (04:55:45):

You can go ahead and be seated, ma'am. Thank you.

Rich Buxman (04:55:52):

Good afternoon.

Madison Osthed (04:55:53):

Good afternoon.

Rich Buxman (04:55:54):

Can you please introduce yourself to the jury and spell your last name for us?

Madison Osthed (04:55:56):

Hi, my name is Madison Osthed. It's spelled O- S-T-H-E-D.

Rich Buxman (04:56:02):

Where do you work?

Madison Osthed (04:56:03):

I work at the Marion County Sheriff's Office.

Rich Buxman (04:56:06):

What do you do for them?

Madison Osthed (04:56:07):

I am a digital forensic technician.

Rich Buxman (04:56:09):

How long have you worked for the Marion County Sheriff's Office?

Madison Osthed (04:56:12):

For almost two years now.

Rich Buxman (04:56:14):

Have you worked as a digital forensic technician the whole time?

Madison Osthed (04:56:17):

Yes.

Rich Buxman (04:56:18):

All right. What do you do on a day-to-day basis?

Madison Osthed (04:56:22):

I complete extractions of digital devices.

Rich Buxman (04:56:26):

Can you explain for the jury your training and your experience that allows you to do that job?

Madison Osthed (04:56:31):

Yes. I have a master's degree in digital forensics, and I also have many certifications, industry certifications in digital forensics, including mobile forensics with certain Cellebrite software certifications. I have almost 200 hours with the Secret Service at the National Computer Forensic Institute.

Rich Buxman (04:56:53):

What is meant by a forensic analysis of a cell phone?

Madison Osthed (04:56:58):

Yes. A forensic analysis is essentially a copy of the digital device, of a digital-

Witness (04:57:00):

... is essentially a copy of the digital device. Of a digital device. And in this case, when we're talking about a mobile phone, it would be a copy of the mobile phone's data.

State Attorney (04:57:11):

Obviously, technology changes pretty rapidly in your arena, does it not?

Witness (04:57:16):

Yes.

State Attorney (04:57:16):

Except for the classes that you've described that you've gone to and the certifications you've obtained, what other things do you do to keep yourself aware of changes in technology?

Witness (04:57:25):

Trying to stay relevant in the field is what we try to do. So staying in groups with other digital forensic technicians or analysts is one way that I do that so that we can communicate about new devices, new softwares. And then, also, the software extraction itself helps. And I try to keep up to date with what is able to be extracted, what is the new challenges that we have, and that comes with that software.

State Attorney (04:57:51):

Are part of your daily duties to actually extract data from handheld cellphones?

Witness (04:57:56):

Yes.

State Attorney (04:57:57):

Okay. Can you estimate about how many times you've done that? How many cellphones you've extracted data from?

Witness (04:58:01):

Probably about 200 cellphones.

State Attorney (04:58:04):

Are you familiar with the different makes and models and operating systems in cellphones?

Witness (04:58:09):

Yes, I am.

State Attorney (04:58:09):

What's an operating system?

Witness (04:58:11):

An operating system is essentially a bridge between the hardware of a device, which is essentially that physical device that you're touching. That could be the board, it could be the memory. And then your software is all of the different applications, for instance, that you're using and your operating system kind of works between the two to tell each one what to do.

State Attorney (04:58:34):

And are you trained in the operating systems of both iPhones and Android phones?

Witness (04:58:38):

Yes, I am.

State Attorney (04:58:39):

What equipment do you use when conducting a forensic extraction and examination of a cellphone?

Witness (04:58:47):

We have primarily two softwares that we use, Cellebrite and Graykey, and those are the softwares that allow us to extract mobile devices.

State Attorney (04:58:53):

And what do they actually do?

Witness (04:58:55):

They help... Well, when we use them... For instance, with Cellebrite, we have Cellebrite software on our computer. It allows us to connect to that device that we're trying to extract from, and then it allows us to forensically extract the data from that device and pull it.

State Attorney (04:59:11):

I think you mentioned this earlier. Have you been trained in how to use Cellebrite?

Witness (04:59:16):

Yes. I have three certifications with Cellebrite.

State Attorney (04:59:21):

All right. Your Honor, at this time, I'd request permission to allow this witness to provide opinion testimony in the area of digital forensics.

Judge (04:59:27):

Okay. Mr. Barrett, do you have any cross-examination at this stage?

Mr. Barrett (04:59:29):

No, Judge.

Judge (04:59:30):

Okay. You can continue, Counsel.

State Attorney (04:59:31):

Thank you, Your Honor. Turning to your involvement in this case, did you become involved in the investigation of the case for State of Florida v. Dwain Hall in the murder of Sonia Exelby?

Witness (04:59:40):

Yes, I did.

State Attorney (04:59:41):

Let me direct your attention to October 17th of 2025. Were you provided a cellphone by Florida Department of Law Enforcement Agent Calvin Lee recovered from Dwain Hall's Jeep that was taken to the Marion County Sheriff's Office?

Witness (04:59:55):

Yes.

State Attorney (04:59:56):

May I approach?

Judge (04:59:57):

Yes, sir.

State Attorney (04:59:58):

Showing you what's been introduced into evidence already as State's Exhibit 28. You recognize that item?

Witness (05:00:05):

Yes, I do.

State Attorney (05:00:06):

Okay. How?

Witness (05:00:09):

This is my handwriting on the inside of the bag, depicting this mobile device. As well as I took photos of this device that are in my report.

State Attorney (05:00:18):

All right. Was a search warrant obtained that allowed you to forensically extract data from that specific cellphone?

Witness (05:00:25):

Yes.

State Attorney (05:00:28):

When you received that phone, was it packaged in any specific way? Like in any type of container?

Witness (05:00:35):

It was inside of a Faraday bag.

State Attorney (05:00:35):

And would that be the proper method by which to collect a cellphone and transport it to you?

Witness (05:00:40):

Yes.

State Attorney (05:00:40):

Why?

Witness (05:00:41):

A Faraday bag is essentially a bag that allows the phone to not be able to access the network. So it essentially protects it from data changes. Nothing can get into that phone. Text messages, phone calls, things like that. Additionally, it helps prevent remote wiping, so it's just a protocol that we use to ensure that that phone is preserved and protected.

State Attorney (05:01:07):

Can you describe the phone for the jury? What make, what type, the model, things like that?

Witness (05:01:12):

Yes. It is a Samsung. And then am I able to refer to my notes for the specific model?

State Attorney (05:01:16):

If it would refresh your memory, with the court's permission, yes, ma'am.

Judge (05:01:17):

Yes, you may do that.

Witness (05:01:19):

Perfect. Thank you. So it's a Samsung, and then the model is an SM-S938U.

State Attorney (05:01:32):

Okay. During your forensic extraction process, did you document certain identifying information regarding the phone, such as the make, the model, the serial number, things like that?

Witness (05:01:48):

Yes, I did.

State Attorney (05:01:48):

And what type of information did you specifically document?

Witness (05:01:52):

I documented the serial number and the IMEI number of the device.

State Attorney (05:01:58):

What is meant by the term serial number?

Witness (05:02:01):

A serial number is a unique number for a digital device.

State Attorney (05:02:05):

So that number is unique to that specific phone right there?

Witness (05:02:08):

Yes.

State Attorney (05:02:11):

What is the serial number of the phone from which you extracted the data?

Witness (05:02:15):

I'm just going to refer to my notes for this one, but it's R5CY32DQBNX.

State Attorney (05:02:25):

And you also mentioned the term IMEI number. What is that?

Witness (05:02:30):

That is also, additionally, another unique identifier to the device. It's 15 digits and that is, in addition to the serial number, meant to make sure that a device is extremely unique and not repeating.

State Attorney (05:02:46):

Okay. And what was the IMEI number for the phone from which you extracted the data?

Witness (05:02:51):

That was 35-708742-571637-6.

State Attorney (05:03:00):

Did you also determine the phone number associated with that specific phone?

Witness (05:03:04):

Yes, I did.

State Attorney (05:03:05):

What was it?

Witness (05:03:06):

That was 330-575-4894.

State Attorney (05:03:13):

And what's the purpose in you documenting all of this information about the specific phone that you analyzed?

Witness (05:03:19):

We do this to ensure that this is the device when we complete an extraction so that, first off, this is a unique device. There isn't a replica of it. And then we do this so that, if later on we give a report, a digital copy of this device later on, we're able to always identify it later on.

State Attorney (05:03:37):

So does the information that you've just described appear on any kind of digital report that's generated from the extraction?

Witness (05:03:43):

Yes.

State Attorney (05:03:44):

So if somebody else looks at that digital report, they can say, "I know this report came from that phone."

Witness (05:03:49):

Yes.

State Attorney (05:03:49):

Understood. Did you in fact perform a digital extraction of the data from that phone?

Witness (05:03:58):

Yes, I did.

State Attorney (05:03:59):

In what condition was the phone in when you received it? Was it on, was it off, in airplane mode?

Witness (05:04:05):

It was in airplane mode already. And just to confirm, it was powered on.

State Attorney (05:04:12):

Okay. Explain to the jury very briefly how you logistically do an extraction. What steps do you take?

Witness (05:04:18):

So essentially when we get the phone, for instance, this mobile device, I have Cellebrite, which is our software that we use to extract that digital device. I have it running on my computer. I take the phone, it's in airplane mode. This ensures that no data is also being coming in, getting changed. I hook it up to our Cellebrite software. And then at that point, we go through a series of prompts and then the Cellebrite software is able to start extracting that digital device.

State Attorney (05:04:48):

Does that extraction process change, modify, delete, or alter any of the information on the phone as it pertains to things like data, texts, calls, pictures? Things like that?

Witness (05:05:01):

No, it does not.

State Attorney (05:05:02):

Okay. And how do you know that?

Witness (05:05:03):

Through experience.

State Attorney (05:05:05):

Through what?

Witness (05:05:06):

Through experience. And also just through the software itself.

State Attorney (05:05:08):

Does the process that you use have steps to ensure that that does not happen?

Witness (05:05:13):

Yes.

State Attorney (05:05:13):

Okay. Was the phone password protected?

Witness (05:05:16):

Yes, it was.

State Attorney (05:05:17):

Did you know the password or were you informed of the password?

Witness (05:05:19):

I was informed of the passcode.

State Attorney (05:05:21):

How were you informed?

Witness (05:05:24):

I believe it was a law enforcement personnel who informed me of the passcode.

State Attorney (05:05:28):

Okay. What type of data were you able to extract from the phone, just generally?

Witness (05:05:35):

It was a full file system extraction. Which just means that we're able to get everything that you would relatively see if you opened up your phone, for instance. And you can kind of go through your application, your messages. You get all of that data, and then you also get hidden files, user files, system data, log data. And you can potentially also get deleted data through a full file system extraction.

State Attorney (05:05:58):

Were there any problems with the extraction process?

Witness (05:06:01):

No, there were not.

State Attorney (05:06:02):

What did you do with the data once you extracted it from the phone?

Witness (05:06:08):

Once that data is extracted, it's essentially in an unreadable format to us. So then it goes through another software, which is Cellebrite Physical Analyzer. It allows us to take that extraction, put it into Physical Analyzer, which allows us to see it in a generated report where you can see those messages, you can look through location data. Things like that. And then you're able to make a digital report of that and then give it to somebody else. So that is what I did. I created a digital report of that extracted data.

State Attorney (05:06:40):

So the digital report is basically the extracted data in a form that we can read?

Witness (05:06:44):

Yes.

State Attorney (05:06:45):

Understood. Did you actually examine the results of the extraction or was that left to other law enforcement officers to look through?

Witness (05:06:53):

That was left to other law enforcement officers.

State Attorney (05:06:55):

All right. Let me direct your attention to a few days later, of October 20th of 2025. Were you provided a second search warrant authorizing you to generate a more extensive forensic report from the contents of Dwain Hall's cellphone?

Witness (05:07:10):

Yes, I was.

State Attorney (05:07:11):

Did you use the same procedure you just described?

Witness (05:07:13):

Yes.

State Attorney (05:07:14):

Any problems with that process?

Witness (05:07:15):

No.

State Attorney (05:07:15):

May I approach, Your Honor?

Judge (05:07:17):

Yes, sir.

State Attorney (05:07:18):

Showing you what's been marked for identification as State's Exhibit F. F, as in Frank. Can you take a look at that and tell me if you recognize it? If you need to open it up and look inside, you can do that too.

Witness (05:07:28):

Of course. Yes.

State Attorney (05:07:57):

Go ahead and keep in your lap for analysis.

Witness (05:07:58):

Sorry.

State Attorney (05:07:58):

No. That's okay.

Witness (05:07:59):

I'm sorry.

State Attorney (05:07:59):

Do you recognize the contents?

Witness (05:08:01):

Yes.

State Attorney (05:08:01):

What is it?

Witness (05:08:02):

It is a USB thumb drive of the copy of the report for the case.

State Attorney (05:08:09):

And that contains all of the extracted data from the phone?

Witness (05:08:11):

Yes.

State Attorney (05:08:11):

And how do you recognize it?

Witness (05:08:12):

Through my handwriting.

State Attorney (05:08:13):

Okay. Thank you. If you could put it back in the container for me? Thank you, ma'am. I have no other questions, Your Honor.

Mr. Barrett (05:08:25):

No questions, Judge.

Judge (05:08:27):

Members of the jury, do any of y'all have questions of this witness? If you do, please raise your hand. All right. Seeing no hands, State, is she released?

State Attorney (05:08:33):

She is, Your Honor.

Judge (05:08:33):

Defense?

Mr. Barrett (05:08:34):

No objection. Yeah.

Judge (05:08:35):

Ma'am, you're free to go about your day. Thank you for your time.

Witness (05:08:37):

Thank you.

Judge (05:08:38):

All right. State, you can call your next witness.

State Attorney (05:08:39):

State calls Brian Hempstead.

Judge (05:08:46):

Let me take that from you, ma'am. Thank you.

Witness (05:08:47):

Sorry.

State Attorney (05:08:52):

Thank you, Your Honor.

Judge (05:09:13):

Members of the jury, if any of you are wondering when we'll take another break, I am told that we're going to have to bring that television in on the red cart again in a couple... Probably about an hour or so. We'll probably take a break around then, just so you all can plan. If anybody needs a break before then, I know we just had lunch, just get my attention. Let me know that you need a break. If you can't wait, we'll take one. Okay? All right. You come on in, sir. Please raise your right hand. Face the clerk to be sworn.

Clerk (05:09:38):

Do you swear or affirm the testimony you're about to give will be the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so help you God?

Brian Hempstead (05:09:39):

Yes, I do.

Judge (05:09:39):

You may be seated.

State Attorney (05:09:47):

Good afternoon, sir.

Brian Hempstead (05:09:47):

Good afternoon.

State Attorney (05:09:48):

Can you please introduce yourself to the jury?

Brian Hempstead (05:09:50):

I am Brian Hempstead. I'm a digital forensic examiner for Gainesville Police Department.

State Attorney (05:09:55):

And how long have you worked for Gainesville Police Department?

Brian Hempstead (05:09:58):

In April, it'll be five years. So we're going on five years.

State Attorney (05:10:02):

And as a forensic digital examiner, what do you do on a day-to-day basis?

Brian Hempstead (05:10:05):

On a day-to-day basis, I do forensic preservation and forensic analysis for predominantly internet crimes against children. I also assist with the Criminal Investigation Division at Gainesville Police Department.

State Attorney (05:10:18):

Can you describe, for the jury, your training and your experience and your education that allows you to do that job?

Brian Hempstead (05:10:25):

A lifetime experience. I started off with being in IT, so I started off doing custom PC builds, PC repair, and virus mitigations. And then I got IT job at an orthopedic clinic where I managed network, client computers, and X-ray machines. And then I worked for a managed service provider, which is a company that gets contracted to do IT services for small to mid-sized businesses. I was a system engineer there. I managed a variety of different servers from email to database to application servers. Different software, different computers.

(05:11:07)
And I went from there and then I got my involvement into law enforcement. I had a friend that needed help, and I became a police officer. And that's when I found out that there was somebody that could go after all those ransomware people that go after companies. And I got into digital forensics there. And there's a school in Hoover, Alabama, that the U.S. Secret Service has. It's called the National Computer Forensic Institute, and it's where they provide digital forensics training for all your smaller cities and other organizations across the country to try to give digital forensic opportunities and capabilities to police departments across the country. So I went to several trainings there. Their digital evidence investigations course, their network intrusion course.

(05:11:58)
After going through the courses there, I decided to try to find a full-time forensic job, and that's when I got hired at Gainesville Police Department down here in Florida. I moved cross country. A little bit hectic, but it was a great decision. So I work in Internet Crimes Against Children. From there, I got the opportunity to go to IACIS, which is the International Association of Computer and Investigation Specialists. It's an organization put on by law enforcement people in the '80s when computers first started getting involved in crime. And it's a training program that trains you how to do everything manually. It's a two-week course where you quite intensively learn how to look at the actual data on a computer device and what it means and how to navigate those file systems.

(05:12:45)
And it's a two-week course followed by a four-month peer review process, where each month you're given a practical problem and you have to answer knowledge-based questions. And then you actually have a forensic image of a device, and you have to answer hypothetical case questions based off of those. And you have a peer coach that works with you to make sure you're answering those not only correctly, but adequately. That you're giving enough information so they know that you have the proper knowledge and understanding. And over those four months, each month is a new problem, and you have only 30 days to complete that problem. If you do not complete it, you don't go on and you don't get the certification. So you have to complete four problems over four months.

(05:13:32)
And then at the end of that, you have to take both a knowledge-based and a practical test. And once you complete all that, you have your certification. And then every three years, you have to re-cert on your certification. Which I just finished my first re-certification. I also have my cybersecurity information security... I hate these acronyms. Sorry. It's CISSP. So it's certified information security specialist, I believe. It's a cybersecurity degree. I have it written down in front of me. Sorry. Certified Information System Security Professional. Sorry. And it's a cybersecurity from a management point of view, where you have seven pillars of information. Each of those you have to pass 70% in each pillar, then pass the overall test. It's about a seven-hour test. So I completed that, and then I've completed several, both third party trainings like Hexordia's mobile forensic course and courses through Cellebrite, Magnet Forensic courses for Griffeye, which is another tool I use. I've completed training through Cellebrite on how to use their extraction and their parsing software. So a lot of stuff.

State Attorney (05:15:01):

Okay. Okay. Have you used the program, Cellebrite, to digitally extract data from cellphones during your career?

Brian Hempstead (05:15:10):

Yes.

State Attorney (05:15:11):

Have you also forensically analyzed that data that has been extracted from cellphones in your career?

Brian Hempstead (05:15:16):

Yes.

State Attorney (05:15:17):

Can you estimate about how many times you've done those things?

Brian Hempstead (05:15:19):

I probably use Cellebrite daily. So hundreds of times.

State Attorney (05:15:23):

Okay. At this time, Your Honor, the State would request permission to allow this witness to provide opinion testimony in the area of digital forensics.

Judge (05:15:28):

Okay. Mr. Barrett, do you want to do any cross- examination at this time?

Brian Hempstead (05:15:30):

No voir dire, Judge.

Judge (05:15:32):

Okay. All right. Go ahead.

State Attorney (05:15:33):

Thank you, Your Honor. Were you provided a digital extraction conducted by Marion County Sheriff's Office forensic analyst, Madison Ostead, of a cellphone belonging to Dwain Hall?

Brian Hempstead (05:15:43):

Yes, I was.

State Attorney (05:15:44):

And did that extraction that you examined have specific details on the phone from which the data was extracted, like the make, the model, serial number, IMEI number?

Brian Hempstead (05:15:54):

Yes, it did.

State Attorney (05:15:54):

All right. To make sure that you looked at the same data that was extracted by Ms. Ostead, what was the make and model of the data from which the... Or the phone from which the data was extracted?

Brian Hempstead (05:16:10):

The make of the phone, it was a Samsung. And the model was a Galaxy S25 Ultra, I believe. Is it okay if I check my notes?

State Attorney (05:16:20):

You can use your report to refresh your memory with the judge's permission.

Judge (05:16:23):

Yes, sir.

Brian Hempstead (05:16:37):

Yes. A Galaxy S25 Ultra.

State Attorney (05:16:39):

And what was the serial number of the phone related to the extraction you examined?

Brian Hempstead (05:16:44):

The serial number was R as in Romeo, five, C as in Charlie, Y as in Yankee, 32, D as in delta, Q as in Quebec, B as in bravo, N as in November, X as in X-ray, 20250315.

State Attorney (05:17:02):

And what was the IMEI number associated with the data you examined?

Brian Hempstead (05:17:09):

The IMEI number was 35-708742-571637-6.

State Attorney (05:17:19):

And what was the phone number associated with the phone that you examined?

Brian Hempstead (05:17:22):

It was 330-575-4894.

State Attorney (05:17:29):

And what were you asked to do in looking through the extracted data from this phone?

Brian Hempstead (05:17:36):

The request was to go back about two years and look for communications between the suspect and the victim, and a third party named R.E. Peterson, I believe.

State Attorney (05:17:48):

Okay. And were you provided a list of contact information, like social media accounts, email addresses associated with Dwain Hall and Sonia Exelby?

Brian Hempstead (05:17:56):

Yes, I was.

State Attorney (05:17:57):

So what did you do once you received the digital extraction copy that was taken from Dwain Hall's phone?

Brian Hempstead (05:18:04):

I loaded that extraction copy into a program called Cellebrite Insights, which is their parsing and analysis program. That extraction, it comes in a container. It's kind of like a zip file. And the file system of the device that was extracted is within there. And what that parsing software does is it goes through there. And inside your phone, most of that data is kept in different databases, SQLite databases, other databases. And it will go through, instead of me having to manually go in, navigate through that file system and write a query to parse that database, it'll do much of that for me and then present that to me in a user-friendly interface. And then it provides me the link back to the original file it got that data from so I can do validation and verify that the data was accurate.

State Attorney (05:19:03):

So you can basically do searches? You can say, look for text messages and-

Brian Hempstead (05:19:07):

Yes.

State Attorney (05:19:08):

... then it'll provide you what you're looking for, as well as the location of that specific file on the extracted data from the phone itself?

Brian Hempstead (05:19:13):

That's correct.

State Attorney (05:19:15):

Okay. Did you specifically look for either text or chat, or any kind of communication between Dwain Hall and Sonia Exelby from the data on Dwain Hall's phone?

Brian Hempstead (05:19:24):

Yes, I did.

State Attorney (05:19:24):

And how did you do that search? Just like what you just described?

Brian Hempstead (05:19:26):

Yeah. So there's a global search function where I can put in those usernames, those email addresses, the phone numbers. And it'll search through all the data in the extraction to try and find that.

State Attorney (05:19:37):

Did you locate any messages or texts or chats between the two of them on Dwain Hall's phone?

Brian Hempstead (05:19:43):

No, I did not.

State Attorney (05:19:44):

Did you locate any evidence on Dwain Hall's phone that suggested that they had, in fact, communicated in the past?

Brian Hempstead (05:19:50):

I did find some artifacts that I believe were indicative of communication between the two of them.

State Attorney (05:19:55):

What's an artifact?

Brian Hempstead (05:19:56):

An artifact is data that can have evidentiary value.

State Attorney (05:20:01):

And what information did you find showing that Sonia Exelby and Dwain Hall had communication in the past?

Brian Hempstead (05:20:07):

I found some images of the victim that had been transferred through the Sessions application.

State Attorney (05:20:16):

What is Sessions?

Brian Hempstead (05:20:17):

Sessions is an end-to-end encrypted communication application that is privacy focused. And by that, I mean it doesn't require any know-your-customer data. So you don't have to put in your email address, your name, any identifiable information. You just download the application, and when you create an account, it just gives you an alphanumeric number that is your user number. And then to chat with somebody, you give them another... It generates another alphanumeric number that you can either provide to them as a number or as a QR code, and they can join a chat that way. And then once you're inside the chat, you can have a nickname set up.

(05:21:04)
So you have a username inside, but when we look at it forensically, the only way we can tell who's in that conversation is by having the devices that are on either side of the communication. By having the suspect's phone, I can tell what the suspect's username at that long streak of numbers is because I have the device. Sessions doesn't know what that information is because they don't know who owns that. It's anonymized that way, so it's used for anonymous communication.

State Attorney (05:21:33):

Is that similar to like WhatsApp does?

Brian Hempstead (05:21:35):

WhatsApp uses end-to-end encryption like that. Except for WhatsApp, you have to have an email address, at least, to set up an account. So there is some know your... You know your customer information involved in that application.

State Attorney (05:21:48):

Did you actually find the Sessions application on Dwain Hall's phone?

Brian Hempstead (05:21:54):

At the time of the extraction of the phone, the application was no longer on his phone.

State Attorney (05:22:00):

Did you find evidence that it had been installed on his phone at some point?

Brian Hempstead (05:22:03):

Yes.

State Attorney (05:22:03):

What'd you find?

Brian Hempstead (05:22:04):

Whenever you download an application from Play Store on Android, there's a database that tracks everything that you downloaded from the Play Store. So the record of the application being downloaded and installed on the phone was in that database.

State Attorney (05:22:20):

Do you remember when it was downloaded onto his phone? And if you need to refresh your memory with the report, with the-

Brian Hempstead (05:22:24):

Yes.

State Attorney (05:22:24):

... court's permission, please do.

Judge (05:22:25):

You may, sir.

Brian Hempstead (05:22:41):

April 11th of 2025.

State Attorney (05:22:43):

That's when it was installed on his phone?

Brian Hempstead (05:22:45):

Yes.

State Attorney (05:22:46):

All right. And you indicated since then it has been deleted?

Brian Hempstead (05:22:49):

Yes.

State Attorney (05:22:50):

And how do you know it's been deleted?

Brian Hempstead (05:22:52):

There's no record of it left on the phone except for that database.

State Attorney (05:22:57):

Did you locate any images of the victim, Sonia Exelby, on his cellphone confirming that they had prior interaction?

Brian Hempstead (05:23:07):

Yes. There was images of Sonia Exelby that, because of the file name structure, I can tell were downloaded from the Sessions application.

State Attorney (05:23:19):

May I approach?

Judge (05:23:20):

Yes, sir.

State Attorney (05:23:20):

Showing you what's marked as State's Exhibit GG. Can you take a look at those and let me know if you recognize those images?

Brian Hempstead (05:23:33):

Yes.

State Attorney (05:23:48):

And how do you recognize those?

Brian Hempstead (05:23:49):

Those are the images that I identified were downloaded from the Sessions application.

State Attorney (05:23:54):

Are those fair and accurate copies of those images recovered from the defendant's... Or from Dwain Hall's cellphone?

Brian Hempstead (05:23:59):

Yes.

State Attorney (05:24:00):

At this time, State would move BB as in boy... I'm sorry, GG into evidence as State's 34, I believe.

Judge (05:24:09):

Could you hand a copy of the photos to Mr. Barrett? You said you needed to look, Mr. Barrett?

State Attorney (05:24:13):

I'm sorry.

Mr. Barrett (05:24:24):

No objection, Your Honor.

Judge (05:24:25):

Without objection, what's been marked for identification as State's Exhibit GG will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 34.

State Attorney (05:24:35):

Thank you, Your Honor. Did some of these images contain nude or partially nude photographs of the victim, Sonia Exelby?

Brian Hempstead (05:24:43):

Yes, they did.

State Attorney (05:24:43):

You mentioned earlier that based on the file names of the images, you were able to determine that they were from the Sessions app. What do you mean by that?

Brian Hempstead (05:24:52):

On the Sessions application, when you're sending images from within the chat, it'll retain the same file name of the person that they originally had. But once you do a download, and particularly a download all from a chat, it changes that file name to be Sessions, and then it'll have year, date... Year, month, day, I believe. And then there'll be a file name. So when it downloads, it puts Sessions at the front and then it'll put a timestamp that's the timestamp of when it was downloaded. And that's how I can tell it was downloaded from Sessions. Because it has that structure that Sessions put on when you do a download of a chat from sessions.

State Attorney (05:25:33):

Okay. Your Honor, may I publish using the exhibit? Because they contain nude images of the victim, rather than putting all this [inaudible 05:25:40]?

Judge (05:25:40):

Yes, sir.

State Attorney (05:25:40):

Thank you.

Judge (05:25:47):

Members of the jury, this exhibit is being published to you by being passed around. You all can take a look at it. Again, I remind you, when you go to deliberate your verdict at the conclusion of the case, all the exhibits that are admitted into evidence throughout the trial are sent back with you when you deliberate. This will not be the only time you're able to view this exhibit.

State Attorney (05:29:41):

Now, you indicated that when something is sent through Sessions, the Sessions application creates a file name for it?

Brian Hempstead (05:29:49):

When it's downloaded-

State Attorney (05:29:50):

Okay.

Brian Hempstead (05:29:51):

... it'll create that file name that we see in these files.

State Attorney (05:29:54):

And the file name you said was sessions-year-month-day?

Brian Hempstead (05:29:58):

That's correct.

State Attorney (05:29:59):

And then a file name?

Brian Hempstead (05:30:00):

Yes.

State Attorney (05:30:00):

During what period of time were those images-

Brian Hempstead (05:30:00):

Yes.

State Attorney (05:30:00):

During what period of time were those images sent or downloaded according to the file names on those images?

Brian Hempstead (05:30:08):

November 11th of 2024.

State Attorney (05:30:11):

Okay. Are all of them the same day or are they...

Brian Hempstead (05:30:13):

I believe they were all the same day. There is one from 11/20 and of March 25th of 2025 are two of them. So outside of the final two images were March 25th of 2025. The two main images before that were 11/20 of 2024, and then the rest of them were 11/11 of 2024.

State Attorney (05:30:56):

Where did you find these images in Dwain Hall's cell phone?

Brian Hempstead (05:31:02):

On his cell phone, they were found within the Samsung secure folder and in the .trash directory, which the .trash directory in Android phones is similar to the Recycle Bin in your Windows computer. So they've been deleted, and that's where I've discovered the images.

State Attorney (05:31:21):

What's a secure folder? What do you mean by that?

Brian Hempstead (05:31:23):

The secure folder is a function within Samsung Galaxy phones where you have a separate folder that has its own passcode so it could be secure, and then it operates within the device like its own user account. So it has its own user identification number, like your normal user ID on an Android device is 100. The Samsung secure folder uses the user ID 150.

State Attorney (05:31:53):

Would the user have to specifically make the decision to store those images in that secure folder?

Brian Hempstead (05:31:58):

Yes.

State Attorney (05:31:59):

Okay. And based on where those images were located in the .trash file, can you tell whether those images were... They were deleted, right?

Brian Hempstead (05:32:13):

Yes.

State Attorney (05:32:13):

Can you tell whether they were deleted by the user, or could they have been deleted by some process that the phone takes on its own?

Brian Hempstead (05:32:20):

They would've been deleted by a user, similar to when you use a Windows computer and you send something to the Recycle Bin, it's because you deleted it. Nothing goes to the Recycle Bin that the system deleted, because the whole purpose of the, in this case, .trash folder or the Recycle Bin in Windows is to give you, the user, the opportunity to recover that file later. In the instance of the .trash directory, once a file goes in there, there's about 30 days that gives you to recover that file if you need to, or it gets removed from the device.

State Attorney (05:32:51):

And in your analysis, were you able to determine that those files were deleted on October 14th, 2025, at 11:41 AM?

Brian Hempstead (05:33:03):

Yes. This is something in my initial analysis I did miss, but doing additional research and communicating with colleagues, we did identify that in the filename of the images, there is a Unix millisecond timestamp in that file system that gives us that date.

State Attorney (05:33:25):

And were all those files deleted at the same time?

Brian Hempstead (05:33:28):

Yes.

State Attorney (05:33:28):

Kind of like a batch delete, you click a bunch of things and hit delete?

Brian Hempstead (05:33:31):

At the same time down to the millisecond.

State Attorney (05:33:33):

Okay. Did you locate any evidence that an application called Telegram was installed or used on Dwain Hall's cell phone?

Brian Hempstead (05:33:48):

Yes, I did.

State Attorney (05:33:49):

What is Telegram?

Brian Hempstead (05:33:50):

Telegram is another end-to-end encryption communication platform where people can communicate.

State Attorney (05:33:59):

Okay. Did you find some images related to the Telegram application?

Brian Hempstead (05:34:03):

Yes, there was images within Telegram.

State Attorney (05:34:05):

Were any of those images of the victim?

Brian Hempstead (05:34:06):

No.

State Attorney (05:34:07):

Okay. Did you locate any videos of Sonia Exelby on Dwain Hall's phone?

Brian Hempstead (05:34:15):

Yes, I did.

State Attorney (05:34:15):

What'd you find?

Brian Hempstead (05:34:17):

I found a video of her being interviewed on a couch on the device.

State Attorney (05:34:24):

And where was that video found in the defendant's phone?

Brian Hempstead (05:34:27):

That was also in the secure folder .trash directory.

State Attorney (05:34:31):

And again, based on it being in the secure folder in .trash, would that mean that it was deleted?

Brian Hempstead (05:34:36):

Yes.

State Attorney (05:34:37):

And would it mean that the user specifically made a decision to delete that?

Brian Hempstead (05:34:40):

Yes.

State Attorney (05:34:40):

May I approach, Your Honor?

Judge (05:34:44):

Yes, sir.

State Attorney (05:34:45):

Showing you what's been marked as State's Exhibit HH. It contains a CD as well as a document. Do you recognize those items?

Brian Hempstead (05:34:59):

Yes, I do.

State Attorney (05:35:00):

And what are those items?

Brian Hempstead (05:35:03):

This is a copy of the video that I watched in your office and initialed, and these are... It looks to be screenshots from my report.

State Attorney (05:35:13):

Okay. The screenshot in your report, does that contain something called EXIF data related to that deleted video?

Brian Hempstead (05:35:20):

Yes.

State Attorney (05:35:20):

What is that? What is EXIF data?

Brian Hempstead (05:35:24):

EXIF data is metadata, which is data about data that's been appended to a photo or a video. For example, in a photo, you might record the camera that took the photo. It might record the lens, aperture, things like that, that a photographer might need to refer back to take another picture like the one he took. Now, since we have cell phones, they have GPS data, we now get GPS data that gets appended into EXIF data, so that if a person wanted to go back to where a photo was taken, they would be able to tell where that photo was taken and go back to it. So things like the device that took the phone, software that was involved on phones, it might tell you whether the front camera or back camera was used, and it'll tell you the location of where that camera was. All that would be included in what's called EXIF data.

State Attorney (05:36:17):

Does the CD containing the deleted data or the deleted video fairly and accurately depict the video that you recovered from the trash folder on the defendant's secured folder on his phone?

Brian Hempstead (05:36:26):

Yes, it does.

State Attorney (05:36:27):

And does the other document containing the EXIF data related to that video fairly and accurately depict the information that you received from his phone regarding the victim?

Brian Hempstead (05:36:36):

Yes, it does.

State Attorney (05:36:36):

At this time, State would move HH into evidence as 35.

Defense Attorney (05:36:42):

No objection, Judge.

Judge (05:36:42):

Without objection, what's been marked for identification as State's Exhibit HH would be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 35.

State Attorney (05:36:52):

So when you look at this EXIF data, the details surrounding the video itself, were you able to determine what type of phone recorded the video?

Brian Hempstead (05:36:59):

Yes, I was.

State Attorney (05:36:59):

I'm sorry?

Brian Hempstead (05:37:02):

Yes.

State Attorney (05:37:03):

And what'd you find?

Brian Hempstead (05:37:04):

Within that EXIF data, there was author data, and that author data listed a Samsung Galaxy S25 Ultra as the device that took the video.

State Attorney (05:37:14):

And it that the same kind of phone as the phone containing the data that you examined?

Brian Hempstead (05:37:18):

Yes.

State Attorney (05:37:18):

Dwain Hall's phone? Okay.

(05:37:28)
Did that EXIF data... EXIF is E-X-I-F, am I right?

Brian Hempstead (05:37:33):

That's correct.

State Attorney (05:37:33):

Okay. Did that tell you when the video was first recorded?

Brian Hempstead (05:37:39):

I believe so, yes.

State Attorney (05:37:40):

Okay. And what date and time was that? And again, if you need to refresh your memory with your report, go ahead.

Brian Hempstead (05:37:59):

I believe it was October 11th, 2025, at 1:37 PM.

State Attorney (05:38:04):

Okay. May I publish, Your Honor, [inaudible 05:38:06]?

(05:38:05)
Okay. What are we looking at here?

Brian Hempstead (05:38:11):

So this is the data from that video that is displayed in the forensic tool that I used.

State Attorney (05:38:19):

Okay. Does it contain the date and time you just described?

Brian Hempstead (05:38:22):

Yes.

State Attorney (05:38:30):

Did you determine whether this video was deleted at the same time the other pictures we just looked at of Sonia Exelby were deleted?

Brian Hempstead (05:38:38):

Yes. When you look at the very bottom there where it says "Source file," so that is the file path. So we see the 150, that is the secure folder. We see the .trash, we see that it was in the gallery when it was deleted, and we see that 13-digit numeric number. So that is the Unix millisecond timestamp. That's what initially didn't click in my head when I saw it, the 13 digit timestamp, but I found that later. And then the second half of that shows us where the file was originally located on the device. So when you put something into Recycle Bin and windows, or in this case, the. trash in Android, the first half of the file path shows you where it's at, the second half shows you where it came from. So in that second half, it shows us it also came from the secure folder at 150, the DCIM folder, which, if you're using a mobile device or a digital camera, you might recognize as that's where your photos usually are.

(05:39:42)
But we have that camera directory, which is important in this case, which I'll get to in just a second. We have a series of exclamation points. That's just a folder within that secure folder. And then we have the file name of that video. But the camera is pretty significant.

State Attorney (05:40:01):

Okay. And what about the camera? What's significant?

Brian Hempstead (05:40:04):

That tells us the camera was used from the secure folder to take that video. So in secure folder, you can not only put things in there, but you can launch applications and different features from your phone from the secure folder, so that we have DCIM camera that's telling us the camera is what took the file that's within that folder.

State Attorney (05:40:23):

So the user would've had to enter in whatever password is needed to access the secure folder and specifically choose to take that video from the secure folder?

Brian Hempstead (05:40:31):

Yes.

State Attorney (05:40:33):

Okay. Did that EXIF data also give you a longitude and latitude of the location from which that video was actually recorded?

Brian Hempstead (05:40:41):

Yes, it did.

State Attorney (05:40:41):

And what do we see here in page 2 of that document?

Brian Hempstead (05:40:44):

We get a map plot of the latitude and longitude that we see above there, and it puts it in the vicinity of Northwest 122nd Terrace.

State Attorney (05:40:58):

May I approach again, Your Honor?

Brian Hempstead (05:40:59):

Yes, sir.

State Attorney (05:41:00):

Showing you what's been marked as State's Exhibit II for identification. Do you recognize that exhibit?

Brian Hempstead (05:41:06):

Yes.

State Attorney (05:41:07):

What is it?

Brian Hempstead (05:41:07):

This is when I took that GPS data there and put it into Google Maps and plotted the point in Google Maps.

State Attorney (05:41:16):

Okay. And does that fairly and accurately depict the results of that Google Map analysis?

Brian Hempstead (05:41:22):

Yes, it does.

State Attorney (05:41:22):

At this time, state would move II into evidence as 36.

Defense Attorney (05:41:25):

No objection, Judge.

Judge (05:41:27):

Without objection, what's been marked for identification as State's Exhibit II will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 36.

State Attorney (05:41:31):

[inaudible 05:41:32].

Judge (05:41:32):

Yes, sorry.

State Attorney (05:41:35):

Explain to the jury what we're looking at.

Brian Hempstead (05:41:38):

So we have latitude, longitude. Latitude, longitude can be put into two different ways. The bottom one there is the one that we see that is the same with the format that's in the EXIF data, and then we see the point there off of Northwest 122nd Terrace. The EXIF data doesn't give us horizontal accuracy, so it just gives us a general vicinity of where that image was taken. I can't tell you within what range, whether it's 10 meters or 100 meters. I just know it was in that vicinity.

State Attorney (05:42:14):

Okay. Did you locate any evidence of any correspondence or interaction between Dwain Hall and somebody named Ari Peterson on his cell phone?

Brian Hempstead (05:42:26):

No, I did not.

State Attorney (05:42:27):

Okay. Did you also examine Dwain Hall's Facebook account and Facebook messages on the phone that we've been talking about?

Brian Hempstead (05:42:34):

Yes, I did.

State Attorney (05:42:35):

Did you locate any correspondence between Dwain Hall and someone named Rick Snyder using the username Rick Stoner?

Brian Hempstead (05:42:42):

Yes, I did.

State Attorney (05:42:44):

And did you locate a Facebook contact for someone with the username Rick Stoner?

Brian Hempstead (05:42:50):

Yes, I did.

State Attorney (05:42:54):

Okay. May I approach again?

Judge (05:42:55):

Yes, sir.

State Attorney (05:42:55):

Showing you what's been marked as State's Exhibit JJ for identification. Can you take a look at that exhibit and let me know if you recognize its contents?

Brian Hempstead (05:43:16):

Yes.

State Attorney (05:43:18):

And generally, what does that exhibit show?

Brian Hempstead (05:43:22):

This is an appendix to my report that had in PowerPoint their conversation listed out with the timestamps from the device.

State Attorney (05:43:32):

I'm sorry. Go ahead.

Brian Hempstead (05:43:34):

I just put the pictures to each person so it was easier to understand the flow of the conversation.

State Attorney (05:43:39):

Does that exhibit fairly and accurately depict the Facebook messages between Dwain Hall and Rick Snyder?

Brian Hempstead (05:43:45):

Yes, it does.

State Attorney (05:43:46):

At this time, State would move JJ into evidence as State's 37.

Defense Attorney (05:43:51):

No objection, Judge.

Judge (05:43:52):

Without objection, what's been marked for identification as State's Exhibit... I'm sorry, JJ will be admitted as State's Exhibit 37.

State Attorney (05:44:00):

We'll look at the messages a little bit later on in the trial itself, but generally, what did the messages indicate around the time of October of 2025?

Brian Hempstead (05:44:12):

Around the time of October, Dwain Hall had reached out to Rick Snyder and asked him for his address, and he needed to send him a package. The package contained his most precious possessions. And he was being very vague and using coded language, and Mr. Snyder was concerned and kind of probative to try and figure out why, but he was just told that the package was going to be sent to him. He needed to hang onto it for about six months and then give it to his wife.

State Attorney (05:44:43):

And did you locate Facebook messages between Dwain Hall and Rick Snyder from back in May talking about a knife?

Brian Hempstead (05:44:51):

Yes.

State Attorney (05:44:52):

What did you find?

Brian Hempstead (05:44:53):

So back around May 8th, it was around the time of the suspect's birthday, and he was going to send him a gift.

State Attorney (05:45:04):

Who was going to send who a gift?

Brian Hempstead (05:45:05):

Mr. Snyder was sending Mr. Hall a gift, and he had sent it off to be engraved, and then the engraver was sending it to Mr. Hall, and it was supposed to be arrived, and Mr. Snyder, having not seen the result of the engraving, wanted Mr. Hall to send him an image of it back to him so he can see how the gift turned out.

State Attorney (05:45:26):

And what was the gift?

Brian Hempstead (05:45:27):

It was a Tanto bladed cold steel knife with an engraving across the blade. I believe it was a username that's associated with Mr. Hall, and then says, "This [inaudible 05:45:40] into the other guy," or something along those lines.

State Attorney (05:45:42):

Okay. So the discussion about the gift Rick Snyder was sending to Dwain Hall happened in May?

Brian Hempstead (05:45:51):

Yes.

State Attorney (05:45:52):

‍

And then in the middle of October were the messages where Dwain Hall was going to send something to Rick Snyder?

Brian Hempstead (05:45:59):

Yes.

State Attorney (05:45:59):

Okay. Did you locate an image taken on October 14th of 2025 showing a shipping receipt on Dwain Hall's phone?

Brian Hempstead (05:46:13):

Yes, I did.

State Attorney (05:46:14):

Was that consistent with the messages that you just talked about, about Dwain Hall sending Mr. Snyder a package?

Brian Hempstead (05:46:20):

Yes.

State Attorney (05:46:21):

All right. Did you also locate other images on Dwain Hall's cell phone involving rape, torture, and murder?

Brian Hempstead (05:46:30):

Yes, I did.

Defense Attorney (05:46:34):

Judge, may we approach?

Judge (05:46:36):

Yes, sir.

(05:46:41)
Ladies and gentlemen, I'm going to put the white noise on. Give me one moment.

State Attorney (05:47:54):

Showing you what's been marked as State's Exhibit KK for identification. Can you take a look at those and let me know if you recognize them?

Brian Hempstead (05:48:22):

Yes.

State Attorney (05:48:24):

And generally, what are those images?

Brian Hempstead (05:48:27):

These are other images. Some of them were from Google cache. I believe one was from Verizon Cloud cache that were on the device.

State Attorney (05:48:38):

Okay. Dwain Hall's device, his phone?

Brian Hempstead (05:48:40):

Yes.

State Attorney (05:48:40):

Okay. Do those fairly and accurately depict the images that you found on Dwain Hall's cell phone?

Brian Hempstead (05:48:46):

Yes, they do.

State Attorney (05:48:47):

At this time, State would move KK into evidence to State's 38.

Judge (05:48:53):

Subject to the discussion of the bench, what's been marked for identification as State's Exhibit KK will be admitted to evidence as State's Exhibit 38.

State Attorney (05:49:02):

You mentioned that those images were found, one of them was in Verizon Cloud cache and the rest of them were in Google cache?

Brian Hempstead (05:49:08):

That's correct.

State Attorney (05:49:09):

What is cache?

Brian Hempstead (05:49:10):

Cache is a function that digital devices use in order to store data temporarily in order to bring it to the user more quickly. For example, the Google Cloud cache, instead of you navigating to a website and having to re-download everything on that website, it caches some of that data so it can load a website quicker than having to download it. An application will do the same. Rather than having to download an image maybe that's in your gallery, it'll keep a cache of that image that's just like a thumbnail to bring up quicker, so it enhances the user experience.

State Attorney (05:49:51):

What would a user have to do in order for images that you just looked at to appear on his cell phone?

Brian Hempstead (05:49:59):

So for the cloud cache, you'd have to navigate to the website that had those images. For the Verizon Cloud cache, you'd have to interact through the Verizon Cloud platform with that image in order to trigger the system to create the cache to try to make your user experience more better.

State Attorney (05:50:18):

So the user would actually have to go to the website where these images appear?

Brian Hempstead (05:50:21):

Yes.

State Attorney (05:50:22):

And by going on that website, would those images download into cache to make it easier and quicker to view them the next time the user goes to the website?

Brian Hempstead (05:50:32):

That's correct.

State Attorney (05:50:32):

Okay. Regarding the image that you said that was found in the Verizon cache data, that was image number one of that exhibit, was it not?

Brian Hempstead (05:50:49):

That was correct.

State Attorney (05:50:50):

Okay. Were you able to determine what the last write time of that image was? And if it would refresh your memory to look at your report, go ahead, sir.

Brian Hempstead (05:51:15):

It was April 5th, 2025, at 1:05 PM.

State Attorney (05:51:19):

And what does it mean by a write time? What does that mean?

Brian Hempstead (05:51:23):

That's when that cache would've been written, so it would've been the last time that the user had interacted with that image to create and trigger the cache.

State Attorney (05:51:33):

That was for the Verizon cache image?

Brian Hempstead (05:51:34):

That's correct.

State Attorney (05:51:35):

Regarding all the other ones in Google cache, were you able to determine the right time for those images?

Brian Hempstead (05:51:40):

I don't... not believe so.

State Attorney (05:51:41):

And why not?

Brian Hempstead (05:51:45):

I'm trying to remember why. I don't believe they had the data. It was not parsed in there.

State Attorney (05:51:51):

Okay. So the data wasn't available for you to look at?

Brian Hempstead (05:51:53):

That's correct.

State Attorney (05:51:53):

Understood.

(05:51:55)
Did you look at other entries in the defendant's Google Chrome web history?

Brian Hempstead (05:52:03):

Okay. Whenever you're dealing with cache, one of the important things to do is look at the web history to try and identify what would trigger that cache. So I did examine his web history to try to determine what could have cached those images.

State Attorney (05:52:16):

And how many total entries were there in his Google Chrome web history?

Brian Hempstead (05:52:20):

It was 479 entries in the Google web history.

State Attorney (05:52:24):

And of those 479 entries, do you remember about how many of them involved the website Motherless?

Brian Hempstead (05:52:32):

276.

State Attorney (05:52:34):

What is Motherless?

Brian Hempstead (05:52:35):

Motherless.com is a now-defunct website that was taken down, but it hosted bondage, masochistic, sadistic images of rape, torture, under bondage-related things, and it was known to also occasionally... criminal sexual abuse of children was found on it, and these are the reasons why the servers were seized and it was taken down.

State Attorney (05:53:04):

Are the images you found in the cache area of the defendant's web history, the images that we just looked at in that exhibit, consistent with images that would generally appear on motherless.com?

Brian Hempstead (05:53:15):

Yes.

State Attorney (05:53:16):

In order for those images to appear in the cache section of the defendant's cell phone, would he have had to visit motherless.com?

Brian Hempstead (05:53:23):

Yes.

State Attorney (05:53:25):

Did you review the entries in his web history that were not associated with motherless.com?

Brian Hempstead (05:53:31):

Yes, I did.

State Attorney (05:53:31):

And what did that reveal?

Brian Hempstead (05:53:34):

The only two other pornographic sites that were in the web history was Chaturbate, which is a live-streaming sexual conversation type of application where somebody would strip or do things like that, bing.com. And then the other things were like espn.com, WikiHow, I believe banking things, or just your regular websites you would go to through your daily life. Nothing else that would be associated with that type of content.

State Attorney (05:54:03):

So did you find any images of rape, murder, or torture in the entries not associated with motherless.com?

Brian Hempstead (05:54:10):

No.

State Attorney (05:54:11):

Okay. In child pornographic cases, child pornography cases and things like that, a common argument is that the images just popped up on the person's phone. Regarding the images that you saw on Dwain Hall's phone that we've been discussing, could those images have simply popped up on his phone without him doing anything to get there?

Brian Hempstead (05:54:35):

No. What we normally see when we see popups, as you people know, by navigating the internet, normally what you see is somebody tried to sell you something, a popup, spin this wheel, get 10% off, something like that. You don't really see sadomasochistic content popping up on your device. You might find a redirect. You go to a website, maybe it's a little bit sketchy, it sends you to another website that sends you to another website, something like that. But in those cases, we see traces of that in the web history. We'll see the redirect in the URL. If it's an advertisement popup, we'll see the advertisement in the web history. So we'll see that in the web history, and I don't see that in the web history on this device. What I do see is navigation, not only to motherless.com, but through the sub-directories of motherless.com. I see searches on motherless.com. I see him looking for things in motherless.com, talking to other people's member profiles on motherless.com, expansively going through the website, not just accidentally hitting it or just going to the front of it.

State Attorney (05:55:44):

Okay. You used the term URL. What is that?

Brian Hempstead (05:55:48):

It's like google.com. That is the URL for Google.

State Attorney (05:55:55):

Kind of like the website address?

Brian Hempstead (05:55:57):

Yes.

State Attorney (05:55:57):

Okay. At this time, Your Honor, I request permission to publish State's Exhibit 38.

Judge (05:56:02):

Yes, sir.

State Attorney (05:56:06):

Showing you image 1 of 38, image 2, image 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, image 10, image 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17. Did you locate any indication in the defendant's phone that he viewed or accessed any videos with the word stab in the title?

Brian Hempstead (05:57:44):

Yes. There was two entries in the Google Chrome web history where there was a video named Short Stab and a video named Short Stab 2.

State Attorney (05:57:56):

Were you actually able to pull the videos up associated with those entries?

Brian Hempstead (05:58:00):

No. The URLs no longer work because the website has been taken down.

State Attorney (05:58:03):

And what did you find as far as when those videos were viewed or downloaded?

Brian Hempstead (05:58:12):

The website those were at were accessed on October 16th of '25 one after the other. One was, like, at 1:01 PM, the other one was, like, 1:02 PM, so they were short videos.

State Attorney (05:58:28):

Thank you, sir.

(05:58:29)
No other questions, Your Honor.

Judge (05:58:30):

Any cross-examination?

Defense Attorney (05:58:31):

Just briefly, Judge.

Judge (05:58:33):

Yes, sir.

Defense Attorney (05:58:40):

When you said these items were downloaded, you talk about whoever was using the phone at the time, correct?

Brian Hempstead (05:58:48):

Yes. In digital forensics, I can only say that the user of the device did an action. I can't tell you who was behind the device at that time.

Defense Attorney (05:58:58):

And also you used the word normally. Is it possible that visiting a site, there can be a download that was not intended download? Do you understand what I'm asking you?

Brian Hempstead (05:59:12):

So you're asking, is there a possibility that he went to a site and then things were downloaded just by visiting the site?

Defense Attorney (05:59:21):

Without you actually doing the download. There's some sites where you may click on to view something and end up putting something on your phone or whatever you use to download it with [inaudible 05:59:35].

Brian Hempstead (05:59:34):

On a malicious website, things like that are possible, but I didn't see anything like that in his web history.

Defense Attorney (05:59:41):

So you're saying all of the photos you saw, you could tell that they were actually downloaded by that person?

Brian Hempstead (05:59:47):

I can't say that they were actually downloaded. What I can say is they were cached, and they're consistent with the content that was on motherless.com. I can't say for certain that that's what caused them to be cached, but I say it's consistent with the content that's on that website.

Defense Attorney (06:00:01):

And consistent just means that those kind of images are also on that website, correct?

Brian Hempstead (06:00:06):

That is correct.

Defense Attorney (06:00:07):

You're not saying that there may not be other website that may have those similar images, correct?

Brian Hempstead (06:00:11):

That is correct.

Defense Attorney (06:00:12):

And you're not saying some of these other website may not have a system where you view it and it downloads itself as opposed to you choosing to download it?

Brian Hempstead (06:00:23):

I did not identify any websites in the web history that I was able to analyze that I think would've caused that.

Defense Attorney (06:00:33):

Say that again. Are you saying in his web history?

Brian Hempstead (06:00:36):

In the web history from Google Chrome that I examined, I didn't see any websites that appeared to be malicious that could cause something like that.

Defense Attorney (06:00:45):

And you said there was another website that you weren't able to view?

Brian Hempstead (06:00:50):

I'm not able to view motherless.com because it doesn't exist anymore.

Defense Attorney (06:00:55):

Okay. Okay. But again, you're not saying that it isn't possible for items to be downloaded onto a cell phone or a tablet because of the sites you've gone to?

Brian Hempstead (06:01:08):

If you go to a malicious website, it is possible that it triggers something to download. That is a possibility. I'm just saying, in his web history, I did not see any indications in what's recorded in his web history to indicate that.

Defense Attorney (06:01:24):

That he's been to one of those sites?

Brian Hempstead (06:01:27):

That I did not see any site that appeared to be malicious in his web history.

Defense Attorney (06:01:32):

Okay. I don't have any other questions.

Judge (06:01:34):

Any redirect examination?

State Attorney (06:01:35):

Briefly, Your Honor.

(06:01:37)
Based on the extensive navigation within the motherless website and the different searches you indicate were run, is that consistent with some kind of accidental thing?

Brian Hempstead (06:01:48):

No.

Judge (06:01:50):

Any recross examination?

Defense Attorney (06:01:52):

No, Your Honor.

Judge (06:01:52):

Members of the jury, do any of you have questions of this witness? If you do, please raise your hand.

(06:01:56)
Seeing no hands, State, is he released?

State Attorney (06:01:59):

He is, Your Honor.

Judge (06:01:59):

Defense?

Defense Attorney (06:02:00):

No objection, Your Honor.

Judge (06:02:01):

Sir, you're free to go about your day. Thank you for your time.

Defense Attorney (06:02:03):

Thank you.

Judge (06:02:05):

State, are we ready for the next witness, or do you need a moment to set up the board, or does that come later?

State Attorney (06:02:12):

Actually, Your Honor, the State's going to call Joe Miller first.

Judge (06:02:15):

Okay. Very well.

(06:02:15)
Come on in, sir. Please raise your right hand. Face the clerk to be sworn.

Clerk (06:03:02):

Do you swear or-

Judge (06:03:00):

Come on in, sir. Just raise your right hand, face the clerk to be sworn.

Clerk (06:03:07):

Do you swear or affirm the testimony you're about to give be the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so help you God?

Joseph Miller (06:03:07):

Yes, I do.

Judge (06:03:08):

Okay. You can be seated. Thank you.

Joseph Miller (06:03:09):

Thank you, sir.

Speaker 14 (06:03:09):

Can you please introduce yourself to the jury?

Joseph Miller (06:03:15):

My name is Joseph Miller.

Speaker 14 (06:03:17):

Okay. And where do you work, sir?

Joseph Miller (06:03:18):

I work for the Marion County Sheriff's Office.

Speaker 14 (06:03:20):

What do you do for them?

Joseph Miller (06:03:21):

I'm currently assigned to the Office of Professional Standards as an inspector sergeant.

Speaker 14 (06:03:26):

Okay. Did you become involved in the investigation into the murder of Sonia Exelby?

Joseph Miller (06:03:31):

Yes, I did.

Speaker 14 (06:03:32):

And did you assist Florida Department of Law Enforcement Special Agent Rebecca McKenzie in interviewing the defendant, Dwain Hall?

Joseph Miller (06:03:39):

Yes, I did.

Speaker 14 (06:03:40):

Do you see Mr. Hall here in court?

Joseph Miller (06:03:43):

Yes, I do.

Speaker 14 (06:03:43):

Can you please point him out and tell me what he's wearing?

Joseph Miller (06:03:46):

He's over there with the blue shirt, has a beard as well, on the left.

Speaker 14 (06:03:49):

Your Honor, may the record reflect the witness has identified the defendant?

Mr. Barrett (06:03:52):

No objection.

Judge (06:03:53):

Without objection, the record will reflect the witness has identified the defendant.

Speaker 14 (06:03:55):

The day after the interview of the defendant, were you responsible for collecting the clothing he was wearing at the time of the interview?

Joseph Miller (06:04:02):

Yes, I was.

Speaker 14 (06:04:03):

And where did you go to collect the clothing?

Joseph Miller (06:04:05):

I went to the Marion County Jail.

Speaker 14 (06:04:07):

What happens when somebody is brought to the jail with a person's clothing?

Joseph Miller (06:04:12):

So once someone's booked into the jail, they get assigned a property box, and within that box goes their clothing and any other personal items that they're brought in with.

Speaker 14 (06:04:20):

So where did you actually go to collect the defendant's clothes?

Joseph Miller (06:04:25):

Within the booking area of the jail, there's an evidence property room area if you... or a property room area, if you would, where all those property boxes get stored, and that's where I went to get the items.

Speaker 14 (06:04:38):

When you saw the defendant's clothing in the property box, did you actually look at the clothes?

Joseph Miller (06:04:43):

Yes, I did.

Speaker 14 (06:04:44):

Were you able to say whether the clothes that you saw in his property box were the same clothes that he was wearing during the lengthy interview done with him the day before?

Joseph Miller (06:04:51):

Yes. They were the same.

Speaker 14 (06:04:54):

Okay. In addition to the rest of his clothing, did you specifically collect his shirt and his shoes from his property?

Joseph Miller (06:04:58):

Yes.

Speaker 14 (06:04:59):

May I approach?

Judge (06:05:07):

Yes, sir.

Speaker 14 (06:05:08):

Showing you State's Exhibit LL for identification. Can you take a look at that and tell me if you recognize the contents, or recognize the package?

Joseph Miller (06:05:16):

Yes, I do.

Speaker 14 (06:05:17):

Do you recognize it? Do you recognize the contents?

Joseph Miller (06:05:58):

Yes, I do.

Speaker 14 (06:05:58):

What's inside?

Joseph Miller (06:06:00):

It's the shirt that Mr. Hall had been wearing during the interview.

Speaker 14 (06:06:03):

Is it the same or in substantially the same condition as when you collected it and packaged it into that package?

Joseph Miller (06:06:08):

Yes.

Speaker 14 (06:06:08):

At this time, State would move LL into evidence as 39.

Mr. Barrett (06:06:12):

No objection, Judge.

Judge (06:06:13):

Without objection, what's marked for identification as State's Exhibit LL will be admitted to evidence as State's Exhibit 39.

Speaker 14 (06:06:19):

I'm also showing you State's Exhibit MM, as in Mary. Do you recognize that item?

Joseph Miller (06:06:31):

Yes, I do.

Speaker 14 (06:06:31):

How do you recognize it?

Joseph Miller (06:06:33):

It's the shoes that were collected. That I had originally collected.

Speaker 14 (06:06:37):

Okay. Can you open that up, look inside, tell me if you recognize the contents?

Joseph Miller (06:07:17):

There's two more inner bags where the shoes are wrapped individually, but it does appear to be the items.

Speaker 14 (06:07:20):

Can you go ahead and open it up and open these two individual bags?

Joseph Miller (06:07:20):

Yep. Yep.

Speaker 14 (06:08:49):

Do you recognize the contents of the two inner bags that were contained within State's Exhibit MM?

Joseph Miller (06:08:53):

Yes, I do.

Speaker 14 (06:08:54):

What are they?

Joseph Miller (06:08:54):

The two shoes from Mr. Hall that I had recovered.

Speaker 14 (06:08:57):

Are they in the same or substantially the same condition as when you collected them at the jail on his property?

Joseph Miller (06:09:01):

Yes, they are.

Speaker 14 (06:09:02):

At this time, State would move MM, as in Mary, into evidence as 40.

Mr. Barrett (06:09:06):

No objection, Judge.

Judge (06:09:09):

Without objection, what's been marked for identification as State's Exhibit MM will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 40.

Speaker 14 (06:09:12):

No further questions, Your Honor.

(06:09:33)
Thank you, sir.

Mr. Barrett (06:09:33):

No questions, Your Honor.

Judge (06:09:35):

Members of the jury, any of y'all have questions of this witness?

(06:09:36)
All right, please hand to the bailiff.

(06:09:38)
Lawyers approach. I'm going to put the white noise on, ladies and gentlemen.

(06:10:27)
Counsel, you all can be seated.

(06:10:27)
Members of the jury, I will now read aloud the question.

(06:10:29)
Sergeant, the question is: Why was first bag opened at the bottom and resealed, and who did that?

Joseph Miller (06:10:46):

So essentially, whenever a bag... once it's sealed, general practice is to not open it in the same spot again. At any point in the chain of custody, whenever someone else opens it, so essentially, if it goes to the laboratory to be processed for DNA or something of that nature, then they'll cut it open, take out the contents, and then reseal it in that area wherever it was cut open. So whoever does it, they initial it here. My initials and ID are up here, and this is where it was originally sealed, was at the top. So then, anywhere within the chain of custody after that, they would've opened it down here. These initials are BH. I, offhand, don't know who that is, but it would be within the report and chain of custody as to who opened that.

Judge (06:11:31):

Any follow up, State?

Speaker 14 (06:11:32):

Very briefly. Based on the markings on this bag, especially the yellow sticker, is that suggesting that this was sent to the Florida Department of Law Enforcement for DNA analysis?

Joseph Miller (06:11:41):

Correct. Yes, it was.

Speaker 14 (06:11:42):

And are you aware of the DNA analyst named Brooke Hoover, BH?

Joseph Miller (06:11:46):

I'm personally not, but that would make sense, with the initials.

Speaker 14 (06:11:50):

Thank you.

Joseph Miller (06:11:51):

Yes, sir.

Judge (06:11:51):

Any follow up, Mr. Barrett?

Mr. Barrett (06:11:52):

No, your Honor.

Judge (06:11:53):

Members of the jury, any additional questions? If so, please raise your hands. Okay.

(06:11:57)
State, is this witness released?

Speaker 14 (06:11:58):

He is, Your Honor.

Judge (06:11:59):

Defense?

Mr. Barrett (06:11:59):

No objection, Judge.

Judge (06:12:00):

Okay, sir, you're free to go about your day. Thank you for your time.

Joseph Miller (06:12:02):

Thank you, Your Honor.

(06:12:02)
Thank you, all.

Judge (06:12:04):

State, will the next witness be the witness during which we'll need the other television?

Speaker 14 (06:12:08):

Not until after her testimony is done.

Judge (06:12:11):

Okay. So we'll call the next witness, and then take a short break.

Speaker 14 (06:12:14):

Yes, Your Honor.

Judge (06:12:15):

How long will this witness be?

Attorney 3 (06:12:17):

15, 20 minutes.

Judge (06:12:18):

Okay. All right.

(06:12:19)
Members of the jury, can you all hold out a little bit longer for any restroom breaks? Seeing all affirmative head shakes.

(06:12:25)
Who would you like to call?

Attorney 3 (06:12:26):

Sarah Exelby.

Judge (06:12:27):

Okay. She may come up. Just come on over here, ma'am. Raise your right hand. Face the clerk to be sworn.

Clerk (06:12:47):

Do you swear or affirm the testimony you're about to give will be the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so help you God?

Sarah Exelby (06:12:47):

I do.

Judge (06:12:47):

Okay. You can go ahead and be seated, ma'am.

Attorney 3 (06:12:53):

Good afternoon. Can you tell the jury your name, please?

Sarah Exelby (06:12:57):

It's Sarah Exelby.

Attorney 3 (06:12:58):

All right. Where do you live, Ms. Exelby?

Sarah Exelby (06:13:01):

I live in South Australia.

Attorney 3 (06:13:03):

How long have you lived in Australia?

Sarah Exelby (06:13:06):

I first moved out there nine years ago. I did have a two-year period back in the UK between 2021 and 2023.

Attorney 3 (06:13:16):

All right. So you currently live in Australia?

Sarah Exelby (06:13:18):

Yes, that's correct.

Attorney 3 (06:13:20):

Are you related to Sonia Exelby?

Sarah Exelby (06:13:22):

Yes. I'm her sister.

Attorney 3 (06:13:24):

All right. What's the age difference between the two of you?

Sarah Exelby (06:13:26):

I'm three years older.

Attorney 3 (06:13:29):

Were you and Sonia adopted at a young age and separated from the rest of your siblings?

Sarah Exelby (06:13:33):

Yes, we were. Yeah. We were taken into foster care both together when I was, I think, five when she maybe about two, and then we were adopted a couple of years later together to a family.

Attorney 3 (06:13:48):

So you were adopted together later on?

Sarah Exelby (06:13:49):

Yeah.

Attorney 3 (06:13:50):

And you grew up in the same house?

Sarah Exelby (06:13:52):

We grew up in the same house, yeah.

Attorney 3 (06:13:53):

All right. And when did you notice Sonia begin to struggle with her mental health issues?

Sarah Exelby (06:13:59):

I would say in her early teens. She first struggled with eating disorders and, yeah, she received the help. My parents made sure she received the help she needed for those. Yeah.

Attorney 3 (06:14:10):

Were you aware that she was also doing some cutting, some self-harm?

Sarah Exelby (06:14:14):

I was aware, yes.

Attorney 3 (06:14:15):

All right.

Sarah Exelby (06:14:16):

Yeah.

Attorney 3 (06:14:17):

And she did receive some counseling, some therapy for the eating disorder and for the cutting?

Sarah Exelby (06:14:21):

Yes. Yeah. It was a very, very difficult time and we were trying to support her through it best we could.

Attorney 3 (06:14:28):

Now, when you and Sonia were young adults, did you reconnect with your older siblings?

Sarah Exelby (06:14:33):

Yes, we did. Sonia was actually probably the reason she'd met up with them before, and she said how amazing and wonderful they are. So she was up visiting me when I was at university. We arranged a meeting shortly after, and then after that, like we'd never been apart.

Attorney 3 (06:14:52):

How often did you and Sonia get to see each other in person as adults?

Sarah Exelby (06:14:57):

So I moved about four hours away to university when I was 19, and she'd come up and visit me, and I'd come home for holidays. And then, when I finished my studies, I moved back to my hometown, Portsmouth, and I moved in with Sonia, so we lived together for approximately two years. I knew she was struggling so much with her mental health and I wanted to see, if I were living with her, I could help her. And then after that, I moved to Australia. I was reluctant to leave, but Sonia always wanted me to go live my life and she hated being a burden. She felt she was a burden, which she absolutely wasn't, but she just had such a beautiful nature. She just wanted us all to do the best and she encouraged me to go. Once I was in Australia, I did come home as much as I could, but yeah, I'd say it was only every couple of years I got to see her in person until the two years I come back.

Attorney 3 (06:15:57):

Would you communicate with her in other ways? Video calls and such, things like that?

Sarah Exelby (06:16:01):

Yeah. Yeah, Messenger, WhatsApp, FaceTime. As previously stated, she had good and bad times, so it was just as much as we could. We never wanted to push. Someone struggling with mental health is so difficult that we didn't want to push or make her feel pressured, but we wanted to talk to her as much as we could.

Attorney 3 (06:16:26):

Did those mental health struggles cause her to often cancel or just not show up for timed meetings or FaceTimes, things like that?

Sarah Exelby (06:16:34):

Absolutely. So we'd always arrange meetings and get-togethers, or me just going around her house, even my parents would go and make sure she was okay. And sometimes she found it difficult even to answer the door. There'd be other times that we'd have a good times and we'd see her a lot more often. It was not very out of the ordinary if she canceled last minute or didn't message back, but we just did the best we could.

Attorney 3 (06:17:04):

Through all of those issues, did you still consider yourself close with Sonia?

Sarah Exelby (06:17:08):

Oh, absolutely. Yeah, we were very close.

Attorney 3 (06:17:11):

When is the last time you actually saw her in person?

Sarah Exelby (06:17:13):

So in 2023, I returned. I was returning back to Australia. We had a family gathering, so we were all together, and that's when I last saw Sonia.

Attorney 3 (06:17:25):

Okay. And at that family gathering, did you become aware that Sonia was communicating with some violent people on the dark web?

Sarah Exelby (06:17:35):

Yes, that's the first time we learned of it, and it was absolutely terrifying to think that she was in such a vulnerable state, and to think there were just these awful people out there who were taking advantage of her was just petrifying. So yeah.

Attorney 3 (06:17:53):

What did you and your sister, Gemma, do once Sonia made aware of what was happening?

Sarah Exelby (06:17:58):

We called the police straight away. We were so worried about all the threats that were being made to her, and she was just such a beautiful soul to think anyone could sort of do any harm towards her. I wanted to cancel my flight back, but we got the mental health crisis team, and she assured she was okay.

Attorney 3 (06:18:18):

Were you a part of contacting the police as well?

Sarah Exelby (06:18:21):

Yeah. So Gemma was on the phone. I was in the room with her at the time.

Attorney 3 (06:18:27):

So the police were contacted, as well as the mental health crisis team at this point?

Sarah Exelby (06:18:30):

That's correct, yeah.

Attorney 3 (06:18:30):

Okay. Now, over the weekend of October 10th of 2025 and October 12th of 2025, did you, Sonia, and Gemma have plans to get together?

Sarah Exelby (06:18:41):

Yes. So the main reason, for me, my return back to the UK for a holiday was to see Sonia and just to check up on her and check she was okay. I was very excited to see her.

Attorney 3 (06:18:52):

Where were you going to meet?

Sarah Exelby (06:18:56):

So originally, she was going to meet me at the airport with Gemma, but she found that too hard, which is understandable. And then, she changed it, saying, "I'll meet you tomorrow on the Sunday, the 12th," which was, yeah, absolutely fine.

Attorney 3 (06:19:12):

So that was Sunday, the 12th, she was supposed to meet you?

Sarah Exelby (06:19:16):

Yeah.

Attorney 3 (06:19:17):

And where was she going to meet you?

Sarah Exelby (06:19:19):

At Gemma's house. So she was going to stay over and we were just going to spend time together at home.

Attorney 3 (06:19:25):

Okay. And did you think anything about the fact that she had changed the plans from, "I'm coming on Friday, that I'm going to be there on Saturday," and then she changed it to Sunday? Was that unusual in any way?

Sarah Exelby (06:19:35):

Not at all, no.

Attorney 3 (06:19:35):

All right. And did you fly in to England, as planned, on Saturday, October 11th of 2025?

Sarah Exelby (06:19:40):

I did, yes.

Attorney 3 (06:19:42):

All right. And did Sonia ever come to Gemma's house on Sunday, as planned? I just need you to answer out loud. I'm sorry.

Sarah Exelby (06:19:48):

No.

Attorney 3 (06:19:56):

Did you try to contact her when she didn't come on Sunday?

Sarah Exelby (06:19:58):

Yes. I sent her a message, saying, "Are you still coming, darling?" on WhatsApp, but it didn't go through, so then I sent her a message on Messenger as well. Again, there was no reply. It didn't look like she had her phone on, which again, was not unusual.

Attorney 3 (06:20:22):

All right. So you sent her the message saying, "Are you still coming?" and she didn't respond, but again, that wasn't unusual?

Sarah Exelby (06:20:28):

Yeah. Yeah.

Attorney 3 (06:20:32):

Okay. Now, did you learn later that Sunday night that Sonia had actually left her house on Friday and was missing?

Sarah Exelby (06:20:37):

Yes. Stevie contacted us and said, "She's been missing since Friday." And we were obviously very concerned.

Attorney 3 (06:20:45):

And the police were involved right away?

Sarah Exelby (06:20:47):

Yes. Yeah.

Attorney 3 (06:20:49):

Now, on Thursday, October 16th of 2025, did you see a message on your Facebook from someone whose profile name was Ari Peterson?

Sarah Exelby (06:21:00):

That's correct, yes.

Attorney 3 (06:21:01):

All right. Did you know anybody named Ari Peterson?

Sarah Exelby (06:21:03):

No.

Attorney 3 (06:21:04):

All right. When was the message from Ari Peterson actually sent to you?

Sarah Exelby (06:21:09):

I think it was Saturday, the 11th of October. It'd gone into my message requests, and I just didn't see this message until then because I don't get notifications for those.

Attorney 3 (06:21:19):

All right. So this person, Ari Peterson, sent you a message Saturday, October 11th, but you didn't see it until Thursday, October 16th?

Sarah Exelby (06:21:27):

That's correct.

Attorney 3 (06:21:39):

Okay.

(06:21:39)
Your Honor, at this time we are moving State's Exhibit NN as a self-authenticating document. A notice of intent to rely on the business record exception has been filed, as well as a business record certification from Discord.

Mr. Barrett (06:21:51):

No objection, Your Honor.

Judge (06:21:53):

Without objection, State's Exhibit NN will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 41.

Attorney 3 (06:21:58):

May I approach the witness, Your Honor?

Judge (06:21:59):

Yes, ma'am.

Attorney 3 (06:22:01):

I'll show you what's been marked for identifications as NN entered into evidence. If you can just look at this portion right here. Do you recognize this to be what Ari Peterson sent you that Saturday, October 11th?

Sarah Exelby (06:22:15):

That's correct, yes.

Attorney 3 (06:22:17):

And was he concerned about Sonia?

Sarah Exelby (06:22:18):

Yes, he was very concerned.

Attorney 3 (06:22:20):

And did he actually send you a letter that Sonia had written to him?

Sarah Exelby (06:22:25):

He sent me screenshots of the messages.

Attorney 3 (06:22:30):

And Your Honor, may I publish?

Judge (06:22:31):

Yes, ma'am.

Attorney 3 (06:22:35):

And I do have copies if there's anybody on the jury that cannot read it. I don't know if anybody wants a copy of it.

Judge (06:22:40):

Do you have enough for everybody?

Attorney 3 (06:22:41):

Yes.

Judge (06:22:42):

Let's go ahead and hand them out. We'll just take them up and collect them when we're done.

(06:22:53)
If y'all want to take about half of those and hand them to the back row. Okay, ladies and gentlemen, if you've all had a chance to read that, go ahead and pass them down to your right side.

Attorney 3 (06:25:33):

Did you give the police a copy of this letter immediately that Ari Peterson had sent you?

Sarah Exelby (06:25:37):

Absolutely. I called the police straight away and sent it across.

Attorney 3 (06:25:40):

Thank you.

(06:25:41)
I don't have any other questions, Judge.

Judge (06:25:43):

Any cross-examination?

Mr. Barrett (06:25:46):

No, Your Honor.

Judge (06:25:46):

Ladies and gentlemen of the jury, do any of you all have questions of this witness? If you do, please raise your hand. Okay.

(06:25:52)
Seeing no hands, is this witness released, State?

Attorney 3 (06:25:54):

We'd ask that she be excused, Your Honor.

Mr. Barrett (06:25:54):

No objection.

Judge (06:25:56):

Ma'am, you're free to go about your day. Thank you for your time.

Attorney 3 (06:25:58):

Judge, we may take a short break to bring in the smartphone?

Judge (06:26:00):

Yes, ma'am.

(06:26:01)
Ladies and gentlemen, we'll take about a 10-minute break. When you're all are ready, just give a quick knock on the door, let Deputy McCullaghty know, and we'll get you all back in. Same rules apply. No pads here, no discussions, no electronic devices to learn about the case. All right, the jury's left the courtroom. We'll take about a five-minute break, here. Mr. Hall, if you need to use the restroom, now would be the time, sir.

(06:27:02)
State, is this Exhibit 35?

Attorney 3 (06:33:13):

Make sure. This is important.

Speaker 14 (06:33:15):

I can tell you in a second, Your Honor. Yes, sir.

Judge (06:33:25):

Are we ready for the jury?

Speaker 14 (06:33:25):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Barrett (06:33:25):

Yes, Your Honor.

Speaker 15 (06:33:25):

[inaudible 06:33:29] one in the restroom.

Judge (06:33:25):

One of the restroom?

(06:33:25)
Ladies and gentlemen, welcome back. Everyone can be seated.

(06:33:25)
State?

Speaker 14 (06:35:43):

At this time, Your Honor, the State would ask to publish State's Exhibit 35, the deleted video of the victim found on the defendant's cell phone.

Judge (06:35:50):

You may publish.

Speaker 16 (06:35:54):

I want you to tell me about why you're here.

Speaker 17 (06:35:56):

I don't know. [inaudible 06:36:01].

Speaker X (06:35:56):

[inaudible 06:36:02].

Speaker 19 (06:36:03):

I'm an awful person, [inaudible 06:36:04].

Speaker 18 (06:36:05):

Yeah, but why are you such an awful person?

Speaker 19 (06:36:15):

I've crushed everyone who ever loves me. I've cheated on my partner. [inaudible 06:36:23]. God, the amount of lie to everyone about this is overwhelming. Led on so many men because I didn't know how to just... Well, it was more just that I didn't have the guts to say no because I knew they probably wouldn't like me or... I don't know. People just always seemed overly nice. Yeah, I was always an oddball.

Speaker 18 (06:37:17):

And how did you want to die? What was your chosen way to die? Kind of describe that. What have you been consenting to here today?

Speaker 19 (06:37:33):

You mean the way that you told me about killing me? Yeah. Is that what you mean?

Speaker 18 (06:37:47):

Huh?

Speaker 19 (06:37:47):

Is that what you mean? Sorry.

Speaker 18 (06:37:49):

You consent to what kind of treatment beforehand that you feel like you deserve?

Speaker 19 (06:38:09):

To be stabbed.

Speaker 18 (06:38:09):

Huh?

Speaker 19 (06:38:09):

To be stabbed.

Speaker 18 (06:38:11):

Yeah, that's what you want. But the last day or two, what has your treatment been? What did you ask for leading up to that?

Speaker 19 (06:38:23):

I can't remember. We've talked about so many different ways.

Speaker 18 (06:38:36):

What's this on your face?

Speaker 19 (06:38:47):

You've beaten me.

Speaker 18 (06:38:50):

Is that what you wanted? Is that what you asked for?

Speaker 19 (06:39:01):

Yes, it's truly speaking.

Speaker 18 (06:39:06):

Now, you're being coerced? You're being forced into this? And this is how you wanted to die, right? You wanted to be beaten and made to suffer because you're such a piece of shit? Say it.

Speaker 19 (06:39:46):

I needed to be beaten and suffer because I'm such a piece of shit.

Speaker 18 (06:39:47):

Good, good. You're not being forced to say that, right? So are you getting what you wanted? Are you pleased? Are you happy?

Judge (06:41:00):

State, you may call your next witness.

State Attorney (06:41:00):

State calls Maria Andreoli.

Speaker 21 (06:41:01):

[inaudible 06:41:36].

State Attorney (06:41:35):

Why don't you?

Speaker 21 (06:41:35):

Give me one second, I'll [inaudible 06:41:42].

Judge (06:41:43):

Come on up, ma'am. Raise your right hand. Face the clerk to be sworn.

Speaker 20 (06:41:44):

Do you or affirm the testimony you're about to give will be the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so help you God?

Maria Andreoli (06:41:44):

Yes, I do.

Judge (06:41:51):

Okay. You can be seated, ma'am.

State Attorney (06:41:55):

Hello again.

Maria Andreoli (06:41:56):

Hello.

State Attorney (06:41:57):

Could you please tell the jury your name one more time?

Maria Andreoli (06:41:59):

Yes. Maria Andreoli, A-N-D-R-E-O-L-I.

State Attorney (06:42:05):

And you work for FDLE, right?

Maria Andreoli (06:42:06):

Yes.

State Attorney (06:42:07):

All right. Let me direct your attention to October 17th of 2025. Did you respond to the Marion County Sheriff's Office to process a black four-door Jeep Cherokee belonging to Dwain Hall?

Maria Andreoli (06:42:18):

Yes, I did.

State Attorney (06:42:20):

Okay. And did you in fact process that Jeep?

Maria Andreoli (06:42:22):

Yes.

State Attorney (06:42:23):

And where was that done?

Maria Andreoli (06:42:25):

That was done in the Marion County Sheriff's Office vehicle garage.

State Attorney (06:42:30):

During the course of your processing of that Jeep, did you take photos?

Maria Andreoli (06:42:34):

Yes, I did.

State Attorney (06:42:35):

May I approach?

Judge (06:42:36):

Yes, sir.

State Attorney (06:42:36):

Showing you what's marked as State's Exhibit OO. Can you take a look at those photos and tell me if you recognize them?

Maria Andreoli (06:42:41):

I do.

State Attorney (06:43:18):

Generally, what do those show?

Maria Andreoli (06:43:20):

These are the photographs that I took while processing the Jeep.

State Attorney (06:43:24):

Did they fairly and accurately depict the outside as well as the inside and the items that you found inside the Jeep?

Maria Andreoli (06:43:30):

Yes.

State Attorney (06:43:30):

State would move 00 into evidence as 42, Your Honor.

Speaker 21 (06:45:37):

No objection, Judge.

Judge (06:45:38):

Without objection, what's been marked for identification as State's Exhibit OO will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 42.

State Attorney (06:45:40):

May I publish?

Judge (06:45:40):

Yes, sir.

State Attorney (06:45:40):

Showing you photo one of State's 42, excuse me. Is this the Jeep you processed?

Maria Andreoli (06:45:40):

Yes.

State Attorney (06:45:40):

Showing you photo two. Just the front view of it?

Maria Andreoli (06:45:40):

Yes.

State Attorney (06:45:40):

Photo three, rear-view of the Jeep, right?

Maria Andreoli (06:45:40):

Yes.

State Attorney (06:45:40):

And did you also document the VIN number associated with that Jeep, photo four?

Maria Andreoli (06:45:40):

Yes, I did.

State Attorney (06:45:40):

Okay. Showing you photo five, did you locate a Florida vehicle registration inside the vehicle?

Maria Andreoli (06:45:40):

Yes, I did.

State Attorney (06:45:40):

And to whom was the Jeep registered?

Maria Andreoli (06:45:40):

It was registered to Dwain Hall.

State Attorney (06:45:40):

Showing you photo six. Did you examine the center console of that Jeep?

Maria Andreoli (06:45:40):

Yes, I did.

State Attorney (06:45:40):

And what do we see in this photo?

Maria Andreoli (06:45:40):

This is an overall photo of the contents in the portion of the center console.

State Attorney (06:45:40):

Photo seven, did you remove the items found in the center console and lay them out?

Maria Andreoli (06:45:40):

Yes, I did.

State Attorney (06:45:40):

After removing all those items, did you locate a brown and gold item that we see in the top left of this photo?

Maria Andreoli (06:45:40):

Yes, I did.

State Attorney (06:45:40):

And what is that?

Maria Andreoli (06:45:40):

It was a brown and gold toned folding knife.

State Attorney (06:45:40):

Showing you photo eight from State's 42. What do we see here?

Maria Andreoli (06:45:40):

This is a closeup photograph of the folding knife.

State Attorney (06:45:40):

Okay. May I approach?

Judge (06:45:40):

Yes, sir.

State Attorney (06:45:41):

I'm showing you what's been marked as State's Exhibit PP as in Paul. Do you recognize that item?

Maria Andreoli (06:45:41):

Yes, I do.

State Attorney (06:45:41):

What is it?

Maria Andreoli (06:45:41):

It is the folding knife that is pictured.

State Attorney (06:45:41):

Okay. And how do you recognize it?

Maria Andreoli (06:45:41):

It has my handwriting, initials, and the FDLE barcode on it.

State Attorney (06:45:41):

Because we have a picture of it in the photograph, I'm not going to go ahead and ask you to open it, but is it in the same, substantially the same condition the box as when you collected it and sealed?

Maria Andreoli (06:45:41):

Yes.

‍

State Attorney (06:45:41):

This time, state would move PP as in Paul into evidence as 43.

Speaker 21 (06:45:41):

No objection, Judge.

Judge (06:45:42):

Without objection, what's been marked for identification as State's Exhibit PP will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 43.

State Attorney (06:45:45):

Showing you photograph seven of State's 42 again. Did you locate some receipts in that same center console?

Maria Andreoli (06:45:52):

Yes, I did.

State Attorney (06:45:53):

And what type of receipts did you find?

Maria Andreoli (06:45:55):

They were UPS receipts.

State Attorney (06:45:58):

Showing you photo nine of State's 42. What does this show?

Maria Andreoli (06:46:02):

This is a receipt from the UPS store that I found in the center console.

State Attorney (06:46:07):

And photo 10, just a closeup of that same receipt?

Maria Andreoli (06:46:11):

Yes.

State Attorney (06:46:11):

What's the date and time of that receipt?

Maria Andreoli (06:46:16):

Oh, thank you. It is dated October 14th, 2025, at 9:23 AM.

State Attorney (06:46:22):

And from where was it shipped?

Maria Andreoli (06:46:24):

3101 Southwest 34th Avenue, Suite 905 in Ocala, Florida.

State Attorney (06:46:32):

How much did it cost to ship this package?

Maria Andreoli (06:46:35):

It was $41.91.

State Attorney (06:46:37):

And was there a tracking number on the receipt that you saw?

Maria Andreoli (06:46:40):

Yes.

State Attorney (06:46:44):

Did you also find a separate shipment receipt associated with this?

Maria Andreoli (06:46:48):

Yes, I did.

State Attorney (06:46:49):

Okay. Showing you photograph 11 of State's 42. What do we see here?

Maria Andreoli (06:46:53):

This is a photograph of the shipping receipt that I found in the center console.

State Attorney (06:46:58):

And photograph 12, just a closeup?

Maria Andreoli (06:47:01):

Yes.

State Attorney (06:47:01):

Does the information, including the tracking number, is it the same as in the prior receipts we just looked at?

Maria Andreoli (06:47:07):

Yes, it is.

State Attorney (06:47:16):

Did it appear that both the receipt and the shipping receipt reflect the shipment of the same package at the same time?

Maria Andreoli (06:47:22):

Yes.

State Attorney (06:47:22):

Okay. And who was the person shipping the package according to the shipping receipt?

Maria Andreoli (06:47:29):

Dwain Hall.

State Attorney (06:47:30):

Okay. At what address?

Maria Andreoli (06:47:32):

16271 Southwest 27th Terrace Road in Ocala, Florida.

State Attorney (06:47:39):

And to whom was this package going to be shipped?

Maria Andreoli (06:47:41):

Rick Snyder.

State Attorney (06:47:44):

At what address?

Maria Andreoli (06:47:45):

10420 State Road 550 in Vincent, Ohio.

State Attorney (06:47:52):

Okay. Showing you photograph seven again from State's 42. Did you also locate a cell phone in that same center console?

Maria Andreoli (06:48:00):

Yes, I did.

State Attorney (06:48:03):

Photo 13 of State's 42, what does this show?

Maria Andreoli (06:48:05):

This is a photograph of the cell phone with the case removed.

State Attorney (06:48:10):

In what condition was the cell phone, specifically the screen?

Maria Andreoli (06:48:13):

The screen was cracked and it appeared that it had a piece of tape over it.

State Attorney (06:48:19):

Okay. I'm showing you photograph 14 of State's 42. Is this the other side of it?

Maria Andreoli (06:48:23):

Yes.

State Attorney (06:48:24):

Did you collect this cell phone as evidence?

Maria Andreoli (06:48:26):

Yes, I did.

State Attorney (06:48:28):

May I approach?

Judge (06:48:28):

Yes, sir.

State Attorney (06:48:29):

Showing you State's QQ for identification. Do you recognize that item?

Maria Andreoli (06:48:36):

Yes, I do.

State Attorney (06:48:37):

What is it and how do you recognize it?

Maria Andreoli (06:48:39):

It is the blue Samsung cell phone with the case that is pictured above, and it was collected from the center console. It has my handwriting, initials, and FDLE barcode on it.

State Attorney (06:48:55):

Okay. Is it in the same or substantially the same condition as when you collected it from Dwain Hall's Jeep?

Maria Andreoli (06:48:59):

Yes.

State Attorney (06:49:00):

At this time, state would move QQ into evidence as 43 or 44, excuse me.

Speaker 21 (06:49:04):

I'm going to ask that she opens it and verify what's in it is what she's testifying.

State Attorney (06:49:07):

Okay.

Judge (06:49:15):

Do you have gloves and scissors over there, ma'am?

Maria Andreoli (06:49:16):

Yes. Thank you.

Speaker 21 (06:49:17):

And Judge, may I approach just to see what...

Judge (06:49:18):

Yes, sir. You can come observe.

Speaker 21 (06:49:18):

Can I see?

Maria Andreoli (06:49:18):

Yes.

Speaker 21 (06:49:18):

Oh, I see [inaudible 06:49:37].

Maria Andreoli (06:49:18):

Sorry.

Speaker 21 (06:49:59):

Okay. No objection, Judge.

Judge (06:50:00):

Without objection, what's been marked for identification as State's Exhibit QQ will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 44.

State Attorney (06:50:04):

Thank you. Showing you photograph 15 of State's 42. Was there a separate compartment inside that center console?

Maria Andreoli (06:50:18):

Yes.

State Attorney (06:50:18):

All right. Did you find a wallet inside?

Maria Andreoli (06:50:21):

Yes, I did.

State Attorney (06:50:22):

Showing you photograph 16 of State's 42. What does this show?

Maria Andreoli (06:50:25):

This is a closeup photograph of a brown leather-like wallet that I located in the center console.

State Attorney (06:50:32):

Did you locate any identification or credit card or debit card inside?

Maria Andreoli (06:50:36):

Yes, I did.

State Attorney (06:50:37):

Showing you photograph 17 of State's 42. What do we see here?

Maria Andreoli (06:50:42):

This is an overall photograph of the cards that were located within the wallet.

State Attorney (06:50:48):

And photograph 18 of State's 42, what do we see here?

Maria Andreoli (06:50:51):

This is a closeup photograph of the Florida driver's license for Dwain Chadwick Hall that was located within the wallet.

State Attorney (06:51:03):

Showing you 19 of State's 42. Did you also find some items in the back seat of the Jeep?

Maria Andreoli (06:51:08):

Yes, I did.

State Attorney (06:51:09):

And what do we see here?

Maria Andreoli (06:51:10):

This is the rear passenger or rear-right side of the vehicle. There was a black crate with several items within it.

State Attorney (06:51:20):

And did you remove that crate and look inside the crate?

Maria Andreoli (06:51:24):

Yes, I did.

State Attorney (06:51:25):

I'm showing you photograph 20 of State's 42. Generally, what did you find in that crate?

Maria Andreoli (06:51:33):

This is an overall photograph of some of the items in the right-rear side of the vehicle.

State Attorney (06:51:40):

I'm showing you photograph 21. Did you specifically find a package of utility line in that vehicle?

Maria Andreoli (06:51:51):

Yes.

State Attorney (06:51:59):

Showing you photograph 22 of State's 42. What does this show?

Maria Andreoli (06:52:02):

This is a closeup photograph of the barcode on the Ozark Trail utility line that was located in the vehicle.

State Attorney (06:52:09):

Now, yesterday we heard from you that you actually were the one that processed the Airbnb.

Maria Andreoli (06:52:13):

Yes.

State Attorney (06:52:14):

Did you find similar Ozark Trail utility line packaging in the garbage can at the Airbnb?

Maria Andreoli (06:52:20):

Yes, I did.

State Attorney (06:52:21):

Showing you photograph 21 of State's 42, as well as photograph 10 of State's 15. What do we see here?

Maria Andreoli (06:52:32):

On the left side of the screen is a closeup photograph of the utility line that was located within the Jeep, and on the right side of the screen is a closeup photograph of the wrappers that were located within the Airbnb trash can.

State Attorney (06:52:50):

Moving on to photograph 19 of State's 42, specifically referring now, not to the floorboard, but to the crate. Did you search the contents of the crate?

Maria Andreoli (06:52:59):

Yes, I did.

State Attorney (06:53:04):

Showing you photograph 23. What was on top of the crate?

Maria Andreoli (06:53:11):

There was an FSU sweatshirt that was on top of the crate. So this is an overall photograph with that removed looking into the contents of the crate.

State Attorney (06:53:21):

And when you removed the FSU sweatshirt, did you locate a pair of scissors beneath it?

Maria Andreoli (06:53:25):

Yes, I did.

State Attorney (06:53:28):

Showing you photograph 24. What does this show?

Maria Andreoli (06:53:32):

This is a closeup photograph of the blades of the scissors where I identified some areas of red brown staining.

State Attorney (06:53:40):

Did you collect those scissors?

Maria Andreoli (06:53:41):

Yes, I did.

State Attorney (06:53:44):

Did that have anything to do with the presence of possible red brown staining?

Maria Andreoli (06:53:47):

Yes.

State Attorney (06:53:47):

Did you think it could be blood?

Maria Andreoli (06:53:49):

There was a possibility.

State Attorney (06:53:50):

Okay.

(06:53:50)
[inaudible 06:53:56].

Speaker 21 (06:53:50):

Yeah. Open it [inaudible 06:53:59].

State Attorney (06:53:59):

May I approach?

Judge (06:53:59):

Yes, sir.

State Attorney (06:54:00):

Showing what's been marked as State's Exhibit RR for identification. Can you take a look at that item, open it up, look inside, and tell me if you recognize the contents?

Speaker 21 (06:54:11):

Again, Judge, may I just to see?

Judge (06:54:12):

You may relocate, yes, sir.

Speaker 21 (06:54:12):

Yeah. Appreciate it.

State Attorney (06:54:12):

And what's inside that?

Maria Andreoli (06:55:40):

There is a brown paper bag that was the original packaging for the pair of scissors, and then inside that brown paper bag are the pair of scissors that are pictured.

State Attorney (06:55:51):

Are the scissors in the bag in the same or substantially the same condition as when you collected them?

Maria Andreoli (06:55:55):

Yes.

State Attorney (06:55:56):

At this time, state would move RR. into evidence as 45.

Speaker 21 (06:55:59):

No objection, Judge.

Judge (06:56:00):

Without objection, what's marked for identification as State's Exhibit RR will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 45.

State Attorney (06:56:10):

Showing you photograph 25 of State's 42. Did you also locate a can of Break-Free aerosol gun cleaning type material?

Maria Andreoli (06:56:21):

Yes.

State Attorney (06:56:21):

Okay. And that's what we see in the bottom right of this picture?

Maria Andreoli (06:56:23):

Yes.

State Attorney (06:56:26):

Okay. Showing you that same photo, photo 25 of State's 42, along with photo eight of State's 15. Did you locate, when you were processing the Airbnb, did you locate a Walmart receipt?

Maria Andreoli (06:56:38):

Yes, I did.

State Attorney (06:56:39):

On that Walmart receipt, was there an entry that corresponds to the Break-Free gun cleaning?

Maria Andreoli (06:56:46):

Yes.

State Attorney (06:56:47):

Okay. Showing you photo 26 of State's 42. Did you locate anything significant in the left front interior pocket front door?

Maria Andreoli (06:57:01):

Yes.

State Attorney (06:57:01):

What did you find?

Maria Andreoli (06:57:02):

I found a blue paper towel with red-brown staining and a handgun.

State Attorney (06:57:09):

Showing you 27 of State's 42. What do we see here?

Maria Andreoli (06:57:13):

This is a photograph of the handgun that was located in the left front door pocket, also known as the driver door.

State Attorney (06:57:22):

And photo 28 of State's 42, what type of firearm was it according to the markings?

Maria Andreoli (06:57:27):

It was a model 1911 A1 U.S. Army handgun.

State Attorney (06:57:33):

And photo 29 of State's 42, was it loaded?

Maria Andreoli (06:57:37):

It was.

State Attorney (06:57:37):

How?

Maria Andreoli (06:57:38):

There was one cartridge within the chamber and six cartridges within the magazine.

State Attorney (06:57:45):

Did you personally collect this firearm or did another crime scene technician collect it at a later time?

Maria Andreoli (06:57:50):

I did not collect it. Another FDLE crime scene analyst collected it at a later time.

State Attorney (06:57:55):

And what did you do with the firearm after you photographed it?

Maria Andreoli (06:57:59):

I swabbed the textured portions of the firearm for possible touch DNA.

State Attorney (06:58:04):

And did you put the firearm in any kind of container to be collected later?

Maria Andreoli (06:58:08):

Yes, I did.

State Attorney (06:58:09):

What did you do?

Maria Andreoli (06:58:09):

I placed the cartridge that was in the chamber in a manila envelope. And then in a separate packaging material, I placed the magazine with the cartridges that were inside the magazine. And then the handgun I placed within a white box, and those items were placed in the rear passenger side of the vehicle.

State Attorney (06:58:32):

To your knowledge, was a subsequent search warrant obtained that allowed you to actually collect the firearm?

Maria Andreoli (06:58:37):

Yes.

State Attorney (06:58:38):

Okay. Not you, but another crime scene technician?

Maria Andreoli (06:58:40):

Correct.

State Attorney (06:58:40):

Okay. You mentioned that you collected a swab from this firearm. How do you do that?

Maria Andreoli (06:58:47):

I will take a sterile swab, which looks like a very long Q-tip, but only one of the ends has cotton on it. I will moisten the swab with deionized water, and then I will rub the swab on the textured portions of the handgun.

State Attorney (06:59:06):

Okay. From where on the handgun did you collect that swab?

Maria Andreoli (06:59:09):

May I reference my report?

Judge (06:59:10):

Yes, ma'am. Okay. [inaudible 06:59:16].

Maria Andreoli (06:59:21):

I collected the swab from the grip, trigger, hammer, slide grip, and magazine release.

State Attorney (06:59:29):

Did you collect one swab from each of those different places or one swab from all of them together?

Maria Andreoli (06:59:34):

I collected one swab from all of those places.

State Attorney (06:59:37):

And why did you do that?

Maria Andreoli (06:59:39):

From my training, I have learned that collecting one swab and concentrating as many areas onto that one swab will help biology get a better sample size than splitting each individual area onto separate swabs.

State Attorney (06:59:57):

So is it more likely for biology to get DNA results if you take swab from various places as opposed to just one?

Maria Andreoli (07:00:05):

It provides a better chance at a more concentrated sample.

State Attorney (07:00:08):

May I approach, Judge?

Judge (07:00:09):

Yes, you may approach.

State Attorney (07:00:09):

Showing you what's marked as State's Exhibit SS. Can you take a look at that item, open it up, and tell me if you recognize the contents?

Maria Andreoli (07:00:42):

I do.

State Attorney (07:00:43):

What's inside?

Maria Andreoli (07:00:44):

This is a swab that I collected from the handgun.

State Attorney (07:00:48):

Is it in the same or substantially the same condition as when you collected it?

Maria Andreoli (07:00:52):

Yes, it is.

State Attorney (07:00:52):

At this time, the state would move SS into evidence as 46.

Speaker 21 (07:00:56):

No objection.

Judge (07:00:57):

Without objection, what's been marked for identification as State's Exhibit SS will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 46.

State Attorney (07:01:02):

I'm showing you photograph 26 of State's 42. You also mentioned a blue paper towel found in that same compartment as the firearm?

Maria Andreoli (07:01:13):

Yes.

State Attorney (07:01:13):

All right. And what do we see here?

Maria Andreoli (07:01:16):

This is an overall photograph of the blue paper towel with red brown staining that was located in the left front door pocket.

State Attorney (07:01:25):

And did you collect it because of the red brown staining and possibility it could be blood?

Maria Andreoli (07:01:28):

Yes.

State Attorney (07:01:29):

Showing you photograph 30 of State's 42, what do we see here?

Maria Andreoli (07:01:34):

This is a closeup photograph of the paper towel not crumpled up so that the staining was visible.

State Attorney (07:01:41):

May I approach?

Judge (07:01:41):

Yes, sir.

State Attorney (07:01:42):

Showing you State's Exhibit TT as in Tom. Take a look at that item, open it up, look inside, and tell me if you recognize the contents.

Maria Andreoli (07:02:31):

Yes.

State Attorney (07:02:32):

What's inside?

Maria Andreoli (07:02:33):

This is the blue paper towel with red brown staining collected from the left front door pocket.

State Attorney (07:02:39):

Is it in the same or substantially the same condition as when you collected it?

Maria Andreoli (07:02:42):

Yes.

State Attorney (07:02:42):

State would move TT into evidence as 47, Your Honor.

Speaker 21 (07:02:46):

No objection, Judge.

Judge (07:02:47):

Without objection, what's been marked for identification as State's Exhibit TT will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 47.

State Attorney (07:02:53):

And did your processing of the Airbnb and your processing of the Jeep that we've been talking about here today all happen in Marion County?

Maria Andreoli (07:03:01):

Yes.

State Attorney (07:03:02):

Thank you, ma'am. No other questions, Your Honor.

Speaker 21 (07:03:04):

No questions, Judge.

Judge (07:03:05):

Members of the jury, do any of y'all have questions of this witness? If you do, please raise your hands. All right. Seeing no hands. State, is she released?

State Attorney (07:03:12):

Yes, Your Honor.

Judge (07:03:13):

Defense?

Speaker 21 (07:03:13):

No objection, Judge.

Judge (07:03:15):

Ma'am, you're free to go about your day. Thank you for your time. Scissors? Yes. Thank you very much. All right. State, next witness.

State Attorney (07:03:21):

State calls Erin Morris.

Judge (07:03:23):

Good. Come on in, ma'am. Raise your right hand, face the clerk to be sworn.

Speaker 20 (07:03:49):

Do you swear or affirm the testimony you're about to give will be the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so help you God?

Erin Morris (07:03:53):

I do.

Judge (07:03:53):

You can be seated, ma'am.

Erin Morris (07:03:53):

Thank you.

State Attorney (07:04:03):

Good afternoon, ma'am.

Erin Morris (07:04:04):

Good afternoon.

State Attorney (07:04:04):

Would you please introduce yourself to the jury?

Erin Morris (07:04:06):

Yes. My name's Erin Morris. I'm a senior crime laboratory analyst in the crime scene investigation section with the Florida Department of Law Enforcement.

State Attorney (07:04:13):

How long have you been with FDLE?

Erin Morris (07:04:15):

I started my employment with FDLE in March of 2019.

State Attorney (07:04:19):

And can you describe for the jury your training and your experience that allows you to do this job?

Erin Morris (07:04:23):

Sure, absolutely. So I've had a little bit of length of career in crime scene. I started at the Clay County Sheriff's Office in July of 2010 as a crime scene technician there. So Clay County had their own field training program, which I went through there, which also it mandated that we went to four external trainings. Once those four trainings were completed and I finished their FTO program, I then moved on to become a crime scene technician on my own there. Once FDLE scooped me up in 2019, I then went through their program.

(07:04:54)
It's a two-phase program. The first consists of a lot of modules that usually specifically address some type of skill or processing technique. Each one of those has either practical, written, or oral assessments to finish each of the modules. Once all of the module training is complete, we then move into what's called phase two, that supervised case work where I then am able to go and complete casework at real crime scenes under the supervision of certified analysts. Once that phase is complete, we finish our training program with a mock trial, and then I'm able to go and be on my own with FDLE.

(07:05:29)
Outside of that, I've completed over, well, probably a thousand hours of external trainings. I also have a bachelor's degree in anthropology from the University of Central Florida. I have a certificate of proficiency in crime scene investigation and a certificate of proficiency in homicide investigation from the Institute of Police Technology and Management.

State Attorney (07:05:52):

You said you were a senior crime scene?

Erin Morris (07:05:52):

Yes.

State Attorney (07:05:52):

What does that mean?

Erin Morris (07:05:53):

So it's basically tenured. Once we've been able to spend quite a few years at our position at FDLE, we're then able to have the title of senior.

State Attorney (07:06:02):

Okay. Do you also teach crime scene work?

Erin Morris (07:06:03):

I do.

State Attorney (07:06:04):

What does that involve?

Erin Morris (07:06:05):

So I'm an adjunct instructor at the Institute of Police Technology and Management. I typically cover crime scene and forensic related courses there.

State Attorney (07:06:12):

And what kind of courses do you teach there?

Erin Morris (07:06:15):

So I assist with crime scene processing, crime scene reconstruction, shooting incident reconstruction, buried bodies and surface skeletons, and other cases or coursework where they request my assistance.

State Attorney (07:06:26):

Let me direct your attention to October 17th of 2025. Did you make contact with a person named Dwain Hall?

Erin Morris (07:06:32):

I did.

State Attorney (07:06:33):

Do you see him here in court?

Erin Morris (07:06:34):

Yes, I do.

State Attorney (07:06:36):

Okay. Please point him out and tell me what he's wearing.

Erin Morris (07:06:37):

He is over here to my left. He's wearing a navy blue button-up shirt.

State Attorney (07:06:41):

Your Honor, may the record reflect the witness has identified the defendant?

Speaker 21 (07:06:43):

No objection, Judge.

Judge (07:06:44):

The record will so reflect.

State Attorney (07:06:46):

Where did you make contact with the defendant?

Erin Morris (07:06:49):

At the Marion County Sheriff's Office.

State Attorney (07:06:50):

And while you were there, did you take some photographs of him?

Erin Morris (07:06:53):

I did.

Speaker 21 (07:06:57):

Okay.

State Attorney (07:06:59):

May I approach, Your Honor?

Judge (07:07:00):

Yes, sir.

State Attorney (07:07:01):

I'm showing you State's Exhibit UU for identification. Do you recognize the person in that photo?

Erin Morris (07:07:05):

I do.

State Attorney (07:07:05):

Who is it?

Erin Morris (07:07:06):

That's Dwain Hall.

State Attorney (07:07:07):

Is that what it looked like when you made contact with him on October 17th?

Erin Morris (07:07:09):

Yes, it is.

State Attorney (07:07:10):

At this time, State would move UU into evidence as State's 48.

Speaker 21 (07:07:14):

No objection, Judge.

Judge (07:07:15):

Without objection, what's been marked for identification as State's Exhibit 48... I'm sorry, UU will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 48.

State Attorney (07:07:21):

May I publish?

Judge (07:07:23):

Yes, sir.

State Attorney (07:07:23):

Is that the photo I just showed you of Mr. Hall?

Erin Morris (07:07:27):

It is.

State Attorney (07:07:27):

Okay. While you made contact with him, did you also collect some swabs from his fingernails?

Erin Morris (07:07:34):

I did.

State Attorney (07:07:35):

Explain to the jury how you do that.

Erin Morris (07:07:37):

So we are provided with sterile swabs, which come in their own sealed sleeves. We're then able to remove the swabs from the sleeves. We moisten it with deionized water, and then that kind of helps collect whatever it is that I'm trying to collect from. So in this case, I swabbed Mr. Hall's left-hand and right-hand fingernails and cuticle areas.

State Attorney (07:07:57):

Okay. May I approach again?

Judge (07:07:59):

Yes, sir.

State Attorney (07:08:00):

Showing you State's Exhibit VV as in Victor. Can you take a look at that item, open it up, look inside, and tell me if you recognize the contents?

Erin Morris (07:08:08):

You said to open it?

State Attorney (07:08:09):

Yes. Do you recognize the contents?

Erin Morris (07:08:44):

I do.

State Attorney (07:08:44):

What is it?

Erin Morris (07:08:45):

They are the two swabs that were collected from Mr. Hall's fingernails.

State Attorney (07:08:48):

Are they in the same or substantially the same condition as one you collected from him on October 17th?

Erin Morris (07:08:54):

Yes, they are.

State Attorney (07:08:54):

At this time, state would move VV as in Victor into evidence as 49.

Speaker 21 (07:08:59):

No objection, Judge.

Judge (07:09:00):

Without objection, what's been marked for identification as State's Exhibit VV will be...

Speaker 22 (07:09:00):

... without objection, what's been marked for identification as State's Exhibit VV will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 49.

State Attorney (07:09:20):

Let me direct your attention to a few days later, October 20th of 2025. Was a second search warrant obtained that allowed you and other law enforcement officers to go into a black four-door Jeep owned by Dwain Hall located at the Marion County Sheriff's Office?

Erin Morris (07:09:36):

Yes. It was.

State Attorney (07:09:37):

All right. And where was that Jeep located when you went there?

Erin Morris (07:09:41):

The Marion County Sheriff's Office had it secured in their auto garage.

State Attorney (07:09:45):

And to your knowledge, had the Jeep been in that same location the entire time since it was first searched by Maria Andrioli on October 17th?

Erin Morris (07:09:54):

Yes. To my knowledge.

State Attorney (07:09:56):

And was that a secured area?

Erin Morris (07:09:57):

Yes.

State Attorney (07:09:57):

Okay. Did you also take some photographs of the Jeep and some of the items that you collected from inside?

Erin Morris (07:10:03):

I did.

State Attorney (07:10:04):

I'm showing you what's been marked as State's Exhibit WW. Can you take a look at those photographs and tell me if you recognize them?

Erin Morris (07:10:11):

I do.

State Attorney (07:10:18):

And generally, what do they show?

Erin Morris (07:10:19):

They show some of the Jeep Cherokee's exterior as well as some of the items that were located within the Jeep Cherokee.

State Attorney (07:10:26):

Do they fairly and accurately depict the Jeep Cherokee as well as those items?

Erin Morris (07:10:29):

Yes.

State Attorney (07:10:30):

At this time, State would move State WW into evidence as 50.

Speaker 23 (07:10:34):

No objections, Your Honor.

Speaker 22 (07:10:36):

Without objection, what's been marked for identification as State's Exhibit WW will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 50.

State Attorney (07:10:41):

May I publish?

Speaker 22 (07:10:42):

Yes, sir.

State Attorney (07:10:43):

Showing you photograph one of State's 50. Is that the Jeep that you examined?

Erin Morris (07:10:47):

Yes. It is.

State Attorney (07:10:47):

All right. Showing you photograph two. Did you locate a firearm magazine and round of ammunition that had been packaged and placed in the back seat of the Jeep by Maria Andrioli?

Erin Morris (07:11:00):

I did.

State Attorney (07:11:01):

What do we see in this photo?

Erin Morris (07:11:02):

This is a photograph depicting those items. You can see the, kind of, white cardboard box that looks like it's in the center seat, that's the rear seat of the Jeep Cherokee, as well as two manila envelopes.

State Attorney (07:11:13):

Okay. Did you also locate a can of Break-Free firearm cleaning spray?

Erin Morris (07:11:19):

I did. It's also depicted in this photograph towards the center. It's sitting on top of that white cardboard box.

State Attorney (07:11:24):

Did you collect those items? Both the firearm and its contents as well as the can of Break-Free.

Erin Morris (07:11:28):

I did.

State Attorney (07:11:36):

Showing you first what's been marked as State's Exhibit XX for identification. Can you take a look at that, open it up, look inside and tell me if you recognize the contents?

Erin Morris (07:11:43):

I do.

State Attorney (07:11:43):

What's inside?

Erin Morris (07:11:43):

The firearm that was retrieved from the Jeep Cherokee as well as the magazine and cartridges that were collected.

State Attorney (07:12:49):

Are they in the same-

Erin Morris (07:12:49):

There's also ... I'm sorry. There's also some test fires, it appears, that were placed in by our firearms' lab.

State Attorney (07:12:55):

Does your Florida Department of Law Enforcement firearms lab routinely test fire and put the results of those test fires in the original container?

Erin Morris (07:13:02):

Yes. They do.

State Attorney (07:13:03):

Is it in the same or substantially the same condition as when you collected it from the backseat of that Jeep Cherokee?

Erin Morris (07:13:07):

Yes.

State Attorney (07:13:08):

And Your Honor, at this point, I'm going to provide it to the court deputy and ask him to take a look at it, make it safe, and turn a lock on it, if needed.

Speaker 22 (07:13:16):

All right. One second.

Speaker 23 (07:13:17):

Is it in evidence? Are you introducing it?

State Attorney (07:13:19):

I will in a second.

Speaker 23 (07:13:21):

Here, let's handle that one first.

State Attorney (07:13:23):

Okay. At this time, the state would move XX into evidence as 51.

Speaker 23 (07:13:27):

No objection, Judge.

Speaker 22 (07:13:28):

Without objection, State's Exhibit XX will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 51. Parties have any objection to bailiff putting the cable through it?

State Attorney (07:13:36):

No, Your Honor.

Speaker 23 (07:13:37):

No objection.

Speaker 22 (07:13:38):

You can go ahead and do that, Deputy [inaudible 07:13:40]. Thank you.

State Attorney (07:13:53):

May I approach again, Your Honor?

Speaker 22 (07:13:54):

Yes, sir.

State Attorney (07:13:55):

Showing you what's been marked as State's Exhibit YY for identification. Do you recognize that item?

Erin Morris (07:14:02):

I do.

State Attorney (07:14:02):

What is that?

Erin Morris (07:14:03):

This is the can of aerosol spray that was located in the Jeep Cherokee.

State Attorney (07:14:07):

And is that in the same or substantially the same condition as when you collected it?

Erin Morris (07:14:11):

Yes. It is.

State Attorney (07:14:12):

At this time, state would move YY into evidence as 52.

Speaker 23 (07:14:16):

No objection, Judge.

Speaker 22 (07:14:17):

Without objection, what's been marked for identification as State's Exhibit YY will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 52.

State Attorney (07:14:33):

Showing you photograph three of State's 50. Did you also locate a black belt and a multicolored towel in the back rear seat?

Erin Morris (07:14:43):

I did.

State Attorney (07:14:44):

And what do we see in photograph three?

Erin Morris (07:14:45):

In this photograph that is depicting the multicolored towel, the black belt, as well as a grocery bag and some [inaudible 07:14:52].

State Attorney (07:14:52):

Did you locate anything noteworthy on that multicolor towel that caused you to collect it?

Erin Morris (07:14:57):

There appeared to be some red-brown staining.

State Attorney (07:15:06):

May I approach? Showing you what's been marked as State's Exhibit ZZ. Can you take a look at that item, open it up, look inside, tell me if you recognize the contents?

Erin Morris (07:15:59):

I do.

State Attorney (07:15:59):

What's inside?

Erin Morris (07:16:00):

The multicolored towel.

State Attorney (07:16:01):

Is it in the same or substantially the same condition as when you collected it?

Erin Morris (07:16:04):

Yes. It is.

State Attorney (07:16:05):

At this time, State would move ZZ into evidence as 53.

Speaker 23 (07:16:09):

No objection, Judge.

Speaker 22 (07:16:10):

Without objection, what's been marked for identification as State's Exhibit ZZ will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 53.

State Attorney (07:16:17):

Did you locate anything under the front passenger seat of the Jeep?

Erin Morris (07:16:21):

I did.

State Attorney (07:16:21):

What'd you find?

Erin Morris (07:16:23):

There was a purple tube of mascara.

State Attorney (07:16:25):

Did you collect it?

Erin Morris (07:16:26):

I did.

State Attorney (07:16:26):

May I approach?

Speaker 22 (07:16:27):

Yes, sir.

State Attorney (07:16:28):

Showing you State's Exhibit AAA. Can you open that up, look inside, and tell me if you recognize the contents?

Erin Morris (07:16:32):

I do.

State Attorney (07:16:32):

What is it?

Erin Morris (07:16:48):

It's the purple tube of mascara.

State Attorney (07:16:49):

Is it the same or substantially the same condition as when you collected it?

Erin Morris (07:16:52):

Yes. It is.

State Attorney (07:16:52):

At this time, State would move State's AAA into evidence as 54.

Speaker 23 (07:16:56):

No objection.

Speaker 22 (07:16:57):

Without objection, what's been marked for identification as State's Exhibit AAA will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 54.

State Attorney (07:17:06):

Are you also trained as a crime scene technician on how to process an item for latent fingerprints?

Erin Morris (07:17:11):

I am.

State Attorney (07:17:12):

What's a latent fingerprint? Just generally.

Erin Morris (07:17:14):

So, in a nutshell, a latent fingerprint is a print that's left behind by the residues on your hands or it could be a footprint. So, anywhere that friction ridge detail comes in contact with a surface and is left behind, that's usually not really visible to the naked eye. It, typically, takes some sort of processing in order to see it.

State Attorney (07:17:33):

And are you familiar with the different methods that can be used in order to lift fingerprints?

Erin Morris (07:17:37):

Yes.

State Attorney (07:17:37):

All right. Did you process the Jeep for the presence of latent fingerprints and palm prints?

Erin Morris (07:17:44):

I did on the exterior.

State Attorney (07:17:45):

And what method did you use?

Erin Morris (07:17:47):

I use what's called dual-use powder. It's a gray-colored fingerprint powder, and I applied that to the exterior, and then I lifted the areas of possible friction ridge detail using clear lift tape.

State Attorney (07:17:58):

You actually found areas that had potential latent fingerprints?

Erin Morris (07:18:02):

I did.

State Attorney (07:18:06):

May I approach again, Judge?

Speaker 22 (07:18:07):

Yes, sir.

State Attorney (07:18:08):

Showing you State's Exhibit Triple BBB as in boy. Can you look at that, open it up, look inside, and tell me if you recognize the contents?

Erin Morris (07:18:29):

I do.

State Attorney (07:18:30):

What are they?

Erin Morris (07:18:31):

They're the latent lift cards that I collected.

State Attorney (07:18:33):

Do you remember how many latent lift cards you collected?

Erin Morris (07:18:35):

I believe it was 13. Yes. 13.

State Attorney (07:18:37):

Okay. Are they in the same or substantially the same condition as when you collected?

Erin Morris (07:18:40):

Yes. They appear to be. There may be some markings from our friction ridge section. Yes, sir.

State Attorney (07:18:46):

Would it be common for a fingerprint analyst to make markings on the prints that you lift?

Erin Morris (07:18:49):

Yes. It is.

State Attorney (07:18:52):

Okay. I may have asked you this if I did, sorry, are they in the same or substantially the same condition as when you collected them?

Erin Morris (07:18:56):

Yes.

State Attorney (07:18:57):

At this time, state would move Triple BBB into evidence as 55.

Speaker 23 (07:19:00):

No objection, Judge.

Speaker 22 (07:19:00):

Without objection, what's been marked for identification as State's Exhibit BBB will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 55.

State Attorney (07:19:00):

And how do you go about actually taking a print from a substance and putting it on the card?

Erin Morris (07:19:00):

So, in this case, after the powder was applied and I identified the areas that I believed may be friction ridge detail, the clear tape was placed over those areas. The tape's then lifted and placed onto a latent lift card of contrasting color than the powder that was applied. So, in this case, I used a white card.

(07:19:00)
Once the tape is applied, we then mark it with the area, usually, a sketch and a description of the location from where it was lifted, so, then it can be referred to later. I also, for this specific case, photographed the tape in place prior to lifting it from the vehicle.

State Attorney (07:19:00):

Are you the person at FBLE that actually looks at the print and determines if it has enough detail to be of comparison value?

Erin Morris (07:19:00):

Not of comparison value. No.

State Attorney (07:19:00):

Okay. Even if there would be enough detail for comparison value, would you be the person that actually does any comparison?

Erin Morris (07:19:00):

No.

State Attorney (07:19:01):

Now let me back up a couple days again. Let me refer you back to October 17th of 2025. Did you respond to 16271 Southwest 27th Terrace Road in Ocala to execute a search warrant on a residence owned by Dwain Hall?

Erin Morris (07:19:01):

I did.

State Attorney (07:19:01):

Did you take photographs of the residence and the items that you located inside?

Erin Morris (07:19:01):

Yes, sir.

State Attorney (07:19:01):

And did you go inside pursuant to a search warrant?

Erin Morris (07:19:01):

Yes.

State Attorney (07:19:01):

May I approach?

Speaker 22 (07:19:01):

Yes, sir.

State Attorney (07:19:01):

Showing you what's been marked as State's Exhibit CCC. Can you take a look at those photos and tell me if you recognize them?

Erin Morris (07:19:01):

I do recognize them.

State Attorney (07:19:01):

What do they show generally?

Erin Morris (07:19:01):

The exterior of the house as well as areas and items located within the residence.

State Attorney (07:19:01):

Do they fairly and accurately depict those items as you saw them when you went to process that house?

Erin Morris (07:19:01):

Yes. They do.

State Attorney (07:19:01):

At this time, State would move CCC into evidence as 56.

Speaker 23 (07:19:01):

No objection, Judge.

Speaker 22 (07:19:02):

Without objection, what's marked for identification as State's Exhibit CCC will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 56.

State Attorney (07:19:03):

May I publish?

Speaker 22 (07:19:03):

Yes, sir.

State Attorney (07:19:03):

Showing you photograph one of State's 56. What do we see here?

Erin Morris (07:19:03):

This is a photograph of the front of the residence.

State Attorney (07:19:03):

Okay. And did you search the garage of this residence?

Erin Morris (07:19:03):

Yes. I did.

State Attorney (07:19:03):

Showing you photograph two of State's 56. Did you locate a shovel in the northeast corner of that garage?

Erin Morris (07:19:03):

I did.

State Attorney (07:19:03):

Can you describe the shovel to the jury?

Erin Morris (07:19:03):

The shovel was branded as an expert gardener shovel. It had a silver and green handle.

State Attorney (07:19:03):

Did you collect that shovel?

Erin Morris (07:19:03):

I did.

State Attorney (07:19:03):

Did you locate any dirt or debris on the scoop? The bottom portion of the shovel.

Erin Morris (07:19:03):

Yes. There appeared to be some soil on the scoop end of the shovel. So, it was removed as much as possible prior to the final submission of the shovel.

State Attorney (07:19:03):

Other than that soil that was on the bottom of the shovel, did the shovel appear new or did it appear rusted and scuffed and old?

Erin Morris (07:19:03):

Yeah. So, the soil indicated that there had been some use to the shovel, but other than that, it looked like it was in good condition.

State Attorney (07:19:03):

Showing you what's marked as State's Exhibit DDD. Can you open that up, look inside, and tell me if you recognize the contents? Let me know if you need help with it.

Erin Morris (07:19:03):

Sure.

State Attorney (07:19:03):

Is there a separate bag inside the box?

‍

Erin Morris (07:19:03):

Yes. There is.

State Attorney (07:19:03):

Would you mind removing the bag for me?

Erin Morris (07:19:03):

Sure.

State Attorney (07:19:03):

Do you mind opening that up, looking inside, and tell me if you recognize the contents?

Erin Morris (07:19:03):

I do. By the way, you're out of gloves.

State Attorney (07:19:03):

Out of gloves.

Speaker 22 (07:19:03):

Do you have some there by the print table? What size you need, Ms. Morris?

Erin Morris (07:19:03):

I'll fit any of them.

Speaker 22 (07:19:03):

We've got a couple coming.

Erin Morris (07:19:03):

So, I've got a pair, Justin. Thank you so much.

(07:19:03)
Do you have a preference on [inaudible 07:24:05]?

State Attorney (07:19:03):

However, you'd like. Do you recognize the contents?

Erin Morris (07:19:03):

I do.

State Attorney (07:19:03):

What is it?

Erin Morris (07:19:03):

It's the [inaudible 07:24:29] from the garage.

State Attorney (07:19:03):

Is it the same or substantially the same condition as when you collected it?

Erin Morris (07:19:03):

Yes. It appears some navy fingerprint processing has been done, but it is.

State Attorney (07:19:03):

Okay. At this time, the state will move DDD, as in dog, into evidence as 56. 57. Excuse me.

Speaker 23 (07:19:03):

No objection to this.

Speaker 22 (07:19:03):

What's marked for identification as State's Exhibit DDD will be admitted to evidence as State's Exhibit 57.

State Attorney (07:19:03):

And may I publish, Judge?

Speaker 22 (07:19:03):

Yes, sir.

State Attorney (07:19:03):

[inaudible 07:24:51].

Speaker 22 (07:19:03):

Ms. Morris, if you want to step down, you have gloves on, you can hold the shovel out to the jurors to see here.

State Attorney (07:19:03):

You said it appears it has been sent to fingerprints for processing. What makes you say that?

Erin Morris (07:19:03):

So, if you look at the handle, there's a little bit of a black residue there. That's usually indicative of something that's been processed.

State Attorney (07:19:03):

Thank you.

(07:19:03)
Did you also examine the inside of the residence?

Erin Morris (07:19:03):

I did.

State Attorney (07:19:03):

And did you locate several laptops in the master bedroom?

Erin Morris (07:19:03):

Two.

State Attorney (07:19:03):

Showing you photograph three of State's 56. What do we see here?

Erin Morris (07:19:03):

So, this is the master bedroom. If you can see towards the center of the photograph, there's two laptops located near the wall.

State Attorney (07:19:03):

I'm showing you photograph four. What does this show?

Erin Morris (07:19:03):

This is a closer up photograph of those two laptops.

State Attorney (07:19:03):

And photograph five, what does this show?

Erin Morris (07:19:03):

This is one of those two laptops, the black one that was removed from that area to be photographed with a little bit more detail.

State Attorney (07:19:03):

May I approach?

Speaker 22 (07:19:03):

Yes, sir.

State Attorney (07:19:03):

Showing you what's been marked as State's Exhibit BDE. Can you open that up, look inside and tell me if you recognize it?

Erin Morris (07:19:03):

I recognize it.

State Attorney (07:19:03):

What is it?

Erin Morris (07:19:03):

It is the black Pavilion laptop.

State Attorney (07:19:03):

Is it in the same or substantially the same condition as when you collected it out of that residence's master bedroom?

Erin Morris (07:19:03):

Yes. It appears to be.

State Attorney (07:19:03):

At this time, state would move EEE into evidence as 58.

Speaker 23 (07:19:03):

No objection, Judge.

Speaker 22 (07:19:03):

That objection was marked for identification. State's Exhibit EEE will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 58.

State Attorney (07:26:40):

I'm showing you photograph six of State's 56. Did you also collect the silver laptop we see in the photo?

Erin Morris (07:28:02):

I did collect it.

State Attorney (07:28:03):

Can you open that one up, look inside, and tell me if you recognize it?

Erin Morris (07:28:03):

I do.

State Attorney (07:28:03):

What's inside?

Erin Morris (07:28:27):

The silver laptop.

State Attorney (07:28:28):

Is it in the same or substantially the same condition as when you collected it?

Erin Morris (07:28:31):

Yes. It appears to be.

State Attorney (07:28:32):

State will move State's FFF into evidence as 59.

Speaker 23 (07:28:36):

No objection, Judge.

Speaker 22 (07:28:38):

What's been marked for identification as State's Exhibit FFF will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 59.

State Attorney (07:28:43):

Now did you have any involvement in extracting any data from these laptops or analyzing any data?

Erin Morris (07:28:51):

No. I did not.

State Attorney (07:28:53):

All right. Thank you, ma'am. No other questions, Your Honor.

Speaker 23 (07:28:54):

No questions.

Speaker 22 (07:28:55):

Members of the jury, do any of y'all have questions of this witness? If you do, please raise your hands. Seeing no hands, State, is she released?

State Attorney (07:29:02):

No, Your Honor. She'll be recalled shortly.

Speaker 22 (07:29:04):

Okay, ma'am, you can step in the back.

Erin Morris (07:29:07):

Absolutely. Is there a trash can?

Speaker 22 (07:29:08):

Yes, ma'am. Bailiff should have one over there by his-

Erin Morris (07:29:10):

Thank you.

Speaker 22 (07:29:11):

There we go. Members of the jury, anybody need a break? Seeing no hands, State, next witness.

State Attorney (07:29:17):

State calls Kip Peterson.

Speaker 22 (07:29:55):

Please raise your right hand. Face the clerk to be sworn.

Speaker 24 (07:29:59):

Do you swear or affirm the testimony you're about to give will be the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so help you God?

Kip Peterson (07:30:00):

I do.

Speaker 22 (07:30:02):

All right. You can be seated, sir.

State Attorney (07:30:05):

Good afternoon.

Kip Peterson (07:30:06):

Good afternoon.

State Attorney (07:30:07):

Could you please introduce yourself to the jury?

Kip Peterson (07:30:08):

My name is Kip Peterson. I'm a sergeant with the Marion County Sheriff's Office.

State Attorney (07:30:11):

How long have you been with the Marion County Sheriff's Office?

Kip Peterson (07:30:14):

About 11 and a half, almost 12 years.

State Attorney (07:30:16):

How long have you been a sergeant?

Kip Peterson (07:30:18):

For the last year.

State Attorney (07:30:20):

What did you do before you were a sergeant?

Kip Peterson (07:30:22):

Before I was a sergeant, I was a detective in our intelligence unit. Prior to that, in our major crimes unit, and then prior to that in our property crimes unit.

State Attorney (07:30:30):

Did you become involved in the investigation into the murder of Sonia Exelby?

Kip Peterson (07:30:34):

I did.

State Attorney (07:30:34):

How did you become involved?

Kip Peterson (07:30:36):

On October 15th of 2025, I was contacted initially to conduct surveillance at a residence in Marion Oaks.

State Attorney (07:30:46):

Did that surveillance eventually lead to a traffic stop of a vehicle associated with that residence?

Kip Peterson (07:30:52):

Yes.

State Attorney (07:30:52):

And did you actually go out to the traffic stop after it was performed?

Kip Peterson (07:30:55):

I did.

State Attorney (07:30:56):

All right. Do you also have any specialized training in the area of cell phones, cell phone records, cell phone towers, and mapping and things like that?

Kip Peterson (07:31:06):

I do.

State Attorney (07:31:06):

Can you describe for the jury what that training is?

Kip Peterson (07:31:09):

In addition to standard detective training, I've received advanced training and analysis related to call detail records, device geolocation, as well as in-depth review of specific data contained within cell phone records that can be used for locating devices.

State Attorney (07:31:29):

And what are call detail records?

Kip Peterson (07:31:31):

Call detail records are, basically, a log of transactions that happen on your phone, calls in, calls out, associated timestamps for those calls. It tracks text messages as well as data sessions.

State Attorney (07:31:44):

And you mentioned geolocations. What does that mean as far as the phone is concerned?

Kip Peterson (07:31:49):

Geolocations can be something as simple as a GPS ping that your phone is connecting to the network and relaying its location back to the network or the cell phone provider.

State Attorney (07:32:01):

Were you provided cell phone records pertaining to the phone number 330-575-4894 belonging to a Dwain Hall?

Kip Peterson (07:32:10):

I was.

State Attorney (07:32:10):

And what provider is associated with those records?

Kip Peterson (07:32:13):

Verizon Wireless.

State Attorney (07:32:15):

And how did you know that that number was associated with Dwain Hall?

Kip Peterson (07:32:19):

In the records, the subscriber indicated for that specific phone number was Dwain Hall.

State Attorney (07:32:24):

At this time, Your Honor, the state would move state's GGG into evidence as State's 60, the Verizon subscriber records for that phone number, the business record certifications attached, and property notice has been given.

Speaker 23 (07:32:35):

No objection, sir.

Speaker 22 (07:32:36):

Without objection, what's been marked for identification as State's Exhibit GGG will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 60.

State Attorney (07:32:42):

May I publish?

Speaker 22 (07:32:43):

Yes, sir.

State Attorney (07:32:45):

Showing you State's Exhibit 60. Can you explain to the jury just what we're looking at here?

Kip Peterson (07:32:52):

The search value is the phone number, obviously, the start date being September 1st of 2025. The last name would be the subscriber of record as well as the first name, and then the address of record for the customer with the carrier, but in this case, Verizon Wireless.

State Attorney (07:33:13):

Did you actually receive the call detail and text detail and data information from the records as well?

Kip Peterson (07:33:20):

All of that is contained in the response that's given by Verizon Wireless.

State Attorney (07:33:23):

And what type of information is actually given to you from those records?

Kip Peterson (07:33:27):

From those records itself, like I said, call detail records, cell site location information, which is just a fancy term for the location of a cell phone tower, as well as measurements taken by the providers, or, again, in this case, Verizon Wireless of what's called timing advance information. What that is is, basically, where the network is measuring how far a phone or device connected to the network is from the actual cell site location.

State Attorney (07:34:01):

Can you explain to the jury a very brief nutshell version of how a phone interacts with a cell tower?

Kip Peterson (07:34:07):

Yeah. So, cell phones are constantly looking for the best connection to a tower. It does not necessarily mean the tower that's closest to that cell phone, but rather whatever tower it can connect to to provide the best signal. Sometimes it's the closest tower, sometimes it's not. The cell phone's constantly interacting with the towers in the environment that it's in to determine what the best signal is, and the towers in turn are measuring the time it takes for the signal to go back and forth from the tower to the phone back to the tower.

State Attorney (07:34:48):

Every time a cell phone interacts with a cell tower, either by making or receiving a call, making or receiving a text, checking the internet, does it create a record in the Verizon network?

Kip Peterson (07:34:59):

It does.

State Attorney (07:35:00):

Is that the information that was provided to you from Verizon?

Kip Peterson (07:35:03):

Yes.

State Attorney (07:35:06):

And you also mentioned timing advance information?

Kip Peterson (07:35:09):

Yes, sir.

State Attorney (07:35:11):

Explain what that is again, briefly.

Kip Peterson (07:35:13):

So, timing advance, again, the providers, again, Verizon Wireless, takes a measurement for how long the cellphone signal takes to travel from the tower to the phone and, ultimately, return back to the tower using, basically, a complicated formula. It uses the frequency and wavelength to determine, ultimately, a distance from the tower for that device.

State Attorney (07:35:42):

And did you analyze that timing advanced data to try to determine the distance of the defendant's cellphone from specific cell towers at issue in this case?

Kip Peterson (07:35:52):

Yes.

State Attorney (07:35:53):

Okay. What did you use to analyze that data?

Kip Peterson (07:35:56):

We use a program called TraX. It is provided through LexisNexis.

State Attorney (07:36:01):

And have you been trained in how to use that program?

Kip Peterson (07:36:03):

I have from LexisNexis, the provider.

State Attorney (07:36:05):

And what exactly does TraX do? What does that program do?

Kip Peterson (07:36:08):

TraX takes the raw records from the provider and it puts them into a user-friendly interface that allows us to take, essentially, what comes down to a bunch of numbers and display them on a map in a way that's actually able to be interpreted.

State Attorney (07:36:25):

When you do this analysis, are you using solely the records that came from the Verizon official company to do your analysis?

Kip Peterson (07:36:35):

Yes. We take the records provided from Verizon and use TraX, again, to display them in a way that's actually manageable to interpret.

State Attorney (07:36:44):

And how does TraX display that information? Do they use a map?

Kip Peterson (07:36:48):

They do. It provides a KML or KMZ file that is then opened in Google Earth that we can use to view the measurements on a map.

State Attorney (07:36:59):

Just in case someone's not familiar with Google Earth, what is that?

Kip Peterson (07:37:02):

It's very similar to Google Maps or Apple Maps. It's just an enhanced version to where it gives some more detail and it just goes a little bit more in depth with what you're actually able to see on the map.

State Attorney (07:37:14):

I'm going to direct your attention to October 16th of 2025. Were the records from Dwain Hall's cellphone uploaded into your TraX program, so, you could begin to analyze them?

Kip Peterson (07:37:24):

Yes.

State Attorney (07:37:25):

Did you also begin to plot various points of interest in the maps that he created? Such as the Airbnb, a Walmart, the defendant's residence, things like that?

Kip Peterson (07:37:35):

Yes.

State Attorney (07:37:36):

Was the program, the TraX program, able to read and interpret the official Verizon records without any problem?

Kip Peterson (07:37:43):

Yes.

State Attorney (07:37:43):

And does the process of uploading those Verizon records into the TraX program change, alter, add or do anything to those records to change them?

Kip Peterson (07:37:52):

No.

State Attorney (07:37:52):

Okay. What were you looking for in doing this whole process?

Kip Peterson (07:38:00):

The first overlook of the records, I, typically, will look to make sure there's no anomalies in any of the information that was provided. Once I can look at the records and say there's not some outlier that has to be accounted for, I go back and look at the records again as a whole and start to look for, essentially, a pattern of life to determine where the device was moving and, ultimately, where the device stops moving and correlate that with known locations such as, in this case, the Airbnb, Walmarts, airports, Mr. Hall's residence, all of those places.

State Attorney (07:38:38):

During that analysis, did you find some periods of time where the defendant's cell phone became stagnant or stopped moving for a lengthy period of time?

Kip Peterson (07:38:47):

Yes.

State Attorney (07:38:49):

And did you look into whether in those places where the phone stopped moving, there would have been a reason for the phone to stop moving? Like, is that his residence and it's in the middle of the night, he's sleeping? Or at the Airbnb, things like that.

Kip Peterson (07:39:03):

Absolutely. So, once a device goes stagnant or stops moving, one of the things that I start to look for is what is in the immediate area, whether it's a business or a known location such as a house, an Airbnb, something like that, some explanation as to why the device was moving and stopped at that specific location or in that specific area.

State Attorney (07:39:26):

Did you find instances where the defendant's cell phone became stagnant and stopped moving and there was nothing around that area that would explain why it stopped moving?

Kip Peterson (07:39:36):

Yes.

State Attorney (07:39:37):

Explain what you found.

Kip Peterson (07:39:39):

On one of the locations of stagnation, there is an access road. It's south of Highway 44 in the area of Marion Oaks. There were two potential areas of relevance that were identified. Both were wooded lots.

State Attorney (07:39:56):

So, what did you do when you saw that? Did that raise concerns?

Kip Peterson (07:40:00):

It did. So, I first looked at both areas to make sure that there wasn't some sort of new construction that had been added, something that maybe hadn't been updated on a map yet. Going out to those areas and verifying that they were actually still wooded lots. Myself and a couple other law enforcement officers walked through those wooded lots.

State Attorney (07:40:21):

And when you walked through those lots, did you find anything of significance at that time?

Kip Peterson (07:40:25):

At that time, no.

State Attorney (07:40:26):

Okay. Did you do an extensive search or did you just do a quick look around?

Kip Peterson (07:40:30):

That was more of a quick look around just to see if there was anything that, again, would stick out as maybe a reason for why the device would've become stagnant.

State Attorney (07:40:40):

At this point in time, was it starting to get dark?

Kip Peterson (07:40:42):

It was.

State Attorney (07:40:44):

Okay. So, what did you do?

Kip Peterson (07:40:45):

At that point, we returned to the office for the night and ended up calling it a day until the next day.

State Attorney (07:40:51):

Okay. So, let me direct your attention now to the next morning. You mentioned earlier that there was a traffic stop done that morning on the defendant's Jeep?

Kip Peterson (07:41:00):

Yes.

State Attorney (07:41:00):

And you went there?

Kip Peterson (07:41:01):

I did.

State Attorney (07:41:03):

Okay. Was the defendant brought to the Marion County Sheriff's Office to be interviewed?

Kip Peterson (07:41:08):

He was.

State Attorney (07:41:09):

And did you have any involvement in that interview process?

Kip Peterson (07:41:12):

I did not partake in the interview myself, no.

State Attorney (07:41:13):

Okay. What were you doing while that interview was going on?

Kip Peterson (07:41:18):

I was listening to the interview while I was conducting another review of the cell phone records using the information from the interview to determine if there was anything that could explain the areas of stagnation that I had located the night before as well as identifying any other areas that were provided as a place where he may have stopped.

State Attorney (07:41:41):

And during your further analysis of the phone records, what did you find?

Kip Peterson (07:41:47):

The same two areas stuck out. The phone was at ... I'm sorry. The device was in the area of that Airbnb, ultimately, moved south through Marion County and go stagnant at the-

Kip Peterson (07:42:00):

... ultimately moved south through Marion County and go stagnant first at a location off of State Road 200, and then ultimately at the area that I had identified south of Highway 484 in Marion Oaks.

State Attorney (07:42:14):

And that area south of 484 near Marion Oaks, is that the area that there was just nothing around and no reason for the phone to be stagnant there?

Kip Peterson (07:42:21):

Yes, sir. It was the area of the two wooded lots.

State Attorney (07:42:23):

So what did you do at this point with that information?

Kip Peterson (07:42:26):

I relayed that information back through the investigative team and ultimately notified our Marion County Sheriff's Office field force team.

State Attorney (07:42:34):

What is a field force team? What do they do?

Kip Peterson (07:42:36):

Our field force team goes out and conducts more extensive searches. Unlike the detectives walking out the night before looking for things that are obvious that would stick out, our field force team does a line or a grid search to thoroughly search an area to verify that there's either something that needs to be further investigated or completely rule out, that there's nothing that needs to be investigated.

State Attorney (07:43:01):

At some point, were you informed that something was located in that same area where the defendant's cell phone became stagnant for a period of time?

Kip Peterson (07:43:10):

I was.

State Attorney (07:43:11):

What did you do then?

Kip Peterson (07:43:13):

I then went back to that area myself to take a look at the scene.

State Attorney (07:43:19):

What did you find?

Kip Peterson (07:43:20):

We found a grave site.

State Attorney (07:43:22):

Okay. Were other law enforcement officers already there and beginning the processing of that grave site?

Kip Peterson (07:43:27):

Yes.

State Attorney (07:43:28):

Okay. Was the location of the grave site that you saw consistent with the location of the defendant's cell phone record showing his phone going stagnant in that area?

Kip Peterson (07:43:40):

It was.

State Attorney (07:43:41):

During what period of time did the record show the phone was stagnant in that same area where the grave site was located?

Kip Peterson (07:43:47):

It was the early morning hours, I believe 9:30 to 10:30 in the morning.

State Attorney (07:43:55):

Okay. On October 12th?

Kip Peterson (07:43:57):

That's correct. I'm sorry.

State Attorney (07:43:58):

Of '25?

Kip Peterson (07:44:00):

2025.

State Attorney (07:44:01):

Okay. Did you create some images showing the Google Map and pictorial representation by TraX of the cell phone and the location where it went stagnant?

Kip Peterson (07:44:12):

I did.

State Attorney (07:44:15):

May I approach?

Judge (07:44:16):

Yes, sir.

State Attorney (07:44:17):

I'm showing you State's Exhibit HHH for identification. Can you look at those and tell me if you recognize them?

Kip Peterson (07:44:27):

I do.

State Attorney (07:44:28):

Generally, what do they show?

Kip Peterson (07:44:30):

These are images that I captured to demonstrate the areas of stagnation as well as the area of my pin drop where the victim was located buried.

State Attorney (07:44:45):

Do they fairly and accurately depict what the TraX program presented and produced?

Kip Peterson (07:44:51):

These are screenshots directly from TraX, so yes.

State Attorney (07:44:54):

At this time the state would move HHH into evidence as 61.

Attorney 2 (07:44:57):

No objections, Your Honor.

Judge (07:44:59):

Without objection, what's marked for identification as State's Exhibit HHH will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 61.

State Attorney (07:45:04):

May I publish?

Judge (07:45:05):

Yes, sir.

State Attorney (07:45:08):

All right. Showing you image one. Can you kind of explain to the jury what we're looking at? Let me give you the pointer.

Kip Peterson (07:45:13):

Absolutely.

State Attorney (07:45:15):

Hit the bottom button and the [inaudible 07:45:17].

Kip Peterson (07:45:17):

Got it. So the pin drops. There it is. Learning how to use this. I'm sorry. So the pin drop here is actually the cell site location. This is going to be the plot of land where the cell tower is actually housed at. So we can see one here and one here. When I describe the measurements that the network captures from the signal traveling from the tower to the phone back to the tower, that's represented by these arcs on the graph. On all of these cell towers, there are basically three antennas and the solid line coming from the tower out indicates the direction of that antenna. Based on the time that the signal takes to travel, the approximate location is then represented by one of these arcs.

State Attorney (07:46:05):

And does each of those arcs represent a different time the cell phone connected to the tower?

Kip Peterson (07:46:11):

It does.

State Attorney (07:46:11):

Okay. We have a whole bunch of arcs on the left side and then another couple arcs on the right side. Why are there two different cell towers being activated?

Kip Peterson (07:46:20):

Again, going back to what I was describing before, the cell phone or any mobile device connected to the network for that matter is constantly looking for the best signal. In this case, based on my review, it bounces from one tower to the other tower and back. So at some point in there, the mobile device decides, "I don't like the tower on the left. I'm going to connect to the tower on the right."

State Attorney (07:46:49):

And you mentioned earlier there were two separate areas of stagnation that concerned you. Are those two areas shown by this image?

Kip Peterson (07:46:57):

Yes. The first one is where this yellow pin drop is, and this is the block of woods that I was previously describing. The second one is down here. And again, it's kind of tough to see through the red lines, but there are blocks of woods right in that area.

State Attorney (07:47:14):

Is it important to you that the arcs intersect in those locations?

Kip Peterson (07:47:20):

It is.

State Attorney (07:47:20):

Explain why.

Kip Peterson (07:47:21):

So the stagnation describes just the fact that the device stops moving. The multilateration is what we see here where one set of arcs is mapped. When a second set of arcs intersects that, that is the multilateration. What that does is it actually shows me through my training that not only was the device stagnant there, but where those lines intersect or actually almost pinpoint accurate to the location of that device.

State Attorney (07:47:54):

Was the information generated by the TraX program consistent with the exact location that you went out and personally saw where the grave site was?

Kip Peterson (07:48:01):

Yes.

State Attorney (07:48:07):

Okay. I'm showing you image two. Can you explain to the jury what we're looking at here?

Kip Peterson (07:48:09):

Yep. Again, the yellow box was an approximate search area that I had identified based on my review of the records. Later on when I was notified that an area of interest had been determined to be a possible grave, I learned that it was within that area, specifically right where this yellow pin drop is. Going back and reviewing the records, confirming that, again, the location was consistent with what I observed in the records. Everything at that point looked like it made sense. Again, just going back to verify the accuracy of my analysis is the reason why I actually went out there to view the grave site itself to make sure that my measurements or I guess my analysis of the measurements rather was accurate.

State Attorney (07:49:04):

Thank you, sir.

Kip Peterson (07:49:05):

Thank you, sir.

(07:49:05)
No other questions, Your Honor.

Judge (07:49:06):

Any cross examination?

Attorney 2 (07:49:07):

No questions, Your Honor.

Judge (07:49:08):

Members of the jury, do any of you have questions of this witness? If you do, please raise your hands.

(07:49:12)
Seeing no hands, State, is he released?

State Attorney (07:49:14):

He is, Your Honor.

Judge (07:49:14):

Defense?

Attorney 2 (07:49:15):

No objection, Judge.

Judge (07:49:15):

Okay. All right. You're free to go about your day, sir. Thank you for your time.

Kip Peterson (07:49:17):

Thank you, sir.

Judge (07:49:19):

Members of the jury, anybody need a break? All right. Seeing no hands, State, next witness.

Attorney 3 (07:49:22):

State calls Carolyn Tanner.

Judge (07:50:04):

Come on in, ma'am. You can stand here. Raise your right hand. Face the clerk to be sworn.

Clerk (07:50:09):

Do you swear or affirm the testimony you're about to give will be the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so help you God?

Carolyn Tanner (07:50:13):

I do.

Judge (07:50:14):

You can be seated, ma'am.

Attorney 3 (07:50:17):

Good afternoon.

Carolyn Tanner (07:50:18):

Good afternoon.

Attorney 3 (07:50:19):

Can you please tell the jury your name?

Carolyn Tanner (07:50:21):

Carolyn Tanner.

Attorney 3 (07:50:23):

Are you employed, Ms. Tanner?

Carolyn Tanner (07:50:24):

Part-time.

Attorney 3 (07:50:25):

All right. Do you do some volunteer work involving cadaver dogs?

Carolyn Tanner (07:50:29):

Yes, I do.

Attorney 3 (07:50:30):

All right. Do you volunteer for a specific agency?

Carolyn Tanner (07:50:34):

I am a member of a team, but I also deploy independently.

Attorney 3 (07:50:38):

All right. Is the team you're a member of the North Florida Search Team?

Carolyn Tanner (07:50:43):

Yes, it is.

Attorney 3 (07:50:43):

All right. Is that out of Tallahassee?

Carolyn Tanner (07:50:45):

It is.

Attorney 3 (07:50:46):

How long have you been a cadaver canine handler?

Carolyn Tanner (07:50:49):

Since 2013.

Attorney 3 (07:50:52):

So over 10 years?

Carolyn Tanner (07:50:53):

Yes.

Attorney 3 (07:50:54):

All right. Do most law enforcement agencies have their own cadaver dogs?

Carolyn Tanner (07:50:58):

Not many of them.

Attorney 3 (07:50:59):

Okay. Why don't they have them?

Carolyn Tanner (07:51:01):

The reason I was told was because they usually get called out of their area for different cases.

Attorney 3 (07:51:08):

All right. So they rely on people like you and the North Florida Search Team?

Carolyn Tanner (07:51:12):

Yes.

Attorney 3 (07:51:13):

All right. What kind of training do you have to be a cadaver dog handler?

Carolyn Tanner (07:51:18):

What do I have?

Attorney 3 (07:51:19):

Mm-hmm.

Carolyn Tanner (07:51:20):

We start out with NASAR going through a testing period.

Attorney 3 (07:51:24):

What's NASAR?

Carolyn Tanner (07:51:26):

National Association of Search and Rescue.

Attorney 3 (07:51:28):

Okay. Go ahead. Tell us about that.

Carolyn Tanner (07:51:31):

Anyway, we can accomplish different levels. I am a SARTECH II, which a lot of the search teams require to be deployable.

Attorney 3 (07:51:42):

What did you have to do to be a SARTECH II?

Carolyn Tanner (07:51:44):

I did a three-week test.

Attorney 3 (07:51:48):

All right.

Carolyn Tanner (07:51:49):

Kind of mostly survival type navigation and how to survive if you get lost and what to do if you find somebody, et cetera. We take crime scene preservation classes, hazmat, bloodborne pathogens, and numerous other certifications.

Attorney 3 (07:52:11):

Okay. So that's for the SARTECH II. What other kind of training do you have?

Carolyn Tanner (07:52:16):

Mostly with the dogs.

Attorney 3 (07:52:17):

All right. Tell us about that.

Carolyn Tanner (07:52:19):

Well, we have to certify usually every year with an organization. Most of the time I've certified through NAPWDA, which is the North American Police Working Dog Association. Currently, my dog is certified with a USPCA, which is the United States Police Canine Association.

Attorney 3 (07:52:43):

All right. Let's talk about you first. So you said you're certified with what?

Carolyn Tanner (07:52:47):

With NASAR.

Attorney 3 (07:52:48):

What does that stand for?

Carolyn Tanner (07:52:50):

North American Search and Rescue.

Attorney 3 (07:52:53):

How long have you been certified with them?

Carolyn Tanner (07:52:55):

Since 2016.

Attorney 3 (07:52:56):

All right. Do you have to get re-certified every year?

Carolyn Tanner (07:53:00):

We do with the canines, yes.

Attorney 3 (07:53:04):

Now you've mentioned your canine. What's your canine's name?

Carolyn Tanner (07:53:07):

Fancy.

Attorney 3 (07:53:08):

Fancy. What kind of a dog is Fancy?

Carolyn Tanner (07:53:10):

She's a Doberman.

Attorney 3 (07:53:11):

All right. Do you also have another dog that you're currently training?

Carolyn Tanner (07:53:15):

I do. A younger dog.

Attorney 3 (07:53:17):

All right. What's the name of that dog?

Carolyn Tanner (07:53:19):

Her name is Allie.

Attorney 3 (07:53:22):

And is Fancy the dog you were using for this case?

Carolyn Tanner (07:53:25):

Yes.

Attorney 3 (07:53:26):

All right. Now we've talked a little bit about that you were mentioning that Fancy is certified, but what kind of training does Fancy have to have?

Carolyn Tanner (07:53:35):

Through our certifications, we, of course, are searching for human remains and we have to go through several different scenarios. We search buildings, we search for buried, we search vehicles, we search rubble piles, we do shoreline. And did I say vehicles? We do vehicles too.

Attorney 3 (07:53:58):

How long has Fancy been certified?

Carolyn Tanner (07:54:01):

Since 2017, I believe.

Attorney 3 (07:54:08):

All right. So about nine years?

Carolyn Tanner (07:54:09):

Yes.

Attorney 3 (07:54:10):

All right. Have you been working with Fancy that whole time?

Carolyn Tanner (07:54:12):

Yes.

Attorney 3 (07:54:12):

All right. Does Fancy have to get re-certified like you would do every year?

Carolyn Tanner (07:54:17):

Yes.

Attorney 3 (07:54:18):

What does that require?

Carolyn Tanner (07:54:19):

The same thing, going through the different scenarios and you have to pass each level. You're allowed one miss. After that, you fail. She has never failed.

Attorney 3 (07:54:32):

Never failed. Great. Okay. So you guys have been doing that for nine years together, getting certified?

Carolyn Tanner (07:54:36):

Yes.

Attorney 3 (07:54:37):

All right. And I think you already said this, but when you have your cadaver dog and you're out somewhere, what are they searching for?

Carolyn Tanner (07:54:45):

For human remains.

Attorney 3 (07:54:45):

Human remains. In general, how long does the decaying process take before Fancy will be able to detect something?

Carolyn Tanner (07:54:54):

Oh boy, that's really a long answer.

Attorney 3 (07:54:58):

Okay.

Carolyn Tanner (07:55:00):

It varies. Everything with human remains, it's in a constant state of change, environment. A lot of things affect it, the age, how long it's been there, if it's exposed, buried or whatever. I would say basically if a dog was presented with a deceased person, they would be able to detect it within five minutes.

Judge (07:55:29):

Hold on one second, ma'am. I just heard a sound from a cellular phone consistent with a recording sound. It came from this side of the courtroom.

(07:55:37)
Members of the jury, I need you all to step out. Notepads here. The jury's left the courtroom. Everyone can be seated. Now, what was the sound I heard? I know what it was. It was the sound of a cell phone beginning a recording. I'm familiar with that sound because I have an iPhone.

Attorney 2 (07:56:41):

My cell phone's been off since I walk in so it's like-

Judge (07:56:47):

Well, I can see you with Mr. Ward's hands...

Attorney 2 (07:56:49):

It's off. It could not have been mine.

Judge (07:56:52):

Mr. Ward, any ideas?

Mr. Ward (07:56:54):

I believe it came from Mr. Bailiff.

Bailiff (07:56:57):

I don't have any recording.

Judge (07:56:59):

Have you been interacting with a cell phone?

Bailiff (07:57:01):

I sent a single text.

Judge (07:57:03):

Okay. All right. Give me two minutes. It's been addressed. Let's bring in the jury.

(07:59:55)
Ladies and gentlemen, welcome back.

(07:59:55)
State, you can proceed.

Attorney 3 (08:01:21):

Thank you.

(08:01:22)
Can you generally tell the jury how the process works? If you go to a scene and you have Fancy, you're going to have Fancy search for human remains. For example, when you get there, do you take Fancy off a leash or do you keep Fancy on the leash?

Carolyn Tanner (08:01:36):

She's off leash.

Attorney 3 (08:01:37):

Okay. So you take her off the leash and then what do you do? Do you give any commands?

Carolyn Tanner (08:01:41):

I just send her and she begins searching.

Attorney 3 (08:01:44):

All right.

Carolyn Tanner (08:01:44):

If it's in a situation where there's traffic or something, we can work on leash if we have to.

Attorney 3 (08:01:51):

All right. So if there's no traffic, it's just an open field, she just goes?

Carolyn Tanner (08:01:53):

Wilderness searches are most common.

Attorney 3 (08:01:57):

All right. What does she do if she identifies human remains or finds them?

Carolyn Tanner (08:02:01):

She sits and occasionally barks also.

Attorney 3 (08:02:06):

All right. Now I want to direct your attention to Thursday, October 16th of 2025. On that day, were you contacted by Detective Joe Miller from the Marion County Sheriff's Office in reference to doing a cadaver search?

Carolyn Tanner (08:02:18):

I was.

Attorney 3 (08:02:19):

All right. And where did you go on that date?

Carolyn Tanner (08:02:21):

To Reddick.

Attorney 3 (08:02:22):

All right. Was that a site of a small Airbnb?

Carolyn Tanner (08:02:22):

Yes.

Attorney 3 (08:02:25):

All right. Approximately what time did you arrive there?

Carolyn Tanner (08:02:28):

Probably 10:00-ish in the morning.

Attorney 3 (08:02:30):

In the morning? All right. And were you given a brief rundown about the case from Detective Miller when you arrived?

Carolyn Tanner (08:02:36):

Detective Miller was not on site at the time. There was another officer there that was securing the area.

Attorney 3 (08:02:43):

All right. Did Detective Miller give you a brief rundown before or did you obtain one from the officer that was on site?

Carolyn Tanner (08:02:49):

From the officer that was on site.

Attorney 3 (08:02:51):

Okay. And then what did you do after you arrived in Reddick at the Airbnb?

Carolyn Tanner (08:02:55):

I just sent the dog around the... There was a tiny house. She searched around that, and then we covered the rest of the area, which was probably a couple acres maybe. There was a pond.

Attorney 3 (08:03:09):

Pond? Okay.

Carolyn Tanner (08:03:09):

Yes.

Attorney 3 (08:03:11):

So she checked everywhere in that area?

Carolyn Tanner (08:03:13):

She did.

Attorney 3 (08:03:14):

All right. Did Fancy alert anywhere at that property?

Carolyn Tanner (08:03:17):

No.

Attorney 3 (08:03:17):

All right. And did that end your involvement in this case on that day?

Carolyn Tanner (08:03:20):

Yes.

Attorney 3 (08:03:21):

Now, I want to move on to the following day, the Friday, October 17th of 2025. Were you called out again on that date to assist law enforcement in this case?

Carolyn Tanner (08:03:29):

Yes, I was.

Attorney 3 (08:03:30):

And where did you go at that time?

Carolyn Tanner (08:03:33):

Near Marion Oaks off of 484.

Attorney 3 (08:03:36):

All right. Would that be past the entrance to the Marion Oaks subdivision?

Carolyn Tanner (08:03:40):

I think it's past. It's either right before or just past.

Attorney 3 (08:03:46):

All right. And why were you called to go there?

Carolyn Tanner (08:03:47):

To check out an area for a possible deceased person.

Attorney 3 (08:03:52):

All right. Your Honor, may I approach the witness?

Judge (08:03:54):

Yes, ma'am.

Attorney 3 (08:03:58):

I'm going to show you what's been marked for identification as State's Exhibit III. It's two photographs. You can look at those and tell me if you recognize those.

Carolyn Tanner (08:04:07):

I do.

Attorney 3 (08:04:08):

Okay. There's one right behind it.

Carolyn Tanner (08:04:12):

Oops, sorry. Yes.

Attorney 3 (08:04:15):

All right. And what are those pictures of?

Carolyn Tanner (08:04:16):

The grave site.

Attorney 3 (08:04:18):

Okay. The area you went to on the Friday, October 17th of 2025?

Carolyn Tanner (08:04:21):

Yes.

Attorney 3 (08:04:22):

All right. Are those a fair and accurate depiction of where you went on that day?

Carolyn Tanner (08:04:24):

Yes.

Attorney 3 (08:04:25):

Your Honor, at this time, we would move State's Exhibit III into evidence.

Attorney 2 (08:04:26):

No objection, Judge.

Judge (08:04:29):

Without objection, what's been marked for identification as State's Exhibit III will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 62.

Attorney 3 (08:04:35):

All right. And may I publish, Your Honor?

Judge (08:04:36):

Yes, ma'am.

Attorney 3 (08:04:39):

Okay. If you can tell us, this is photograph number one. Does this show the areas as an aerial view of the area where you went and took Fancy?

Carolyn Tanner (08:04:45):

Yes, it is.

Attorney 3 (08:04:47):

Okay. I'm going to give you this pointer. Right here on the bottom. You can show us what area on this map that you took Fancy to.

Carolyn Tanner (08:04:55):

Did I push?

Attorney 3 (08:04:57):

You got it. Yep. It's right there.

Carolyn Tanner (08:04:59):

Oh, I see. Okay. I parked right here and let the dog out. Met with a detective here and sent the dog that direction.

Attorney 3 (08:05:08):

Okay. All right. I'm going to show you photograph number two. Can you tell us what we're looking at in this picture?

Carolyn Tanner (08:05:15):

The grave site.

Attorney 3 (08:05:24):

All right. I'm going to give you this pointer back again. Right here on the bottom. The amount of dirt in the back of the picture?

Carolyn Tanner (08:05:25):

Yes.

Attorney 3 (08:05:26):

Okay. And then you originally had said you let Fancy go right here. Is that where this actual dirt was located, right?

Carolyn Tanner (08:05:42):

Yes.

Attorney 3 (08:05:42):

In this area on this aerial map here?

Carolyn Tanner (08:05:44):

Yes.

Attorney 3 (08:05:45):

Okay. All right. So what happened? You arrived there. Did you let Fancy off the leash?

Carolyn Tanner (08:05:49):

Yes, I did.

Attorney 3 (08:05:50):

Okay. And what happened?

Carolyn Tanner (08:05:52):

She went directly to the burial site.

Attorney 3 (08:05:56):

Okay. And the burial site right here?

Carolyn Tanner (08:05:58):

Yes.

Attorney 3 (08:05:59):

Okay. So she went right there, and what did she do?

Carolyn Tanner (08:06:01):

She dug a little bit, left the area, made a circle, came back in, dug a little more toward the far end of it. She wasn't actually on the pile of dirt. She was actually next to it.

Attorney 3 (08:06:16):

Okay.

Carolyn Tanner (08:06:17):

And then she gave a full TFR, which is a Trained Final Response, indicating that there was human remains there. Yes.

Attorney 3 (08:06:26):

Would that be sitting as you told us before?

Carolyn Tanner (08:06:28):

Yes. And then she barked also.

Attorney 3 (08:06:30):

Okay. So she did both of the signals?

Carolyn Tanner (08:06:31):

She did.

Attorney 3 (08:06:34):

Okay. And do you know what was found there, where Fancy did alert?

Carolyn Tanner (08:06:38):

I didn't at the time. The next day I was told, yes.

Attorney 3 (08:06:42):

That there were human remains found?

Carolyn Tanner (08:06:43):

Yes.

Attorney 3 (08:06:45):

Did that end your involvement in this case?

Carolyn Tanner (08:06:46):

It did.

Attorney 3 (08:06:47):

Thank you. I don't have any other questions.

Attorney 2 (08:06:49):

No questions, Judge.

Judge (08:06:50):

Members of the jury, do any of you all have questions of this witness? If you do, please raise your hand.

(08:06:54)
All right. Seeing no hands, State, is she released?

Attorney 3 (08:06:56):

We'd ask that she be excused.

Attorney 2 (08:06:57):

No objection, Judge.

Attorney 3 (08:06:58):

Thank you.

Judge (08:06:58):

Ma'am, you're free to go about your day. Thank you for your time.

Carolyn Tanner (08:07:00):

Thank you.

Judge (08:07:01):

Members of the jury, anybody need a break? Let's call the next witness.

State Attorney (08:07:04):

State recalls Erin Morris. While Ms. Morris is coming to the courtroom, Your Honor, at this time, I would request that the court read the identity stipulation agreed to by all the parties.

Judge (08:07:14):

All right. Lawyers, we all approach?

State Attorney (08:07:52):

Judge, I'm going to wait and hold off on the deputy stipulation.

Judge (08:07:54):

Yes, sir.

(08:07:56)
All right, ma'am, you remain under oath, okay?

(08:07:58)
State, you can continue.

State Attorney (08:08:01):

Good afternoon again.

Erin Morris (08:08:02):

Hello again.

State Attorney (08:08:03):

For the record, can you please tell me your name one more time?

Erin Morris (08:08:05):

Erin Morris.

State Attorney (08:08:06):

All right. Let me direct your attention again back to October 17th of 2025. Did you respond to the area of south of the intersection of Southwest 32nd Avenue and Southwest 27th Circle in Ocala near Marion Oaks?

Erin Morris (08:08:21):

Yes.

State Attorney (08:08:21):

Can you describe that area?

Erin Morris (08:08:23):

So there was kind of an open, kind of grassy area, a little bit south of the roadway, and then kind of just beyond that was some wooded area. It kind of looked like it had been a dried up retention pond or a ditch in the area as well.

State Attorney (08:08:38):

What was going on when you arrived? Who was there? What was happening?

Erin Morris (08:08:41):

Yeah. When I arrived, Marion County Sheriff's Office, as well as some Florida Department of Law Enforcement special agents were on site. They had started excavating what they believe may be an area for burial.

State Attorney (08:08:51):

Did you actually see a mound of dirt, what could be a grave?

Erin Morris (08:08:56):

Yes.

State Attorney (08:08:57):

‍

Okay. Were photographs taken of the area as well as the grave site as well as the excavation process?

Erin Morris (08:09:03):

Yes. Marion County did that.

State Attorney (08:09:05):

May I approach?

Judge (08:09:05):

Yes, sir.

State Attorney (08:09:06):

Showing you what's been marked as State's Exhibit JJJ. Can you take a look at those photos and tell me if you recognize them.

Erin Morris (08:09:26):

I recognize the items in the photos.

State Attorney (08:09:26):

Okay. Do they fairly and accurately depict the area you described as well as the grave and the excavation process?

Erin Morris (08:09:34):

Yes. For the parts that I was there. Yes, sir.

State Attorney (08:09:34):

This time the State would move JJJ into evidence as 63.

Attorney 2 (08:09:37):

No objection, Judge.

Judge (08:09:39):

Without objection, what's marked for identification as State's Exhibit JJJ or triple J will be admitted to evidence as State's Exhibit 63.

State Attorney (08:09:46):

May I publish?

Judge (08:09:48):

Yes, sir.

State Attorney (08:09:49):

Showing you photograph one of 63. Can you explain to the jury just kind of what we're looking at?

Erin Morris (08:09:53):

This is some sheriff's line or the barrier tape that was in place to kind of help mark the area where they believe the burial may be.

State Attorney (08:10:08):

Okay. Do we see an area of disturbed dirt in the center of the photo?

Erin Morris (08:10:10):

Yes.

State Attorney (08:10:10):

Showing you photograph two of State's 63.

Erin Morris (08:10:10):

This appears to be a photograph a little bit closer to that area, just beyond the crime scene tape.

State Attorney (08:10:15):

Do you remember about how far off the roadway this mounted dirt was?

Erin Morris (08:10:18):

Oh goodness.

State Attorney (08:10:18):

Just an estimate.

Erin Morris (08:10:19):

I'm really horrible at distance. Maybe 20 yards.

State Attorney (08:10:23):

Okay. And showing you photograph three of State's 63. What do we see here?

Erin Morris (08:10:29):

So there's a mound of dirt kind of near a little bit of a brush wooded area.

State Attorney (08:10:34):

In the photograph we saw earlier, we see some yellow tape across that. What is that?

Erin Morris (08:10:39):

So that's the crime scene tape.

State Attorney (08:10:43):

Okay. And photograph four of State's 63, we see some pink lines surrounding this area of dirt. What is that for?

Erin Morris (08:10:53):

It's common in usually an excavation process that you'll mark a grid or an area of interest that you believe you're going to be trying to kind of dig and search for.

State Attorney (08:11:03):

Have you personally been involved in excavations during your career?

Erin Morris (08:11:06):

I have.

State Attorney (08:11:07):

Can you very briefly explain to the jury kind of the processes you go through when doing an excavation like this?

Erin Morris (08:11:13):

Sure. They kind of can vary, but essentially once an area has been identified, probes may be used or it may be something like this where there looks like there's some disturbed soils. It will typically be either gridded or a baseline or some form of area that can be referenced for measurement. It may be a data point, like a 0,0 point if you think back to school where you kind of had a grid or a map system. So if evidence is located, the investigators or technicians who may be excavating the area can then take measurements and help with their documentation process.

(08:11:47)
Once the area is photographed, if they found it, they're going to begin kind of removing vegetation, some of that topsoil, so then they can look and see if there's an area of disturbed soil or discoloration that kind of helps mark the area of the burial site.

(08:12:02)
As soil is removed, it's going to be sifted and searched for any additional evidence that may have been picked up with the removal of the soil. And as areas are fined, again, they're going to be documented, marked and measured usually in place.

State Attorney (08:12:15):

Is this a very long, painstaking, tedious process?

Erin Morris (08:12:18):

Yes. It can be usually several hours.

State Attorney (08:12:21):

Does that looks like taking a shovel and start digging?

Erin Morris (08:12:22):

No.

State Attorney (08:12:22):

Okay. Showing you photograph five of State's 63. What does this show?

Erin Morris (08:12:30):

This appears to be kind of the beginning stages of their excavation. It looks like they have removed several kind of inches of dirt and soil. That bucket there in the kind of upper top corner would be used to help remove that soil from the area and then take it over to a sifting area for that soil to be searched.

State Attorney (08:12:48):

At some point during the process, was a label discovered during the excavation process?

Erin Morris (08:12:53):

Yes.

State Attorney (08:12:54):

May I approach?

Judge (08:12:58):

Yes, sir.

State Attorney (08:12:59):

Showing you what's been marked as State's Exhibit KKK. Can you open that up? Look inside and tell me if you recognize the contents.

Erin Morris (08:13:30):

I do.

State Attorney (08:13:32):

What's inside?

Erin Morris (08:13:33):

It is the shovel label that was received from the burial site.

State Attorney (08:13:37):

Is that the photo of the same shovel label we see in photograph number six of State's 63?

Erin Morris (08:13:41):

Yes, it is.

State Attorney (08:13:42):

Is it in the same or substantially the same condition as when you received it and packaged it?

Erin Morris (08:13:46):

Yes, it appears.

State Attorney (08:13:47):

At this time the state would move KKK into evidence as State's 64.

Attorney 2 (08:13:51):

No objections, Judge.

Judge (08:13:52):

Without objection, what's been marked for identification as State's Exhibit KKK will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 64.

State Attorney (08:14:06):

A few minutes ago when you testified last, you testified you found a shovel at the defendant's residence in the garage?

Erin Morris (08:14:13):

Yes, I did.

State Attorney (08:14:15):

Do you remember what type of shovel that was?

Erin Morris (08:14:17):

Expert Gardener.

State Attorney (08:14:18):

Okay. Is the label that was found at the grave site the same or consistent with the label that will be associated with the shovel found in the defendant's garage?

Erin Morris (08:14:27):

Yes. In this photograph, it's a little hard to see the top part of that brand since it's a little folded upward, but it is an Expert Gardener label.

State Attorney (08:14:38):

Is there a barcode on the shovel label?

Erin Morris (08:14:42):

There is.

State Attorney (08:14:43):

Okay. Can you read that?

Erin Morris (08:14:45):

Yes. 885441012177.

State Attorney (08:14:50):

Okay. Showing you photograph six from State's 63 as well as photograph nine from State's-

State Attorney (08:15:00):

... create as well as photograph nine from State's 15. Photograph nine from 15 is a receipt found in the garbage of an Airbnb. Looking at the barcode on the shovel label and looking at the barcode on the Walmart receipt showing the purchase of a shovel, are they consistent?

Erin Morris (08:15:19):

Yes. The numbers are a little faded on the receipt, but they appear to be consistent with those on the barcode.

State Attorney (08:15:26):

Showing you photograph seven of State's 63. At some point during the excavation process, was the body of Sonia Exelby located?

Erin Morris (08:15:35):

Yes. Remains were located and they did believe it was Sonia Exelby.

State Attorney (08:15:38):

And how does the process... Is that what we see in the photo at the beginning of [inaudible 08:15:43]-

Erin Morris (08:15:42):

Yeah. So there are some areas there that are exposed, one kind of towards the center top of the photograph there, as well as that white floral pattern that you kind of see towards the center bottom.

State Attorney (08:15:53):

Once human remains have been reached in the excavation process, does the process change a little bit?

Erin Morris (08:15:59):

Yeah.

State Attorney (08:15:59):

How?

Erin Morris (08:16:00):

Usually, it slows down quite a bit. You typically tend to begin working with the soil around the remains, and focusing on that area to help remove it and locate the positioning of the body more quickly.

State Attorney (08:16:13):

About how deep was her body to reach this level?

Erin Morris (08:16:18):

I would say maybe a foot.

State Attorney (08:16:21):

Maybe a foot, you said?

Erin Morris (08:16:22):

Yeah. The top of the remains, yes.

State Attorney (08:16:24):

So, very shallow?

Erin Morris (08:16:25):

Fairly shallow for the top, yes.

State Attorney (08:16:27):

And I'm showing you photograph eight of State's 63. What do we see here?

Erin Morris (08:16:31):

This is a photograph depicting the remains that are mainly uncovered now.

State Attorney (08:16:37):

How was she dressed?

Erin Morris (08:16:41):

Right now she has a floral patterned item of clothing that's kind of draped over her torso and kind of upper legs area. Once that was removed, she had only a bra and shoes on.

State Attorney (08:16:54):

Okay. So the dress, she wasn't actually wearing a dress, it was just draped over her?

Erin Morris (08:16:57):

That's correct.

State Attorney (08:17:02):

Showing you photograph nine of State's 63. What does this show?

Erin Morris (08:17:06):

That is the floral dress that was draped over the remains.

State Attorney (08:17:10):

And was the dress collected?

Erin Morris (08:17:11):

Yes, it was.

State Attorney (08:17:12):

Showing you what's been marked as State's Exhibit LLL. Tell me if you recognize the contents.

Erin Morris (08:17:24):

Is it okay to remove the inner bag?

State Attorney (08:18:01):

Yes, ma'am.

Erin Morris (08:18:04):

I recognize the item.

State Attorney (08:18:05):

What's inside?

Erin Morris (08:18:06):

It is the white floral dress that's depicted in the photograph.

State Attorney (08:18:09):

Is it in the same or substantially the same condition as when you collected it?

Erin Morris (08:18:13):

Yes.

State Attorney (08:18:13):

At this time, State would move LLL into evidence as 65.

Junior Barrett (08:18:16):

No objection, Judge.

Judge (08:18:18):

Without objection, State's Exhibit LLL will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 65.

State Attorney (08:18:23):

May I publish, Your Honor?

Judge (08:18:24):

Yes, sir.

Erin Morris (08:18:25):

Do you want it back in the bag?

State Attorney (08:18:25):

Would you mind removing it from the bag and stepping down and showing the jury?

Erin Morris (08:18:39):

Okay. Here. Judge, there's going to be some materials. It's okay since it's dried up.

Judge (08:18:51):

If you want, you can step down.

Erin Morris (08:18:52):

Okay.

Judge (08:18:52):

If you place it on the rail in front of the jury.

Erin Morris (08:18:54):

Sure.

Judge (08:18:54):

[inaudible 08:18:55].

Erin Morris (08:18:54):

Is it okay to leave it just towards the bag so that material stays within the... I mean, we don't want to-

State Attorney (08:18:59):

[inaudible 08:19:02] remove the whole dress at some point.

Erin Morris (08:19:05):

Okay. I might try to just do it over the bag as best as I can.

Judge (08:19:07):

Yes, ma'am. You can do that.

Erin Morris (08:19:08):

Okay.

Judge (08:19:09):

And if you think that you have more room to work here, you can stay here at the witness stand as well.

Erin Morris (08:19:12):

Okay. That might contain it a little better. Is that okay?

State Attorney (08:19:12):

Yes.

Erin Morris (08:20:04):

Can I ask for your help?

Bailiff (08:20:04):

Yes.

Erin Morris (08:20:05):

If you don't mind holding that bottom half and just kind of traveling with me a little bit. Thank you. Is this okay?

State Attorney (08:20:15):

Yes, that's great. Thank you. Did you notice any cuts or slices or defects in the dress itself?

Erin Morris (08:20:32):

No, not at the time.

State Attorney (08:20:32):

No?

Erin Morris (08:20:40):

No.

State Attorney (08:20:41):

Okay. If you could package that up for me again. Thank you.

Erin Morris (08:20:43):

Sure. It's going to be a little... If it's okay, I might put this in this one. Is that all right?

State Attorney (08:20:56):

Do whatever you'd like.

Erin Morris (08:20:57):

Since we kind of...

State Attorney (08:21:27):

I'm showing you photograph 10 of State's 63. Let me direct your attention to where we see her left foot with the sandal on it.

Erin Morris (08:21:37):

Yes.

State Attorney (08:21:38):

Okay. Next to her left foot was another piece of clothing found?

Erin Morris (08:21:42):

That's correct.

State Attorney (08:21:43):

Showing you photograph 13 of State's 63. What do we see here?

Erin Morris (08:21:48):

So just kind of below where the leg is, you can see a little bit of a floral patterned piece of fabric. That is the top portion of what eventually was removed as a navy blue kind of floral patterned skirt.

State Attorney (08:22:05):

Photograph 13, I think, of State's 63. What do we see here?

Erin Morris (08:22:12):

That is more of the floral skirt that's been removed and kind of uncovered in the burial site.

State Attorney (08:22:18):

And she was not wearing the skirt, correct?

Erin Morris (08:22:20):

No.

State Attorney (08:22:21):

Okay. Was she wearing shoes?

Erin Morris (08:22:23):

Yes.

State Attorney (08:22:24):

Showing you photograph 13 or 14, I believe, of State's 63. What is this?

Erin Morris (08:22:31):

That is the floral skirt.

State Attorney (08:22:32):

And actually this is photograph 14. I apologize. What do we see here?

Erin Morris (08:22:37):

That is one of the shoes.

State Attorney (08:22:40):

Showing you photograph 15 of State's 63. Did you notice any injuries to her body?

Erin Morris (08:22:45):

Yes. Well, we observed what appeared to be some injuries to the left side of her torso.

State Attorney (08:22:54):

Do we see those in this photo?

Erin Morris (08:22:54):

You can. If you look just kind of below on her torso where that black bra is located, you can see some sort of elliptical looking, darker areas.

State Attorney (08:23:06):

And photograph 16, is that just a closeup of that general area?

Erin Morris (08:23:09):

That is.

State Attorney (08:23:12):

Once the excavation process was complete, what was done with Sonia Exelby's body?

Erin Morris (08:23:19):

So from my understanding, the body was removed and placed in a body bag upon the arrival of the medical examiner's office. Marion County Sheriff's Office wrapped up some of their processing until I arrived back at the site to do some additional processing alongside of them.

State Attorney (08:23:35):

And was her body eventually taken to the medical examiner's office?

Erin Morris (08:23:38):

Yes, it was.

State Attorney (08:23:39):

Thank you, ma'am.

(08:23:39)
No other questions, Your Honor.

Junior Barrett (08:23:40):

No questions, Judge.

Judge (08:23:41):

Members of the jury, do any of y'all have questions of this witness? If you do, please raise your hand. Seeing no hands, State, is she released?

State Attorney (08:23:48):

She is, Your Honor.

Judge (08:23:49):

Defense?

Junior Barrett (08:23:49):

No objection, Judge.

Judge (08:23:50):

Ma'am, you're free to go about your day. Thank you for your time.

Erin Morris (08:23:52):

Thank you.

Judge (08:23:54):

State?

State Attorney (08:23:55):

State recalls Patrick Vitellaro.

Judge (08:24:00):

Mr. Buxman and Mr. Barrett, will y'all approach about scheduling?

Junior Barrett (08:24:02):

Yes, Your Honor.

Judge (08:24:45):

Members of the jury, State, you all know it's about quarter to five right now. The State has three more witnesses that are present today that they're intending to call. This will cause us to go a little past 5:00 today, but it will keep us on schedule. Is everybody here able to stay a little past 5:00, probably not later than 5:30 to continue to hear testimony today? I see nobody shaking their head in the negative. Very good.

(08:25:09)
Come on in, sir. All right. Sir, you remain... You were here yesterday, correct?

Patrick Vitellaro (08:25:15):

Yes, Your Honor.

Judge (08:25:15):

Raise your right hand again. We're going to place you under oath again.

Patrick Vitellaro (08:25:17):

Okay.

Clerk (08:25:17):

Do you swear or affirm the testimony you're about to give will be the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so help you God?

Patrick Vitellaro (08:25:21):

I swear.

Judge (08:25:21):

Okay. You can be seated.

State Attorney (08:25:25):

Good afternoon, sir.

Patrick Vitellaro (08:25:26):

Good afternoon.

State Attorney (08:25:27):

Can you remind us your name and where you work?

Patrick Vitellaro (08:25:29):

Special Agent Patrick Vitellaro with the Florida Department of Law Enforcement.

State Attorney (08:25:33):

Let me direct your attention to October 17th of 2025. Did you travel to the medical examiner's office in Leesburg, Florida, to attend the autopsy of Sonia Exelby?

Patrick Vitellaro (08:25:42):

I did.

State Attorney (08:25:42):

During the autopsy, were various items collected from the victim, such as blood standard cards, swabs from her body, fingernail clippings, things like that?

Patrick Vitellaro (08:25:50):

Yes.

State Attorney (08:25:51):

Did you collect those various items or did the medical examiner technician collect them and provide them to you?

Patrick Vitellaro (08:25:57):

The medical examiner's office collected the items and provided them to me.

State Attorney (08:26:01):

And were you present to see the collection?

Patrick Vitellaro (08:26:03):

Yes.

State Attorney (08:26:03):

Following the autopsy, did you take possession of those items and transport them back to the Florida Department of Law Enforcement?

Patrick Vitellaro (08:26:10):

I did.

State Attorney (08:26:14):

Was a blood sample collected from Sonia Exelby during the autopsy?

Patrick Vitellaro (08:26:21):

It was.

State Attorney (08:26:22):

Showing you what's been marked as State's Exhibit MMM. Can you take a look at that item and tell me if you recognize it?

Patrick Vitellaro (08:26:28):

Yes.

State Attorney (08:26:28):

What is it?

Patrick Vitellaro (08:26:29):

This is a bloodstain card.

State Attorney (08:26:31):

And is it the same or substantially the same condition as when you took possession of it and took it into evidence?

Patrick Vitellaro (08:26:37):

Yeah, this is my handwriting on here.

State Attorney (08:26:38):

At this time, State would move MMM into evidence as 66.

Junior Barrett (08:26:42):

No objection, Judge.

Judge (08:26:43):

Without objection, State's Exhibit MMM will be admitted as State's Exhibit 66.

State Attorney (08:26:49):

Were fingernail clippings also collected from the victim's hands during the course of the autopsy?

Patrick Vitellaro (08:26:53):

They were.

State Attorney (08:26:54):

How was that done?

Patrick Vitellaro (08:26:56):

Just the same way you would clip your own nails, just a lot closer to the cuticle.

State Attorney (08:27:03):

Okay. Do they collect one package from one hand and one package from the other?

Patrick Vitellaro (08:27:07):

Pretty much.

State Attorney (08:27:08):

All right. I'm showing you what's been marked as State's Exhibit NNN. Do you recognize that?

Patrick Vitellaro (08:27:13):

I do.

State Attorney (08:27:14):

What is it?

Patrick Vitellaro (08:27:16):

This is the right-hand nail clippings of Sonia Exelby.

State Attorney (08:27:19):

I'm showing you State's Exhibit OOO. What is that?

Patrick Vitellaro (08:27:23):

This is the left-hand nail clippings of Sonia Exelby.

State Attorney (08:27:27):

And are both of those in the same or substantially the same condition as when you took possession of them from the autopsy?

Patrick Vitellaro (08:27:32):

Yes.

State Attorney (08:27:32):

At this time, State would move NNN into evidence as 67.

Junior Barrett (08:27:32):

No objection, Judge.

Judge (08:27:32):

Without objection, State's Exhibit NNN will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 67.

State Attorney (08:27:33):

And the State would move OOO into evidence as 68.

Junior Barrett (08:27:36):

No objection.

Judge (08:27:37):

Without objection, State's Exhibit OOO will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 68.

State Attorney (08:27:50):

During the course of the autopsy, were swabs collected from the victim's genital area and her anus?

Patrick Vitellaro (08:27:58):

Yes.

State Attorney (08:27:59):

And what's the purpose of that?

Patrick Vitellaro (08:28:00):

The purpose of those swabs are... It's basically like a sexual assault kit for DNA evidence.

State Attorney (08:28:10):

Showing you what's been marked as State's Exhibit PPP. Can you tell me what that is?

Patrick Vitellaro (08:28:16):

This is the external genitalia swab of Sonia Exelby.

State Attorney (08:28:20):

Showing you State's QQQ. Can you tell me what that is?

Patrick Vitellaro (08:28:24):

This is the vaginal swab of Sonia Exelby.

State Attorney (08:28:27):

And State's RRR for identification. What is that?

Patrick Vitellaro (08:28:30):

It's the anus swab of Sonia Exelby.

State Attorney (08:28:33):

And are all three of these items in the same or substantially the same condition as when you collected them from the autopsy?

Patrick Vitellaro (08:28:38):

Yes.

State Attorney (08:28:38):

At this time, State would move PPP into evidence as 69.

Junior Barrett (08:28:44):

No objection, Judge.

Judge (08:28:45):

Without objection, State's Exhibit PPP will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 69.

State Attorney (08:28:49):

QQQ as State's 70.

Junior Barrett (08:28:51):

No objection.

Judge (08:28:52):

Without objection, what's been marked for identification as State's Exhibit QQQ will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 70.

State Attorney (08:28:58):

And RRR as State's 71.

Junior Barrett (08:29:00):

Also, no objection.

Judge (08:29:01):

What's been marked for identification as State's Exhibit RRR will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 71.

State Attorney (08:29:07):

And finally, were known fingerprints, collected from Sonia Exelby?

Patrick Vitellaro (08:29:11):

Yes.

State Attorney (08:29:11):

Showing you what's been marked as State's SSS. Do you recognize that item?

Patrick Vitellaro (08:29:14):

I do.

State Attorney (08:29:15):

What is it?

Patrick Vitellaro (08:29:16):

This is the fingerprint card that was completed at the autopsy.

State Attorney (08:29:21):

Is that in the same or substantially the same condition as when you collected it from the autopsy?

Patrick Vitellaro (08:29:25):

Yes, it is.

State Attorney (08:29:25):

At this time, State would move SSS into evidence as 72.

Junior Barrett (08:29:29):

No objection, Judge.

Judge (08:29:30):

Without objection, what's marked for identification as State's Exhibit SSS will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 72.

State Attorney (08:29:36):

And were all these items eventually turned over to the Florida Department of Law Enforcement biology section to be analyzed?

Patrick Vitellaro (08:29:42):

Yeah, to the biology section and that one was to the friction ridge section.

State Attorney (08:29:47):

Okay. Thank you, sir.

(08:29:47)
No other questions, Your Honor.

Junior Barrett (08:29:48):

No questions, Your Honor.

Judge (08:29:49):

Members of the jury, do any of you all have questions of this witness? If you do, please raise your hand.

(08:29:54)
Seeing no hands, State, is this witness released?

State Attorney (08:29:56):

He is, Your Honor.

Junior Barrett (08:29:56):

No objection.

Judge (08:29:57):

Sir, you're free to go about your day now. Thank you for your time.

Patrick Vitellaro (08:29:59):

Thank you, Your Honor.

Judge (08:30:00):

All right. State, you can call your next witness.

Attorney 3 (08:30:02):

State calls William Porter.

Judge (08:30:14):

Come on up, sir. Raise your right hand and face the clerk to be sworn.

Clerk (08:30:18):

Do you swear or affirm the testimony you're about to give is the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so help you God?

William Porter (08:30:20):

I do.

Judge (08:30:20):

You can go ahead and be seated.

Attorney 3 (08:30:25):

Good afternoon.

William Porter (08:30:26):

Good afternoon.

Attorney 3 (08:30:26):

Can you please tell the jury your name?

William Porter (08:30:28):

William Porter.

Attorney 3 (08:30:29):

Okay. Where are you employed?

William Porter (08:30:30):

I'm the resident agent in charge of the FDLE Gainesville field office.

Attorney 3 (08:30:34):

How long have you worked for FDLE?

William Porter (08:30:36):

11 years.

Attorney 3 (08:30:37):

Right. What are your duties as resident agent in charge?

William Porter (08:30:40):

I supervise the Gainesville field office, the agents there and their investigations. The investigations include anything from homicide, violent crime, fraud, internet crimes against children, stuff like that.

Attorney 3 (08:30:51):

All right. I want to direct your attention to October 18th of 2025. On that date, did you go to the Butler Plaza in Gainesville?

William Porter (08:30:59):

I did.

Attorney 3 (08:30:59):

Why did you go there?

William Porter (08:31:00):

I was looking for a green and white donation bin. Special Agent McKinzie indicated that during her interview with the defendant in this case, he said that he put the victim's bag and personal belongings in a green and white donation bin in Butler Plaza.

Attorney 3 (08:31:16):

All right. And did you locate a green and white donation bin at that location?

William Porter (08:31:20):

I did.

Attorney 3 (08:31:21):

All right. Was that near Walmart?

William Porter (08:31:22):

Yes.

Attorney 3 (08:31:23):

Was there contact information on that green and white donation bin?

William Porter (08:31:26):

Yes. There was a phone number, (813) 802-3084 on the bin.

Attorney 3 (08:31:31):

Did you contact that phone number?

William Porter (08:31:32):

I did.

Attorney 3 (08:31:33):

Were you able to speak with the owner of the recycling bin?

William Porter (08:31:36):

Yes. His name was Nestor Herrera.

Attorney 3 (08:31:38):

All right. Did you learn where the contents of that bin were?

William Porter (08:31:41):

Yes. He said that the contents of that bin were picked up the day before or the day before that. They were on a box truck and they were in Tampa. The Butler Plaza location was one of the last pickups for the donation bins, and he indicated that the items from those bins would be in the back of the truck.

Attorney 3 (08:32:02):

Okay. So the items from that donation bin were on a box truck in Tampa, they were still on that truck?

William Porter (08:32:08):

Yes.

Attorney 3 (08:32:09):

Okay. What did you do with that information?

William Porter (08:32:11):

I kind of gave him a brief overview, that we were working a homicide investigation. I asked him if I could send an agent out there to go through the truck.

Attorney 3 (08:32:19):

Okay. And did you do that?

William Porter (08:32:20):

Yes.

Attorney 3 (08:32:20):

Okay. Who did you contact?

William Porter (08:32:22):

Ryan Bailey.

Attorney 3 (08:32:23):

Who's Ryan Bailey?

William Porter (08:32:23):

He's a special agent in Tampa. He was the on-call agent when this happened.

Attorney 3 (08:32:29):

All right. And what did you ask him to do?

William Porter (08:32:31):

I told him to call Mr. Herrera, the owner of this company, and get with him and then go through the contents of the truck. I told him we were looking for a black book bag with a pink inscription that says Superdry. That's the brand of it.

Attorney 3 (08:32:48):

All right. And did you give him just a brief rundown on the case as well?

William Porter (08:32:51):

Yes.

Attorney 3 (08:32:52):

Okay. I don't have any other questions. Thank you.

Junior Barrett (08:32:54):

No questions, Judge.

Judge (08:32:55):

Members of the jury, do you have any questions of this witness? If you do, please raise your hands. All right.

(08:32:59)
Seeing no hands, State is he released?

Attorney 3 (08:33:01):

We'd ask he be excused.

Junior Barrett (08:33:02):

No objection, Judge.

Judge (08:33:03):

Sir, you're free to go about your day. Thank you for your time.

(08:33:04)
All right, State, you can call your next witness.

Attorney 3 (08:33:06):

State calls Ryan Bailey.

Judge (08:33:48):

Good morning, sir. If you can raise your right hand, face the clerk to be sworn.

Clerk (08:33:51):

Do you swear or affirm the testimony you're about to give will be the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so help you God?

Ryan Bailey (08:33:54):

I do.

Judge (08:33:56):

All right. You can go ahead and be seated.

Attorney 3 (08:34:00):

Good afternoon. Can you please tell the jury your name?

Ryan Bailey (08:34:04):

Yes. Ryan Bailey.

Attorney 3 (08:34:05):

Where are you employed, Mr. Bailey?

Ryan Bailey (08:34:07):

With the Florida Department of Law Enforcement.

Attorney 3 (08:34:09):

How long have you worked for the Florida Department of Law Enforcement?

Ryan Bailey (08:34:11):

27 years.

Attorney 3 (08:34:13):

What is your position with them?

Ryan Bailey (08:34:14):

I am a special agent assigned to the violent crime squad in our Tampa Bay Regional Operations Center.

Attorney 3 (08:34:21):

On October 18th of 2025, did your office receive a request for assistance from the FDLE Gainesville field office?

Ryan Bailey (08:34:28):

Yes, we did.

Attorney 3 (08:34:29):

All right. Were you the on-call agent?

Ryan Bailey (08:34:31):

Yes.

Attorney 3 (08:34:32):

And on the day that you actually received the call for assistance, did you do anything?

Ryan Bailey (08:34:37):

I did not. I was only given instruction on what would be following the next day.

Attorney 3 (08:34:41):

All right. And did you go somewhere to look for potential evidence in this case that following day, which would be Sunday, October 19th of 2025?

Ryan Bailey (08:34:49):

Yes, I did.

Attorney 3 (08:34:49):

Where did you go?

Ryan Bailey (08:34:51):

I went to a clothing and shoes recycling center located at 9508 North Trask Road in Tampa, Florida.

Attorney 3 (08:35:01):

All right. And why did you go there?

Ryan Bailey (08:35:04):

It was to search a storage container for a black bag that belonged or was associated with a victim of a homicide.

Attorney 3 (08:35:18):

Okay. Wasn't the container a box truck?

Ryan Bailey (08:35:20):

Yes, it was.

Attorney 3 (08:35:22):

All right. And did you meet with anyone once you arrived at that location?

Ryan Bailey (08:35:24):

Yes. I met with the owner of the clothing and shoes recycling center, Nestor Herrera.

Attorney 3 (08:35:30):

All right. And did Mr. Herrera take you to that box truck that we've been talking about?

Ryan Bailey (08:35:34):

Yes. I was shown a box truck within a warehouse that was associated with a storage bin for this particular investigation.

Attorney 3 (08:35:42):

All right. And what did you do once Mr. Herrera took you to that box truck?

Ryan Bailey (08:35:45):

I searched the box truck for the black bag that was associated with the victim in this case.

Attorney 3 (08:35:54):

All right. And did you find a black bag searching the truck?

Ryan Bailey (08:35:58):

I found 20 black bags.

Attorney 3 (08:36:00):

All right.

Ryan Bailey (08:36:01):

Yes.

Attorney 3 (08:36:02):

And what did you do with the 20 black bags that you found?

Ryan Bailey (08:36:05):

I took all of those bags, I placed them on the ground. I took pictures of the bags. After taking pictures, I collected them, and put them inside a large plastic bag. Took those back to our Tampa Bay Regional Operations Center and put them into temporary evidence.

Attorney 3 (08:36:24):

All right. And later that same day, after you took all 20 of those bags, did you learn that one of the black bags you collected matched the description of Sonia Exelby's black bag with some pink glitter on it that said Superdry?

Ryan Bailey (08:36:37):

Yes, I did.

Attorney 3 (08:36:39):

And what did you do with that bag?

Ryan Bailey (08:36:41):

I separated that bag, with SuperDry on the front, from the other bags. I put it into a brown paper bag, sealed it with evidence tape.

Attorney 3 (08:36:52):

Your Honor, may I approach the witness?

Judge (08:36:54):

Yes, ma'am.

Attorney 3 (08:36:56):

I'm showing you what's been marked for identification as State's Exhibit A. If you could look at those photographs and tell me if you recognize those.

Ryan Bailey (08:37:02):

Yes.

Attorney 3 (08:37:03):

You can just look through there. There's going to be-

Ryan Bailey (08:37:19):

More. Yes.

Attorney 3 (08:37:19):

Are those a fair and accurate depiction of all of the black bags you saw, plus specifically the one identified to be Sonia Exelby's bag?

Ryan Bailey (08:37:25):

Yes.

Attorney 3 (08:37:26):

Your Honor, at this time we move State's Exhibit A into evidence.

Junior Barrett (08:37:28):

No objection, Judge.

Judge (08:37:30):

Without objection, what's been marked for identification as State's Exhibit A will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 73.

Attorney 3 (08:37:35):

And may I publish?

Judge (08:37:36):

Yes, ma'am.

Attorney 3 (08:37:37):

I'm showing you photograph number one. What are we looking at in this photograph?

Ryan Bailey (08:37:40):

This is the box truck that was within the warehouse at that clothing and recycling center I was telling you about.

Attorney 3 (08:37:46):

This is what it looked like when you got there and you started searching?

Ryan Bailey (08:37:48):

Yes.

Attorney 3 (08:37:49):

All right. And photograph number two?

Ryan Bailey (08:37:51):

Yes, that's a photo I took of the 20 black bags.

Attorney 3 (08:37:56):

And then photograph number three?

Ryan Bailey (08:37:58):

Yes. That is the bag that was, I was told, identified as being associated with Sonia Exelby.

Attorney 3 (08:38:05):

Because you were specifically told to look for one with the pink glitter that said Superdry on it?

Ryan Bailey (08:38:11):

I was told to look for a black bag, and then later after finding the 20, I had learned that there was a bag associated that had Superdry on it. I recalled that being one of the 20, that is in fact the bag.

Attorney 3 (08:38:26):

And photograph number four, is that just the back of that same black bag bag?

Ryan Bailey (08:38:29):

Yes.

Attorney 3 (08:38:32):

And five?

Ryan Bailey (08:38:33):

Yes.

Attorney 3 (08:38:33):

And photograph six, that would be inside?

Ryan Bailey (08:38:38):

Yes.

Attorney 3 (08:38:38):

Was anything inside of the bag?

Ryan Bailey (08:38:40):

No.

Attorney 3 (08:38:43):

Now you said you took that black Superdry bag out and repackaged it.

Ryan Bailey (08:38:48):

Correct.

Attorney 3 (08:38:48):

And then did you do anything with that?

Ryan Bailey (08:38:50):

I then took that particular bag, the bag with Superdry on the front, and drove to a TA Travel Center, a gas station off of I-75, Interstate 75 in Wildwood, and met with FDLE Special Agent Calvin Lee to transfer that item to him.

Attorney 3 (08:39:09):

Okay. And did you give actually that bag to Calvin Lee?

Ryan Bailey (08:39:11):

Yes.

Attorney 3 (08:39:11):

Your Honor, may I approach the witness?

Judge (08:39:16):

Yes, ma'am.

Attorney 3 (08:39:16):

I'll show you what's been marked identification as State's Exhibit TTT. If you can look at that and tell me, do you recognize that?

Ryan Bailey (08:39:26):

Yes.

Attorney 3 (08:39:26):

Okay. And how do you recognize it? Does it have an FDLE tag on it?

Ryan Bailey (08:39:27):

Yes. It has our FDLE sticker for evidence that we use, and then the tape that we use as well, yes.

Attorney 3 (08:39:37):

And does it, on the bag, indicate that that was given to Calvin Lee?

Ryan Bailey (08:39:41):

Yes.

Attorney 3 (08:39:42):

Your Honor, at this time, we move State's Exhibit TTT into evidence.

Junior Barrett (08:39:47):

No objection, Judge.

Judge (08:39:48):

Without objection, what's been marked for identification as State's Exhibit TTT will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 74.

Attorney 3 (08:39:54):

And did that end your involvement in this case?

Ryan Bailey (08:39:57):

Yes, it did.

Attorney 3 (08:39:58):

Thank you.

(08:39:58)
I don't have any other questions, Judge.

Junior Barrett (08:39:58):

No questions, Judge.

Judge (08:40:00):

Members of the jury, do any of y'all have questions of this witness? If you do, please raise your hands.

(08:40:04)
Seeing no hands, State, is he released?

Attorney 3 (08:40:06):

We ask that he be released, Your Honor.

Judge (08:40:07):

Defense-

Junior Barrett (08:40:08):

No objection, Your Honor.

Judge (08:40:09):

All right, sir, you're free to go about your day. Thank you for your time.

Ryan Bailey (08:40:10):

Thank you.

Judge (08:40:12):

All right, members of the jury, we've gotten now to a good stopping point. It's 5:01, so I apologize for going a little late, okay? But we're going to pick up tomorrow morning at 8:30, okay? I'd like you all back here at 8:10, just like today. I think everybody was here by 8:02, so thank you for that. Before we all go, remember what I instructed you on. I'm going to instruct you on it again, okay? We're going to be on a recess. During this recess, you cannot communicate with any person about the case, including one another, okay? You also cannot use your cell phones or electronic devices to do any research about the case, the people or places involved in the case, or anything else having to do with the case at all. Okay? You should not use your cell phone or electronic device to communicate about the case either.

(08:40:54)
I'm also going to continue to instruct you not to access social media or any type of local news, okay? It's probably prudent at this point not to access any news at all at this juncture of the trial. Okay? So go home and unplug for the night and have dinner, and we'll see you all back here tomorrow morning. Any questions for me?

Judge (08:41:12):

No, none.

Judge (08:41:15):

Okay. Leave your notepads here on the chairs and we'll see you back in the morning. Everyone get a good night of sleep.

Judge (08:41:19):

Thank you.

Judge (08:41:45):

You're taking lunch orders as well, Deputy?

Bailiff (08:41:46):

Yeah, I'll go for lunch.

Judge (08:41:47):

Okay. There's been a change of plan for lunch tomorrow, so we got menus. All right. For the benefit of the record, the jury has left the courtroom. Y'all can be seated. We had planned to get the jurors lunch from general staff dining tomorrow, but tomorrow happens to be the day the sheriff does a annual Thanksgiving lunch for his 1,200 employees. So they can make food for 1,200 people, an additional 14 might complicate it. So we're doing Jimmy John's again if y'all wondered if that was allowed.

(08:42:25)
With that being said, State, Defense, is there anything that we need to take up from you all before we recess for the afternoon?

State Attorney (08:42:30):

No, Your Honor.

Judge (08:42:30):

Okay.

Junior Barrett (08:42:31):

No, Your Honor.

Judge (08:42:33):

All right, Mr. Hall. Tomorrow, obviously, the trial will continue. Based upon the pace at which we're going, I'm expecting that sometime tomorrow afternoon, you're going to be called upon to make a decision whether or not you choose to become a witness in the case. Okay? Whether you become a witness and testify is going to be your decision, your decision entirely. I'm going to ask you when you are deciding whether you want to testify to it. You're going to have to make that decision. When you do that, understand it is your decision to make, okay? Because it involves the exercise of a fundamental right, that being the right to remain silent or the right to testify.

(08:43:05)
Your attorneys will give you advice and counsel. If you want to talk to them now, I can ask the bailiffs to keep you here to give you a couple minutes to talk with them. You'll have time to talk with them tomorrow, but I just want tonight, for you to kind of be kicking around if you've not been already, what you want to do regarding that decision that you'll have to make tomorrow. Do you understand?

Dwain Hall (08:43:22):

Yes.

Judge (08:43:23):

Okay. Very good, sir. All right. I'll see you all back tomorrow morning. We'll start-

Junior Barrett (08:43:27):

I just have a logistic question.

Judge (08:43:28):

Oh yes, sir.

Junior Barrett (08:43:29):

Plan on going out there. I just want some idea if they can tell me what time you would make it back here so I can kind of plan out when to go out to the jail to sit down with-

Bailiff (08:43:38):

Within the next half hour probably.

Junior Barrett (08:43:40):

Okay. That's great. Thank you.

Judge (08:43:41):

Okay.

Junior Barrett (08:43:41):

So I'll be there.

Judge (08:43:42):

All right. Very good. We'll start promptly at 8:30 tomorrow. If y'all could be here about ten after, take up any matters we have to, that would be appreciated.

State Attorney (08:43:50):

Yes, sir.

Judge (08:43:50):

Okay. Thank you all.

‍

Topics:
No items found.
Hungry For More?

Luckily for you, we deliver. Subscribe to our blog today.

Thank You for Subscribing!

A confirmation email is on it’s way to your inbox.

Share this post

Copyright Disclaimer

Under Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing.

Subscribe to The Rev Blog

Sign up to get Rev content delivered straight to your inbox.